This is a hidden gem! Located in an okder strip plaza one would miss out if they didn't know. We where fortunate to get the recommendation. Wonderful!! Being native to Sarasota and have been to all that Sarasota, venice lbk siesta Bradenton beach, anna maria and beyond multiple times. When we find a new place that hits all the marks we will share. The first thing even though in an older plaza. Plenty of parking unlike downtown Sarasota. Typically a struggle to park and high prices due to there high rent. Plus now pay to park. So we typically avoid.. once inside you will find it very comfortable warm and inviting. Tables have really nice wood and leather chairs. Table cloths with glass tops. Unique menu with authentic Portuguese and classic Italian dishes. The really good ones. Kitchen is visible through glass walls. So its right there no secrets. Every thing made from scratch in house and quality ingredients. Good size portions too. Nice selection of both Italian and Portuguese wine. Every thing from appetizers to desert was spot on. We are foodies and know quality when we find it. We will be returning multiple times . Multiple dishes to try. read more

We wanted something different for Valentine's Day and the idea of Italian/Portuguese intrigued me. It's East of downtown in a strip mall with plenty of parking. You get a warm feeling when you walk in. We were seated and ordered wine and the salted cod fritters as an appetizer. The presentation was nice and I enjoyed the taste. I loved the bread they served as well, Portuguese I presume. Iordered the chicken parm as my entree and my wife, the octopus. Both dishes were polished off and we had no room for dessert. Service was professional and clean silverware was exchanged each time. As we were finishing, a piano player started playing which added to the ambiance. A nice way to spend Valentine's Day. 4.5 stars read more

See all

Fantastic knowledgeable and friendly service! Wonderful decor with great live music - piano. You can sit close or further away depending on your mood. We chose about mid-way so we could still hear/enjoy but talk, as well, without distracting anyone. The Sarasota Summer 3-course menu is still available- great value. The Cesar Salad was really good - served in a crispy fried cheese bowl - NOT greasy at all, added good crunch and flavor. The cod fritters and shrimp and corn soup were very well received. The pasta bolognese was excellent. The chicken parmigiana was also excellent and liked by all. The custard pastry desert was a perfect ending to the whole meal. read more

See all

Wonderful restaurant with a lovely atmosphere. The dinner rolls are homemade, I had the pork and it was incredible. Great service too! read more

Amore Restaurant - Italian Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

This is a find! In a small plaza but plenty of parking! The menu is Portuguese on one side and Italian on other side . Never a disappointed with the food delicious and their once a month wine tasting is over the top! Last Tuesday of the month. All inclusive 4 courses with wine $140.00!! Incredible deal for the food taste and picks of wine! And they are doing Savor Sarasota menu thru the summer! Plus there is music We'd thru Sunday with wonderful piano players and singers who are wonderful and fun! Don't miss out! read more

Had dinner tonight with friends from out of town. Again , nothing short of outstanding !!! The food was prepared flawlessly. The service was impeccable. Thanks for making us feel welcome. read more

On June 6, we had the Savor Sarasota menu. The soup and the cod fritters were so good. Our entrees of the pork tenderloin and the veal piccata with artichokes were cooked to perfection. The service was great and the inside of the restaurant was decorated so pretty. The homemade bread was so unique and excellent. The owners wife stops by to ensure we were satisfied with the food. We will be returning very soon. read more

Amore Restaurant - Veal piccata with artichokes, veggies and a heart shaped potato. Very good food! - Italian Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

We had a table for 5....great service at a table in back...Savor Sarasota menu and regular menu items were ordered...food was wonderful. Amore is not to be overlooked read more

Excellent service and food. Always looking for good Portuguese food in any area that we stay and this restaurant met the Bill. Highly recommend this restaurant as a place to have an excellent dining experience. read more

Amore Restaurant - Italian Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

See all

Intimate little hidden gem ! The food , the staff , the piano player all wonderful!!!!!!! Perfect Valentines evening out ! We will definitely be back! read more

See all

Amazing food and service. Not a special facility but the food is some of the best! I love the chicken korma and wife loves the lentils.

