Arnie's Pizza

For a small dive bar / Pizza joint this place is not to be skipped over ! we were in Naperville…read morefor hockey one parent found this place 10 mins away. we walked in one hour before close - they accepted us but said we have one hour until close ! The pizza was phenomenal nice krispy crust the cheese was slightly cooked more then most places and made it stand out it's really too bad we all live an hour away or this would be our new staple hands down don't sleep on this place .

This is my favorite pizza spot whenever I'm in the Warrenville area. They have indoor seating and a…read morebar area. I always get mine to go. It's a very popular spot. So we had to wait for an hour. To receive our pizza but its definitely worth the wait. Second time here. Pizza was as delicious as I remember it years ago. Family owned with a good reputation. This pizza is thin crust which I prefer to be able to taste more of my toppings then dough. So if you're looking for a deep dish thick crust. You would need to go elsewhere. I know they have a customer right here. Enjoyed every bite. We had leftover pizza the next day. We just put it in the oven and it was good to go.

More inconsistency

See all

Louie's Pizza

4.6(103 reviews)

5.9 mi

When I order pizza, I typically go for the same 2 or 3 places. This night I wanted to try something…read moredifferent. I saw that Louie's had good reviews and it wasn't far from where I lived, so I thought why not? I ordered online and it was easy to navigate. It was ready when I got to the restaurant. Keep in mind there is no seating here, so it is just for take out. I got a thin crust pepperoni and sausage. It was very good and the cheese had a nice taste to it. I do wish the crust was a bit crispier but that was my only complaint. Would order again!

Chicken gyro is fire - way better meat quality than expected, super fresh and crunchy and chilled…read morelettuce and onion, great grilled pita bread. Good tzatziki and feta. Much better quality than expected, zero grease. Why on earth eat a sub next door when this exists?! The gyro and grill items seem to be where it's at. I will come back and try the crepes, too.

Interior with owner

Thin crust cheese/ sausage. Sauce is dynamite.

See all

Gianorios Pizza

4.7(153 reviews)

4.7 mi

Simply the best pizza around. Always cooked perfectly. Great ingredients. No way to improve (other…read morethan maybe offer delivery, but I get why they don't). And their frozen pizzas are the best frozen I have ever had! And I've tried many different frozen pizzas... And did I mention their desserts!?

Local hidden gem! Best pizza around this area- different worth a try. Pizza quality is consistent…read moreevery time we order. Desserts are great. Staff very friendly.

Best pizza I have have ever eaten by far!

Vegetable Pizza

See all

Garden salad

Milanos Pizza

3.3(3 reviews)

0.2 mi

Milanos Pizza is brand new to Warrenville and located in a plaza. My husband and I decided to…read moresupport this new and locally owned business during their opening week. We were looking to have a date night in and placed an order for pick up/carry out. They are in the process of completing their online ordering platform so we placed an order via phone instead. The staff member that took the call offered a 5% discount which I found nice. They currently have higher promotions on their printed menus so we used a 15% discount instead. We tried their 12 inch veggie supreme pizza and their baked mostaccioli. The pizza was decent - my husband said he liked their crust since it was on the chewy side. I personally thought it was just OK, it lacked flavor for me. We both agreed that the ingredients and the cheese they use for the pizza is great. The baked mostaccioli was a big miss for the both of us. It lacked seasoning and we don't really consider what we received a baked mostaccioli.The sauce was not mixed with the noodles and it lacked the baked appearance. Unfortunately it looked as if everything was all thrown in a container and packed up. We probably won't order pasta from here again but we are happy we tried it.

Not bad, ordered a Milanos special and swapped mushrooms for olive and it was good. Did the chicken…read morewings dry with xtra side sauce. Very accommodating. I'll be back.

Outside

12 inch veggie pizza

See all

Baked mostaccioli

Rosati's Pizza

3.6(39 reviews)

0.1 mi

It's been a hot minute since I've had Rosati's and I'm glad that dry spell is finally broken. My…read morehusband and I had a busy weekend and were not in the mood to cook dinner for a Sunday night. This specific location brought their A++++ game. They sent us a free 16" 1 topping welcome pizza coupon that we greatly appreciated. We weren't able to place the carry out order online, however, they did accept the coupon over the phone. The staff member that took the call radiated with positive energy. He welcomed us to the neighborhood and got our order in right away. My husband picked up our order and said this location appears to be a carry out/delivery spot only. I meannnnn, I like to ugly face eat pizza in peace so I'm all about it, haha. We ordered a pepperoni pizza and devoured it. The crust was the perfect amount of thin and was cooked crispy. I really like how Rosati's puts their toppings in between the sauce and cheese. SO FREAKING GOOD. Everything was flavorful and we will definitely be ordering from here again.

