The food is good but not great, and they tack on a MANDATORY 20% gratuity, and a 3.99% add on for the use of any kind of card. If it weren't for my friends who really like the crab cakes, I'd have absolutely no reason to eat there. Maybe I won't be able to make it next time... read more

Service was very iffy on a holiday weekend. Good food. (I have to add more characters to post this review, so I feel like our party of 12 got ignored. No refills. Naive hosts and waiters. And then a forced tip. Felt like the forced tip was a reason to be ignored. We were polite, we asked and waited, but the establishment was not ready. We had a reservation..... They failed. This might have been a one time issue, but it most definitely made us all feel unwelcome. read more

Go Check out there new Patio. Enjoy some Music. And Have some of the best Italian around. The Chicken A la Crema is my favorite read more

Little Angelo's - a plate of salad and a bottle of beer - Italian Near Me - Newburgh, Indiana

See all

I consider myself an Alfredo snob. I make it at home and have practiced perfecting it for years and it's wonderful. I would never never ever buy Alfredo from a jar! I've ate Italian food all around the United States from New York to Chicago and this Alfredo is my favorite! The pesto tortellini is outstanding! Its actually the only thing I've ever ordered. It's so rich and creamy with peas, mushrooms and sun dried tomatoes. If I had to give constructive feedback it would to add more mushrooms, peas and sun dried tomatoes as it's just a hint. Portions are good and you should take 1/2 to go , hard to do! Their salad is also good as it's very zingy and zesty! I wish the garlic knots or rolls had 50% more garlic on them. Eat here, it's great! read more

Hours need to be updated please , we were there today at noon and doors locked ! The one downtown was a bit too far , now going to think about those stuffed mushrooms for days ! read more

Little Angelo's is a nice restaurant that offers refreshing beverages and yummy Italian food. The Chicken with cooked with Marsala wine is fine! I also love the fresh salad mix. Sooo delicious! read more

Absolutely love eating here. The food is prepared when ordered, the salads that come with entrees are the best ever. Pizza is excellent! Their portions are quite large as my husband and I we always split even our appetizer, best appetizer I've ever had at a restaurant is there crabcakes? They are a must so delicious. In addition for the atmosphere, their service and the taste of the food I rate this a five star restaurant. Our waitress is one of the best. I find it very affordable! Pam E. read more

Little Angelo's - Meat pizza - Italian Near Me - Newburgh, Indiana

Good food at a reasonable price. Got takeout and food was still hot when I got it home

The food and service are always fantastic! My husband and I eat there about once a week.

Everything was excellent. The veal Parmesan was everything we hope for being real pasta lovers.

It's a cute little restaurant with decent food. They have great salad. It's definitely worth a visit.

We stopped in for a late lunch. Splitting a pasta and having salads and those yummy rolls. Mary Anne served us and made good drinks and gave good service, attentive but not intrusive. Atmosphere was great. read more

Mediocre food, not great service and rundown inside. We won't be back. Disappointing and pricey.

We really enjoyed our dining experience here. We got there at 6:45 on a Friday night and got right in. The place was crowded but they do a good job of quickly turning over tables. We quickly got our drinks ordered. I got the house Chianti which was a big pour and a good tasting wine for $6. I ordered the lasagna and my wife ordered the eggplant parmesan. The lasagna was delicious. It came out baked with a good red sauce, tasty cheese, and right amount of noodles. Deceptive amount of lasagna in the bowl. My wife said the eggplant was delicious. It came out baked and the eggplant was perfect. Lightly fried and breaded eggplant with cheese and the good red sauce. The service was perfect and our server could not have been nicer. read more

Just had a wonderful dinner with our family here, it was all great! Our server was on it. We will definitely be back.

I've eaten here a couple times now and have really enjoyed the food. I haven't been disappointed. The service is always friendly. If you go for lunch the prices are reduced, but there's still more than enough food. Get a side salad for $2. read more

Amazing food with paired authenticity. The Marsala is that if a more traditional style and true to how I know it should be. Have never had a single disappointing meal here. read more

Little Angelo's - Chicken Marsala - Italian Near Me - Newburgh, Indiana

Three steps above Fazoli's one step below Olive Garden. Very good food nicely priced. Had the fried ravioli and spinach ravioli followed up with some tiramisu. read more

Little Angelo's - Spinach Ravioli - Italian Near Me - Newburgh, Indiana

We like to support local business. Went in and was not busy. Had appetizer and salad. Tables around us got food and left. 2 tables after us got food and were ordering desserts. We ask and were told it was due to lots of to go orders?????? If that were true why all the orders coming out before ours??? Very poor service with no apology just a lame excuse. Will never go back. read more