Place is ok, nothing fancy, Service was great. Has a nice atmosphere with a lady playing piano, except the menu is not really as Italian as it should be, nor the Portuguese menu have too many choices. I think there should be more choices, typical Italian like stuffed shells, manicotti etc. and tastier Portuguese and not so bland. AGAIN...Somewhat of a short menu, food was a bit bland...and pricey for what you get. Will not be going back. read more

Old and average nice people but a very old following. Food is average and same with the wine. Friendly staff. That's all I have for you

Reconnected after a few years with Lianna and Tito at their Lime Ave spot having frequented both their previous locales on Longboat Key and Burns Court. They have significantly increased their Portuguese menu as well as maintaining their core Italian menu. Had a great meal and enjoyed the piano player. Food was plentiful and well-prepared. We were adventurous and tried their Portuguese entrees, including Cataplana Alantejana and Bacalhau a Bras. The Fireman Chourico was a sausage grilled at the table. All wonderful and full of flavor. Our favorite dessert, Pastel de Nata was incredible. We were so impressed, we immediately made a reservation for a party of 18 ROMEOS (Retired Old Men Eating Out) who absolutely enjoyed the experience. (Not an easily pleased group!) Well worth finding of the beaten path. read more

An Italian and Portuguese menu which is extensive and maybe if shortened the quality of the food would be better. The entertainment provided by pianists including the wonderful Eddy Tobin is excellent. read more

Amore Restaurant - Lamb shank - Italian Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

This is a real gem in Sarasota. A MUST GO place for anyone that wants excellent food, service and entertainment! read more

3 stars for nice food and service. If Yelp offered stars for individual items I would give the salted cod 5, the fritters were delicious, a first in Sarasota. I would go back only for these. The pappardelle with bolognese sauce was tasty, the pasta was too thick, should have been served piping hot though, but the flavor was great, huge portion. Pricey but that's Sarasota now LA & NY prices for normal food. The restaurant is darkish but the open kitchen is a nice touch. Decor is from the old place in Burns Court. read more

Amore Restaurant - Salted cod fritters, delicious - Italian Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

Food was mediocre.....Side came out cold....Scallops in our appetizer were not cooked and has a real fishy smell....I ordered a Ribeye and was totally disappointed.....Reminded me of a Denny's steak.....Managment seemed very annoyed when they came over and asked how things were and we told them the truth read more

Loved this hidden gem restaurant. Everything from our bottle of Sauvignon Blanc to the Portuguese Egg Custards we had for dessert was amazing. Order a veal dish and you won't be disappointed: tender, flavorful, just awesome. The service is perfect. Our server was friendly, helpful and always there when we needed her but never hovered. Cozy and welcoming, we even found the entertainment charming. Great little place. It may be in a strip mall but it is a classic. Already anticipating our next visit. read more

I enjoyed dinner with a group of friends. There were five of us altogether. I had Shrimp Scampi and really enjoyed it. Also, the dinner rolls were fantastic. Everyone loved their food and will be back again! Great food and service with relaxing piano music in the background. read more

Amore Restaurant - Desserts! - Italian Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

See all

Took my grandson here after his first opera. The food was amazing, service excellent and staff very accommodating and nice. Unfortunately it's almost an hr drive so not sure if or when we'll be back. read more

These wings are super delicious and I favor them over bbq and buffalo.the gyro is delicious also. read more

See all

Good atmosphere w soft lighting & nice music Pleasant servers Nice that they have a Portuguese as well as an Italian menu Bread is a big deal to us, they served bread sticks w butter. why oh why did this Portuguese/Italian restaurant not serve good bread w good olive oil. Portuguese & Italian breads & olive oils are some of the best ! The Chicken from the Italian menu was tough & very small amount of pasta came with it. The Seafood w Potatoes from the Portuguese menu was presented very nicely in a cute copper pot. The seafood was good other than the tiny clams. The potatoes in this dish were Not good at all, they really seemed to be from a can...I sure hope I am wrong about this, but I don't think I am. We were really looking forward to coming here We did not complain about anything Not sure if we will return read more

