Have been ordering here for a while but absolutely love the pizza here! The sausage and pepperoni thin crust pizza is my go to. The mozzarella sticks were delicious. The service was quick and easy. Price is a plus! read more

The Best stuffed pizza I've ever had... The most beautiful crust I've ever ever seen.. The most memorable thin crust I have ever tasted. Just look at the pictures...it really is as good as it looks...only better.. And if it weren't for Lily F.'s pictures, I may have never stopped here.. Yes, you were spot on Lily. The rustic flaky crust on what felt like a 7 lb. stuffed cheese pizza (with spinach & mushrooms) was indescribably delicious...the mozzarella cheese was the STAR here.... Really. flavorful. cheese. Gooey cheese. TONS of cheese. This mozzarella WAS NOT salty at all..(& I'm sensitive to salt....). Tremendous flavor...I could go on & on about Anthony's cheese... Topped with a delicate layer of fresh sauce... The fresh mushrooms were some of the best I've ever had in or on a pizza - almost tasted as if they were roasted first... gorgeous sliced mushrooms....loved these... Thin crust - All mushroom, 1/2 sausage, 1/2 pepperoni - MMMMmmmm. Crust was somewhat flaky - almost missing that dash of salt, but that made me love it even more. This was not what I consider to be a crispy crust...more chewy texture... With every bite I took - I tasted every component of this pizza separately ...everything stood out on it's own...the crust, the sauce (w/a hint of garlic), the cheese, the perfectly placed toppings... so methodically placed...I managed to get a piece of each topping with every single bite......Anthony does not overdo the toppings... Loved the flavor of this pepperoni....again, not salty... I wonder if they smuggle it from Italy... I'm still in awe of their mushrooms.....the sausage is homemade and very, very good.. This is a carryout joint, almost divey looking...it is in a small strip mall off North Ave & Roy St...(look for the big white, red striped awning..). Anthony was all alone when I picked up our order... He is the owner and was making his special pizza's....and yes, I happen to think his pizzas are truly special... Anthony is a nice, soft spoken man from Sicily - and he's one hell of a pizza maker.... If you love pizza as much as I do - your going to want to taste this... so....what are you waiting for? Lily F. & I wasted NO TIME ;) read more

Anthony's Pizzeria - Pizza Porn.. (Thin, mushroom half pepperoni, half sausage) You WANT this... @ Daniel S. - look away.. - Pizza Near Me - Northlake, Illinois

See all

We ordered a stuffed pizza (sausage and garlic) and baked cavatelli. The current picture for Anthony's does not do it justice. I hate to admit it but even when I was deciding on which pizza place to try out, I almost, ALMOST skipped this place because the photos weren't eye popping enough. Let me assure you that if the picture was in 3-D and a scratch and sniff, everyone would go here. Or you could just take my word for it. The 6 pounds of cheese, huge slices of garlic and chunks of sausage was as perfect as it could get already. But the crust was a whole other eating experience. Random fact about Lily F. No matter how awesome a pizza is, I typically do not eat the crust. I know...But most of the time it's like eating pure bread where all I really want is more cheese and toppings. The crust on this bad boy is a little bit crispy, crunchy, chewy, flaky with layers like a biscuit somehow and has residual sauce from the non-crust side so you're not just eating mouthfuls of dry bread. I don't know how else to explain it other than I ate every piece of it. The cavatelli (first time to have it) was like a giant gnocchi drenched with sauce and more cheese, and was worth the price. I will definitely be a repeat customer for Anthony's as I must try their other pizzas. Total price for a small stuffed pizza and the pasta was about 28 bucks. read more

Anthony's Pizzeria - Baked Cavatelli - Pizza Near Me - Northlake, Illinois

See all

bad working environment, swearing and yelling infront of customers, a guy named tony who i assume is that owner was yelling at the employees and swearing while me and my family was waiting for our food, the lady with black glasses on the cashier seemed under the influence and was slurring her words, a lady cute herself with a staple and still grabbed our pizza with the same hand without washing or anything, over all very bad costumer service. read more

First time ordering & it won't be our last! This is a hole in the wall pizzeria that I've driven by many of times but never thought twice. That is until tonight. My girlfriend & I were looking for a new pizzeria & we stumbled upon, Anthonys on here. The owner is very friendly & personable. He takes great pride in his product by using fresh ingredients. The pride, love & dedication to his food & customers shows beyond words. If you're in the area or even if you aren't & you want a well made true pizza, don't hesitate to call in an order. You won't be disappointed!! Prost! read more

Anthony's Pizzeria - Italian beef & pepperoni. Absolute masterpiece!! - Pizza Near Me - Northlake, Illinois

well i ordered 2 pizzas for the first time customer i had called to see if my order was on the way.after 5 calls they answered the phone told me dont call here no more were busy lol true statement i spent 36 dollars plus on 2 10 inch pizzas and 2 cans of coke.my wifes pizza was good my pizza had so much cheese it was delivered all white on top so much cheese was not cooked . so when the cock sucker told me not to call any more i wont bad pizzas shit service 0 stars .little ceasers has better. read more

Baked Shells, Saturday special. New to neighborhood and I thought I would give it a try. First off, customer service was great. The baked shells were pretty good, the filling was delicious, shells nicely cooked however to my taste the sauce didn't really hit the spot and was a little too thin. The bread had a nice crunchy crust and soft on the inside. I will definitely order again. read more

Pizza is okay. But very pricy for what you get. The delivery guy is really nice though.