Great local Italian place for a quiet dinner. We've always had hot, tasty meals here. The inside of the restaurant has a nice theme. We'll be back. read more

This restaurant is a hidden gem. It's serves family style on the weekends with unlimited salad and garlic knots. And the garlic knots you will want to keep eating. All the food is made authentic and the service is great. read more

See all

This place was stumbled upon by accident and SO GLAD WE DID. Some of the best Italian food I have ever had. Wish I would have taken a pic but couldn't wait to dig in. Service was great.....definitely will be back read more

I waited 2 hours for fettuccine Alfredo, cheese sauce and noodles ...while the restaurant was empty, waiter had an attitude the whole time and brought out completely different meals to our table, first time going there and will never be back absolutely horrible service. So bad I had to download Yelp just to let others know. read more

Eggplant Parmesan. Omg. It's amazing and delicious. I've also had the raviolis, which were great. But the Parmesan is just the best Italian meal I've had in years. Salad and bread are okay. Would be nice if they freshly grated Parmesan and asked if we wanted freshly grated pepper for the salad, at the prices. But the entree is worth it. read more

I have ordered here several times now, three takeouts and today we ate in. The food has consistently been delicious and the service exceptional. My experience with this restaurant has always been exceptional, I'm not sure why they have the lower star but in my opinion it's a 5 star!! My favorite is the shrimp alredo and the rolls!! Thank you for the amazing food and service!!!! read more

Worth a sit. Well decorated - not too ornate but enough for a nice ambiance. May need a reservation for 4 or more. Limited menu, but covers most popular dishes. Also a good idea for a new location (I imagine the downtown menu is same? though). Service was good, waiter probably checked up on us a bit too much. We were seated quickly, water/salad/entree brought on time. Buttered buns a little too greasy but seasoned well. Salad was a little heavy on dressing. Lasagna was good portion and taste. Chicken masala w mushrooms and noodles was good with excellent proportion of ingredients. The house merlot and Chianti were nice - not harsh or sweet. Prices are fairly close to Biaggi's but the overall experience is not yet as good. I like having another dining option close by. We had a $43 bill w/o appetizer. Average portion size. Give Angelo's a try but keep expectations in check. read more

See all

Went last night and the service was very very sub-par. We came in around 6:30 and they closed at 8 because it was Sunday. The server, Kaitlyn made us feel very rushed but that not what even bothered me honestly. We both ordered Alfredo so it comes with a salad. We asked to have it with ranch, she brings it out with their house dressing. Also not a big deal, I ask again if we can get it with ranch. She kinda makes it seem like we're putting her out but whatever. I start eating this salad and I notice after a few bites this long blonde hair in my salad. I have thick curly black hair, definitely wasn't mine. She comes up we tell her about it. She looked at me like she didn't believe me, didn't even look at the hair I was pointing at on my plate. And instead of say sorry or can I make this right she says "well it must've been an accident". Well no shit, I'd hope it was an accident. This type of stuff happens all the time in restaurants, it's how you deal with it that matters and I don't think it was dealt with properly. Now that being said I'm not saying don't go to Little Angelo's because their food is great. I'd just watch for what server you get. She also messed up the food for the people who came in after us and they were complaining about it. We also asked about if the cheesecake was baked and she never gave us an answer. We asked in the beginning of the bread was something we could get more of and she didn't ask once if we wanted more. We actually tried to ask a few times but she was in such a rush that we never got a chance. And it wasn't even busy there was 3 tables there total. I did consider asking to talk to a manager but she took our drinks off our check so I said good enough let's go, because they were obviously rushing to close down. read more

Excellent service, below average food. I had Lasagna, which consisted of a bout 1TBSP of bland meat, canned tomato sauce and overcooked noodles. No taste really. Wife's Fettuccini just tasted weird. I couldn't have had more than one bite if I had ordered that. Almost felt like the dishes were all frozen portions microwaved. Salad was lettuce, tomatoes, black olives and tasteless oil/vinegar. Garlic knots were the best part but nothing special and really heavy on the garlic. Waitress was very upbeat and always checked on us. Decoration is very nice and if only they could get the food to match the atmosphere. Me and another guest were pretty sure there was a couple "celebrating" Valentine's Day in the Men's room as it was occupied for a LONG time. Overall it's not worth it. You're better off spending money across the street. read more

Smh...Yelp listing categorizes this restaurant as a business that provides a delivery service. They do NOT deliver! Yeah, it says takeout when you launch the details...WHYYYYYYY? Is is that difficult to get services into their database correctly? read more

