A true hidden gem bakery in the Jefferson Hills area and is right on one of the main streets in Elizabeth. This is a nice little gift store with a little bakery in the back. I loved seeing all the Christmas decor as I walked in! Now the desserts were unbelievable! I was not expecting them to be so good! I got a dozen thumbprint cookies for homecoming later in the day and also a lady lock and two donuts. Anything I tasted was awesome! The almond donut was delicious. I tried two of the cookies and WOW so good! I had the raspberry almond thumbprint and the chocolate peanut butter thumbprint and I was obsessed. I also had a pepperoni roll that was big and delicious! This is a MUST STOP for anyone in the area or anyone looking for cookies for a cookie table. I will definitely be back! read more

Barton's Flowers & Bake Shop - Assorted desserts - Florists Near Me - Elizabeth, Pennsylvania

See all

Rating: 4.8 Stars My parents got a Pumpkin Roll through a fundraiser so I am not overly familiar with this shop or their other product offerings. However, the Pumpkin Roll was a great choice! It had a great pumpkin taste with a nice hint of spice that was not overwhelming. The cream cheese icing had an excellent sweetness, and it complemented the pumpkin flavor quite nicely. I highly recommend this Pumpkin Roll! read more

Barton's Flowers & Bake Shop - Pumpkin Roll!!! - Florists Near Me - Elizabeth, Pennsylvania

Excellent baked goods! We get their cookies for treats and gifts for others! Purchased a cake for a christening and cake was beautiful and done on time! Staff is always helpful and friendly! If you're not familiar with the store and can be a little difficult to navigate. Not really wheelchair friendly. read more

Excellent service and extra extra extraordinary taste! Haven't had a bakery like this in about 30 years. Their artistry is just mind blowing. Great prices. Thank u BARTONS read more

Barton's has been on my bakery wish list for awhile now, but their hours always prevented me from being able to visit. I was really craving baked goods yesterday and my bf was kind enough to go to Barton's since he was done with work early. It's a pretty decent drive, but somewhere I've been wanting to try so I was excited that I finally was going to get to. Unfortunately, I wish I would have picked another bakery for him to stop at yesterday because it was a total fail. He brought home pretty much 1 of each cookie, half a dozen cupcakes, an apple pie, cake pops and a brownie. When he arrived home, I noticed that the decor was red, white and blue... which was concerning since Memorial Day was Monday, Barton's is closed Sunday's so I can only assume that the baked goods were from Saturday and they were purchased on Wednesday. At that point I was questioning their freshness, but they looked so good that I remained hopeful. We waited for some friends to join us and as we began to try the items, our fears came true. Everything tasted old. The items were dry, hard, stale and the worst part was that they tasted freezer burned. Like the freezer burn flavor overpowered the chocolate, almond, vanilla, whatever other flavoring was in the item. I'm not sure if they were actually frozen? Or maybe their bakery case or refrigerator just has that awful freezer smell that the items absorbed? They were genuinely inedible. As we sampled the cookies, we hoped that the cupcakes would be good... but when we tried the cupcakes, they were just as bad... but how could a brownie be bad? So we tried the brownie and it was awful; we continued until finally we were out of things to try and it was 1 let down after another. I can honestly say that I don't remember the last time I had to spit something out because it was that bad and the 4 of us did on numerous times. I'm not sure that we actually consumed anything. I can imagine that everything would be absolutely delicious if it was fresh, but the only "clearance" item that we got were the sugar cookies. Everything else was full priced. The purchase totaled $35 which isn't unreasonable for high quality, fresh bakery items, but I have a feeling we paid full price for 5 day plus old items and are incredibly disappointed. If it was close by, I might give them another chance, but it absolutely isn't worth the drive to risk having the same experience the second time. I've heard wonderful things about this bakery so maybe it was just an off day... read more

See all

The best cookies and cakes! We ordered our wedding cake from here and the girls were so easy to work with. The cake was top notch delicious! Their sugar cookies are one of a kind. They are huge, delicious, and they can be customized for your event. The flower shop is wonderful as well. This is probably the best business in Elizabeth! Cant give them enough stars!! read more

Barton's has the best buttercream frosting!! Their cakes are delicious with a ton of options for batter, filling, and frosting. I love the chocolate cake with a peanut butter butter cream frosting and filling . I'm not a big coconut fan, but the German chocolate cake is a must try! Their cookies are also very good! I love the chocolate chip and m&m. The carrot cake cookies are also a big hit! They are also a flower shop they does weddings, bouquets, and other arrangements. They are affordable and they do a beautiful job. The shop also has a ton of holiday decorations to sale. read more