Amazing family owned business and great pies! Delivery or pick up really good quality!!!

If I want some good pizza, REAL good pizza in fact, I can get it here. I don't need any other reason to give it five stars. Lots of people agree with me. Why else would Anthony's still be in business after 26 years? 26 years, meaning I was still in diapers. Practically still wet behind the ears. Breath smelling like Similac. My dads mustache was still black, for crying out loud. 26 years these days means you're doing something right. Unfortunately, I can only vouch for the pizza. But I can tell you that the pizza here is original. Blindfold me, and jumble up Anthony's pizza with 5 other local or non local thin crust pizzas, and I undoubtedly will pick it out. It seems they go a little heavier on garlic and oregano than most places, which I totally condone. And plentiful on cheese, which I also advocate. They also do other usual Italian fare, including pasta, a variety of sandwiches and appetizers, chicken parmigiana, soups, etc. They have one or two small tables to eat in, but presumptuously make most their business through carry-out and delivery. You have to appreciate places like this because it seems to be just one little Italian man running this joint. He was the one who answered the phone and took my order, made my pizza, and upon pickup, swiped my credit card with doughy hands, apron still on and everything. Here's to Anthony's and another 26 or more years. read more

First off, I'm VERY picky about Italian food, and this surpasses some of the 'best' Italian food I've eaten in Italy as well as in NY where I'm from. This place is absolutely AMAZING! My friend and I were in from out of town, and we were looking for a place to eat close to our hotel at like 10:30pm tonight. Anthony's showed up on Yelp and we decided to give it a try. OH.MY.GOD. - Unexpected PURE GOODNESS and AUTHENTICITY is what we got! I ordered the cavatelli with extra red sauce, and my friend got a meatball sub with mozzarella. Again...OH.MY.GOD! Was it the sauce!? Was it the homemade cavatelli!? Or, the homemade meatballs that are better than my Italian mother's!? Either way, the sounds we each were making as we were eating were comical as we BOTH couldn't get enough. Anthony is from Sicily, and he knows good food. DEFINITELY go to this place - do NOT pass it up, even though it's a random small place. You won't be disappointed. read more

I moved not too far from this place a few months ago and I've been lookin around for good local pizza. This place is beyond good its downright amazing. I ordered a stuffed pizza last night and I was not dissapointed. The crust was perfectly soft and the cheese was wonderful. The sausage was pretty good and I quite enjoyed the pizza sauce itself. I like the hint of garlic in the pizza as well its like getting garlic as a topping for free. I am eager to try the non pizza items and the pricing is good so I will be odering from here again soon. read more

Anthony's is just your typical old school Chicago "mom/pop" shop where the owner is in the back making the food and his wife is the one up front answering the phones. All Anthony's consists of is a kitchen, counter, a couple of tables for folks to wait and a heck of a pizza! Ordered a couple of thin crust pizzas and we weren't disappointed. Their crust is very thin and very crisp. The cheese they use is real, and when I say real I mean freshly grated 100% mozzarella. The sausage tastes homemade and has a very distinct flavor and the rest of the toppings are fresh, and not out of a can Prices are reasonable and definitely a must try! read more

Ordered a couple pizzas from here for the first time recently. Pizzas were: Spinach + Mushroom and Sausage, Pepperoni, and Mushroom. Now, I love independent pizzerias, especially Mom + Pop places which this definitely checks those boxes. Service was friendly from ordering to pick up. As for the pizzas, they were pretty good. One small gripe is that I did not think they were rightly balanced. There was too much cheese. Others may find this a plus but to me a great pizza is many things. Good fresh ingredients balanced throughout the pizza. The ingredients were good, I liked the sauce and toppings but if I were to order again, I would request that they go a little easier on the cheese. My humble opinion. My rating falls between 3.5 +/ 4 stars but since they are an independent business, they always get the higher rating. Always support your independent small business pizzerias. They provide an important service to our communities, so support them whenever you can unless you want to live in a world where Poppa Johns (Ugh) or Dominos (Ugh again) would be your choices and who would want that??? Cheers to All read more

Anthony's Pizzeria - Spinach + Mushroom - Pizza Near Me - Northlake, Illinois

lol. I came to write a review and just realized that I already had! YOU MUST ORDER FROM THEM! read more

Great food but the owner is really shystie when it comes to the pricing when you pick your food up.