I forgot I was here once before. It's ok. Nothing to get overly excited about. Food was a tiny tiny bit bland. Their garlic rolls need a little more zip in their step. I had the lasagna and my baby had the spaghetti with meat sauce. Crab cakes graced our table as an appetizer and they were pretty good. Overall it was OK. Give it at least one try and decide for yourself. read more

Chicken Marsala... WOW!!! I had been having a craving for this but it's hard to cook for one. I tried it via delivery last week and was MORE than impressed! The chicken was moist and tender and the reduced white wine, paired with the mushrooms, gave it the sweet, dry, earthy taste. Ordering again for the second time in a week! read more

I have NEVER paid 15.00 for a meal and left hungry! I had chicken Marsala; the chicken breast had been pounded down to less than 1/4 inch thick and cut in small pieces. I had 4 pieces on my plate that measured about 2 x 4 inches and a scoop, literally a scoop of spaghetti! The mushrooms and sauce were fabulous. Another person at our table ordered spaghetti and meatballs. The meatballs were the ones you would buy at Sam's, Costco or GNC. How hard is it for a supposedly Italian restaurant to make fresh meatballs. They were so bad that they only ate 1. Will not go back. read more

It's not the downtown one. The table cloth was dirty, the calamari came from Sam's along with the tortellini. The Alfredo sauces were decent but nothing you could not get out of a jar. The pizza for the kids was good but not as good as across the street. Service was excellent. read more

Took a family of five, three kids and two adults to Little Angelo's this evening, and it went very well. The food was top notch, maybe the best Baked Ziti I've had. Wife loved the Carbonara. The kids both got fettuccine alfredo and loved it. Very generous portions on the adult & kids plates. They serve the salad family style, and a basket of garlic rolls. Only not giving a five star due to the fact that we didn't get plates to eat the salad with, and had to re-use our appetizer plates. We got the fried provolone (cheese sticks) and they were very good. I would say that it is a bit pricey but not any more than any other Italian restaurant i've been to around here. Perfect place for a birthday or special occasion. I recommend it highly. Having a nice Italian restaurant in Newburgh is a nice change from the mass of pizza and Mexican restaurants that we have. read more

We started with the stuffed mushrooms which were tasty followed by the house salad and rolls. Yum. I had the Tortellini ala Pesto which was wonderful. It had a lot of flavor and was cream but not drowned in sauce. My hubby had the Chicken Marsala. It was a little sweet for me but the very tender and moist. We really enjoyed our visit and are happy to see a nicer restaurant in Newburgh. read more

The food is decent and the service is fine. My only complaint is the temperature of restaurant. It felt like it was 65° in the dinning room. We told the waitress and her response was they have to keep it cold to cut down on the humidity in the restaurant and if they don't keep it that cold, the floor gets slippery. So we put our food in boxes and left. read more

We stopped in for dinner and we really, greatly surprised. The food was/is wonderful!! The rolls are to die for! They melted in our mouth.

I love the salad and garlic rolls! So delicious. Their spinach ravioli and fettuccini Alfredo are both great. I've always had very nice waiters here. Great place in Newburgh! read more

I love Angelo's in downtown Evansville so I was really excited to see a new location closer to home. I was a little worried that it wouldn't be the same though, and unfortunately my worries were confirmed when I ate here this evening. First came the garlic knots which I always enjoy. They were good but not quite as good as the Evansville ones. I ordered what I always get: chicken alfredo. My favorite part is the chicken because it's breaded and so tender. It really makes the dish! What I got tonight was not nearly as good. The sauce was great and tasted the same for the most part, but the chicken was incredibly disappointing. It wasn't breaded, it was grilled and very boring. I'm sad to say that I was not satisfied with the Newburgh location. Now I know that it's definitely worth the drive downtown for the real Angelo's. read more

I ordered online via Yelp, their menu neglects to let you know the dinner entrees come with a salad. So I ordered a side salad and spent the extra money for no reason. I let them know when I went to pick up my food and saw all the salads - they said sorry but since I paid online they couldn't fix it...sure they could have - a coupon for an appetizer, free dessert etc would have been just fine... When we got home the salads where old lettuce as the iceberg lettuce was orange - very disappointment. I suspected they may not be aware of my online order and called a few minutes after I placed my order and sure enough it caught them by surprise. To their defense they are new to Yelp so they will most likely get used to keeping an eye out for online orders. But I would call to make sure they saw the order for the time being. Overall I think this will be the last time I order from there. read more