Angelo&#x27;s

Fantastic Italian food! Its our regular place we go every week seriously i cant get enough! Lasagna…read moreand pasta Roma their spaghetti with meat sauce and their crabcakes are divine

Worth the wait and the money..love the vibe.. small and dim just like a old romantic movie.read more

The Little Italy Restaurant in Evansville Indiana

Shrimp penne pasta, Alfredo, Parmesan cheese, very good.

See all

Huge order of Lasagna yum!

Biaggi's Ristaronte Italiano - Evansville

3.8(221 reviews)

5.4 mi

I just needed a good comfort food meal and to get away and clear my head…read more Wow, what a great experience here from the focaccia bread with dipping oil to the wedge salad. It was really good. Most places give one big wedge. They do three small wedges here that way you don't get a bunch of lettuce at the bottom and no toppings. The Bruschetta bread was really good. I did the Pick two shrimp scampi with a kicked in up sauce and the other one was scallops with apples and a honey glaze with some crumbles. Service is excellent here. Jordan is a great waiter and very prompt with refills and checking on me. The dining room atmosphere is nice and quiet and charming. Not too busy for a Sunday afternoon.

Visited Biaggi's while in Evansville for a swim meet. The service was wonderful on the floor but…read morethe kitchen was obviously overwhelmed. I found the restaurant to be loud. So loud it was difficult to carry on a conversation and so loud it spoiled to overall experience. Now to the food... the wedge salad was fantastic, the bread was hot and tasty but the entrée was less than satisfying. I asked for a cup of soup that came out with the entrée. The spaghetti and meatball entrée was hot but the meatballs were significantly overcooked. I had high expectations as the decor is very nice and the staff was approachable. I won't be back due to the issues mentioned above.

The room.

Biaggi's Ristaronte Italiano - Evansville

See all

Menu

Smitty's Italian Steakhouse

3.0(137 reviews)

1.5 mi

Had dinner there last night (Friday) and we all (5) made the decision that we would NOT be back!…read moreThe table we were seated at had an old plastic table cloth with numerous tears, looked terrible. After waiting about two hours we received our entrees. We all agreed taste was ok at best. Steak was not prepared accurately, a chicken cutlet picatta came out on a plate with only two cutlets. Presentation was horrible, looked like it was thrown together. Ordered the side of pasta, finally got it as we were ready walk out the door, served to go. Did get a comp of $5, oh boy. Alfredo had red sauce splattered around. Our server was polite and apologetic. We don't know who had the most fault, but as I said this is our last time there!

Nice, quiet little restaurant in the historic district. The architecture is beautiful, the ambience…read moreso warm and inviting. The staff were so friendly and accommodating. Everything was served orderly, not too long of a wait, and it all tasted excellent. I had an appetizer, salad, main course and a drink from the bar. All were fantastic. My waiter was Michael, who was kind and made sure my entire stay was enjoyable. Will be back next time I'm in town!

Interior

Fettuccine Alfredo, potato skins, house salad

See all

Ice cold beer

Pangea Kitchen

4.7(335 reviews)

4.3 mi

Total different new age take on a pizza creation that me and my partner enjoyed! Service was…read morepriority and very clean tidy facility, I would recommend!

The drunken noodles were a masterclass in disappointment, the kind of dish that confidently walks…read moreinto your life and immediately lowers your expectations for everything else. They redefined "flavor" as a full-contact salt assault on my taste buds, like my mouth accidentally signed up for a sodium-based action movie. What arrived was essentially plain noodles in a flimsy oyster sauce disguise, like a sad costume party where everyone showed up as "slightly sauced pasta" and no one committed to the theme. If you've ever wondered what it's like to taste the ocean's worst mood swing, congratulations--this is your dish. And just when I thought things couldn't get more confusing, the pizza arrived, boldly pretending to be pizza while secretly auditioning as naan bread in a low-budget culinary identity crisis.

Open Kitchen

See all

Old Fashioned

Milanos Italian Cusine

3.3(31 reviews)

0.1 mi

Dinner was yummy service great piano music made meal special my dish was baked zita with garlic…read moreknots and salad my water was kept full and our table was checked on as needed

Decided to try this place last night for dinner. It wasn't crowded at all, the waiter was very…read morenice. The atmosphere was a little strange. It looks like it hasn't been updated in decades and was decorated in the typical Italian-American sort of way. The salad and rolls were free with our meals which I will say were pretty tasty. The salad dressing was a pretty usual Italian style oil/vinegar situation; not sure if they make it themselves but I quite enjoyed it. The garlic rolls were tasty and fresh. We also got toasted ravioli which was also good, maybe a little oily. I got chicken parm for an entree and I was somewhat disappointed. The chicken texture was weird and it was dry. There was also a lot of grease that had leached out from the cheese on my plate. The sauce was unremarkable. Had better, had worse. They do also make pizza which I'm curious to try. But as of now, I don't think I would recommend this place. Theres simply better options for Italian food in town.

