Enjoyed the evening!! excellent food and service!! The best Italian food around!! Enjoyed the evening with friends and listening to Angelo talk about his olive tree farm and the making of his olive oil which is outstanding!! I recommend giving this restaurant a a try, you will not be disappointed!! Rated 5 stars Try the shrimp and scallop Bella Donna ,you won't be disappointed!! Dennis and MK read more

Staff were nice and accommodating. Nice artwork and painting giving Italian atmosphere. I wish they were playing music that matches Italian atmosphere. The lighting could have been better. Clean bathrooms. Started with the house salad and bread -5 Salad had too much dressing on it. Bread was homemade and tasty but too much oil. Spaghetti was a 7 The pasta quality was average at best. The sauce was well balanced but seemed store brought. This meal cost $14. I believe the portion was decent for the cost. Stuffed mushrooms were a 6 They were not stuffed with real crab meat and I didn't taste any ricotta cheese or bread crumb. The cheese was good that the mushrooms came in. Italian margarita was a 5 They were out of orange juice so I subbed pineapple juice and it did not hit. Dessert wine was a 9 Silk pie is just a chocolate cake. They were out of chocolate syrup. The texture was not our favorite - 7 Cheesecake - 7 It was a cheesecake lol not a fan of cherry sauce but not bad. Overall, Angelo's was a 4 star. I would eat there again but maybe not dine in. read more

Angelo's - Dessert wine - Italian Near Me - Evansville, Indiana

OMG. Do not miss this gem. So happy I chose to try this place near where my Sister lives. We had the cheese ravioli for the appetizer along with complimentary rolls and salad. The ravioli and rolls were among the best ive ever had. Will order again sometime. Then i had the shrimp alfredo for my entree and it was also among the best ive ever had. It was so creamy and just the perfect balance of everything youd like in an alfredo. Lastly i had the tiramisu for dessert and the dessert along would make me come back. I am really picky about tiramisu, but this tiramisu is DANGEROUS. I could eat a whole pan. My Sister had the lasagna and said it was delicious. She also throughly enjoyed the cheese ravioli and rolls. Im not really a salad girly, but the one they offered here was definitely one I would eat! Recommend to everyone! read more

It's not too fancy, but I got exactly what I wanted (baked ziti), good portion, priced well, and the available beverages include a few that I liked. The gentleman behind the counter was polite and helpful. I went at an off hour and it was not busy. Older building and interior, but wasn't there for architecture or decorations...I was hungry...and this place satiny needs. Thank You! read more

Always great food! And great service! I love going for lunch! Their tortellini is delicious

We had a party of seven and all received their orders promptly and all dishes were excellent! Our waiter was attentive and helpful. We will happily return again soon! read more

We were in a rush since we were trying to get to the OVC championship and they were more than happy to accommodate this request. Highly recommend the shrimp and scallops with pasta! To our surprise, dinner included a salad and garlic bread. The service was fast and excellent. read more

I always like to start off with the positive. On a warm summery evening, under the shade of huge trees overhead, the sidewalk outdoor dining ambiance of this place is as nice as any place in Rome. And the staff is great -- friendly, prompt and helpful. Now for the bad news: what they gain in atmosphere they lose by cooking lousy food. We shouldn't have to throw $15 onto a plate of food to eat what tastes like leftovers, should we? But when you order "crab cakes served on a bed of Angel Hair pasta," and it arrives within three minutes, noodles hopelessly mushy and crab cakes barely warm, you know that this dish was sitting in the fridge when you took your seat and was microwaved shortly after you ordered it. It gets worse. The "crab cakes" were made from a product called "artificial crab," which is a mass produced, pressed fish meal food substitute and costs about $3 a pound in a supermarket. It has no actual crab in it. Maybe this restaurant thinks it's fooling someone -- and maybe it is -- but that someone is not me. C'mon Angelo, do the right thing. Serve some decent food! You've got a great location, now do something with it. And Angelo, make it a dining experience! Italian dining is not done in 30 minutes. Stop rushing people. Grazie. read more

See all

We went here after being told hour long wait at several other nearby restaurants and ultimately I'm so glad we ended up here! We love family owned vibes and glad for that bc we even got to meet the owner! The food was absolutely fantastic. I got the ravioli and it was some of the best sauce I've ever had. Very tomato based! The salad was excellent as well. I do recommend getting a dip for the bread bc without one, it was pretty plain (still very good though). The server we had was very kind and hooked us up in more ways than one. She also seemed to be very distracted, as our service was extremely slow and other servers were taking our orders and bussing our table for her. We will be returning here in the future! read more

