Alright, I've ate wings at probably over 500 places at this point in my life, parents went to school in Buffalo, and finding a good to great Buffalo wing is HARD venture this day and age. Absolutely incredible wings here, they're the 1%er of wings. It's not a debate. I see a few complaining about small wings lol. 1. If you're just hungry for chicken go do that, small wings are a way to maximize flavor and that's what Anthony's accomplishes in these perfectly cooked, crisp, flavor packed hot and extra hot (my personal reco but not for faint of heart) wing 2. They have jumbo wings for you non wing knowing hungry eaters that don't get it, so order that before complaining, you're just getting an inferior wing but can enjoy their incredible sauces that way Sorry, I'm a wing snob and I'm riled up at poor reviews from non wing knowers, who are the reason why we as a country are losing ground on good Buffalo wings. They're going extinct because of viewpoints like some of what I see on here. Go to KFC if you're gonna hate, don't bring a good business down (also please note I'm being jestful in tone if you can't parse through, but I'm also serious). Second - really great other options including Buffalo tenders, cheesesteaks are great, some fish options (Buffalo shrimp of course!). But again, for true wing enthusiasts, this is my WING OF THE YEAR for 2023 and beyond. Also very friendly customer service there, clearly good people. Comfortable vibe inside, kind of diner type feel, the right feel for a true wing spot. Clean bathrooms. I ate these wings 4 hours ago and now writing about it and all I want to do is drive the 50 minutes back to get more. ***** read more

Very friendly service and the food was excellent I recommend this restaurant It's inexpensive and quite the surprise

Great food and customer service Best wings and chicken in nj Plus they deliver read more

Local spot... and a not. Not impressed. I gave three stars for the friendly service, I have got a 15.60 dinner with 8 of the smallest chicken wings I have ever witnessed. I couldn't believe that they sell them as wings and not tiny winglittles, chicklets, or henlettes. Chicken fingers were well-sized, but tasteless. The fries wete good well done with salt. Oh make sure you request blue cheese n celery it's not automatic. Who knew... oh it says it in the upper corner of the menu, not the wall. Ok... not a fan. Perhaps other items on the menu win. There's a lot to try. read more

See all

Really bad service and food, more than enough better places around town for better prices too.

It's me again, Brendan from the review that if sorted chronological, should be right below this one. Also my wife wanted to review too so counts as another review. Incredible wings and service. People writing about "small wings" are simply non wing knowers around the proper taste for a buffalo wing. Anthony's accomplishes this and if you want big wings get the jumbo ones, you clearly are more about quenching hunger than finding the perfect wing, which is fine. I know there are a lot of people out there wondering where they can get a REAL buffalo wings in a world where the art of the wing simply seems lost. Well, I'm happy to tell you that not all hope is lost, not all wings clipped, Anthony's is the place. I thank them for persevering through the critics, and I encourage the community to push back on these non wing knowers with both support in the comments and at the cashiers. We will be back REAL soon. read more

I was so pumped for a really good wrap - I work so hard for my money - But sadly, this was not worth over $15 (wrap/sauce/can of coke) I knew that it didn't come with anything - However, there was not too much (dry) chicken in the wrap and it looked as if it was slapped together... Pictured below, is the wrap (over $13 - extra for the sauce - and I added a can of coke)... I was originally going to go to Chicken Holiday, but I wanted to support a local business... Maybe I will try, again, in a few month - I have already given them another chance - But, hey - maybe they will surprise me! read more

Anthony's Chicken & Grill - ...over $13 - some dry chicken and tomato inside - Sandwiches Near Me - Hightstown, New Jersey

Got some wings delivered from here today and I really liked the flavor. I do wish I had read the restaurant's description on Yelp because I was definitely surprised by the size of the wings - they really are small! Beforehand, I thought I would be stuffed from my order of 14 wings, but I was definitely still hungry afterwards (and would have ordered more if I had known that the wings would be small). That being said, because the wings were tasty, I would definitely order from here again but would just order a larger number of wings :) read more

Anthony's just catered my daughter's birthday party. They did an amazing job. Everyone raved about the food and we even had left overs. I would recommend! Thank you! read more

