Showed up on a Tuesday afternoon(today). Was greeted with "I can only make two sandwiches because I…read moreonly have two knives", well okay, we just so happened to only need two sandwiches. We begin our order and we got to topping, they were out of three of the 4 toppings I eat, so I asked to cancel my order. This includes tomatoes, oil, and vinegar. What a let down. How can you be out of so much? The bread was slim pickings as well. Had three options and one was only a 6".

If this is the subway in the Road runner gas station thing, it was really good. I had a small…read moreveggie sub and the bread was nice, everything was fresh. The ovens were really fancy too and there was even fresh produce in actual fridges behind the counter. The lady who made our food was very efficient and nice to us. She deserves a raise honest to everything.

We love coming here! They subs are very good - I love getting them toasted. This little pizza was…read moredelish and seemed fresh. The sausage on the pizza was bomb. They also have UW Babcock ice cream in the summer which is the best ice cream! Follow me on Instagram at yelpershawn for more reviews!

Service is really good. The food has been going downhill calzone only had spoonful of pizza sauce…read morewas dry and overcooked. Also the subs I have to ask for extra lettuce because they hardly put any lettuce on a I believe that is the staple of sub. I shouldn't have to ask for extra lettuce.

The vibes are immaculate. On a day when I was feeling a little less than, the coffee was good and…read morestrong, the chai tea latte was delicious, the cran-orange scone was tasty and not too dry, and the avocado toast was flavorful and satisfying. The folks working were high energy, friendly and efficient. McFarland House Café is everything you want in a small town coffee house. If you're in the McFarland area and need to good cuppa and a tasty bite, don't sleep on this spot!

Nice small business coffee/tea shop with a lunch sandwich menu. Sandwiches were fresh and well…read moreportioned. Large drink menu along with a nice cabinet of pastries, pumpkin bars and donuts! Service was quick and friendly, order at the counter and table delivery, bus your own table. Beautiful old historic landmark building is very charming! Parking is free and plentiful, on the other side of the double railroad tracks. This is a nice lunch option if you find yourself in McFarland!

Came here for easter brunch! We all went for the buffet option. It was great! Food was delicious…read moreand everyone enjoyed it. The baked cod and steak was my favorite. We all also enjoyed the desserts. I would love to come back for their dinner/buffet options again. Highly recommend. Our waitress was super friendly as well.

I don't like giving 5 stars but this place deserves to better than a 3 star rating. They are so…read moreawesome! Even for big parties-- they welcome and take care of you properly. Love the outdoor eating area directly on the lake with plenty of watercraft parking. Inside is super Wisco tavern vibes with a pool table and separate seating on the other side for more of an intimate dining experience. Food is served hot & fresh, with lots of ranch. Only problem was the rare steak came medium well, but we had 11 people in our party and I'm sure they did their best to get everything out at the same time. It was unfortunately they left the steak on the grill too long for the dude that was paying.

My sister and I ate at Toby's last night. We arrived early and they allowed us to sit at a table…read morethat wasn't already reserved. Our waitress was fantastic, bringing everything we ordered plus more, a vegetable tray, warm buns, dessert buns and her shrimp was out of this world. My lobster tail was also out of this world and my baked potato was big enough for six, plus there was lots of butter and sour cream. The bill was surprising low, and we definitely will go back soon!!!!

We had a few days off and we went to 3 supper clubs in WI. This was a bit disappointing. The place…read moreis loud! You order at the bar and when your food is ready, you are seated. They said it would take 45 minutes but an hour later we were seated with our salad. Then another 20 minutes for our food. I didn't think the lake perch had any flavor but the shrimp was good. I would seriously debate going back just due to the long wait and the food wasn't phenomenal.

Unless your A Regular…read moredon't expect great service.. went for breakfast and food was not good.. I think the sausage links were reheated several times.. toast over Buttered by a lot, couldn't get refill on coffee unless you flagged bartender down, hash browns iffy, couldn't even get our bill without asking.. bartender was literally washing dishes Right in front of me as I stood there.. will not be back for a long time

After a beautiful fall day with my family, filled with hayrides, corn maze, pumpkin patch, and…read morecaramel apples, we stopped at a local bar and grill known for its Wisconsin charm. We filled two tables in the main dining area and just needed a third to accommodate our group. There wasn't one available in that space, so we simply asked if we could borrow a table from the adjacent banquet hall. That room was wide open, with dozens of empty tables, no signage, no setup, and nothing to suggest it was reserved or in use at any point that day. The staff refused. No explanation. Just no. We asked again. Same answer. Interestingly, another group nearby ended up with an extra table. I don't know where it came from, but it raised questions about how decisions were being made. Here is what made it hard to ignore. I have lived in Wisconsin long enough to know what normal looks like in places like this. My family does not quite match that mold. The refusal did not come with a reason. It came with a shift in tone. A kind of quiet gatekeeping that did not feel like policy. It felt selective. I am not here to accuse. I am here to ask why our request was denied when others appeared to be granted the same. Why was no reason given. And why did it feel like our presence changed the rules. Hospitality means making people feel welcome. That did not happen here.

At first glance, the place presents itself as a neighborhood dive--a worn-in local haunt where the…read moredécor is secondary to the conversation. But the illusion fades the moment a Bloody Mary arrives at the table. This is a bar that takes its craft seriously. The cocktail was thoughtfully prepared and balanced, revealing an attention to detail rarely found in establishments trading on casual charm alone. The atmosphere is equally compelling: lively without being chaotic, welcoming without feeling manufactured. It possesses the kind of authenticity that cannot be designed or replicated. In an era of increasingly curated hospitality, this remains a genuinely local gathering place--unpretentious, distinctive, and unmistakably its own.

We like our walleye and eggs for breakfast, and decided to try out the Squirrel's Nest. It is a…read moresmall establishment with a bar to the left and seating area, to the right, with two smaller tables on the side of the bar. We arrived about 10:00 am, and it was packed. It was very loud with people talking, due to the small space. We sat at our table and waited awhile for a server, but didn't know if we needed to order at the bar. After a while, a waitress arrived to take our order. She was very joyful and friendly. We both ordered the walleye and eggs, which included hashbrowns and toast. My husband added cheese and onions on the hashbrowns at no extra cost. We also ordered a Bloody Mary, which came with a chaser. They arrived with a spear of mozzarella cheese, pimento olive, smoked sausage, and a dill pickle. The walleye had a nice thin crust and the eggs and hashbrowns were cooked perfectly. My better half said that he didn't taste any onions in the hashbrowns and they used American cheese, which made them runny. It was a good breakfast, and we enjoyed our time there. However, due to the loudness, we probably won't go back, as it was hard to have a conversation. Be aware that they only take cash, but they do have an ATM in the building. This establishment definitely had a great atmosphere and service, with friendly staff.

I love the Kwik Trips, and this one is no exception. The store is very well managed, organized and…read morea pleasure in which to shop. No matter the time of day or night, this store is great. Their coffee bar is one of best around, and the staff is super professional and courteous. They are very good at remembering their regulars. Highly recommend this store, Karen, Mary and Sheila are fantastic, to name a few.

I volunteer at a meal program and once a month I order a case of bananas from Kwik Trip for the…read moresack lunches we now provide instead of our usual sit down hot meals we serve. Opps... I forgot to order them this month because I thought we had another week to do so. I called Sheila at the McFarland, Wi store and she only had green ones. She recommended I contact the Monona/Broadway store in Madison. I talked to Abby and she will save me a case of yellow ones to be picked up tomorrow morning. 50 stars for Kwik Trip!!!