I have performed several times at Amore and you could not ask for nicer people to work for in the Restaurant Business. Entertainers are treated like family at Amore. You are not only welcomed but your craft is respected and made part of the evening for the wonderful Patrons of this establishment. Thank You L and T for treating us all so well. read more

Veal piccata was delicious cooked to perfection along with a mixed vegetables that were also cooked perfectly ambience was beyond anything I've seen around here in a long time soft piano music with a female vocalist throughout our dinner. Service was also superb. We will go back again and again. read more

We had a great experience here! I had the steak Diane it came a bit raw than my taste but Liana was very nice to offer to cook a bit more. We enjoyed the live music too. thank you all! read more

Amore Restaurant - Italian Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

See all

This is a fantastic and charming restaurant. It's a must, if you are visiting or haven't been there. I've been there many times and am never disappointed. read more

We were treated yesterday to Amore Restaurant's once-a-month wine paring feast. Last night's was named "Tito's Favorites" and every one of the 5 delectable courses is now my favorite. I don't know better food, wine, service, value in Sarasota/Bradenton. read more

The food is very good. Our server was nice, but as the evening wore on - things became a little testy. We came in for a "late night dinner" - 8:30PM which can be a hit or miss depending on the area, but being downtown, places should expect to be busier as the evening progresses. This is a bit of an unassuming place, but as soon as you step in, it feels cozy and I love the outdoor seating - bar is large enough and they have misters/fans going to keep you cool (as well as a few tvs to keep you entertained). They have an inside and upstairs, but I prefer to be on the main level and outside. The Carpaccio app was so good - fantastic quality of meat and salad/avocado. I could eat that all day long. It was hard to stop eating the bread and caponata as well. We got the mussels app too - it was ok, but definitely not spectacular (side note - have had mussels in a few places in Sarasota and not impressed to date - not sure where these are coming from but not up to par in general so this isn't a knock on Amore). The Drinks are fabulous here and by the time we got apps/drinks and ordered food - it was probably close to 9:15 or so and we ordered our main meal. Clearly by that time, the kitchen was either annoyed that we were one of the last meals or something cause the person who served it to us (wasn't the server) - maybe someone from the back literally came to the table and dropped the plate with a thud. Asked if we wanted cheese and haphazardly scooped some on. The Carbonara was delicious, but we sensed an annoyance from him by being there so late. Just strange. But whatever, we still really like this place and would recommend it. read more

See all

A small place hidden in a shopping center. The food was delicious and I'll be back! Friendly people and great service! The presentation of the food was amazing! read more

We stumbled upon Amore and glad we did because we had a wonderful evening. There were a lot of people dining in the outdoor /covered area but they were able to give us a table for 4. It was our server's first night and she was great ! I ordered the risotto/shrimp-scallops special and it was fabulous. They make some of the salads and desserts table side which is fun! We ordered bananas foster for dessert and that was prepared table side . It was very good. There was a piano player and it created a nice energy in the room. At one point a couple got up and began to dance . It was sweet . I hope to get the opportunity to return! read more

Amore Restaurant - Italian Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

Food and service was good though pricey. We had ceasers salad prepared at the table. Quite an experience and very tasty, pricey but large portion for each of us. My wife had lasagna and my entree was gnocchi. Both were quite good. My gnocchi had sausage (excellent) and mushrooms (not too good, They were chewy and stiff with NO flavor). The lasagna was very good and really got the spot. Both portions were large and easily shared, wish we would have done so but we enjoyed what we had and took large servings home for later enjoyment I ended with a cappuccino which was good but a Very small serving, more the size of a double expresso vs a cappuccino We enjoyed the evening and as I said service was good. Only disappointment was an $80 bill for a shared salad and 2 entrees, no alcohol. read more