This food was excellent! The owner was very accommodating to my husband's allergy. The service was great and very friendly. I would love to try everything on the menu! However, we live about 200 miles away. Please try this hidden gem in Evansville,IN read more

Food was amazing!!! Love the service, he was super nice and friendly. The atmosphere was very quiet and pleasant. Everything was perfect! read more

See all

Angelo's is good, solid Italian food that it feels like it's catering to their guest base. Service is kind and professional. Friendly with suggestions and happy to help. The house salad is very good. Nice dressing but a free too many chopped black olives which are a bit out of place. I had the Chicken ala Crema. The chicken is tenderized and falls apart under a very thick sauce. Mushrooms were not overcooked which was nice. It's a take on Marsala but the cream gets in the way. So much sauce. Good flavors but it was hard to taste anything but the sauce. Perfectly cooked pasta. They understand the process perfectly. I also had the Tiramisu. The dessert was quite authentic and the server said was made in house. The top layer was a bit frozen so I think the refrigerator was set too low. A nice place. I'll order my dish with easy sauce next time. read more

Angelo's - Chicken Ala Crema - Italian Near Me - Evansville, Indiana

See all

This is one of the true Italian restaurants in EVANSVILLE. Everything is good. Tried the pizza tonight. DELICIOUS. Not my first choice with all the other good things on the menu. Definitely 4.5 bellies read more

Great food. Cleaning looking service was good. Parking is good. Nice place to take family. Highly suggest

Food was superb. However, treated like an inconvenience from waiter. I would have given a 5 star had the service been even a little better. When i walked in the one seating people completely ignored me. And the waiter never once smiled, and barely stopped at the table to get my order: had to ask another waiter for change so i could leave. Just because of service would not recommend especially for the price. And i left a generous tip. read more

Great Food and great atmosphere. Will definitely eat again when we are visiting again.

Delicious food and customer service . So far it's my favorite Italian restaurant . Love absolutely everything in the menu. read more

Owner usees the best tomatoes and the best mozzarella available on the comercial market. Top notch eggplant parmesan layered with ricotta. Pizza would be awesome but the crust is terrible I suspect frozen pizza shells and then proofed in house. Only in Indiana would an Italian restaurant get away with that. Pizza was disappointing. Great service read more

Great service, great food, and very good atmosphere! I recommend the eggplant parmigiana. read more

Angelo's - Eggplant parmigiana - Italian Near Me - Evansville, Indiana

See all

This place definitely blew my expectations out of the water. From walking in to leaving, everything was perfect. I recommend trying the tortellini with chicken. Definitely will be coming back!! read more

Angelo's - Italian Near Me - Evansville, Indiana

FAVORITE place to eat when visiting on business. In one week I went there 3 times. The chicken cordon blue is the BEST. Service is always amazing and their fountain Cokes are the best......real Coke loves will get how important that is. read more

Angelo's - Chicken Cordon Bleu - Italian Near Me - Evansville, Indiana

The food was excellent, the ambience was very nice, especially while seating outside, the service was ok, but what ruined the experience was the seating outside and the staff not conforming to the current COVID suggested regulations. Our server was not initially wearing his mask and my wife had to kindly ask him to put it on, of which he obliged. They also were seating people too close. Overall not a bad dining experience, but not following COVID dropped the experience a bit! read more

Angelo's - Chicken Cordon. It came with salad and a light Italian dressing with rolls. We also ordered the stuffed mushrooms as an appetizer. - Italian Near Me - Evansville, Indiana

See all

Absolutely love coming here! Great food and great atmosphere. Nice place to go on date night or even just for your lunch break!

To be very honest the food is very normal. Like a olive garden type of style, not bad but nothing surprising.

BEST ITALIAN IN EVANSVILLE! I love their fettuccine Alfredo and my husband like the lasagna. You also get garlic knots and salad with meals. Very authentic. read more

We went to Angelo's for dinner before a Jason Aldean concert. The hostess and waiter were very friendly! The toasted ravioli appetizer was really good. My husband ordered the Chicken Alfredo and I ordered the Chicken Ala Crema. Hands down the best Chicken Marsala I have ever eaten. The next time we are in Evansville for a concert, we are eating here! read more

Highly recommend Angelo's for some of the absolute best Italian I've ever had! Everything we ate was delicious! Very friendly staff as well!