The yummy bucket of unwrapped straws.

See all

Chicken Parmesan.

The Lobo Lounge

4.5(14 reviews)

1.2 mi

This place is great place to get lunch or dinner, they even have breakfast. My friend and I tried…read morethis place after a mutual friend recommended it. It did not disappoint. We went to Lobo Lounge about 1:15 on a Thursday afternoon. The place had a couple people in there, but we were greeted as soon as we entered which is a HUGE in my book. I enjoyed the Loaded BBQ Chicken nachos and the BBQ sauce was sweet and mildly spicy. It was delicious. They were actually out of their normal tortilla chips but found a way to improvise as I showed my disappointment. I thought that was really nice and most any other restaurant I've gone to would not even consider this. So I was really impressed with their service. My friend got the pizza with pineapple, ham and brown sugar and it was excellent. She let me sample it. The crust was great, a thin style but crispy chewy... really good. Someone said they allow smoking on their review but that is no longer true. The staff was extremely friendly and went out of their way to make us comfortable and satisfied (as I mentioned early about the chips). The chef that made our food was personable and funny, he even let me sample his own sandwich he had just came up with for himself - it was delicious! Our server was so friendly and prompt, I wish I could remember her name. The prices were a nice surprise and so we will be going back very soon to try a lot of the other great sounding food they offer. They have a parking area across the street in addition to street parking. There is also an outdoor dining area that would be great for the evening or if the weather hadn't been so hot. The only thing negative I can say is the place is a little small but not really intimate because their juke box is a little too loud to have a quiet conversation at least I thought it was too loud for lunch. We were still able to talk, but I felt I had to talk louder than normal and ask her to repeat herself more than I should've. Overall, I highly recommend this little hidden gem.

This spot is awesome! Was working in Henderson for a couple of weeks and wanted to try everything…read morelocal....Cant go wrong here! I had the famous stromboli and my sister had the nachos and chicken wings. They even gave us a free sample of their salt & vinegar wings...They are the bomb!!!! Love that they make everything right in front of you and they make their own sauces! Super impressed that they check their wings with a thermometer to make sure they are the right temp! Sorry I didnt get a pic of the nachos before they were gone...A half order is HUGE!

See all

Gardo's Italian Oven

4.1(25 reviews)

8.9 mi

•$

Amazing pizza. Great ingredients with exceptional flavors. Top notch!…read more I can't say enough great things about heir pizza!

Extremely disappointing experience. We paid about $75 for three small pizzas and canned sodas, and…read morethe pizza was not good. The crust tasted like frozen/pre-made dough, and for the price, we expected much better quality. What made the experience even stranger was the atmosphere. There are only about four tables in the restaurant, and the owners were occupying most of the available seating while eating takeout food from another restaurant in the same complex. There was also an ashtray with cigarette butts sitting on one of the indoor tables. One of the owners came over to introduce himself and speak with us, and based on his behavior during our interaction, he appeared to be extremely intoxicated. It was uncomfortable and certainly not what we expected while dining at a restaurant. The whole experience was bizarre. When the people running a pizza restaurant are sitting in their own dining room eating food from somewhere else, that says quite a bit. Unfortunately, between the food, the price, and the atmosphere, we will not be returning.

Burnt crust.

Gladiator Pizza

See all

Dedicated staff taking orders - open kitchen.

Little Angelo's

3.6(50 reviews)

9.6 mi

The food is good but not great, and they tack on a MANDATORY 20% gratuity, and a 3.99% add on for…read morethe use of any kind of card. If it weren't for my friends who really like the crab cakes, I'd have absolutely no reason to eat there. Maybe I won't be able to make it next time...

Service was very iffy on a holiday weekend…read more Good food. (I have to add more characters to post this review, so I feel like our party of 12 got ignored. No refills. Naive hosts and waiters. And then a forced tip. Felt like the forced tip was a reason to be ignored. We were polite, we asked and waited, but the establishment was not ready. We had a reservation..... They failed. This might have been a one time issue, but it most definitely made us all feel unwelcome.

