I think made in Italy is 5 stars. Now - I am sure some might ask how you can rate Otto's 3 stars…read moreand made in Italy 5. But you have to rate what they are made for. If you want comfort Italian on a Thursday night at home. This is your spot. I would pick them 100 times out of 100. Pizza is excellent and well priced for what you get. Pastas pack a punch but are well sized. Service is incredible and whilst I have never eaten there it's never long to wait. I actually ate a couple of times at the restaurant before it became just a takeaway and it was perfectly fine. Service 5/5 Food 5/5 Ambiance 4/5 Price 5/5

The reviews previously written definitely do this place justice. The pizza and pasta were great,…read morethe service okay, and the atmosphere was pleasant. The price was a little high, but the quality of the food was worth it. That all being said it wasn't a very memorable dining experience, neither good nor bad. It's convenient and cute so I'll likely go back.

I had been scouring the internet for a good restaurant for the boy's birthday. Nothing too fancy,…read moresmaller/more intimate setting, decent pricing and overall just solid food. I had a very hard time making a reservation. Their website on my mobile within the yelp app never finished loading. Neither when I switched to safari mobile browser. Neither when I switched to my laptop. When I finally landed in Sydney and switched to an Australian SIM card was I able to call the restaurant. When I brought up this issue, I'm not sure if they took me seriously and checked their website. By this time, the latest slots were 5:45 and 9PM. We arrived and decided to order a la carte rather than their set menu of $55. We ordered the bread (large piece that can easily be shared between two people), sardine app (nice and light), chicken liver mousse (needs more bread, maybe something else for a bit more texture), broccoli, pappardelle (best pasta we had, cooked perfectly), bucatini (disappointing compared to pappardelle because it didn't have the same depth of flavor), lemon and pistachio semifreddo (delicious!) and sheep's milk panna cotta (a bit sour if you've never had sheep's milk. The semifreddo was better). As you can tell, this was a lot of food for two people plus two glasses of wine. Our meal was $120 USD.

A great meal, hip environment, and quick service! Main courses were delicious. Not pictured was the…read moreCarrot Triangoli, sourdough bread, and pistachio and vanilla house made gelatos. Would return again!

Loved the atmosphere and food here, I had the veal scallopine which was delicious…read more Friendly helpful staff and fabulous ambience Can't wait to return next time I'm in Sydney

Good meal in a pinch. Tried too hard to make the pizza have too many toppings. Excessive arugula…read moreand Parmesan cheese. The prosciutto with a small helping of arugula would have been much better and the Parmesan was overkill, but easy to just take off. $29 dinner special with pizza/pasta soup and one drink is a very good deal.

Great neighborhood eats! The staff & food here was amazing especially considering we ate on a night…read morethat a BIG and LOUD dinner party was there. The sound was deafening and made it difficult to have any conversation without shouting over the din. You could tell when they were eating - it got quiet:-). Loved the BYOB option for smaller guest parties. Servings were generous and we probably could have shared but it made great leftovers for the next night. We each tried something different, lasagna, spicy spaghetti, spaghetti Bolognese and seafood risotto. We saw lots of takeaways (takeout orders for us) the pizza looked wonderful but we were stuffed!

Great Pizza. I was traveling in Australia for work and craved a pizza--very comfortable and super…read morefriendly staff. The people there were so nice and friendly.very clean and proper.

My friends took me here on my last day in Sydney, and it was the perfect farewell brunch!…read more There was a festive menu at the time that we dined, and it was great! 3 courses for $40AUD (or 2 courses for $35AUD), you know I had to get the 3 courses! For Starters, I got the Ora King Smoked Salmon Pate. For my Mains, I got Primavera Ravioli. For dessert, I got the Jamie's Black Forest Panna Cotta. Everything was soooo good! The ambiance was chic & cute, and the server was great! I honestly felt like I was back in the US for some reason!

I've been to Australia 3 times and 2 of those visits brought me to this establishment. My first…read morevisit was memorably bad. I couldn't recall the details but I remember not being a fan. My second and most recent visit helped extinguish that memory. Our waitress was very lively and sweet. She gave us plenty of time to look over our menus and made solid recommendations. I ordered the Spaghetti Alla Norma and it was pretty tasty. I also sampled some of the polenta chips which were surprisingly good. We opted to get dessert elsewhere but overall the food was pretty good. I'd like this place more if the prices were a little lower and they had more basic pastas available. I'm not a fan of seafood or mushrooms and can't handle spicy so I felt a little limited...although the pumpkin ravioli was tempting. Next time!

We order through Uber eats so don't know what the restaurant looks like inside or the dine in…read moreservice but, the order was delivered within 20 minutes of ordering. This particular location was highly recommended. Order the Americana pizza. Loved the thin crust and the flavor was good. Looked a little overcooked and would have liked more spicy salami but, nonetheless it was tasty. The garlic bread was perfect. Glove don start to finish. Not an ounce of the bread didn't have the garlic butter which is how I like it. I would order from her again.

I had the fettuccine carbonara and chicken schnitzel combo. $32.50. It was delicious and plenty of…read morefood for one person. The Carbonara was super creamy and cheesy. The ham was in large chunks. The schnitzel was perfectly cooked.

I came here for a relaxed lunch with my sister and left with a disgruntled tummy due to the…read moreover-ladened/excessive taste of the dishes. Don't get me wrong. This restaurant has a pleasant atmosphere and the waiters are generally very very nice. However, the food was just not up to par with the prices. We ordered a pizza crust that wasn't actually a pizza crust, it was basically a plain pizza (anyone can just google what the dish pizza crust is suppose to be), a scampi risotto that tasted like the proportions of the ingredients involved were x50 in ratio and a blue crab pappardelle. My pappardelle was so bad I don't even know how to explain it. Imagine, a dish so swamped in sauce that a pasta dish, that had once probably had the garnishes and original flavors of a blue crab pappardelle, tasted like 5 sticks of butter. I have had this dish at various locations throughout Sydney's dining scene--from low end to high end-- and never have I tasted such a poor version of the dish. If this type of flavoring is your style, however, then this place is very very compatible for you!

While only opened maybe 6 months ago, we've become regulars very quickly. Food is fantastic and we…read morehaven't had anything from the menu that we wouldn't have again. The staff are great with friends and family alike. Our 2 year old even walks right up to the table we sit nearly every time. Very much recommended if you're looking for great Italian food in the area. The mussles are to DIE FOR!

Great Italian! (American tourist review ahead) Our driver from the airport recommended this place…read moreand we were not disappointed. We came starving, ordered right away and the food came almost instantly which was great! It was packed too and the food still came hot and delicious. It seemed everyone else came before the opera to get in and out quick but for a great meal. We had Fregola alle vongule which had great flavor and the clams were fresh and sauce full of flavor. For salad we had Isalata Estiva which was ok. A little awkward to eat since it thinly sliced red cabbage. Wasn't my favorite but I had to try it. Then the finale was the Buffalina Pizza. YUM! Such a tasty pizza with prosciutto and delicious buffalo mozzarella. Loved the decor and atmosphere--Definitely worth a visit!

Very legit pizza!! Nice ambience as it overlooks the water. Only drawback was food took a long time…read moreto arrive (waited 30+ min and a bit challenging with small kids). Restaurant was quite busy. We got margherita pizza and the shrimp pizza. Both were really good. Arancini also great.