Highly disappointed in their pricing. I paid 15 dollars for this and the sandwich is far from great. Won't be coming here again. read more

Bagels On the Hill - Bagels Near Me - Landing, New Jersey

Ordered a western omelet. When i got back to work i realized that the omelet only had ham. NO ONIONS, NO PEPPERS, NO CHEESE...REALLY? And they had the nerve to charge me $14. never again! read more

Bagels were good, but the service was very unwelcoming, they messed up my sandwich order, and gave me far less turkey than the other sandwiches in my order. Prices listed inside were lower than we actually were charged. Italian Melt panini was not actually pressed; was just made like a sandwich. Not sure I'll return. read more

Bagels On the Hill - Turkey on an Everything Bagel - Bagels Near Me - Landing, New Jersey

Bagels were mediocre, one step above grocery store. Not sure what's changed but quality has gone way down

Now as a chef myself I have to say this place rocks. The food is made to order fresh ingredients the workers always greets you with a smile respectful the place is always clean. It's 5 minutes from my boro Hopatcong love this place never let me down. Especially my pastrami egg and cheese sautéed onions and Mayo best breakfast and lunch spot anywhere. read more

I give this bagel shop credit! Since I moved to landing they have been there and where they're located throughout the years it has gotten like a ghost town. But they have held on with the same great tasting bagels and same faces (in the back). If it wasn't for my metabolism I'd be there daily. Support our local town Restaurants they are the true gems. And for the price it's so worth it!! I usually get a Taylor Ham (pork roll whatever) with egg and cheese on an everything bagel. Ughh I'm hungry now .... If you haven't had them go for it!! If you have go have some more. Enjoy! read more

Bagels On the Hill - Inside store - Bagels Near Me - Landing, New Jersey

I asked if I could use the rest room and I was very rudely told no. Even though I had a bagel. The bagel was ok, nothing to write home about. Many of the stores are closed in this mini mall. I was well dressed and asked as gentlemen. Stores that don't let ordinary people use their restroom are not good to go to. Period. read more

Pretty good bagels @ Bagels On the Hill. Family lives nearby and this is "the" bagel shop for the traditional Sunday morning bagels. There's a wide variety, including all the classics and a few modern-day combinations (like black russian) that would make my Jewish grandma say "huh?". Bagels are fresh, but smaller than I've seen. It seems like they have gotten smaller here over the years. Service is quick, and the place is busy, so expect to wait a few minutes. It's a solid bagel shop, and good for a dozen for Sunday breakfast or a sesame with a shmear on the way to work. read more

Bagels On the Hill - Bagels & lox - Bagels Near Me - Landing, New Jersey

Tasty good ingredients and amazing and wonderful and nice and clean and nice what more can I say

I recently moved to Hopatcong NJ and was looking for a good Bagel place when I found one Called pops but they were not very good so I found a jewel called Bagles on the Hill well they got my order wrong twice so I gave them another chance and let me tell you they went above and beyond paid for my food and I will keep on going to them until I move they will be my go too love love love love this place! read more

Bagels On the Hill - a hand holding a sandwich - Bagels Near Me - Landing, New Jersey

See all

Excellent bagels! Toasted to perfection and taste. Great and fast take out service! Bravo!

Mo is the best. His cooking skills are top notch and superb. My family loves the bagels and I love the breakfast burrito. Give this place a try read more

Really good bagels BUT they refuse to toast them! I always specify to and they say "ok," then I get home and see it's not toasted even a little! Fresh out of the oven is not the same as toasted. Some people like them a little crispier. read more

Bagels On the Hill - a half eaten bagel - Bagels Near Me - Landing, New Jersey

Just rude people, especially the older woman who works there. She put her hand up to my wife's face when she went to order because she wasn't done putting in mine yet. That's disrespectful on many levels. Lucky I have been to anger management classes and can control myself these days. NEVER going back here again. 20 years of putting up with it because it was close. No more. read more