Chicken Marsala

Cannoli

See all

Spaghetti with meatsauce

Lombardi's New York Pizza and Wings

4.4(66 reviews)

5.1 mi

Only thing that sucks about this place is the hours! We would end up here all the time if it…read moredidn't close so early! With kids and sports we end up eating around 9:00 and they are closed by 8:00 :/ This is by far the best pizza spot in the Ville! They have amazing "slice of the day". They have these delicious mozzaballs and great NY cheesecake! Crave them often, get to satisfy those cravings rarely ... sad face

This New York-style pizza and wings offers an authentic experience rarely found elsewhere in…read moreSouthern Indiana.The crust was excellent with air pockets found in the outer crust and the wings were of decent size and taste. The real winner though was the stromboli we ordered. It exceeded anything else we've found -- including a so-called famous strom found in our hometown of Bloomington. The guys were nice. Frankly, the absence of "New York attitude" was good too. Focus is on the food.

Buffalo Bone-In 12 Wings

See all

The Calzone

Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

3.0(72 reviews)

4.4 mi

I just got home from the Olive Garden and the food was delicious I had the eggplant parmesan and…read morethe salad.Service was great all I had to drink was water and it was a glass that never went dry. Ambiance was wonderful had light music in the back ground and was smoothing .

Ordered cocktails. They were delayed. He said the Bartender was behind - just like the last time…read morewe were there. He kept presssuring us to order and I said I like to have my cocktail before dinner. He brought Salad and then asked for our orders again. The G&T came with the salad. It came with the ice melted and even though I ordered it with a lime (Classic right) It had none. There were 4 of us and all ate salad. Needed a refill, unfortunately Dinner was served immediately. We did get another salad. At the end, I felt extremely rushed. when we arrived, we told the server we were on two tabs but when he sat the credit card machine down he said, we'd have to split it up ourselves unless we had cash. All in all, the food was good. Just not a pleasant dining experience.

Fettuccine Alfredo: Our signature alfredo made fresh in-house every day, served over fettuccine.

Minestrone: Fresh vegetables, beans and pasta in a light tomato broth.

Olive Garden Italian Restaurant - Five Cheese Ziti al Forno: Oven baked blend of Italian cheeses, pasta and our signature homemade five cheese marinara.

See all

Five Cheese Ziti al Forno: Oven baked blend of Italian cheeses, pasta and our signature homemade five cheese marinara.

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

9 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Marta R.

62

3

0

11 years ago

Great meal, and excellent service. The manager, Jason server us personally as is was a busy night and we got our food very quickly. The chicken cordon bleu was delicious and my friend's meal was as well. The salsd & galic rolls were also very good. We will definitely be going back. It is a good place to eat before a concert or performance downtown. I highly recommend. read more

Tricia R.

0

1

0

4 years ago

Amazing food! Great service! If I had to make one complaint, I'd say the salad was a little overdressed, but no big deal considering the overall quality of the meal. We were visiting from out of town, from another state even, and truly impressed to find that Evansville had a great little Italian restaurant! read more

Dawn O.

6

4

1

6 years ago

Absolutely one of the best Italian restaurants I have been to out of Chicagoland where I am from. I had Eggplant Parmesan and we had a pizza too. They serve salad and garlic breadsticks with the meal also. Very accommodating. Second time we were there while we visited there in the past month. Thank you! read more

David W.

0

2

0

11 years ago

Your review helps others learn about great local businesses. Please don't review this business if you received a freebie for writing this review, or if you're connected in any way to the owner or employees.Newburgh's latest and one of the best resturaunts read more

Andrew M.

0

1

0

6 years ago

Angelos served our group of 42 reasonably with great meals. It was so good that we changed our dinner plans and ran it back again the next day. Next time I'm back in Evansville, Angelo's will be my only call! read more

Christian A.

0

1

0

1 year ago

if I could give it zero I would, the owner is a worthless scum bag. wouldn't let us eat there because my brother works on the powerlines at Centerpoint trying to prove a political message. absolutely hateful read more

Click4AMeal ..

0

1

6 years ago

We want to thank Angelo's Italian Restaurant for choosing our Online Ordering System! We are proud to be your partner. Hurry up and place your order today! https://angelosevansville.click4ameal.net/ read more

Jennifer C.

55

2

6

11 years ago

We had Angelos cater a family gathering, it was amazing. Everything was fresh and flavorful and they delivered it right on time!