When we moved here several years ago, we were very pleased with the variety and quality of the restaurants, from Ophelia's and Indigenous, to the small cafes like Rick's on Siesta Dr, and Fiorella, to Chayhana Vostok (and who would have thought to find an Uzbekistan restaurant in Sarasota?). Another great find, is Amore on Lime Ave. A very pretty restaurant, with great ambiance. The service is knowledgeable, professional, and friendly. Liane, the owner, and Laura, our server, make us very welcome. The Wine list had a nice selection of whites and reds by the glass. We had the Savor Sarasota special, which they will run through December, I believe. We both had the soup of the day, potato with bacon. The chunks of potatoes were tender, but not mushy, the bacon crisp and smoky, with a cream base. My husband had the Pork a Trasmontana, pork tenderloin tournedos, and Pastel de Nata for dessert. I had Bacalhau Ribateljano, a salted cod casserole served with potatoes and boiled eggs, and Tiramisu for dessert. I can't come up with a single complaint! It was all well prepared, well presented, and delicious. Please go and support this lovely restaurant! read more

See all

We visited a couple of times before when they were still on Longboat Key and liked it there. A while ago Amore moved to downtown Sarasota. The location is nice and easy to find. The restaurant is a bit less classy than the Longboat one and no A/C. There is an early bird menu for $27. 6 appetizer options, 6 main courses and 3 dessert options. I had the mussels with garlic, capers and white or red wine. A very nice starter, very tasteful. For my main course I had the pasta with shrimp a diavolo. A nice size serving with a great tomato sauce, 5 huge shrimp and parmesan cheese. Too bad the shrimp still have their tails on. You have to dig into the tomato sauce to eat the shrimp and clean your fingers every time. My dessert was tiramisu. Nice flavor but a little soggy. All in all a decent meal for a decent price. Yes, I will be back there. read more

The food was delicious and the live music was a treat. Fresh grouper and shrimp. I can't wait to return to try the Portuguese menu.

While visiting the area from out of town, a friend suggested i try amore restaurant. Being that it came highly recommended, I was super disappointed in the food. I understand they had a new chef. I came with friends who lived locally and had tried this restaurant before. All the pasta dishes we ordered were not good. They didn't even know the difference between octopus and calamari! Don't your time here! The only reason I gave it two stars is because the wait staff was attentive and really tried. Not an Italian Restaurant! read more

Amore Restaurant - Italian Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

We were recommended this restaurant by a friend but sadly it didn't meet our expectations. Dark dining area with older decor. We sat next to the kitchen so we were able to see many of the dishes being served . We attempted to order a cocktail but were sadly informed they only sold beer and wine . We skipped appetizers and headed right for the grouper and beef F mignon. Fresh rolls were brought to us hot while we waited . Our meals look beautiful on our plate but unfortunately we're not seasoned well . The grouper was very fishy to taste , my husband took two bites and couldn't eat it . The beef mignon was overly salted , thick sauce that hid my not so tender steak . Potatoes were the best part of our meal . The waitress checked on us and when telling her it was really fishy she said sorry but didn't offer to have them remake it or suggest ordering another item . Sorry to say we won't be returning . read more

Amore Restaurant - Grouper - Italian Near Me - Sarasota, Florida

See all

Just had a delicious dinner with a group of guys. My lamb Shank was perfect as was everything else. Highly recommended! Oh and the deserts!!! Save some room! read more

40 plus in our group had dinner there. Food was delicious. Their staff did an incredible job serving all of us. Great experience.

Located in the former Gold Star luncheonette, Amore moved 3 years ago from Burns Court. The Pineapple Ave. location had several issues and Covid didn't help. The new space is warm and friendly. The service was top notch and the pleasant live music added just the right touch. The menu is half Portuguese and half Italian. The authentic offerings in both are not to be missed. I would have given five stars except that when I inquired, I learned that the evening's special veal offering used a formed veal patty rather than fresh veal. A correctable error I would hope. We order one dish from each side of the menu. Don't miss the Amore shrimp and lobster. All of the Portuguese specialties were very good. Preparation and presentation were sparking. The largely open kitchen was a nice touch. The lobster bisque was a super starter and a "cup" was what other places call a bowl. It was the best I have had in Sarasota. All in all, don't miss Amore. read more