I really enjoyed my cheesesteak today. All the fresh veggies and the warm roll made it extra good. Takeout service was super fast and friendly. read more

Anthony's Chicken & Grill - "Junior" Cheesesteak yum! - Sandwiches Near Me - Hightstown, New Jersey

Super simple! - Too expensive for what it is....go to Chicken Holiday in East Windsor, should you have a craving for some Fried Chicken. read more

I was very disappointed because the wings were very small, rather meatless, very dry and hard and tasteless. If you are looking for wings I suggest you try another place. They used to be better than this. I don't know what the rest of their menu is like, but I won't be coming back to find out. read more

This is the worst place if you're looking for decent chicken wings. Going to keep it really simple. If you like chicken wings about the size of your pinky no exaggeration come to this place. If not please go somewhere else. read more

We were headed north for a wedding and hopped off the Jersey turnpike for a quick meal in Hightstown, New Jersey. We found Anthony's Chicken and Grill where the wings were tasty, hot, and made with their homemade Buffalo Wing sauce. I got the Jumbo Wings and boy, were they yummy. You could tell from the stream of people picking up food that it was a staple with the locals. The menu selection was large for a small restaurant. My husband got the wings/ribs special with a tasty St. Louis style spare ribs. The wings were smaller but came the same yummy hot sauce. The French fries were deep fried and tasty, not oily. We all kept stealing those fries. Our other diner had their chicken, deep fried and delicious. The mashed potatoes and gravy were overshadowed by those fries. The Manager set up table and chairs so we could eat outside, even though they had been put up earlier due to possible rain. Food was delivered and they checked to make sure we had everything we needed. Unexpected great service. So, if you are near this town, stop in at Anthony's. I might have to go back when traveling the turnpike for that Hot Wing Sauce. Maybe I'll ask them to sell me a quart. read more

Anthony's Chicken & Grill - Anthony's Chicken and Grill Restaurant - Sandwiches Near Me - Hightstown, New Jersey

Their corn fritters were good, their shrimp pretty good but their chicken wings tiny and dry- gross, their ribs SUPER salty- I wouldn't suggest either of them (which is dissapointing since those are the things on their sign) I even tried it twice... its pretty gross, to be honest read more

Anthony's Chicken and Grill has really bad food, which is unfortunate, because it's a restaurant. I don't fear for the owners, though; my heart goes out to the clientele. Below is a psychographic breakdown of Anthony's loyal customers (because let's face it: they aren't winning over any new customers): Anthony's Chicken and Grill Client Psychographics # AGE: 60 - 85. Customers since the 80's or 90's. Boomer. # MARITAL STAUS: Divorced. No love. No intimacy. No hope. # MED HISTORY: Diabetes Type 2, GERD, CHD, COPD, Anemia. # EDUCATION: High School Diploma/ School of Hard Knocks # OCCUPATION: N/A. Disabled in 2004. Annoying backstory. # PSYCH HISTORY: Depression, Anxiety, Dementia. # PERSONALITY: ENFJ, low openness, high neuroticism. # ACTIVITIES: Watching cable news, TV, and neighbors. # DIET: Canned soup, Hot Pockets, Anthony's Chicken & Grill. # EXERCISE: N/A # ATTITUDES: "I don't like to order from new places. I keep it simple." "The World Wide Web, right? Or is it The Internet? Not for me." "I've been ordering from Anthony's since 1993! Can you believe it? Before you were even a glimmer in your mother's eye. And that's where we're ordering from. Anthony's! I don't care about the reviews. Who are these people that write reviews anyway? What do they know? Do they think they know more than me? They know nothing. Now give me the damn phone so I can order." Just keep the above information in mind when reading through the other reviews for this place. read more

Great menu, love their steak sandwiches, Grilled chicken Sandwich, chicken parm and french fries. Great service and reasonable prices. Highly recommend!!! read more

I've ordered several times from them, the chicken has always been crispy, moist and delicious. The side dishes taste is where they lost me a little, also prices for individual pieces of chicken seemed a bit high. The wings were good, I'll continue being a customer. read more