Got some Rosatis pizza delivery for a game night with friends and thought it was alright. The pizza…read morehas the signature rosatis construction with a slightly chewy crust with light flavor, a light amount of herbs over a flavorful tomato sauce, and a generous amount of cheese. The price is reasonable and delivery was pretty quick.

Outside

See all

The Slice Spot

4.6(114 reviews)

2.2 mi

Staff are all very friendly, helpful and accommodating. Have gotten lunch here with my husband a…read morecouple of times and it's been a lovely experience each time. Pizza is always delicious and cooked to perfection! I appreciate the array of pies and slices to choose from, as well as accommodations for GF individuals.

If you could see me right now as I write you would find me in an inexplicable state of both…read moreimmense satisfaction and utter perplexity. Satisfaction at the most remarkable service and richly appointed New York Pizza. Perplexity at my inability to capture what a surprisingly enchanting place this is. After five minutes here, you feel cleansed of the noxious multinational restaurant chains that dot the landscape of our beloved western suburbs. You feel like you've come into an actual place owned by actual people with honest opinions. Our host was Nicole who was beyond kind... and Interesting... And utterly amazing. If you want delicious pizza, eat here. If you want authentic human interaction, eat here. If you want a deeply satisfying experience of actual West Suburban Chicago culture (and, yes, I appreciate the irony that it is East Coast Pizza... but trust me here), I beg you, gentle reader, eat here.

Half Jersey Pie (Pepperoni and Sausage) Half Margarita

See all

Nonno Carm's pizza & pasta

4.3(66 reviews)

6.4 mi

We placed an order for delivery. Food was delicious! Nice and warm when we brought home- our…read morefavorites were spinach calzone with marinara and the baked pasta paisano!

I can only give 1 star because I was so confused trying to order their Wednesday $15.65…read moreCarry out large cheese with one topping pizza, I didn't order here. I went to our usual Domino's. The reason we wanted to try Nonno Carm's is because we never had it before and their reviews were good. Getting back to attempting to order the special using the app, when we checked out our $15.65 pizza, we got a message that said we had to order another $4.50 in order to get the special! We didn't want to order anything else. I didn't see anywhere on the app where it said that the $15.65 price is only valid on orders greater than $20,00. That did not seem like a very special Special to me. Doubt if we will be back. Ordering a Carry out Special should not be that difficult.

Menu, prices may have changed!

See all

Nonno Carm's youngest granddaughter Gianna hard at work.. lol

Papa Ray's Pizza & Wings

3.9(30 reviews)

3.6 mi

Pretty good pizza with a unique crust. They have a lot of deals/coupons online. Got pizza and…read morewings, both were really tasty. They called us to let us know it was ready. There was also a coupon for free delivery which would come in handy with the winter weather coming up.

i like it. the fries are good. so is the calzone. came with sauce and comes in a pizza box which is…read morecool

Store front

Hand tossed pizza half sausage, mushroom and jalapeño/half cheese DELICIOUS!!

See all

Paparays Meal deal offers

Paisans Pizzeria & Bar

3.6(307 reviews)

5.4 mi

Just threw a party with 40+ people at this location and I cannot say enough great things about this…read morerestaurant! The staff was so accommodating and helpful; I had never thrown a party myself before and they made everything a breeze. Super well organized, such a fun space, and people are still raving about the food! Our server was attentive the whole time and did a great job, which is not easy with a group of that size. I absolutely recommend Paisan's for everything from a date night out to a family party. This place has you covered!

We decided to come here since the food at the Brookfield location was solid. The service was like…read moremeh. Our server Victor was gone half the time. However, when I asked for a water refill or a new plate, he got it. I would say average but not above average service. We ordered dragon fries, baked ziti, and supreme pizza with the caramelized crust. Overall this is like a 3. 3 for me is a one and done. I wanted to try a new pizza place but this was a disappointment. -dragon fries 5 - this was good. The sauce is tangy with some spice. It's not super spicy but this would go well on wings. -baked ziti 2 - I had a lot of pasta and this one was one of the worst. The noodles tasted a bit too rubbery, it should be softer. The sauce had no flavor. -supreme pizza 3 - maybe I should have gotten the tavern style because the supercharged pizza tasted doughy and kind of bland. I even reheated it on my pizza stone at home and it does taste better with a crispier crust. However, it was still mid.

