I absolutely love taking Amtrak to NYC and even as far as Philly. You never have to deal with traffic or worry about the weather. You know that in about 3.5 to 4 hours you will get to your destination- the most you will generally encounter is maybe a 20 minute delay, even if the weather is absolutely horrible. One time I had to get Mississippi for work but there was a huge blizzard and Logan canceled all flights. Amtrak saved the day! I took a train down to Baltimore and flew out of BWI. It was a looong day but I made it!
Obviously Amtrak is more expensive than taking the bus, but you pay for the comfort and conveniences, like again not having to worry about traffic and weather. I also love that there are outlets for every seat so I either get a lot of work done or just watch movies on my laptop.
I take the train a lot for work so I take the Acela frequently rather than the Regional trains. The Acela apparently has more legroom (I am short so I never notice a difference, but taller people have informed me that there is a difference) but even the Coach Regional seats have as much legroom as a first class seat on a plane. Even the bathrooms on both are very spacious!
The Acela also has a fancier cafe car BUT they rarely ever have most of their good food selections and you have to ask for three things before finally finding something they have. Somehow they always have the cheeseburger though, but beware, it is not very good! I have gotten it quite a few times when I want a real meal, but after a few bites I always regret my decision and wish I just got a bag of chips. The pizza is pretty good though so I recommend that if you are looking for a meal. Best advice: if you are hungry, get to the cafe car quickly in hopes of snagging one of the good meals before you are stuck with the cheeseburger! OR buy a meal at the train station, that way you have a lot more options.
The other cool thing about the train is the rewards points. When taking the Acela, we are lucky because Boston is a "select city pair" with all the main cities. So whether you are traveling to Stamford, NYC, NJ, Philly, or D.C., you automatically get 500 rewards points on the Acela. And since you only need 3,000 points to get a free Coach Regional ticket, it only takes 3 round-trips on Acela to earn a free ticket. If you travel on any other train or to any other city, you get 2 points for every $1 spent (100 point minimum).
The only thing I dont understand is why they dont have internet available yet on the Acela and Northeast Regional trains because I am pretty sure those are the most popular Amtrak trains in the country. At first I thought maybe it was too difficult to have internet on the train for some logistical reason, but then I took the train to Maine and THAT had internet! And even airplanes (at least Delta) are now starting to offer internet access on flights so I cant figure out why they cant have it on the Northeast trains. For those who have Blackberrys though, apparently you can use them as a tethered modem. Thanks to my awesome friend who showed me how to do this, I now use my BB on the train to get internet on my laptop.
The other interesting thing about the Acela and Northeat Regional trains is the quiet car. If you have a lot of work to get done, you want to sleep, or you just dont want to chance the person next to you trying to start a conversation, then you can sit in the quiet car which is the second car of the train, after the first/business class car. However, there are two things you should know about sitting in the quiet car: 1) It is the car that fills up the quickest. The rest of the train can be nearly empty but the quiet car is always crowded. If you are traveling during off-peak hours, you may end up getting a row to yourself in any other car, but you will most likely get someone sitting next to you in the quiet car, at least by the time you reach Providence. 2) A lot of people dont know about the quiet car and then it becomes even more annoying than the other cars because you hear this conversation ensue...
Loud person: Blah blah I like to talk
Conductor: I'm sorry but this is the quiet car so conversations need to be kept to a minimum at a quiet whisper and you cannot talk on your cell phone
Loud person (right after conductor walks away): What? He cant tell me that I cant talk, I will talk if I want to. Blah blah I am obnoxious
Annoyed person in quiet car: If you want to talk, you can sit anywhere else on the train. Why dont you move back to another car?
Loud person: You cant tell me what to do, I want to sit right here and I want to talk. Blah blah I am dumb
All in all, Amtrak is so much better than driving. It is also much better than flying to somewhere as close as NY or Philly because the amount of time you save not having to get there early to go through security and not dealing with delays, it ends up being a similar amount of time anyway...and then you are already in the heart of the city. read more