I've recently moved into the area. Growing up in Jersey and having the best of the best in bagels at my fingertips, it didn't take me long to find the best bagel place around here. Bagels On the Hill beat out all the other guys by far! Take it from a bagel connoisseur, nobody makes them any better than this. read more

Thé staff at this establishment does NOT wear gloves. No one in the kitchen wears gloves. We witnessed everyone cooking, touching bagels, utensils, raw taylor ham, containers of raw eggs with NO GLOVES and then serving the food they made. Esp during this time of covid -- y'all should prob be wearing gloves. Please do not eat here. read more

Every time I've gone and picked up my breakfast or had it delivered through door dash, the sandwiches are consistently delicious! Friendly staff and short wait times when I'm in the shop. Otherwise delivery is also pretty quick. The sandwiches aren't the biggest but you can add extra meat etc. depending on your preference. I would recommend them! read more

Bagels On the Hill - Sausage, egg and cheese on a Kaiser roll - Bagels Near Me - Landing, New Jersey

Multiple times have called my order ahead of time, atleast 20 minutes and still end up in the shop waiting for my order. I've gotten several everything bagels toasted with butter and yet they put basically no butter. Always a line, always waiting. I give up on this place. read more

If only I could leave a 1/2 star, I would. We moved to the area about 2 years ago this May 5th. We discovered many places in the area that we like. Bagels on the Hill is not one of them. To be honest, the place is quite filthy. Just look as you enter at the walls, and the baseboards. Crud all over. While you're waiting, you have time to see it all in the little standing room at the front. I try not to look at it when I've gone there because sadly, they are about the only game in town (this has changed and I'll get to that at the end). Once you get past the filth, the bagels are good, made the old fashioned way. However the real problem is the attitude of the workers. They really are quite rude and it's off putting. But my family and I have dealt with it. The most recent time was this past Sunday. I went in for a simple toasted bagel with butter. The short girl, a little chubby was maybe half friendly but what annoys me is as my bagel popped up out of the toaster she started to prepare it, but kept turning around to talk to a customer that they obviously know very well. I'm like the only other person waiting and she did this several times. Pausing to say a word or too. I'd like to get in and get out because this order was for my daughter who would be leaving for work within 10 minutes of my return. I felt like saying to the girl, "the most important customer you have, is the one you're dealing with at the moment." But why bother? They are always like this. Just not friendly service from ANY of the counter people. They act as if THEY are doing you a service. I'm sure they are aware that they are the ONLY game in town, BUT this has changed as someone opened up a Bagel place in a much more convenient location now. So you would think that they would be on their toes and greet people in a more friendly manner. And I will tell you this, other people must have stopped going to Bagels on the Hill because I noticed they are not as busy as before. My message to the owner, you make good bagels, but your place is filthy, and your workers both young and old need to respect the customer's and treat them friendly, and with a smile. I'm going to POP's. (i'll review them next) read more

I will no longer be coming here. it's unfortunate that this place has potential but the one lady has to drag down the customer service. The lady was not only rude on the phone (almost every time I call), but she told me i had a weird order. This place needs to hire more friendly people like the southern gentleman that works here. read more

I love this place! Totally has that mom and pop feel. Everyone who works there is super friendly, polite, and efficient. The food is consistently delicious and the orders are always accurate! Great job, Bagels on the Hill! read more

My fiancé and I love the bagels here!! Friendly staff and quick service!!! And the everything bagels are awesome!!!