Interior

Jumbo wings tossed in Paisans Sweet and Spicy Dragon Sauce

See all

Vanilla | Chocolate | Strawberry | Oreo | Banana

Gia Mia

4.3(333 reviews)

4.8 mi

My favorite Italian spot in Naperville! Definitely check it out if you're in the area. We came for…read moredinner, and there's both outdoor seating and a ginormous interior with plenty of tables. It's definitely a good spot for larger groups. Our server was also super knowledgeable about the menu and walked us through which pastas and pizzas were the most popular, which ones were seasonal, and which ones get rotated out. I really appreciated the recommendations because there were so many things I wanted to try. We ordered: - Short rib gnocchi: The short rib was extremely tender and basically disintegrated as soon as you touched it. The gnocchi paired really well with it too. - BBQ chicken pizza: We ordered both the Margherita pizza and BBQ chicken and I would definitely get the BBQ chicken again. The sauce had the perfect amount of tanginess and savory flavor without overpowering the pizza. - Chicken parmigiana: Don't skip this! The chicken had the perfect amount of savory flavor and worked so well with the tomato sauce and vodka rigatoni. This ended up being one of my favorites of the meal. I was so glad we were able to order and try so many different dishes. This is definitely a family-style kind of spot, so if you come with a larger group, you'll get to try a lot more options. Already looking forward to coming back and trying more of their rotating dishes!

3-Star Review - Gia Mia…read more The food and overall experience were worth recommending, but unfortunately, our first interaction with the hostess/greeter was disappointing. The Hispanic woman with long hair who greeted us seated us at a table right by the entrance. We politely asked if another table was available because we preferred not to sit directly in the path of people coming in and out. She rolled her eyes and walked away without saying a word. When another table finally became available, she brought us over, and we both thanked her about twice. She wouldn't even look at us or acknowledge our thanks and simply walked away. Her attitude came across as very rude and unwelcoming, and it left a bad first impression. On the other hand, our waitress was wonderful! She was kind, polite, and welcoming, and she did an excellent job throughout our experience. She deserves recognition for her great service. I would still recommend Gia Mia, but I hope management addresses the importance of hospitality with the greeting staff. The hostess is often the first person customers interact with, and unfortunately, this experience made us feel unwelcome before we even had a chance to enjoy our meal. Everyone deserves to be treated with courtesy and respect, especially when making a simple, polite request. It would have been 5 stars if it weren't for that first interaction!

Dining area

Brussel sprouts

See all

Chicken Parmesan (December 2024)

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

6 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

John W.

16 years ago

Arnie's is hands-down the best thin crust pizza in the area. If you are looking for a thin, crispy and delicious pie, go no farther than Arnie's. Try the sausage and also try their BBQ pizza...you won't be disappointed. Their pizza is excellent and has been made the same way ever since I started eating it in 1989! read more

Rick K.

200

8 years ago

Great pizza my favorite a staple in warrenville. Never had bad food here. Arnie was a great man and will be missed in Warrenville. He lives on through his pizza. read more

Mary K.

14 years ago

The pizza here is awesome! I love the crust!! However, it is pricey. Two large cheese pizzas cost me 32.00.... That is a little much if you ask me. read more

Jennifer R.

15 years ago

Best pizza! Once you eat pizza here, everything else tastes like garbage.

andy d.

16 years ago

Great Thin Crust, some of the best anywhere! I highly recommend!!!

Michael L.

165

15 years ago

Grew up with this place, great pizza

Arnie's Pizza - pizza - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Warrenville, Illinois Restaurants near Arnie's Pizza

BEST of Warrenville, Illinois Coffee near Arnie's Pizza

BEST of Warrenville, Illinois Breakfast near Arnie's Pizza

BEST of Warrenville, Illinois Desserts near Arnie's Pizza

BEST of Warrenville, Illinois Things to Do near Arnie's Pizza

BEST of Warrenville, Illinois Parking near Arnie's Pizza

BEST of Warrenville, Illinois Dinner near Arnie's Pizza

BEST of Warrenville, Illinois Burgers near Arnie's Pizza

BEST of Warrenville, Illinois Shopping near Arnie's Pizza

BEST of Warrenville, Illinois Movie Theatre near Arnie's Pizza

People found Arnie's Pizza by searching for…

Best of Warrenville

Things to do in Warrenville

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Arnie's Pizza also viewed

Al's Pizza

4.0

(356 reviews)

Gianorios Pizza

4.7

(153 reviews)

Local hidden gem! Best pizza around this area- different worth a try. Pizza quality is consistent…read moreevery time we order. Desserts are great. Staff very friendly.

