Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Almighty Pit BBQ

    4.3 (18 reviews)
    Closed • 10:00 am - 7:00 pm
    Updated 3 months ago

    Almighty Pit BBQ Photos

    ALMIGHTY PIT BBQ ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Almighty Pit BBQ

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Mac n cheese
    Jennifer J.

    Support local BBQ! In the same building as ACE hardware. Grab a meal and do some home improvement shopping. Ribs fall off the bone and have good smoke flavor. Chicken & brisket could use a bit longer in the smoker, but were still good. Sausage is the star. Absolutely delicious. BBQ sauces are really good. Mac N Cheese is excellent. Banana pudding was a bit of a letdown. Not very flavorful. The whiskey caramel sauce to go on top is perfect. Don't change that. Service was great. We'll be back!

    Richard R.

    Almighty Pit BBQ was set to be the first SCATHING review I had ever done. If you have followed me or read my reviews in the past 15 years, you know I'm not typically one to write negative reviews. Even on the rare occasion that I'm provoked, I try to be constructive. But this review was gonna be way outside my norm! I was infuriated with the food and the service, but decided to give them another try instead of giving a harsh review. [ FIRST VISIT ] It was the day before the 2026 Superbowl, and everything seemed to be wrong with every part of my experience. No plates offered, no napkins, website was incorrect, food was terrible and came out at different times and overall service was lacking. The spare ribs were way overcooked, extremely greasy and mushy while the brisket was under-cooked and tough. The yams were okay, but the mac n' cheese was blah. The collard greens (spelled callard on menu) tasted two weeks old and the sweet tea was just brown water and not very sweet at all. Their rating on GOOGLE was 4.9 after 105 reviews, driving our decision to give them a try. TOTAL FAIL!!! SIDE NOTE: I should mention the owner did refund me for the brisket and collards after seeing how unhappy we were, but not for the whole meal, which imho should have been his response. [ SECOND VISIT ] However upsetting my experience was, I decided to come back just to see if this is truly how they operate. I returned on Monday, the day after the Superbowl and although the hours on the door suggested they should be open, they were not. STRIKE TWO!!! [ THIRD VISIT ] Came back again the following day on Tuesday and they were indeed open for business. The lady taking my order was different than the one on Saturday and she knocked it out of the park with her customer service. Friendly, informative and made sure I had everything I needed to eat my meal as well as brought a variety of sauces and napkins. I ordered the pork spare ribs, beef ribs at her high recommendation (which were not on the printed menu), and fried catfish plate with a side of french fries. This was far more food than I could eat in one sitting, but I wanted to really give them a chance. The difference in the ribs on this visit verses my first were night and day in every way. I will admit the seasoning was better on my first visit, but everything else about them was good. One customer recommended the habanero sauce and it was a great complement to the PORK RIBS. (3.75 stars) Afraid to try the BEEF BRISKET again, I opted for the BEEF RIB instead. They were tougher and less meaty than I expected, but the bark flavor was good and he added two additional bones, making it much more worthy of the price. (3 stars) Finally, the FRIED CATFISH (3.75 stars). Picture perfect in its golden presentation and meatiness. Could have used a tad more seasoning, so I added a little salt. Otherwise pretty good! The fries were also good. I did not order any drinks or sides (other than the fries that came with the catfish plate) and my total with tax came to around $53 or basically $17 for each meal I got out of my visit. [ VERDICT ] I'm happy that I returned and came away with a better experience than my first. Time will tell me which experience was the real one, since both were completely different. However, I've got a good feeling that first visit was just one of those Murphy's Law days! In the mean time, I will be conservative with my rating until I have a few more visits under my belt (literally). 3 stars overall counting the first visit. Looking forward to trying the shrimp & grits offered on weekends for breakfast.

    Delish!
    Laura B.

    Amazing food! Great service. To go we had pulled pork, Mac & cheese, collards, coleslaw and chocolate cake. We drank the juice from the collards!