The baked goods and flowers Chrissy and her family put together are the best! I want to take a moment to acknowledge their kindness as well. They put together a beautiful flower and cupcake combination (with birthday candle) to deliver to my elderly aunt at a time when it was most needed. What wonderful people. Thank you for your caring. You've made my day, week, year! read more

Great locally owned business that has been around the area for decades. Their cookies are so good that we have shipped them out of state to friends. their pastries and cakes are great. They also have a good selection of flowers for any occasion. read more

Cute little shop.I've tried their thumbprint cookies was very disappointed. Tried their cakes did not like the super sweet icing . I did enjoy their mini pies . read more

I explored this wonderful shop when I was in town visiting my half-sister and niece. The shop itself is more than just flowers and a bakery. There were so many wonderful gift items to offer it was difficult to choose which ones to purchase - Halloween, Christmas, nursery, etc. Staff in the bakery assisted me by carefully packing the cream rolls and cookies I purchased to take on the plane as I traveled back home. My family loved these delicious treats! I plan to visit again when I am in town. read more

I am going to start this post by saying that I rarely give reviews, especially negative ones. However, I feel so strongly about my experience here that I am sharing with hope no one has the same horrific experience that I did. I ordered cupcakes and cookies from Barton's Bake Shop for my sister's baby shower. I had not ordered from this bakery before (and will never again), but after seeing the beautiful baby girl themed cookies and cupcakes they had posted on their Instagram page I decided to give it a shot - they looked perfect! When ordering the girl on the phone was very friendly and helpful. She took my order, I placed a deposit, and all was well until the day the order was picked up. First off, I ordered 5 dozen cupcakes and 5 dozen cookies. When picking up the order one of the dozen cupcake containers was short 4 cupcakes. I understand people make mistakes, but the containers held one dozen each. I mean, counting isn't even necessary. After acting like we were a bother, they refunded us for 4 cupcakes. The cookies were beautiful, although they still did not contain the flower details on the onesies that they had in the picture on the Instagram post. I was satisfied with them. However, the cupcakes looked NOTHING like the photo from their Instagram page that I referred to when ordering. I will also say I am not a super picky person and love supporting small local businesses (especially at this unprecedented time), but when paying TOP DOLLAR for a large order for my sister's baby shower I also expect to be satisfied with my purchase. When I called the bakery and asked to speak to a manager to express my concern they connected me to the owner. This is what led me to write this review. The owner was completely disrespectful and had NO CARE whatsoever about my concerns. He told me he saw the order before it went out and they were just fine. He repeatedly asked me what he could do to help and every time I expressed how I felt and what I would like to be done he told me it wasn't a possibility they have no time to redo any cupcakes. All I asked is for the dozen and a half of the cupcakes that looked nothing like the photo to be remade for the next day and I would bring the unacceptable cupcakes back. Not to mention this bakery is at least a 45 minute drive from my house. After going back and forth for what seemed like an eternity his final solution was for me to bring ALL of the cupcakes back and get refunded for them. What was I supposed to serve all of the guests at my sister's baby shower the next day?? He didn't care and wasn't concerned. My final solution was to replace the dozen and a half of the cupcakes with cupcakes from another local bakery I know I can rely on. I did not receive any money back, I did not get new cupcakes that look like what I had ordered, but I did get a headache from this bakery. I am extremely disappointed and upset with his rude attitude as well as the lack of care for their customer's satisfaction and will never be going back to this bakery. I would recommend you do the same. I have posted pictures of both the Instagram photos advertised and the product I received. read more

Barton's Flowers & Bake Shop - a dozen cupcakes - Florists Near Me - Elizabeth, Pennsylvania

See all

Barton's did the cake and flowers for my wedding last year. First of all, let me say you will never meet a sweeter family. They are so very kind and patient. When we went for our tasting, the cake was out of this world amazing. Unfortunately, it didn't taste as good on my wedding day, but it wasn't bad. Our cake did look absolutely beautiful though! I loved the flowers also. I couldn't have been more pleased with how they matched our colors. I would use them again for sure. I would just want to make sure the cake I receive the day of my event is fresh. read more