Brian R.

2

21

3

14 years ago

Outstanding food and outstanding service. The rolls were incredible! The staff very professional! The food excellent!

Angelo's - italian - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Evansville, Indiana Restaurants near Angelo's

BEST of Evansville, Indiana Coffee near Angelo's

BEST of Evansville, Indiana Things to Do near Angelo's

BEST of Evansville, Indiana Desserts near Angelo's

BEST of Evansville, Indiana Cocktail Bars near Angelo's

BEST of Evansville, Indiana Pizza near Angelo's

BEST of Evansville, Indiana Parking near Angelo's

BEST of Evansville, Indiana Shopping near Angelo's

BEST of Evansville, Indiana Dinner near Angelo's

BEST of Evansville, Indiana Wineries near Angelo's

Best of Evansville

Things to do in Evansville

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Angelo's also viewed

Milanos Italian Cusine

3.3

(31 reviews)

Dinner was yummy service great piano music made meal special my dish was baked zita with garlic…read moreknots and salad my water was kept full and our table was checked on as needed

Decided to try this place last night for dinner. It wasn't crowded at all, the waiter was very…read morenice. The atmosphere was a little strange. It looks like it hasn't been updated in decades and was decorated in the typical Italian-American sort of way. The salad and rolls were free with our meals which I will say were pretty tasty. The salad dressing was a pretty usual Italian style oil/vinegar situation; not sure if they make it themselves but I quite enjoyed it. The garlic rolls were tasty and fresh. We also got toasted ravioli which was also good, maybe a little oily. I got chicken parm for an entree and I was somewhat disappointed. The chicken texture was weird and it was dry. There was also a lot of grease that had leached out from the cheese on my plate. The sauce was unremarkable. Had better, had worse. They do also make pizza which I'm curious to try. But as of now, I don't think I would recommend this place. Theres simply better options for Italian food in town.

Bastoni

4.4

(15 reviews)

Date Night Dinner…read more Enjoyed a delicious dinner tonight at Bastoni in Newburgh. We were fans of Little Angelo's so we were not sure what to expect. Definitely glad we finally gave them a try. The interior remodel made the restaurant feel so much more open and brighter. Our server, August, was the absolute best. She gave me a great description of the Veal Parmesan, which was so delicious. She kept our drinks filled and those garlic knots replenished. Their stuffed mushroom, lasagna and cannolis were just as yummy as before and the salad was fresh and crisp and now saturated in dressing. We will definitely be returning. Sorry only picture we got was of my to go Tiramisu

We've been looking forward to trying Bastoni's pizza, it was definitely worth waiting for. As…read morenative New Yorkers, my husband and I are always searching for good pizza. Although the pizza is cut in squares, (not a NY triangle cut 8 slice pie) it was absolutely delicious, the flavor of the sauce was pretty fabulous and it was obvious that the cheese products used are of good quality. We'll definitely be coming back again. No pictures, we were too busy eating and talking about the great flavors.

Crust and Roll Pizza&Sushi

4.7

(9 reviews)

Pizza is gourmet! Crazy little great find for pizza and sushi. I highly recommend! It's definitely…read moreone of our favorite pizza places.

Service was very good and attentive. You wouldn't think of a pizza joint fussed with a sushi joint…read morebut they make it work well. Extremely well made rolls avg cost $12.50 per. The presentation of the rolls was Michelin quality. Highly recommend!

Spankey's Una Pizza

4.3

(63 reviews)

We arrived at 9pm on a Saturday night and we were seated in a booth immediately. The restaurant…read morewasn't busy, as it was pretty late. The decor was colorful and the music playlist was perfect for this millenial! Our server, Jake, was awesome. He was super nice and kept our drinks full. We started with a half order of classic buffalo wings. They were pretty petite but extremely flavorful and fresh. We went with a 20 inch Philly Steak pizza. It was AMAZING. Queso sauce, real pieces of steak, peppers, onions, mushrooms. The crust was great texture. We definitely fell in love! The menu has the usual apps and sammies but there are quite a few unique pizzas to try. We will be back for sure!

We ordered the cheese toast, Stromboli pizza, and the House special pizza. We enjoyed everything we…read moreordered. Our waiter was very friendly. We came on a Sunday afternoon and it was not busy at all. We were able to walk right in and get a table. We love that they have Graeter's Ice Cream for dessert! If you ever find yourself on the West Side and want pizza, this is a good option!