    Half bbq smoked fall of the bone chicken
    Brad C.

    I definitely recommend Almighty pit, this is a talented bbq crew. When we saw the big hardwood fired smoker chugging smoke outside this place we knew we had to try it. This was mid afternoon 3:15PM Friday 8/7/26. We live in Buford and aren't down this way often. They were sold out of pork which was a good sign to try that in the future. I had the hot buffalo wings, collard gumbo, and my wife had smoked half chicken and Mac & Cheese and later some banana pudding. We tried a bit of each other's meal. All epic and tasty, the half chicken was fall off the bone tender, well smoked and crazy good, the Mac and cheese served In a little cast iron skillet, the pasta was ridged for cheese retention, was creamy and delicious, huge portion too enough for 2 people. The hot buffalo wings large and meaty, tasty, spicy. They were an order of 8 and at 6' 7" tall 275 lbs I could only eat 5 of them. The wings were cooked fresh to order and took 15 minutes, but they brought out the other dishes as they made it, so it was all temperature hot. The collard gumbo was the bomb. At least 4 medium peeled shrimps were in it with tail on and and 2 small pieces of sausage, the collards themselves were the BOMB. I could tell they were freshly made, not canned. Collards were dark leafy greens but well cooked and seasoned these were also served in a small cast iron skillet, I ate all the collards. Epic collards I can't stress this enough. If you need a collard green fix go to Almighty pit. They had several unique bbq sauces too, blueberry, guava, and a 3rd one. Portions were big and prices reasonable for the portion sizes. I should mention on the menu. The only chicken wing flavor mentioned was lemon pepper, which we learned from their chef. Stan, is their signature flavor wing, I will definitely try those next time. We had a nice visit with him, and learned they just opened earlier in 2026. This man and his team know what they are doing. Just stand in the parking lot and take a whiff of that big giant smoker they have and you will know you're at a great place. We didn't try the brisket, only later on as I was reading reviews I saw some people mention the Brisket here is a little different. But based on what I saw when we were dining in and in the pictures in reviews Almighty Pit's brisket looks like the kind served at Jasper's BBQ in Waco, TX. Jasper's has been open for over 100 years, is world famous, and they are known for their unique brisket, and I can't wait to try. Almighty pits brisket in the future. I am going to attach pictures of our actual plates. We had they put a tasty unique seasoning blend on top of my buffalo wings and my wife's mac & cheese. Later on we had the banana pudding, which was fluffy, Rich, not too sweet, not an overbearing banana flavor, but tasted like something. My grandmother would've prepared. We were stuffed and unable to eat all of our food and got to go containers, which I should mention are high-quality containers. I should mention the staff was very friendly, attentive, answered our questions and delightful. I'm going to go out on a limb here, but I believe these people are gonna be famous one day for bbq in Georgia.

    See all

    6 days ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 months ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Stanley H.

    Stanley H.

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    13 days ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    15 days ago

    This place is downright inspiring to amateur smokers like me. Top notch meat and sides, original sauces, even desserts. It's all amazing.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 days ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 months ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Stanley H.

    Stanley H.

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Richard R.
    4995
    1585
    26080

    8 months ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Stanley H.

    Stanley H.

    Helpful 64
    Thanks 17
    Love this 53
    Oh no 9

    3 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    15 days ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Brad C.
    4
    33
    42

    2 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 months ago

    the bbq sandwich and Mac and cheese is awesome. sweet heat sauce and bananna puddding was great also.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 months ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Stanley H.

    Stanley H.

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 months ago

    Everyone is Amazing. The food is definitely worth the visit. Try the Sampler and a side of Smoked Watermelon.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 months ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Stanley H.

    Stanley H.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 months ago

    Great brisket! Got the good fatty pieces too. Everyone was super nice. Will be stopping in regularly going forward.

    Business owner information

    Photo of Stanley H.

    Stanley H.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 months ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Stanley H.

    Stanley H.