See all

Barton's Flowers went above and beyond for an arrangement requested the SAME DAY. This was for a funeral service in the midst of COVID-19. They not only provided a beautiful peace lily but delivered to the relatives home after driving to the church and noticing that the service was over. They truly went above and beyond the call of service especially during an already emotional time. I would definitely use them for any future purchases. You pay for quality and get the best...the best for flowers is Barton's. read more

When looking for a wedding cake and flowers, these guys know their stuff. Delicious cakes, pretty decorations, and all of the rentals you could ask for. Unfortunately the price is high and we just couldn't justify the money. The consultation was personal and they woo you with their cupcakes made just for your tasting. Marble cake with raspberry filling and white buttercream - yum! We felt that they wanted our business and that impressed us. When it came to the "estimate" it was not what we discussed. Everything was just thrown in an email, not a professional or seemingly legitimate estimate. It was just a bunch of random notes with a high price. I recommend their bakery because they're delicious and treat you well. Unfortunately the price and the way the estimate was delivered did not match the taste. read more

Just moved to Elizabeth and I love this bakery!! So many choices and everything I have tried is delicious! I get cookie trays or cupcakes for clients and they love it. Everyone who works there is super friendly and helpful too! read more

Wow! Purely Awesome Bakery. Do yourself a favor & drop-in ASAP. This way you can tell your mom or grandma that they can take a break this Holiday Season, w/regards to baking Thanksgiving & Christmas cookies- Bartons has it covered! Great selections of true classics w/many variations as well. What can be better than a Family Business that has been a part of my life since going to pre-school next door & sitting on Santa's lap :) Years later now I return for a visit to find they've expanded & all for good reason- "Passion of the Craft" Go In, Check them out, & I can assure that you will not be disappointed! read more

The baked goods are amazing. I all ways seek out bakeries in the area and saw the high rating for Bartons. I knew I had to check it out myself. The baked section is small itself but packs a punch. I ordered cookies and cupcakes. The cookies were soft enough that they didn't crumble and we're not too hard. The cupcakes are to die for. I had the funky monkey -chocolate icing, banana cake and peanut butter filling. A little too heavy for me but still good. The cinnamon roll, which was amazing but it is pretty sugary so a half was perfect. Then the pumpkin pecan. That was perfection so good. I wish I had pictures but I got too excited and ate them before I could even write a review. Will definitely stop in again. read more

Thank you to Hillary and Hailey! The decorated cookies were both beautiful and delicious as always. The cake was also the same! If you have never tried Barton's, I strongly suggest you do! Hillary had the patience of a Saint when going over the theme I was looking for and showing her my pictures of ideas! The girls did an amazing job on everything. Their adorable flower and bake shop is worth the 30-45 minute ride! read more

See all

I purchased a yellow gluten-free cake with chocolate frosting from Barton's for my Aunt and Uncle's anniversary. (Gluten-free is better for your health, btw.) I was just glad to find one that was gluten-free, and hoped for the best. To my surprise, it was the best cake I have ever eaten. Everyone who had a piece agreed. Even if you aren't gluten-free, get the gluten-free option anyway. It is fantastic. I don't live in the area, and depended on yelp ratings to find the best. That's why I bothered to come back on to give a rating. Seriously five stars. read more

I Have A 5 Year History With Barton's. Both In The Bakery, And Flower Shop. I've Never Experienced Such Exceptional Customer Service As I Consistently Get From Them. Actually The Only Other Place That Is Just As Good As Them On The Service level Is A Beer Distributor Just A Few Blocks Away From Them.... Birthday Cakes, Cookies, And Flowers. They Nail It Every Single Time. If They Don't Have It, They Have Always Come Up With An Excellent Substitution, Or They Always Got It For Me. Sometimes Due To Time Constraints There Were Times When They Could Not Get My Desired Flower In Time. No Order Was Ever To Big Or Small. It Never Mattered, Spend 5 Bucks Or Spend 200, I Was Treated Each Time As If I Purchased A Million Dollars Worth Of Product. read more

We recently stopped in one morning and requested 14 dozen cookies for the staff at my mom's nursing facility. We returned about an hour later and they had them all beautifully arranged on trays topped with lovely bows. Later that day a friend had called from out of state, and had the same cookies delivered to us, along with an adorable arrangement of sweetheart roses in a teacup. I highly recommend both the bakery and florist. Great, friendly folks and delicious and lovely products. Wonderful service, as well read more

I have only used the bake shop. The cookies are delicious! We have them in my office once a week and they are eaten quickly! I love the chocolate chip ones! It is hard to have just one! read more