Excellent food and excellent service. I enjoyed the Penne Carbonara. My wife's Chicken Parmigiana was tender and flavorful. The lasagna was delicious although the sausage may have been a little strong flavored. When mixing a bite with all the ricotta and toppings it was still good. read more

Angelo's - Empty table because we ate it all before we thought to leave a review. - Italian Near Me - Evansville, Indiana

Yum yum yum! Angelo himself is the best!! My fav is the veal Marsala! I sub in Alfredo instead however and it's Devine! Some amazing rolls and toasted ravioli is the perfect cheesy spice as an app! read more

Absolutely wonderful experience. The food was positively outstanding. Tonight we started with the Crab Cakes which were made fresh and served over a small bed of angel hair, everything covered in a creamy pesto. I ordered the Lasagna after deciding I wanted something traditional. It came out baked in a dish, absolutely delicious in a slightly sweet marinara sauce covered in mozzarella. Mmm. He ordered Tortillini Alla Pesto. A cheese tortillini with peas and sundried tomatoes served in a creamy pesto sauce (which seemed to be a combination of pesto and alfredo, making it very creamy and delicious). The food was outstanding, and we even got free dessert: red velvet cake. Mmm. My only real complaint is the crying baby at a near by table--this seems to be much more of an adult restaurant, lots of ambiance. Also, having to wait a good while be for being waited on. After that though, it was a very pleasant meal. read more

See all

I was fortunate to spend a wonderful evening at Angelo's with family and friends. I was surprised for my birthday. The downstairs area easily accommodated our large party. The staff from the owner,to his wonderful employees, were absolutely superb. The food was amazing from the appetizers, the main course to the desserts. I especially recommend the chicken Alfredo, toasted cheese ravioli and canollis. Next time you have an event, you should definitely plan it for Angelo's. The people,atmosphere, and food will make a great night that much better. read more

My friends & I went to Angelo's for dinner and our experience was amazing. It's New Years Eve so they were super busy, but we still managed to get our food quickly. Our server was super attentive which was nice for how large our party was. The chicken parmigiana was so yummy and their pricing is pretty average for the portion sizes. Our server also made sure that my four year old daughter was happy and went out of her way to ensure a good experience was had. I was a fan of their wine, but because of staffing they did not have a bartended; any liquor we ordered was super strong or the flavors were off. Overall I definitely think this is a place that everyone should try :) read more

Excellent dining experience! Food was great, presentation pleasing, and service was efficient and personal! We enjoyed catching up with friends over a delicious dinner of Chicken a la Angelo's, a veal dish, and shrimp Alfredo! We definitely weren't rushed for our table! We'll be back to one of our favorites! read more

I must say that when walking in I was a little skeptical, the front entry did not made the best impression. Well, I was wrong ! The place is rather basic but fresh garlic rolls came out quick and plenty of them The meal includes a bowl of mixed House salat and was nice and fresh. The seafood dish was great ! Very nicely done and tasty! The service was quick and friendly and the prices are very reasonable ! All in all a very good experience ! We see you again ! read more

My husband I went here before a concert and were rushed for time but our food was excellent. We can't wait to go back. Our food was excellent and the service was too. read more

Angelo's - White wine with dinner - Italian Near Me - Evansville, Indiana

Went here for lunch, late on a Friday afternoon. Our party of three ordered toasted cheese ravioli, crab cakes and baked ziti. Salad and bread automatically came with our dishes and were served family style. Overall, each dish was delicious and service was outstanding. Will definitely be back. read more

My family and I found this spot on accident. I was a little nervous to go in because how it looks on the outside and the inside decor outdated. Our waiter was excellent and the food was outstanding! The only reason I didn't give 5 stars is because whatever they use to clean the floor is oil based and slippery, I was fearful I was going to fall. I watched two others have the same probably walking through the restaurant. read more

Average. Mediocre. Salad was swimming in dressing. Rolls (packaged) were swimming in butter and garlic splashed with pesto. Overwhelming. Tortellini Alfredo was nothing special. Overcooked pasta. Not any better than store bought. Really was hoping for better quality at super high price. The tortellini and a Diet Coke was $23. read more

Walking in provides the aroma of real Italian restaurants in Chicago. Excellent house salad that's a perfect complement for the southern Italian meal. Service was quick and efficient and the meal was excellent, as with each visit to Angelo's. A nice touch is the available dining in front on the walkway with white table cloths. Pleasant way to spend a summer evening. The only negative is the restaurant interior could use a little freshening. On the other hand, maybe that just adds to the character of this excellent Italian restaurant. We've had several repeat visits and the experience is always good. When we're still talking about the meal the next day...that's a mark of fine dining! read more

Angelo's - Italian Near Me - Evansville, Indiana

Wonderful food fresh, hot, service is great. Definitely a must for anyone in the Evansville area. We will be back!!!