After the excellent experience we had at Amalia cafe I can't wait to go back to St. Thomas and visit our excellent server, Cara. Great food, wine, and service. Top notch! read more

Amalia Cafe - Paella and Stuffed Lobster - Spanish Near Me - St Thomas, Virgin Islands

See all

Second time coming here is in the beginning of the passage mall, beautiful comfortable, elegant dining with wonderful food! read more

Amalia Cafe - Outdoor sitting area nice breeze flows through here - Spanish Near Me - St Thomas, Virgin Islands

Good rest in middle of Historic district. Great Paella, and eggplant rollatini. Service was good in afternoon, atmosphere is really casual and nice. read more

Great food and ambiance. Service is good too would definitely recommend. Never had a bad meal there.

What cute little spot, nestled in a small Courtyard, this little gem is not to be missed. The staff was fantastic and super friendly. The owner was present and engaging. We started off with some Polpo de Gallician and it was out of this world. The spices were perfect, the octopus was tender and amazing. Then we went for the Paella, which was almost perfect. Flavors and medly of seafood was perfect, I was just missing the crispy rice on the bottom, but I still cannot complain about a stunningly fantastic meal. Must try location! read more

OBSESSED with this place! Waitress & owner are amazing and I loved the amount of recommended foods that were not found on the menu! I had the filet mignon cooked medium rare and it was served perfect! I also tried both the white and red sangria, the red sangria was my favorite it was sweet and refreshing! Finished off the meal with their house made crème brulee, was very good and had a thick sugar coating on top! Highly recommend. read more

Amalia Cafe - filet mignon - Spanish Near Me - St Thomas, Virgin Islands

See all

Amazing Tapas! You must get the Piquillos Rellenos (Cod stuffed piquillo peppers), it was a sleeper hit. The Pulpo de Gallega (Grilled octopus) was the best I've had, and the portions were large. Chorizo a la Sidra (spanish sausage) was delicious and worth the order. Think twice about the Boquerones (smelts/anchovies), they're a bit much. You have to really like anchovies to get through it, my wife quit on me. read more

Found this gem after a week of sailing. It's in an adorable shopping alleyway and was so quaint. The food was fresh and delicious- so glad to get a beautiful salad. The shrimp was excellent. Great service, delicious food. Spanish atmosphere was lovely. read more

Amalia Cafe - Patio view - Spanish Near Me - St Thomas, Virgin Islands

Wow..a real gem. A very comfortable setting off the main avenue with open seating and very nice staff. Sangria a big hit with a nice hit back. We had eggplant rollatini, beef kabab, blackened shrimp, Caesar salad, gazpacho and other dishes that were all wonderful. Highly recommended read more

Absolutely superb dining ambience tucked away in a secluded classy courtyard across from the harbor. Great Caribbean beach vibe with a Spanish twist read more

See all

Zarzuela de Mariscos was amazing and flavorful. Wonderful ambiance, great service - perfect spot for any traveler. Highly recommend, 6 people got 4 different items and all 5/5 read more

Overall, it was a good experience but didn't blow me away. Service was slow even though we we were only one of a couple tables in the restaurant. Complimentary sangria with the order of paella which was really nice (but you need to ask the waiter about it.. it's not written on the menu). The escargot and octopus apps were very good. The paella was tasty (doesn't compare to it in Spain but nice). read more

See all

I'm glad such a great restaurant didn't shut down due to Covid. Food are still good. Service are always satisfying. Thank you for being there. read more

See all

Located in a quaint cobblestone alley, our waitress was Cara and she was very friendly and attentive. We had the garlic shrimp which was very nice although a bit spicy and the Zarzuela, which was good but perhaps with too much oregano which completely overpowered the delicate fish. Maybe this is the point of Zarzuela, but you could have put Tilapia rather than grouper, salmon etc. Overall a very pleasant evening read more

Always a favorite, and always better than we remembered. This time we brought our daughter who has several food allergies, and they didn't even flinch. She loved her meal, as did everyone else at the table. Sangria is amazing. Cara took great care of us. We can't wait to come back again! read more

Amalia Cafe - Fish stew special - Spanish Near Me - St Thomas, Virgin Islands

See all

Pricey, but worth it. This is the best meal we had on the island. The servers were so welcoming and kind.