I would make sure before you use this bakery for your wedding they give you a detailed invoice with what you agreed upon before you pay. They messed up my relatives wedding cake order and did not have the integrity to admit it! read more

Wonderful bakery!! Wish Elizabeth had a few more quality food choices like this. Very pleasant and accomplished young staff. Will be back soon. read more

Where do I begin? Loved the raspberry thumbprint cookies, peach pie ,brownie, pumpkin bar, lady lock, raspberry Danish, apricot Danish. We loved it all. It was our final summertime field trip for my granddaughters before school starts. The gift shop is overwhelming with beautiful flower arrangements, pictures, gifts, and bric-a-brac. Autumn and Christmas decor plentiful. Ambiance peaceful and calm with a Christian influence. Very refreshing. read more

Hillary at Barton's Bake Shop made our wedding cake, and it was truly the best wedding cake we have ever had! Our guests told us the same thing the night of the reception and are still raving about it. Not only were the cakes (we selected three different flavor combinations) delicious, but our display cake for cutting was gorgeous! Hillary and her team are incredibly talented and easy to work with. From our first phone call to the wedding-day delivery that Hillary made herself, we experienced service that was friendly and beyond accommodating. The "icing on the cake?" Everything was extremely affordable - even for our 220-person wedding. Highly recommend Barton's for your wedding cake. Scrap the over-priced bakeries in the city and contact Hillary! read more

The cake for my Mom's birthday was quite the disappointment. Although it tasted good, it was not what I had ordered. Colors were wrong, they added her name by squeezing it in at the end with a different color icing and the "roses" were piles of squiggled icing. It was also raised up in the middle, not level. I was very embarrassed to have our 40 guests even look at it. A grade school child could have done a better job. It was a $45 mess. When I went to the bakery to complain and show pictures of the monstrosity, the woman showed no concern at all. She said "Those ARE our roses." Looked me right in the eye and lied. I let her know they had done my Father's cake a year before and THOSE were roses. I didn't want anything but an apology. Never again. read more

Cookies were nice and the pastry shop was filled with yummy goodness. Great place to wasye an hour gettin lost inside.

I got my wedding flowers and cake through Barton's. I absolutely adored my flowers and they were beyond my expectations. The issue I had was with my wedding cake and the way Barton's handled the issue after the fact. From the beginning, I made them aware of my husband's allergy to chocolate. Hilary assured my they had it written down on our sheet. We ordered a small two tier white cake for our wedding cake and full sheets for everyone else. We confirmed this exact order two weeks prior to the wedding. Come day of wedding when we go to cut our cake and it is chocolate. I contacted Barton's the next day letting them know I loved the flowers but was very unhappy about the wedding cake and how they knew of my husbands allergy, and it was disappointing we spent a lot of money and can not eat it. Barton's insisted I ordered this cake and confirmed it. They said it must have been my error because I "was most likely busy with wedding planning." I know for a fact what I confirmed two weeks prior, and regardless I made sure from the very beginning they had it written down he was allergic to chocolate. The fact that Barton's could not humbly acknowledge their mistake and even just apologize for ruining a special part of our day was very unprofessional. I wouldn't trust this bakery for any special occasion, especially if they blame you for their wrongs. read more

We had one of their pies at the farmer's market. Very good .. a little pricey, but tasted just like Mom used to make.

Ordered cookies for my daughter in law and son's baby shower. It was a baseball theme!! The cookies were adorable and tasted wonderful!! Received a lot of compliments. Will definitely order again. read more

Charming shop.The flowers are lovely but the bakery is awesome! Worth a trip to Elizabeth for this sweet treat!

Thank you for making some excellent cookies. My husband was in El Paso over Christmas and New Year's. The Bake Shop sent some cookies to us in Phoenix. Long story short, days after baking, shipping and waiting for my husband's return we had some of the most excellent cookie's. Fantastic baking and decorating. Great, great job. High praise and fantastic baking. read more

Had a delicious cake for an event at work today- marble cake with raspberry filling. It was moist, flavorful and beautifully decorated. Thanks, Bartons! read more

I stopped here once on my way home from work and it has now become a weekly stop. The cupcakes are wonderful my husband and I are hooked. The owners are also very nice we like to support local businesses this shop is a favorite. read more

Just had a gluten free cake from Barton's at a birthday party. It was moist and full of vanilla flavor. Delicious!!!