Deerhead Sidewalk Cafe & Bar

(80 reviews)

Food is never disappointing that's why it's a place we frequent often!…read moreEven when they are busy the service is always great! The ambiance and atmosphere is great very welcoming!

I ordered a 1/2 Deerhead club sandwich. It is described on the menu as being "thinly sliced turkey,…read moreroast beef, smoked ham and cheddar cheese on a hoagie bun. It does not come with tomato, onion, lettuce of mayonnaise, you have to order it on the side. I also ordered a cup of beef vegetable soup with my meal. What was served to me did not in the least look like what the menu described. It looked like ground beef with cheese melted on top. When I told the waitress that this was not the club sandwich that I had ordered, she assured me that it was their club sandwich. Upon looking at the menu online it appears to be their BBC sandwich instead of the Club. I went ahead and dressed the sandwich with the lettuce, tomato, and onion (I had asked for mayonnaise too, it didn't have any on the side, nor could I see or taste any on the sandwich) I dressed the sandwich and ate it. While it didn't taste bad, the hoagie bun was soft, but the meat and cheese inside were bland and had absolutely no flavor. I didn't taste turkey, smoked ham, or beef. Even the tomato had no flavor. The only thing I could taste was the red onion they served with it. The waitress forgot to bring my soup and I had to ask for it. It was good but could have used more salt. My overall impression of the food was not bad, but I certainly was not impressed. The last time I ate there, I had their Greek Salad (I had been told that it was wonderful, it was not.) I have a lot of friends who love to eat there. I guess I just haven't ordered the right dish. My husband had their Stromboli and said it was very good. I think it will be very unlikely that I will ever go back. The seating was good and the restaurant was clean. Our waitress was nice . Other than forgetting to bring my soup and not correcting my order, she was fairly attentive.

Sam's Pizzeria

(29 reviews)

•$

Started looking at places to go pick up food from. Checked out their website. But when I saw…read morealmost double the prices on some items without any noticeable improvement to the quality. I was turned off. Love the stroms. But when the prices almost doubled. It's good just not that good. 25$ for a 14 inch pizza is crazy. 29 for a 16 inch. 12 for a strom. That I swear used to be bigger I may be wrong. Disappointing. Lost a long time customer.

My husband and I love Sam's. They are always welcoming and friendly, great service. Their foods are…read morealways freshly made and delicious. We will miss them, heading back to Washington. When we are in town we will always stop here! Thank you for always making us feel like family! Pizza picture: the big meat, kitchen sink Dessert: Apple empanadas & cinnamon bread

Turoni's Pizzery & Brewery - Forget Me Not

(39 reviews)

One of our favorite pizza places when we're in Evansville. Craft beers are great too.read more

Ok.. I spent 17 years in the pizza business so I consider myself a pizza "snob". Some friends…read morewanted to meet up here and when I saw the outside I knew it would be good! At first glance this place had the feel of an old school pizzeria. Think late 70's and early 80's and you'd be spot on! The waitstaff was friendly, punctual and attentive. I order the flight of beer, which comes with one of each of their self-brewed beers, and the IPA was the best. The crust I would give a 2 (because I don't like thin) but the sauce and combination of toppings made me forget I was eating a cracker! If you've never been here give it a whirl. Oh, yeah... the walls are decorated with photos and news clippings of local and otherworldly famous people who have visited, so there is definitely a cult following!

Lily’s Mediterranean Express

(13 reviews)

We were passing through on a road trip and this place was where we stopped for a bite to eat. It is…read morea great grab and go place. They have some outdoor seating as well when the weather is nice. The owner was super nice and knowledgeable on the menu. We had people in our party with various dietary needs (vegetarian, vegan, gluten free) and they were accommodating to all of our questions and we all LOVED our meals. 10/10 spot.

This is a small place but worth a visit! You order at the counter inside and then either get your…read morefood to go or eat on the patio. We got the chicken schwarma rice bowl and the stuffed pepper rice bowl, kids chicken tenders and some deserts. We ordered the Dubai chocolate cup and I mentioned that we've been influenced about them. The counter guy was like "oh you like viral foods? We also have the viral fruit pastries!!" So we got the raspberry and strawberry ones! My kids were so excited. We at the pastries while we waited for the food and they were delicious. The raspberry was wonderfully tart and the strawberry was smooth and delightful. The food came out in good time and smelled amazing. We ate when I got to our hotel room (about 45 mins later) and the food was still delicious. The meat was well spiced and the portions were big.

Sandy's Pizza

3.0

(50 reviews)