My first time trying this pizza. The GREAT reviews sold me to try it. I got a stuff cheese half pepperoni. I was so overwhelmed LOL! The cheese,the crust,the garlicky sauce. OMG! Food coma! I literally needed a tub of pizza sauce to finish the crust! Really good tasting pizza. Next time I will try the thin crust. read more

Anthony's Pizzeria - I cut a slice before I took the pic LOL! - Pizza Near Me - Northlake, Illinois

Slice of pizza was a joke. Very rude and made me feel unwelcome.... Wow, I will never return. This is woman with the white Avalon you looked out the window as i left. Pathetic read more

A Northlake staple. Only 2 pizza places had stood the "taste" of time. Perry's and Anthony's. There's a reason these places still exist! Good, quality ingredients makes ALL the difference. Family owned, operated and quality assured. Years and years ago they had a restaurant and now it's a delivery/take-out place. That's OK. I'm good as long as I get my pizza! For birthdays I usually order buffalo size pizza. It's a gigantic rectangle that serves at least 10 beasts during football season! lol. Ah... memories. My favorite is ricotta, sausage and mushroom. SOOOOO delicious- think I need pizza tonight! read more

Having exhausted all the pizza places in Elmhurst, my boyfriend and I decided to try Anthony's because of the reviews and pictures. So glad we did! We got a stuffed Pizza with pepperoni and Italian beef. You could taste the fresh garlic in the sauce, taste the aus jus that the beef was simmered in... so delicious! Italian beef on a pizza is so good, but not everyone does it right. Anthony's does it right. We'll be back! read more

Anthony's Pizzeria - Stuffed Pizza with pepperoni and Italian beef. ..YUM! - Pizza Near Me - Northlake, Illinois

My boyfriend & I love the pizza at this place!!! This is probably the best thin crust pizza I've ever had, it's close to our house so we order at least once a week. So glad we found out about this place!! You will not be disappointed. read more

Great homemade pizza. This is the authentic Chicago style pies that people are always raving about. I was here a few weeks ago while visiting my sis in law and decided to give it a try. Loved the cheese to crust ratio and they're easy on the sauce so you get a true taste of the fresh ingredients without the sauce overpowering the taste. Will try it again soon. read more

It's about average. If I really had to eat it again if it was the only place open then sure I'd eat there pizza. But personally Perry's Pizza Joynt beats them by far!!! read more

When my family went on vacation in Rome last year we were dreading the return because we were going to miss that Italian pizza. After a few weeks of not eating pizza we went to Anthony's for the first time. Now we're pizza geeks and have tried everything from Tombstone to Nancy's, but if you want the most authentic Italian pizza in the area (and I've ever tasted this side of the Atlantic) go to Anthony's. I've never had their stuffed or other items on the menu, but for a thin crust pizza they can't be beat. read more

I like to order from this place because they are pretty original. On a hot summer day you will catch the owner with a dago-tee on..... just like in Sicily. The last thing I ordered from them was a small pizza , order of mastacolli , mushrooms ,and anthonys special salad which was amazing ( iceberg lettuce, salami, tomatoes, black olives, Italian Cheese, Italian Ham, with like an oil vinegar topping and peppers. read more

Two times in the past 2 months we ordered a buffalo pizza half sausage half pepperoni and it came half cheese half pepperoni. So my girlfriend called them just to get into a screaming match with the owner, who argued you did not say sausage there was 5 of us we all heard her order. The owner sends a small pizza. My girlfriend has order from then for 20 years and we will never order from them again. Not to mention the buffalo pizza being a huge sloppy mess. Was a challenge to eat. read more

I worked here in High School 25 yrs ago and the food was GREAT then. The Pizza & Everything else is still GREAT. Real Italian food.. Some of the Best around !!! read more

I happen to live in Bensenville have been going to Anthony's for pizza I have to pass a few others on the way there however it has the best pan pizza around. My family loves this place will keep going back that's for sure... read more

We moved to Northlake a couple years ago and were faithful to our pizzeria from back in the city. That is until we tried Anthonys and we were hooked. The pizza is so delicious. The crust nice and crisp. Just all around delicious! I love to support small businesses and the food speaks for itself. It has been 7 years since we first tried Anthony's and have moved back to the city. Anthony's is still our fav pizza! We go back and pick some up whenever we can. read more

Have yet find "my pizza place" in the area but this will do in a pinch. Good thin crust. Need to remember to ask for extra cheese and have it well-done. read more

The worst customer service I've ever had. I placed an order for a pizza, I wanted an Italian beef pizza with sausage and jalapeno stuffed. WAited 45 minutes for a pizza that was a thin crust, jalapeño pizza with sausage. I call them back to let them know this wasn't what I ordered and the guy taking the order tells me with attitude this is what I ordered. With an attitude and didn't even offer to change my order. The worst customer service ever. I paid for a pizza that I didn't even want. Avoid them at all costs read more

Order full slab of Ribs and lasagna. It was nothing to brag about the foods. Taste oaky. It was good first try. And last. read more

Anthony's Pizzeria - I order full slab of ribs. and dinner size lasagna. it was okay. first and last. - Pizza Near Me - Northlake, Illinois

See all

Man What Can I Say This Place Is Great Pizza Is Good The Beef WOW Haven't found a good place in town I been here over a year and this is my go to place for Italian beef great place friendly people great prices read more