Excellent customer service and solid breakfast sandwich. Bagel on its own is decent at best but great sandwiches loaded with bacon and Taylor ham respectively. Nice inside of the shop with polite workers. Overall good experience and fair price, would eat again. read more

You should feel confident that when you stop at Bagful O Bagels, you'll get a fresh, flavorful, crispy example of what makes NJ bagels the envy of people who are merely visiting or have moved away. Lafayette, where BOB is located, isn't on the way to anywhere that I'm usually going. But it's worth the detour. There's a minimal wait, a jam-packed menu, and plenty of places to sit. I usually go with a toasted everything with peanut butter. The warm, salted, and seasoned exterior melds with the creamy peanut butter, for a balanced and tasty bite. read more

See all

Bagful o bagels has't most wondrous bagels and s'rvice. The people w're very much kind spirt'd bagel cameth out v'ry fastly

Award noteworthy freshly made on-site bagels and other baked goods. Consistently service with great hospitality and pride. A few tables and chairs for those who wish to dine in, no frills, but the food is why you come here. Have not had any of their sandwiches nor the bagel dog, but I will definitely be getting those in the near future! read more

See all

Fresh bagels and quick service. Breakfast sandwiches were hot and tasty. Coffee was good too. Great place to stop for morning breakfast.

Another really solid bagel place. Good food and good sandwiches. They offer a pretty wide variety of food. I will definitely need to find time to come back for lunch. Staff is really friendly and attentive. The bagel sandwich was tasty. Have had both the Asiago and Everything bagels and both are winners. read more

Bagful O Bagels - Delis Near Me - Lafayette, New Jersey

This was so worth the stop as we are headed back home to SC! The bagel is airy and I love the eggs being scrambled! I haven't had one of these in so long and it's awesome. One of the things I miss now that we don't live here. The employees and owner were great! Smiling faces on a Monday morning! read more

Bagful O Bagels - Yum! Taylor ham, egg, cheese, SPK on a toasted everything bagel! - Delis Near Me - Lafayette, New Jersey

Friendly service with a good product as opposed to the slave station down the road. Stop there the food is good too...

Is it cheating on your bagel shop if you're over 40 minutes away? I'd like to hope not! We stopped at Bagful of Bagels on the way back from our excursion to Stokes State Forest to fill up on artesian water. Until the day before, I had no idea that was a thing people did, but am glad my friend brought me along for the ride! Bagful of Bagels can compete with the rest of them, I guess if you're in the tri-state, you can expect the bagels to be good! read more

Everything so good. Fast friendly service. A must stop when in the area! My favorite stop of our trip.

Great spot. Fantastic bagels and their sandwiches are outstanding. I was really impressed. Nice people too.

Walked into this cute little bagel shop. The oldies colorful vibe brought a smile to my face. the chairs reminded me of my grandmas house, which was a sweet memory! The girl who helped us was so patient and kind. She had the best smile & amazing costumer service! The prices are unbeatable and the food was cooked to perfection. It was a treat coming here! Also don't leave without taking a selfie with the selfie frame! read more

Bagful O Bagels - Delis Near Me - Lafayette, New Jersey

Hangry and fed up looking for a breakfast sandwich and a cup of Joe: All the way queens NY, 718 we found the perfect bagel place. Service was too knotch, baked goods and bagels were bomb diggity. Nothing beats the dollar$ lemon bars and fudgie brownies!!! The tie dye shirts were so funky fresh and really added to the colorful vibe of this joint! I recommend everyone to stop by for the amazing breakfast sandwich special $3.50 for a bacon, egg and cheese - how can you beat that? read more

Bagful O Bagels - Delis Near Me - Lafayette, New Jersey

Best bagel place around the area, and they have plenty of breakfast options. Great prices as well. I usually get the burritoful with beef or the taylor egg ham and cheese when I come here. Love their coffee; it's better than dunkin Servers are so polite. This is my favorite bagel shop since I moved in the area! read more

We get our bagels there always. They are the Best and service is great! Love getting the 15 bagel dozen.

Some of the best bagels I have ever eaten, especially the pumpernickel bagel. It was perfect - crispy on the outside and chewy on the inside. I am from the West Coast where it is impossible to find a good bagel. Visiting the area, I noticed the packed parking lot and went in on a whim. I'm happy that I did! Would recommend. read more

Friendly, helpful staff. Little or no wait. Fair prices. Good food and menu. I drive out of my way to come here as opposed to the bagel Station so I don't have to wait forever and usually get poor service over there. read more

Where to go if you prefer crispy over doughy bagels. Staff is always friendly and quick.