If you want to clog your arteries and render yourself a lethargic glutton, then make sure you order the crazy Phat Frank's Burger. It's basically a double cheeseburger (cooked to your request) smothered in chili. Add to this a generous heap of cajun fries and you're all set to go on your adventure (or lack thereof). After consuming such a heavy helping of food, I'm sure you'll be able to check off one of the items on your todo list of deadly sins. It's now nearly 6 hours after consumption and I'm finally able to come to my senses to write a review. read more

Come here for the ribs. They're delicious. The bbq sauce is a perfect blend of tang and spice, the ribs are nice, they're large and meaty - not too fatty, although you will of course get some fat in there. They're ribs, after all! I just tried the buffalo wings which are yummy too. The classic buffalo sauce is sufficiently spicy, even for someone who loves spicy food (I tend to have to split the difference, as my husband has a more sensitive palate). The rotisserie chicken is decent, but not my favorite. The potato skins are also delish. Crisped up, covered with melted chedder and of course, bacon - ya can't go wrong there. Anthony's is always a solid choice for your rib and tater craving. read more

I tried wings takeout from here, and was disappointed! The place seemed understaffed, and the sole worker spotted had his mask down to his chin, and a long beard with no hair net or anything. The food was 10 mins later than promised, aaaand the wing sauce all leaked to the bottom of the plastic bag. The wings didn't taste good enough to justify anything. read more

Here's the thing, I have nothing to say about the chicken. The chicken is delicious. It's literally the only thing that is worth eating at Anthony's. The macaroni and cheese is tasteless (I promise that I am not even exaggerating. It's TASTELESS). I mean that I had to load on the salt and pepper and I even threw some shredded cheese of my own on it. Mac & cheese isn't difficult to make so I have no clue how it's so bad. Unfortunately the lack of seasoning carries over to the macaroni salad too. It was truly terrible. No flavor at all. What's strange is that it wasn't even mayo flavored. I don't know how it happened. I ordered $70 worth of food for a large family. Imagine the laughter that broke out when I pulled a "Martin's Potato Rolls" bag of rolls out of the bag. Just threw the whole bag into my paper bag of food. Last, (because there's MORE) the french fries were soggy and we threw them away. Only 2 years ago I gave Anthony's a 5 star review. My family and I used to have Anthony's night twice a month when I was younger. I guess I will not be continuing this tradition with my children and suddenly Chicken Holiday is looking really promising. read more

I ordered because online order was available. It was fast and efficient. I had a buffalo chicken sandwich special that came with fries and a fountain drink. It was delicious, hot and ready when I arrived. It was a easy delicious solution to a lunch time need read more

I went to high school around here and have eaten more Anthony's than I'd care to admit. It only gets 4 stars because it is a bit on the pricy side, but who am I to argue. I am a guy who loves buffalo anything, and this place delivers in spades. The buffalo chicken fingers are better than I have ever had anywhere else on the planet, and if I was to be put down tommorrow, they would be my last meal. I cannot say enough about them. This review is more about them than the actual restaurant. The perfect size and crispiness of the fingers is the definition of perfection. The way the grease and hot sauce coat the fries and potato roll, which you then dip into the blue cheese dressing is a close second. I'm getting hungry even thinking about it... read more

We ordered the worst chicken sandwich in the history of the world here. No toppings, tough grilled chicken and soggy fries. Terrible. On the plus side, the bathroom was clean. read more

The best wings, always stop in and get some when I'm in town. Service is great food is done quick and always taste great.

Excellent steak sandwich as well as chicken. My only suggestion is the menu. Specifically, the menu states "1/2 12 oz steak sandwich" is $11.10. Wasn't sure what I was ordering. Ended up being a full-sized steak sandwich on a hoagie roll. Sandwich quality and portion size were excellent. Instead of saying "1/2 12 oz" I would instead say "full hoagie." Or maybe have a picture of what the 12 oz steak sandwich looks like. Definitely plan on returning!!! read more

Ordered food on a Friday night. Didn't feel like cooking. I ordered a wings & fries combo. Well when they arrived 90 minutes later, the wings are a joke! Although I can't say they tasted bad, they were so small that I was thinking this place should be ashamed of themselves for selling these little nibbles with a bone and calling them buffalo wings‍ really? Where in the heezies do you get off saying these are wings! Shame on you! read more