I order every Saturday The egg and cheese on a bagel with an orange juice. So good. And they are now available on Uber Eats read more

100% without a doubt the best bagels in the area. Their Taylor ham, egg & cheese sandwiches are top notch and this is coming from someone who's sampled many many different varieties in the area. Even their traditional subs and sandwiches are great. Nothing not to like here read more

Good bagels, lots of beverage options, easy to get to. Parking can be tough, but there is a maternity parking spot that is usually open. I am a 27 year old fetus so I figure I am eligible for the spot. Service is efficient and friendly, they take orders over the phone which is nice. There are some cool historic pictures of the area which are interesting to look at while waiting. read more

Just your average neighborhood bagel spot. Nothing worth seeking out as a go-to destination for anything special. The bagels are good, the taylor ham egg and cheese are decent, and the lines are always long on a saturday and sunday morning. read more

Great bagels and friendly staff! My daughter loves going in and seeing everyone! Delicious bagels, cookies, muffins, and pies during thanksgiving! read more

Went today for bagels to this shop. First thing that tipped me off was the aroma of a bagel shop while growing up. That smell of bread and bagels - unmistakably exciting. The next was the metal cages that were empty of almost every popular variety (plain, everything etc). The good news was that the many people that were standing and had ordered were also waiting for plain, everything or breakfast sandwiches. A hot spot indeed! As soon as the bagels were slid off of the pizza style spatula into their respective cages, my order was prepped. I got one dozen a pound of plain cream cheese. When I returned home, the paper bag was wet and had to be torn open to get to he bagels - a testament to the condensation and oven fresh bagels. When I asked the family how they were, they didn't talk, just opened their eyes wide and gave me a thumbs up- my new go to place. Their mouths were too stuffed with bagels and cream cheese - hilarious! read more

Bagels On the Hill - Condensation from the hot dozen 'melted' the bag so we had rip it open. - Bagels Near Me - Landing, New Jersey

See all

Great bagel shop but every time the owner isn't there, my sandwich arrives missing a component (ketchup, egg, etc). Come on guys, help him out a little more and take pride in the product your putting out. read more

Got four bagels with butter, a large coffee for me and a coke for the wife all for under 11 dollars. Service was fast. No waiting. The smell of the bagels being made was evident when I pulled into the parking lot. Saw the local law enforcement in the parking lot on their break. So you know Bagels on the Hill are doing it right. I saw the gentleman in the back making bagels, he was quite friendly. The bagels were great. read more

This place has pretty good bagels. However their muffins are amazing! My only gripe is that their staff can be a little rude at times. Otherwise great place. read more

This was my favorite breakfast place growing up!!! I will never forget their amazing breakfast sandwiches!!! I think they have the best taylor ham around and still do. Bacon, egg, cheese, and taylor ham on everything bagel with mayo is my favorite of all time! read more

We ordered through doordash and we did not receive our full order. When we called to fix it they said "we can bring it to you later" what good will it do us later if our food is here now? Very poor service I'm disappointed. read more

Best bagels in town. Food is amazing. the cook is very fast and very professional. I try to go every Monday and Friday's... keep up the good work read more

Best bagels around this area. Always travel there and pass other bagel shops on the way. Consistently great bagel sandwiches!

Great spot for coffee, bagels and sandwiches. Wheat everything bagels are the best around. Scallion cream cheese is a stand out. Great service from a family owned small business. Support them! read more

Place is overpriced , , Chicken Salad on bagel = $7.58. A couple days after , I stopped with my brother (not my choice) got a couple of bagels with spread , one egg sandwich two drinks and it was over $32.00 and no receipt .....Not to mention , the woman taking our order walked away in the middle of it and left an old guy to finish the order!! Place is the pits...... read more

We ordered something on the phone and when we got here to pick it up they said "we don't have an order." So we then called the same number standing outside the entrance and they answered the phone and they said they didn't have the order. So I will never be going here again, but there is a really nice pizza place down the street! Go there instead. read more

They have great bagels here! This is the only place in the area that I will get bagels from, and I drive about 10 minutes just to come here.

I'd love to give them more stars but they don't seem to grasp the concept of lightly spread butter or cream cheese. The bagels and other bakery items are quite good, but it's so frustrating and gross to have to clean up the globs of excess cream cheese and butter. read more