Really glad I finally tried this place! I'm closer to Adams bagels but I'd rather drive here! Variety of bagels- I had wheat and my husband got everything wheat which were both pretty good! I ordered the Mouth Full- 2 eggs, tater tots, bacon, Taylor ham, and sausage! Holy moly a lot but really tasty! Bacon was crispy which I love. Young and hard working employees that didn't slow down the entire time we were there. Also couldn't resist getting apple crumb cheesecake bar was also delicious! Very creamy and fresh. I saw they also make pies which I will return for! Would definitely suggest going here. Pleasant experience read more

Bagful O Bagels - Mouth full bagel - Delis Near Me - Lafayette, New Jersey

See all

Best Bagel place ever! Staff is great and kind. They deserve to be one of the best in the country! read more

Bagful O Bagels - Delis Near Me - Lafayette, New Jersey

Have been to this place many times and usually don't have a problem, however this time they gave me bacon in my sandwich which tasted absolutely rancid and made me almost throw up. It's smelled terrible and now I have a headache. If you like rancid bacon and racism I suggest you go to this place. Not even going to mention their patronizing signs over the covid pandemic or their blatant disregard for human life. read more

Amazingly delicious. We got breakfast sandwiches that were fantastic. The bacon was crunchy and awesome. I got the butter cookies, a brownie, and some of the chocolate bark and everything was so freakin good. We will def be back!! read more

I'm writing this review expressly because I moved away, and this is among the bagel shops I miss the MOST. I grew up in northern NJ and discovered this bagel shop shortly before college. Every time I visited home, I'd make the trek to Lafayette and try a different flavor. The classic Taylor ham egg and cheese is so good here. Bagels are your typical north Jersey bagel, which is to say that they're DELICIOUS. Fluffy, but with a bite. Great texture. They've got the boiled sheen on the outside. Flavored bagels are well made. Toppings are flavorful but not overpowering. Coffee is good too. Workers were always friendly. I miss this place. I'm literally sitting here eating a North Carolina bagel, wishing it was from Bagful O Bagels. read more

Very good bagels in a shop where you can see the dough mixing - like you're walking into an active bakery - because you are! Good variety and quicker service than Bagel Station down the street (I'm a fan of both). Also has a larger seating area if that's your thing in bagel places. Personally I'm not. FYI - a dozen bagels = 15 here, so you can try something out to go with your regular order. Great crumb cake too! read more

Been coming here since a was in high school and I'm almost 30. I probably bought the owner a car by now on THEC at a time. I still live in Sparta but the complete opposite end. I will gladly pass the multiple bagel shops I pass so I can eat bagful. It doesn't matter who answers the phone or takes my order, each person is more polite than the next. One day I'll try something other than a bagel sandwich I promise. Please don't change a thing. read more

So many bagels!!!!!! My favorite were the blueberry and the whole wheat. They were speedy and very nice. read more

Bagful O Bagels - Delis Near Me - Lafayette, New Jersey

Two years and three months since my first 5 star review and it's still the place with the best bagels, nicest staff and we still haven't been disappointed. read more

Good place for bagels. Nice hard textured bagels on the outside and soft on the inside. Nice people. The owners work very hard and are great people. Support them!! read more

Best bagels in town by far! Family owned and friendly service. Personally love everything bagels and theirs does not disappoint! Coffee is also fresh and good read more

I really like the bagels here, however, I gave it only 3 stars because of their choice of a paper bag for the bagels. After keeping the bagels in a bag for just a day, it dried out and was almost inedible. Needless to say, most of them went to waste. It would still be "Bagful of Bagels" of they used a plastic bag and would stay moist longer rather than a brown paper bag. I haven't really had anything else here so I cannot really comment. I will update if I go here again. read more

Really loved the HUGE freshly baked onion bagel with delicious tuna fish, crunchy celery and onions! Savored this huge tasty bagel sandwich till Route 80! It came with a side of macaroni salad with peppers and lots of mayonnaise and a pickle on the side. Good cup of coffee too. Be back when I come up to north Jersey again! read more

Best bagels in the area! Great service and bagels are fresh. Prices are also very good! I would have given 5 stars if I'm basing it only on Sussex county but being a nj native I definitely am biased on bagels! read more

My favorite bagel place around. Love their cinnamon walnut cream cheese on a raisin bagel. Fast service. Always friendly too. Love being able to sit in if I wanted to as well. Coffee always made fresh and better than anywhere else around. read more

Friendly staff, great food! Was pleasantly surprised to learn they had a massive menu! More then just bagels! The place is very clean as well, which is a major plus. read more

Second breakfast sandwich I got from there and found an egg shell in it :( the rolls are good.

I'm very sad to report that one of my favorite local Deli / Bagel shops has today revealed they are not interested in the safety of their customers. While waiting to pickup my order, I noticed an unmasked customer literally hanging into and around the owner and staff joking and milling around near the bagel production area. There was approximately four to five other customers, all wearing masks, in the shop. When I asked him where his mask was, he reached in his pocket and defiantly held it up to show me. I asked him why it wasn't on his face and he became irate with me... asking me if I was a Democrat? The owner was witnessing this exchange and instead of demanding that the person put on his mask... I was asked to leave. The owner of this establishment has no right to endanger the lives of each patron and the families and friends of these patrons. Please try to remember this place is definitely unsafe when deciding where to eat. You will no doubt be risking your life and the lives of your loved ones and friends. read more

Great place. good food and friendly . Go there at least once a week. Bring bagels to work for my co-workers all the time. And from sussex county! read more

Best Bagels outside of Brooklyn NYC. Seriously delicious, surprised of the shape and taste , coming back here every time I am in PA.

This place is terrible. Bagels suck, food sucks. Won't be back. Not much else to say. I've tried it a few times, haven't liked it yet. Too much competition around to throw my money away at this crap. read more

Great place to grab breakfast or lunch sandwiches or bagels in general. They also have bagel dogs which have always been a favorite of mine. read more