I was looking for something healthy to eat. I checked out this place's website. Its menu said "Big Salads," so I decided to give it a shot. The salad was a healthy portion for $10. Although the chicken was cut up small, there was enough of it even at the end of eating. (I hate it when places skim on the meat, and you are left with all lettuce at the end.) It wasn't too bad. Sadly, they don't have a good selection of low-fat or fat-free dressings to put on the salad, so I had to use my own. read more

Anthony's Chicken & Grill - Garden Salad with Grilled Chicken - Sandwiches Near Me - Hightstown, New Jersey

I ordered the half a rotisserie chicken for $7...what can I say the chicken was DRY, WAY OVER COOKED, NO FLAVOR, SIMPLY BLAND. You are better off going into shoprite or any local super market paying half of what I paid get double the food that is fresh. This place also does not know the idea of customer service, after I called them and told them the chicken was dry to the point I could not swallow he said they give me "credit towards a future order" rather than offering another dish or simply my money back. He also said "that's how people here like their chicken.... well done'. I was under the impression that chicken is either raw, cooked, or over cooked. This place probably doesn't even know how to roast a marshmallow let alone a chicken. Its a same because this isn't my first time ordering from them but it definitely is the last. The food was 2 stars but due to the customer service 1 star. read more

Anthony's Chicken & Grill - supposedly a "half rotisserie chicken" more like half chicken jerky - Sandwiches Near Me - Hightstown, New Jersey

These have got to be the smallest chicken wings I have ever seen! They must be from pigeons. I mean seriously...not even exaggerating. I don't even know where you could buy wings that small. Such a shame, because the sauce was good. Won't be going there again. read more

Five stars for the buffalo wings!! Fried chicken is juicy, tender and tasty! I don't know about the rest of the menu but wings are the best!! read more

Great menu, love their Cajun Chicken Grilled Sandwich with Fries, great service and reasonable prices Highly recommend!!! read more

Ordered wings from here a couple times, they are amazing. Downfall is the price and the size of the wings and extra charges. I really didn't know chickens could be that small. Also the wing sauce, which is a mix of hot and sweet. There was a little confusion about that when I ordered and the guy was a little rude in explaining as if I should've known. Extra blue cheese, charge, extra tartar sauce charge, extra cocktail sauce charge. For six jumbo shrimp they give you one little packet of sauce. Overall great food, service is ok, but pricey. read more

The wings were tasty But when I opened the package I saw these miniature wings I thought there was a mistake. The smallest wings I ever saw. Must be from that movie "Honey I Shrunk the Chicken". Can't be from a real chicken. Should double the number per order if that small .....was ridiculous for $$ read more

i ordered delivery from here for lunch today. paying $15.00 for 14 wings is crazy. but i wanted to give them a chance. they were so incredibly small, it felt like eating half of that. the only positive were my curly fries. definitely won't order here again read more

Unfortunately, you're wrong! Considering the fact that I don't drink, you couldn't be any more wrong. Second, I walked in because he did not use the bathroom. Third, I would be happy to have your illegal employees vouch for the turnover and horrible management. Shall I continue? Or should I just have the department of health contacted? I'll be glad to reach out to the mayor's personal office to make sure this is looked into. Thanks Jennifer PS..How can it be that they have been with you for 10 yrs if this place was for sale just about 7 years ago when I was approached as well to buy this run down hole? read more

Unbelievably good wings. The buffalo sauce is on the sour and spicy side rather than just straight up spicy. Out of all the buffalo wings I've tried in New Jersey, this places comes closest to the buffalo wings from Anchor Bar/Duff's in Buffalo, NY. The wings taste good even cold. Besides their wings they also make a delicious chicken pot pie. Flaky crust, creamy sauce, full of chicken and vegetables. This place was a childhood staple when I was still around the area. read more

Familiar with the Food Network show "The Best Thing I Ever Ate"? Well, if I was on that show, I'd be talking about the wings at Anthony's! These guys do wings right - small in size, no flour, and plenty of hot sauce. Ask for potato rolls to dip in the remaining sauce. Plus, the guys behind the counter are awesome. I've moved around a lot in the past few years, and have never found a place that even remotely compares. read more

Best wings anywhere. But a little on the expensive side given the Formica atmosphere.