Pizza was delicious and they were able to accommodate my order even though I called just 15 minutes before closing! My friend has this rule: Always judge a pizza place by the cheese pizza - and it definitely did not disappoint there! Excited to come back and try again! Additional note: Seems like a lot of the more recent low ratings are taking stars because of the salad, we didn't try it but why you judge a pizza place on the salad is beyond me. read more

Anthony's Pizza and Pasta - 18" Neapolitan - Pizza Near Me - Aurora, Colorado

My favorite pizza place. Bacon and pineapple is the best. We also ordered a pepperoni it I didn't try it. Great pizza and great crust We wanted bone in wings but apparently we didn't order them properly. Oops!! Still good read more

See all

The perfect fix for a super cold night! I love that you can still get pizza by the slice. The guys working were so kind and you could tell they were working hard to sling those pies! They came out hot and super tasty. Keep it up guys, we love Anthony's! read more

The best pepperoni pizza around. Huge slices and if you are a sucker for a good crisp crust like myself you should definitely try them out!

Food and customer service is always great. Do yourself a favor and don't forget an order of cannolis

I really enjoy the pizza here. Their Napoleon and Sicilian are both great. I enjoy their salads and sandwiches too. Everything tastes fresh. Also the staff are amazing. From the front desk to the people making the pies, they are all upbeat and welcoming. Anthony's is our go to neighborhood pizzeria. read more

Anthony's Pizza and Pasta - Pizza Near Me - Aurora, Colorado

Tried something different when we didn't want pizza, so we ordered the chicken Parmesan sandwich and ravioli. Both were less than average. The chicken Parmesan sandwich with extra cheese seemed quite small, in fact we thought it was the garlic bread that was supposed to accompany the ravioli but didn't. There were small pieces of chicken on bread that was about the size of a hotdog bun, so not quite as expected. It seemed so small that we actually weighed it- and it was 6.05 ounces. The ravioli was supposed to come with bread but the bread was missing. The pizza is usually decent but I probably would never order this sandwich or ravioli again. read more

See all

Amazing service! We got turned down at Chicago's pizza (horrible service) and this little spot didn't care how many of us showed up (a whole softball team). They took great care of us! And the food was bomb and affordable. read more

Anthony's Pizza and Pasta - Pizza Near Me - Aurora, Colorado

This place never disappointed me. I stopped by really quick for some yummy, warm and delicious pizza today and all the ingredients were fresh. I ordered a 18" pizza with pepperoni,ham, spinach and pineapple. Their hot wings are also yummy. read more

Anthony's Pizza and Pasta - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Aurora, Colorado

See all

Great pizza spot with a very friendly atmosphere. Their pizzas were huge and tasted delicious. It was worth the price for sure. They put the meat underneath the cheese which I really liked because a lot of the time when I'm eating a pizza, the toppings tend to slide off. Well done! read more

See all

Always loved ANTHONY's. Stopped in after a pedicure at Le Nails for a quick slice. It's my favorite thing to do when I lived in Mayfair/Park Hill. Now that I'm in Aurora I enjoy picking up chicken wings, pizzas, pasta and calzones to go for large gatherings. They also have a Anthony's lunch weekday special for two cheese slices or a cheese slice and salad for $9.59. Today I just got a slice and added Pepperoni and mushroom toppings. Total with tax and tip was $6.47 for my slice with toppings. Friendly and quick service. The fresh slice comes out of the oven and incredibly hot but YUMMY! There is limited seating inside and more of a grab and go spot. There is a collage of photos on the wall and a menu board to the right of the entrance. read more

Anthony's Pizza and Pasta - Cheese slice with added mushrooms and pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Aurora, Colorado

Great slice in a hurry. Highly reccomend. Everyone is friendly and it's consistent. I still need to try they Pasta and wings though.

Not sure why they keep putting pepperoni under the cheese in their pizzas. It sucks when they do this.

They just lost a 20+ year customer. Service has been going downhill bad since covid. Two orders back to back screwed up. Tonights order went 1.5 hours before I called them. They knew they screwed up the order but waited till I called them to tell me. The last order was 1.25 hrs and arrived cold with a 30% tip. No more anthony's, were done. read more

I'll start by saying the pizza tastes good. I have no issues with that. My husband and I came in and ordered 2 slices. One with pepperoni, one with sausage and mushroom. We sat in there for 7 or 8 minutes.And another man walked in and asked for his usual, and he got his five minutes before we did. And when I did get my slice, it's not even a complete slice. It's not the end of the world.I just really couldn't believe it as someone who's owned 4 pizza restaurants.I would never serve a customer this. Might or might not be back.There's lots of other choices. I will say the man who took our order was welcoming and friendly, so no issues there. read more

Pizza was fantastic! Pies are even bigger in person! Ordered an 18" and was shocked with how big it was. Will be coming back!

