FANTASTIC pizza! Trying to get away from the big & small chains, we stumbled upon this mom & pop-style neighborhood gem and wow, were we glad! We tried a single crust and a double crust. The single wasn't cracker-thin, just normal, but good texture, not soggy or greasy or hard/dry, very fresh and the ingredient quality and quantity were both excellent. Double-crust was exactly that: somewhere between thin & pan, also very generous. Silly us, we ordered the same toppings on both but next time will branch out more. Service was timely, ready upon arrival as ordered, and friendly. Not cheap but worth it for the quality. We will we back next time! read more

Excellent cracker thin crust pizza! Just learned they deliver too! Been going here for almost 40 years

Double Decker pizza is our favorite. We drive 30 min to pick it up. Looks are deceiving. The pizza is great!

I'll start off with I can only be honest with my experience and the food quality and the taste of the food I had - I was completely taken back after reading good reviews of this pizza, which were outstanding, my opinion - well below average tasting, I certainly won't be back ! Lack of flavor in - crust, sauce, cheese & sausage, lack of sauce, cheese & sausage compared to some of the local competition, I'm only being honest, service was good and pizza was hot, no issue there just pizza not so good. read more

Word of mouth recommendation was totally worth it. I've lived in Warrenville for some time and have been wanting to try this. Delicious thin crust. Great flavor in the sauce. Slightly hidden off Rt 59. Longer wait time so call ahead. Slightly higher prices but you can taste it in the quality. read more

This is a hole in the wall pizza spot. It looks like a run down old dine in pizza place, but don't let that discourage you because the pizza is good! It is now pick up only, the dining area is closed off. It usually takes about 30 minutes, so call in your order. read more

Ordered from here for the first time last week, kept it simple, 1/2 sausage, 1/2 pepperoni. The pizza was excellent! Cracker-like crust, great savory sauce, good amount of toppings! I will definitely be ordering from Arnie's again my for great, tavern style, thin crust pizza read more

Awesome thin crust pizza! Highly recommended if looking for a new place. Recently moved to Warrenville and very happy with the find.

Best pizza around. They don't deliver to my area and I pass several pizza places that do, on my way to pick a pizza from Arnie's. Best cracker thin crust in the area. Villa Nova quality. read more

Best pizza around. Hands down. If they delivered to Naperville I'd order once a week minimum.

Pizza is good but place is very dirty inside. Makes me wonder? Not sure I want to order anymore from there. read more

Found Arnies Pizza by mistake. The outside or inside nothing to attract you but the pizza is really awesome! Great crust, lots of cheese, and toppings. I would highly recommend if you're looking for a great thin pizza. Could become one of your favorites. read more

Hands down the best pizza I've ever eaten. I've had pizza in Chicago, New York, Italy and lots of other places and all those places have terrific pizza. This pizza is the best because the crust is thin and crackery like no other. The pepperoni is perfectly cooked and packed with flavor. The cheese is well-balanced - just the right amount. The other thing that makes this place great is the consistency. I've gotten pizza here for close to 15 years and it never disappoints. Huge credit to the owners who focus on just making great pizza and not trying to sell a bunch of other stuff and be something they are not. read more

Best best pizza ever!!!!!! Thin crust best sausage and owner Brian is awesome! read more

OMG! Major attitude problems. Okay I been ordering take out for years from this place and they never really treated me with the utmost respect but they had decent pizza. However after the way I was treated when I phoned to place an order for delivery I can honestly tell you I won't ever be ordering anything from them again! There are plenty of pizza places in Warrenville who don't treat their loyal customers like second class citizens. If there's one thing I've learned about the restaurant business it's customer is king and word of mouth is extremely important. After the manner in which I was dismissed by some unprofessional jerk I was turned off and will never order anything from them again. You have my word. You've been warned folks!!! read more

This is the best pizza place around! I wish they had it by my house. We get pizza when I visit my boy friend in Warrenville. This place rocks!!! Pizza night don't get it too often but every time I am in warrenville I wo't pass it up! The best thin crust pizza in the Chicago are hands down! read more

Classic "Old School" style pizza joint serving a perfect thin/cracker crust pie. Almost too perfect as the crust can dominate your taste buds at times. Why's that you ask? Because the perfectly Sweet Italian Sausage is rather sparsely distributed offering minimal contrast of taste, most of the time. And that leaves us with the perfectly tasty pizza sauce that forms a visible ring around the outer edge...and only the outer edge, all of the time. But, somehow it all comes together... every time! read more

See all

Arnie's is the jam.. family/I have been ordering pizza from there for years. if I ever move out of Warrenville I'll probably have pizza withdrawal. read more

Still the best pizza joint around. Delicious pizza and amazing owners. Cracker thin crust served hot and fresh, what's not to love?

First time ordering pizza here-- the large size pizza looks like a medium compared to the other pizza places I ordered from. Pizza taste ok. read more

Best crust in town. Owner takes pride in his pizza and it shows. Do yourself a favor and check it out. Ask him for a chefs special, he's got some great recipes. read more

They have lost my business. I called and made a request due to a situation. He claims he "cannot make a pizza for me". I repeated it, and he hung up on me. In the day and age when EVERY customer is important, a tiny request that is basically nothing should be honored. I don't see this place being around much longer with that service attitude. I found another place happily willing to accommodate me. And they have earned my business. read more

Love pizza. Love this place. Best in the area. Thin crust Fairly priced, May be a little on the high side, but the quality is top notch. If you are someone that enjoys a good cheese sauce dough ratio, Arnies is the place. Friendly staff, quick service even on weekends. read more

Does anybody ever eat inside? Dine in? The past 3 times we have called, there is always an excuse why we can't eat our pizza there. The air conditioning is broke The dining room is closed Tonight it was no heat..... Starting to think they don't want dine ins. read more