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 1
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Almighty Pit BBQ

    You might also consider

    The AfterTaste Smokehouse & Grille - Smoked Chicken Tips

    The AfterTaste Smokehouse & Grille

    4.3(8 reviews)
    3.9 mi

    This is not your corner bbq joint. This is more of an upscale bbq spot. It also gave off a romantic…read moretype of vibe. Seating is very close and intimate and nice music is playing in the background. At first glance it seemed like a place you would want to come back to again and again. The waitress/cashier was very welcoming upon our entrance. I don't know if she was one of the owners but she was very nice and apologetic. We drove 30 minutes to try out this restaurant and let's just say it was not worth the drive. Since it was our first time there we were excited to try some of the ribs. Unfortunately they were out of the pork ribs. They were also out of the mac and cheese. That was a little disappointing but I figured because we got there around 7 and they close at 8 they could have run out of items. No biggie. We opted to get the fried chicken with fries and fried mushrooms. I got the pulled pork sandwich with onion rings, and a lemonade. The lemonade was perfect, to me it wasn't too sweet and had just enough tartness to make you want to drink more. Presentation was EVERYTHING. When the sandwich came out I wasn't even sure how to eat it lol. It looked great on the wooded plate. I wish the plates would have been bigger because the sandwich was a little sloppy, nonetheless it was presented very classy. The bowl that the onion rings came in was also wood and it was cute and different. I have not seen dishes like this before. The chicken was on one of the wooded classy plates a little small for the chicken but cute as well. Now here is the part where I had to deduct stars. The chicken was fried perfectly, it was juicy, crispy and hot. The only thing that was missing was the seasoning. It was very bland there was absolutely no salt or pepper or any flavoring that I could taste on the chicken. I just knew we couldn't go wrong with the chicken because after all it is a bbq spot right? Wrong..maybe because it was late they were just trying to get the food out so they could go home. But whatever the case it was not good. We did not have any bbq sauce or hot sauce. It wasn't offered and we didn't ask. Same thing with the fried mushrooms. The coating did not have any flavor and we did not have any dipping sauce. Again we didn't ask and it wasn't offered. The waitress did provide ketchup with both meals, but I feel like something was off with the flavoring. The onion rings were good and the steak fries were good. I would not drive that distance just for those items. One couple at a table next to ours had something that looked like fish or very large chicken tenders. Either way hers did look good but I wondered if it had any flavor. Hers was plain, no sauce or anything like that. I did see she had something to dip the food in and it looked like she enjoyed it. As I mentioned previously it is a very cosy atmosphere. It was very humid inside though and the sunlight was beaming in hard. The waitress tried to close the curtains but that didn't help much because the curtains were kind of see-through so the sun still hit us hard in the face and back, and again because it was so late maybe they had turned down the a/c. The waitress did apologize but basically there was nothing she could do about that. They do have a rewards program that you can sign up for to aquire points and discounts on things but I wasted time signing up because I will not be returning. I was so excited to have a new bbq place to frequent but unfortunately this will not be the one. To end on a positive note, the presentation was everything and the environment was very inviting.

    I love this place!!!! OMG I cannot emphasize how much this place is wonderful. I went here with my…read morefamily on 9/2 and at first we were nervous because it took forever to get our drinks. Also, they were out of brisket which is what the whole family was craving, so two red flags. We wanted to run out and go to the Mexican Restaurant next door, but then the manager came out and change our whole mood. We got chicken wings, a veggie platter, a burger and beef ribs. It was so delicious and you can tell they really season their food and cook their food with love. The ambience was gorgeous and felt so cozy. I definitely am coming back to this restaurant.