Ach-N-Lou's Pizza Pub

3.7

(177 reviews)

Ach-N-Lou's Pizza is one of the best I have eaten in the Aurora area. The crust is cooked to…read moreperfection. The sauce is tomato-sweet and fresh. The toppings are generous.

Was really surprised with how good the pizza tasted. It tastes better than some of the photos if…read moreI'm being totally honest. The pizza sauce is slightly sweet, almost more so of like a marinara with really rich flavors. Two of us pointed out how much we enjoyed the sauce. Everything was hot and tasted so fresh. The drink selection was pretty bare minimum but what is expected for a pizza joint.

Sugo Mio Pizza & Pasta

(76 reviews)

Sometimes I like the convenience to get a slice or two instead of a full pizza…read more Sugo Mio was on my way home so I decided to give it a try. Great flavor and great crust! The sauce is delicious and good amount of toppings! It definitely hit the spot. Also the manager is amazing. Great customer service.

Great thin crust veggie pizza Everyone loved it from grandpa…read moreto the 3 year old grandson.

Dan's Pizza

(191 reviews)

•$

Dan's is definitely growing on me! I'm not normally a pizza person, but I'm so glad my friends…read moretalked me into trying it. We've ordered pickup for the last two UFC fight nights, and the staff have been consistently friendly, patient, and thorough when taking our order. It's clear they care about getting things right, which is especially impressive given how busy they are on weekend evenings. Excellent customer service and well worth a visit!

Dan's Pizza is the definition of a busy neighborhood classic--always people in and out, which is a…read moregood sign that locals love it. It's a quick pick-up spot, nothing fancy, but exactly what you want when you're craving pizza! The staff were super welcoming, especially since it was our first time, and they made the experience feel personal! We went with a large pepperoni & jalapeño pizza. Flavor-wise, the sauce and cheese ratio was spot-on--tangy, cheesy, and really well balanced. The crust was the real star, perfectly crispy in the middle (which is rare to find and made every bite even better). If I had to nitpick, there were a ton of jalapeños but not quite enough pepperoni to balance it out. Still, the overall taste carried the pie, and it was definitely satisfying. All in all, a solid pizza joint with great service, and I'd for sure go back to try more of the menu!

Gianorio's Pizza & Pasta

(142 reviews)

Absolutely the best pizza spot around. Never disappoints and you cant go wrong with anything on the…read moremenu!

First time at Gianorio's Pizza & Pasta!…read more I ordered pickup and it was ready in 25 minutes - fast friendly customer service. Standard pizza shop ambiance. I ordered a large cheese pizza half cheese and half buffalo chicken, order of Garlic bread, and Fried ravioli. Food was good - Worth checking out!

Pizza Cucina

4.0

(121 reviews)

First time at Pizza Cucina with my wife!…read more We have a friend who lives in Oswego so had stopped to get pizza from here. The lady who had taken my order was wonderful and very friendly and explained how the breadsticks are made fresh daily. The order was ready for pickup in less than 25 minutes! Amazing. The pizza shop has a welcoming ambiance and is very lit up. We ordered the thin crust Veggie Delight Pizza, The Double Dough Cheese Pizza, and Breadsticks. The food was absolutely delicious and tasted very fresh - I definitely recommend Pizza Cucina to all pizza lovers!!

Pretty tasty. Thin crust is ordered. Like that tavern style. Crispy cracker like. Sauce had good…read moresweetness and the sausage was good. Definitely recommend this place.

Little Italian Pizza

3.9

(214 reviews)

I genuinely love the pizza and mostcollis! The nostalgic old-school atmosphere and wonderful…read morebartenders make it a special place for me. I truly love this spot!

Been going here for 40+ years and will keep going. Same dependable tasty pizza, time after time. We…read morekeep it simple, cheese and sausage. Sometimes green pepper and mushroom. It's crust that we will eat instead of tossing.

Capri Pizza & Pasta

3.8

(89 reviews)

•$

On my way home I obtained a slice of delicious sausage pizza...surprisingly past lunch time it was…read moreavailable unlike other pizza establishments. Highly recommend!

My friends and I get Capri every single time we get together. This place is solid for thin crust…read morepizza. The sauce is slightly sweet and toppings are spread out evenly. Our regular order is the sausage and giardiniera. We also get pepperoni and that's placed below the cheese so don't freak out if you don't see it on top when you open your box! They also do gluten free here, but it's a 12" thin crust only. Clutch for my GF friends. Capri is your go to local Italian joint for pizza, but you can also get subs, sandwiches, and some other items. Good for friends and fam!

Nonno Carm's pizza & pasta