Great thin crust pizza. Think cracker crust. So they don't let you eat in. So they don't deliver far. That's how it goes and it's a great pizza. Get in your car, go pick it up, go home and eat that bad boy up! read more

For thin crust pizza this is the place! Arnie's Pizza vs. the rest of the western 'burbs. Arnie's wins hands down. Right amount of sauce (even though I could drink it by the gallon), cheese and toppings all laying neatly on the best pizza crust ever! You know it's crispy when you are waiting ever so patiently and your ears hear them cutting through the "crispiness" of your pie into the most glorious little pieces that will soon be consumed. On a side note; I hate to complain about fellow yelpers, but I'm sorry Joe E. "Pizza Expert" (Reviewer from 2011); "Ordered the Double Decker, assuming it would be similar to a Chicago-Style stuffed pizza. I was disappointed because when I opened the box, the pizza had cheese on the top layer. Pizza experts like myself know this is not stuffed or deep dish, so I was a bit upset. You call yourself an Expert of Pizza....from the Chicago area....and think a double decker = Chicago Deep Dish? COME ON MAN! read more

This place is a little bit difficult to find cuz it is at the end of a little strip mall and is not readily seen from the street. However, it is definitely worth taking the time to find it. The pizza had a ton of toppings...obviously, they do not skimp here. The sauce was tasty and not too salty. The sausage was perfect. It is a small place, so if they get busy they do not use the dining room cuz they do not have servers. Crust was crispy and topping went to the end of the pizza. Can't wait to go back...YUM!!! read more

Ordered the Double Decker, assuming it would be similar to a Chicago-Style stuffed pizza. I was disappointed because when I opened the box, the pizza had cheese on the top layer. Pizza experts like myself know this is not stuffed or deep dish, so I was a bit upset. The pizza was two thin crusts stacked on top of each other, with a hand rolled crust. The crust was definitely the saving grace for this pizza. It lacked sauce which was a disappointment. The restaurant is located in Warrenville, and is about 20 mins from my house. I probably won't try again unless I'm looking for a thin crust pizza, and I have a coupon of some sort. The prices are reasonable, but this place is nothing spectacular. It's solid; something you can count on, but nothing you look forward to. One final note: PUT MORE SAUCE ON THE PIZZA! It's a good sauce, but it was seriously lacking on my order. read more

We ate in on a Monday night. We chose Arnie's because Al's is closed on Monday's. Let me be up front, the atmosphere of Arnie's is not very good when compared to Al's. Essentially, it is a take out operation that has added 5 booths. The booths are nice but in desperate need of repair. The system is much the same as Al's. You order at the counter and they bring your pizza out too you. The service was friendly and prompt. The folks running the place seemed very friendly and helpful. Now, as for the pizza, it was very good! Just like it's Warrenville rival, it is a cracker style crust. The ingredients seemed to be fresh. They make their own sauce (witnessed this process myself). The one thing I didn't like was they seemed to take the pizza out just a little to soon. While there was a ton of quality pepperoni on the pizza, it never had a chance to crisp up or gt some of those tasty carbonized edges. I know this is a matter of personal preference, but for me, this is a key element to pepperoni pizza. All in all, this is the second best pizza in the suburbs. They lose a star for broken tables and taking the pizza out to early. read more

Our go to pizza place, wish they delivered to north naperville, but the drive to pickup pizza is not that bad. Great cracker thin crust pizza, perfect amount of sauce. read more

Couldve been a B+ has the sauce not been so skimpy on the Lg bacon & pineapple pizza I picked up today for $23. Id rate a solid 3.75 otherwise if there was that option. read more

Went here for the first time and was very impressed. The mushrooms were fresh and crust awesome. Will definitely be back and recommend it

Thin crust heaven. This pizza is just plain awesome. The edges are crispy the sauce is tasty and the topping are plentiful. You need to go here. read more

This is a hidden gem. I ate this pizza growing up and any opportunity my family and I get to go back to warrenville, we love getting arnies. Their cheese pizza and the sauce they use is on point. They also have one of the best Mexican pizzas I've had. Their garlic bread is wonderful too. read more

Pretty good pizza! Comparable to the pizza at Roma D'italia down the street. You get these pizza points / dollars for each pizza you order which adds up to a free pizza when you have enough. Pretty good deliver area too and reasonable prices. read more

Here we go, see that picture of the booths? They need to remove that because they are NEVER AVAILABLE!!! I used to live in Warrenville and frequented Arnie's quite often because they had a pretty good pie. I have been there twice in the last month or so with my Family and we were told the dining room is CLOSED! I asked the owner why and he responded he was basically alone so he closes the dining room. What a genius business decision to turn about 25-50 people away a night that want to put money in your pocket. I was pissed this 2nd go around and the guy tells me "then you should have known better and called ahead". Look Dumbass, are you running a F****** business or not? If this is your attitude then sell the business to someone who gives a Shit!!! Better yet, hire a high school kid for $7.50 an hour and utilize all your space you're paying for every month....NOT rocket science is it! read more

Best pizza ever! I had to take one on a plane to Florida for my daughter. No other pizza even comes close.

Pretty solid pizza, crispy crust for sure. I prefer Al's, but this place is still pretty darn good.

Always love Arnie's pizza. Not too greasy, the thin crust is great. I don't have to wait long for it to be ready. Best pizza in the 'Ville

Quick service, fair prices, and delicious as hell. Arnies Pizza makes the kind of classic cracker-thin crust, tavern cut pizza that everyone in the Chicago area grew up eating. This is real Chicago pizza. Not the touristy deep dish that you get with your out-of-town friends. read more