    Photos
    The AfterTaste Smokehouse & Grille - Smoked Chicken Sandwich

    Smoked Chicken Sandwich

    The AfterTaste Smokehouse & Grille - Pulled Pork

    Pulled Pork

    The AfterTaste Smokehouse & Grille

    See all

    Tipsy Pig BBQ - Brisket Plate with Cole Slaw and Mac & Cheese

    Tipsy Pig BBQ

    4.2(484 reviews)
    8.4 mi
    •$

    I went to Tipsy Pig last week, and it looks like they're in the middle of a little upgrade--the…read moresetup has definitely changed. One thing on the menu I *had* to try was their Nashville Hot Chicken Sandwich. I'm very familiar with true Nashville hot, especially after having Prince's Hot Chicken in Nashville, so I had a solid benchmark. Honestly, I was pleasantly surprised by how good it was. It was so good that I actually called the location afterward because I wanted to give props to the person who made it. I told him they really have something special. And that coleslaw on top? Absolutely essential. Great Sandwitch and highly reommened!

    The food was excellent. We ordered over the phone and the gentleman was very polite and patient and…read morethorough. It's in a gas station and the gas station owner does not mind if you park at a gas pump which you may have to because the parking lot is very crowded because of the barbecue place inside the gas station. We got baby back ribs, which were delicious. We also got a Memphis pulled pork sandwich, which has coleslaw and pork on it. I got a side of coleslaw and peach cobbler. The ribs were juicy as was pork on the sandwich. The coleslaw was very fresh, the sauces were delicious. I didn't really love the peach cobbler because I love it to be more about the peaches than the cobbler part but we will be back and I'm gonna try the blackberry cobbler next time.

    Photos
    Tipsy Pig BBQ
    Tipsy Pig BBQ - Pulled Pork Plate with mac & cheese and cole slaw

    Pulled Pork Plate with mac & cheese and cole slaw

    Tipsy Pig BBQ - Two Meat Plate with Smoked Chicken and Ribs

    See all

    Two Meat Plate with Smoked Chicken and Ribs

    It's Different BBQ Company - 1/2 pork ribs

    It's Different BBQ Company

    4.7(66 reviews)
    7.7 mi

    I've lived in Georgia my entire life, so I've eaten my fair share of barbecue, and I can honestly…read moresay It's Different Barbecue Company is some of the BEST barbecue I've ever had. Everything tastes homemade, fresh, and like somebody genuinely cares about what they're putting on your plate. The food is hearty, comforting, and absolutely delicious. But the BRISKET. Y'all. I don't even have the words. It is ridiculously good. Tender, flavorful, perfectly cooked, and apparently addictive because I have literally eaten it three days in a row. THREE DAYS. And I'd happily eat it again tomorrow. What makes this place even better is the family behind it. They are some of the sweetest, kindest people, and the chef is incredibly nice. You can tell there's a lot of heart behind this business, both in the way they treat people and in the food they serve. If you're anywhere near Buford and looking for genuinely great barbecue, GO HERE. Support this sweet family, order the brisket, and thank me later. Just maybe don't blame me when you're back again the next day.

    It's Different BBQ Company is such a gem! It's a family run business delivering the most tasty…read morefall-off-the-bone bbq I've had. Dare I say - the best one in GA?! This review is overdue. I've visited 5-6x at this point and have both dined on the spot and picked up to-go here. Meats are a la cart and by the pound. There's also burgers/sandwiches and various sides available. All the meats we've tried did not disappoint. Items we've ordered: *Sliced brisket *Pork ribs *Prime ribs *Pulled pork *Mac n cheese The house BBQ sauce is super flavorful and available for purchase in 3 sizes. Pickles and pickled onions are available upon request. It's Different BBQ operates mainly as a takeout spot with some counter seats around the front and 2 picnic tables outside. All orders are packed in to-go containers. They also cater!

    Photos
    It's Different BBQ Company
    It's Different BBQ Company - Pulled pork, slaw, strawberry jalapeño soda

    Pulled pork, slaw, strawberry jalapeño soda

    It's Different BBQ Company - Preach!!! The experience of being glutened is similar to food poisoning. That's why places like this are needed and appreciated.

    See all

    Preach!!! The experience of being glutened is similar to food poisoning. That's why places like this are needed and appreciated.

    Almighty Pit BBQ - bbq - Updated October 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...