Hotel concierge recommended and all I can say is OMG. Probably the best salad I have ever had. Salpicon de Mariso. Wow!!! Service was great and wine was fantastic. Highly recommended read more

Great food, very quick service. You need to try seafood zarzuela it is outstanding. 3 course dinner for 2 with best red sangria ever, cost us a little bit over $100. Totally worth it. read more

Excellent Spanish cousin in most enjoyable Palm passage. One of my favorite spots for leisurely lunch. Excellent consistency of the dishes. Loved the gaspaccio, zarzuella and clams. The service is outstanding and sophisticated. It is pricy but as they say. You get what you pay for. I hope to return time after time. read more

Very lovely setting to the restaurant! Our service was excellent and the food exceeded expectations! This place is a gem! Upon walking up to the cute alley it is located in, we were facing two restaurant choices. A local was walking out and immediately informed us that the Amelia Cafe had way better food...we took her advice and it didn't disappoint! read more

The atmosphere is so beautiful at night. The location is in a outdoor walkway type area next to some other stores but it's very peaceful to eat outside. There's also a cat I saw around there; a calico. The shirley temples are exquisite and the chicken alfredo was enjoyable. My mom got the lobster and it was a little too chewy and plain for me. My dad got the seafood platter which he liked. read more

Amalia Cafe - the outdoor seating area (to the left) - Spanish Near Me - St Thomas, Virgin Islands

We chose to have our final night dinner at the Amalia Cafe and couldn't have been happier with our decision. The staff was friendly, dynamic and made sure we had a lovely experience. Rum cocktails, calamari and octopus appetizers were a perfect start. Our entrees were fantastic, surpassed only by the amazing Blueberry Bread Pudding. (I normally dislike Bread pudding, but I couldn't get enough of this one!) We were pleasantly surprised with the impressively reasonable bill for the incredible quality food and service we received. Make this a must visit when in Charlotte Amalie! read more

Amazing little spot, especially if you have an appreciation of Spanish cuisine. The location is quaint, charming and picturesque. The list of tapas was impressive. The pulpo de Gallegos was top notch. The rest of the menu made it hard to decide, and my fresh local lobster stuffed with crab meat was enough to make me pause and exhale. Maynard, the owner, and Sean, at whose table I had the pleasure of dining, were both a pleasure to meet. I finished the evening with a delicious glass of port and my novel. Classic spot. I'll be back. read more

See all

Nice setup on a side street. We decided to sit and have some drinks and eat a little something. We got there fairly early and so it wasn't no one there. It was 5 of us and the waitress sat us outside and she came over and took our drink order which we ordered some white sangria which was so so at best. They we ordered 2 garlic shrimps. She only heard 1 order so she had to go place another order of garlic shrimp. We asked her if they had bread or rolls but the rolls we $1 per roll in which we ordered 10 rolls so that was $10. Then let's get to the shrimp which was medium at best and you only get 4 shrimp for $14. Way overpriced. They charged $3.50 per medium shrimp when a 2lb medium bag at Costco costs $14. So we pay total $28 for shrimp, $10 for bread and $23 sangria. If you like overpriced food this is the place for you because the shrimp tasted good but just can't get over paying damn near $30 for medium shrimp. Not large or colossal. My recommendation is 2 thumbs down just cause they way overpriced and even with covid I can't see paying those prices read more

Amalia Cafe - Advertisements - Spanish Near Me - St Thomas, Virgin Islands

See all

Perfect and will probably visit again before we leave. Great little spot, waiter was awesome. Friendly, there when we needed him and not too attentive. Great wine choices. We had their daily soup specials to start. I had tomato bisque with crab and husband had lobster navy bean and we both would've eaten 3 bowls. The calamari wasn't very flavorful but husband loved his stuffed lobster and I loved my Cesar salad. I was sad I wasn't very hungry because another choice looked so amazing. Owner was there and very thankful we came. Highly recommend. read more

I appreciate the effort and the ambiance. The food is bland. We can blame it on Covid or whatever... The service was dismal. The food was unimpressive. Yet, there were a lot of people. I mean I give them credit and maybe our experience was just bad but nothing was great and I think we could've had a much better dinner (which we have) at multiple other restaurants close by. Skip it. Truly unimpressed. read more

Stopped in for bite during cruise - best meal we've had! Lobster on point and berthing else we had

Let me begin by saying this WAS one of our favorite restaurants. We went tonight with friends and I must say I have never encountered a more rude server by the name of Cara or Carol. In hindsight, we all agreed we should have walked out. I mentioned that the server within 2 feet of us had his mask under his chin and can you please have him put it in properly. She then called me the "mask police" and spoke to me with such anger and disrespect. At this Point we had waited almost 30 minutes for just drinks. My husband was seething. He Asked to see Maynard ( owner) and we were told he was not in yet. The real disappointment here was that when Maynard did arrive he spoke with her and NEVER came over and wore NO MASK ALL EVENING. Again, we should have walked out. The food was Ok. The service was awful. I will NEVER step foot in this establishment again. read more