Pizza is always Great. I always pickup and it's hot and fresh. Had it delivered by GrubHub for the first time. Was cold and looked as if it was dropped. Some of the slices were up side down. Very disappointing. read more

The pizza is always delicious, staff is excellent. But, my gf got a large Caesar salad yesterday and it was very lacking in size and appeal read more

Anthony's Pizza and Pasta - Large Caesar - Pizza Near Me - Aurora, Colorado

Tried to place a phone order, the woman who picked up took my order and hung up the phone. Called back, thought maybe it got disconnected, and she hung up on me again. Odd, but obviously not a good experience. read more

If you're looking for that big New York slice this is the place to go, but if you're not into the grease I would skip it. The staff are nice and friendly. The inside is small yet has lots of seating for those wanting to dine in as most people take it to go or order delivery. I don't particularly enjoy overly greasy pizza and Anthony's pizza is very greasy. I love the huge slices, but the greasiness makes the dough soggy and collapses when you pick it up. Overall, a decent place for pizza and the staff are nice. read more

Pizza was brunt, stale, and nasty. When I called in about it, the manager said he would replace pizza if I brought it back. Even after I sent him pics of pizza a day later, he insisted I bring it back to him. It's been 4 days and the slice is going in the trash now?! Because who knows when I'll have time to make it back!! Should have been comped a refund immediately!!!! Terrible management, food, and service! I Will never be returning back. read more

Paid 7.50 for a large salad with romaine which I fully admit is completely stupid on my part. However, I ordered it with romaine and received a spring mix and the salad was very small it looks like they just put it in a large container with a total of FIVE pepperoni's talk about a colossal rip off. Just another reason to not eat out anymore. By the time u pay delivery, tip etc its ridiculous the pizza had only two ingredients I ordered a small and it was as much as a large. No coupons anywhere. I cannot recommend this place to anybody. Save your money and make your own food. This restaurant gets a huge F read more

I am not the biggest fan of Anthony's but last night I wanted pizza and they are around the corner from my house. I found 2 long brown hairs imbedded in the cheese. Definitely the last time I will eat from Anthony's. read more

Just started going to this place because my daughter brought home garlic bread. Super delicious! They are close to my house but do not deliver. It is worth it to have 3rd party delivery. Besides the amazing garlic bread, the pizza & meatballs are great too!! read more

The carry out order of pizzas and salads was great! A delicious meal for my family and especially our grandchildren!

Don't get their wings. They count all bone wings as 1 wing. Extra charge for ranch. Extra charge for multiple sauces, even on 12 wing order. read more

Anthony's Pizza and Pasta - Pizza Near Me - Aurora, Colorado

Not only the best ricotta around but add exceptional customer service by Huzaifah & you are lucky. Huzaifah was absolutely outstanding & the cheesy, ricotta & mozzarella Calzone is absolutely delicious! Anthony's is so lucky to have Huzaifah. Absolute top notch customer service!!! Give this man a raise! read more

Anthony's is my favorite restaurant by far. Amazing food and great service. Ah-Ah-Ah Anthony's!

got the cheese pizza and ranch it was good and big slices tastes what i imagine new york pizza would be like since i've never been and friendly worker was great and it was super quick read more

Anthony's Pizza and Pasta - Slice Sicilian - Pizza Near Me - Aurora, Colorado

I got the Neapolitan with meatballs and basil. The sauce and meat were delicious, the dough was good, the basil was a little burned. Overall a good pizza. read more

Hated everything! Nuff said!! Salad lettuce was wilted, the dressing was inedible, don't really even know what it was, sandwich was not made according to my clear instructions, za was burnt, wings were dry, clearly over cooked, but served to me and my family anyway! The only good thing about this Hell hole was the counter help, they were very nice! Never ever going back! The kitchen staff clearly do not know what they are doing! Thanks for nothing1 read more

Pizza was extremely greasey and doe was chewy. They said it was NY style. I guess that's the way they like it there.

Food is great pizza is customizable regarding amount of sauce and ingredients and services always good.

They used to have a big dinning room where we could dined in. But they got rid of the dining room probably due to COVID and cost. So it's more like a takeout pizza place now. Other than this, their pizza and food have always been good! read more

Great pizza - just like Manhattan! Friendly staff! Ordered large 18" Sausage and pepperoni read more

Good pizza, super friendly delivery service and great cashier/customer-friendly energy!

I was teetering on 3-4 stars for this this place. The pizza is very good by the slice, but lacks a bit of oomph if you buy a whole pie. I don't know what they do different, but whether you buy pizza by the slice, or by the pie matters. They taste completely different, so if you are looking for a well-oiled NY style slice, this is a great spot. You want the whole pie? It's alright. The service in house is very good. The manager is great and the staff is personable. Delivery can take a while (a long while). I suggest you go pick up your order. It's worth it. read more

Anthony's Pizza and Pasta - Art - Pizza Near Me - Aurora, Colorado

I order at Anthony's pizza for the second time I never ate at this place but glad I did, It was so amazing I ordered it again Unbelievable I order the meat lovers The pizza was hug !!! And hug pieces !!! Lots of topping and cheese!!! Th crust was fabulous it held a mountain of toppings and didn't fail wonderful sauce It was just as perfect as tge second time I ordered it I wasn't disappointed read more

We ate at the location at ILLIF and Buckley tonight 2/24/22. Never going back, ever. The pizza was bland and had not enough sauce or cheese. The sauce tasted like unflavored tomato sauce. The peperoni was tasteless. There was not a redeeming quality about the of the pizza. That really was $30.00 down the tubes. I expected much better from such an established pizzaria. Serious folks Domino's pizza is better. The crust on one of the pizzas was burned black. The service was great but not good enough to make up for the yucky pizza. Too bad for this pizza joint. Going to the Garlic Knot from now on or Dion's. read more

Wow!! The front of the house customer service is the worst I have experienced in a long time. They were so rude and uncaring and did not even offer you hell me fix the wrong order that they messed up.mind you it was so Saturday night customer service should still be to good expectations always. And fix the mistakes that were made. $35 of my $ down the drain. This is not how a business should be ran. read more