A must try when you are on the island. The ambiance is romantic, the staff is beyond amazing, enough can not be said about the food. We accompanied the garlic shrimp appetizer with the warm bread, delectable. I had the Zarzuela de Mariscos, it was fresh and so very flavorful. I feel like I can have that dish weekly, definitely a must try. My husband had the Salmon Ammiel. He loved it! Kara was our sever and she super friendly, very knowledgeable regarding the menu and her recommendations where on point because we loved them. She also recommended things on the island, super helpful. I will definitely return. read more

Went without a reservation and they were full. Our waitress May came out and set up an extra table for us so we could dine at Amalia. May was a great, attentive, knowledgeable, and kind server. We had garlic mushrooms, and a Caesar to start..both delicious. My wife had the grilled snapper and I had the Zarzuela seafood stew. We were both very happy with our meals. Great setting in a small stone lined alley on a long porch with lots of fans and a great tropical breeze. read more

Went here for lunch my second day in St Thomas. Ordered the Ensalada Catalana (seared tuna, hard-boiled eggs, asparagus, olives, tomatoes, prosciutto, onions and peppers on a bed of romaine lettuce) with a lime coconut vinaigrette. Best part of the salad was the prosciutto - ridiculously savory. Had the Codillos de Cordero Asados - oven roasted lamb shank and sherry with carrots and pearl onions. Just very well cooked - tender, and juicy, with a side of rice with roasted nuts and raisins (not mentioned in the online menu). But the best part was desert with a blueberry banana bread pudding. (I will add a photo of this later). The owner was there, super friendly, and took the time to greet us. He said Amalia Cafe been open for seven years. I googled it and found the NY Times review, which notes that the chefs are actually from the Dominican Republic, but have all been "extensively" trained in Spanish cuisine, and make the best paella and sangria on island. read more

Amalia Cafe - Spanish Near Me - St Thomas, Virgin Islands

The service provided by Adam was perfect. The food was amazing and the atmosphere was great!! Would strongly recommend.

St. Thomas, check. Food, check. Fine dining, check. Now, in most cases some of you may want to find a place that is upscale for the Honeymoon, anniversary, or just want to sink your taste buds into something exquisite. I can understand the need to scour around looking for that "perfect" place or setting! So this place is in a business setting of a building located in downtown Charlotte Amalie. It is close to the waterfront of the bay and dining is outdoors. Now don't let that deter you away. The setting is quite elegant, Restaurant is highly recommended by myself and many others, the food is phenomenal, and the service is above and beyond my expectations! So to give you an idea I have dined at fine steakhouses where the bill toppled $140 easily for just a dinner of two. When we went here for dinner for the evening we thoroughly enjoyed the experience and dining of Amalia Cafe. My wife and myself came here during our honeymoon for a fine dining experience. The service we received was amazing, hands down, one of the best restaurants we have dined at! The menu is a bit small, but don't let that count against them. What they have to offer is enough for anyone to choose something and be happy. When we come back to St. Thomas we will look up Amalia Cafe for the same experience we have encountered. read more

Great location, friendly staff, mediocre food at premium prices. We ordered stuffed peppers appetizer and seafood paella main dish. Stuffed peppers were tasty but had too much sauce, paella on the other hand lacked most of flavoring. Rice in paella was bland and was missing that traditional flavoring. In the end, for an mediocre appetizer and a main course we paid $50, which was not the best proposition for your wallet. read more

What a pleasant luncheon atmosphere - quiet, classy, comfy, great service. The gazpacho, garlic shrimp, and Caesar salad were yummy. This is a hidden retreat in the center of town. Family managed and run - don't miss it. read more

Hands down! best Spanish food i ever had. We loved the garlic mushroom, octopus (no tentacles), ceviche ahi tuna, lobster special with pasta omg! so good. Banana raspberry bread pudding with vanilla ice cream so good. Will come back again for sure. love the ambience and the service was superb attentive and give us good recommendation shout out to "Mimi". Thank u read more

Wonderful food. It is tucked away in a walkway center. The staff was very friendly. The bread basket was so good I almost filled up in it. The salmon was excellent as was the steak. Met a very nice couple there and talked for awhile. read more

A local recommended this restaurant and it was so good, we went twice! Great food and great service. Highly recommend it!

Food is tasty but OMG! The mosquitoes were eating us alive!!!!!! The servers totally knew that because they had bug spray ready. Make sure you are covered before you go! read more

The second I had the water here I knew it was going to be a good place. I can't STAND when I go to a nice restaurant and they serve non filtered water. Multiple people got the lamb shank and there was not a crumb left! Our server was amazing constantly making sure we are okay. Overall amazing experience! read more

Amalia Cafe - Non tap water - Spanish Near Me - St Thomas, Virgin Islands