I'm often grabbing bagels for my staff on Breakfast Fridays. Bagels here are very good and the creme cheese flavors come in a variety, so that's a plus for my staff, everyone likes the vege and regular, I like the sugar one.. I would, lol, according to my team. ANYWAY, reasonable prices and grab an apple turnover they are perfect and I don't share them. Get there early on weekend or Fridays, they get busy. read more

Ordered breakfast ahead it wasn't ready when we got there and then got back to work only to find out pancakes with no syrup no utensils what a waste of time!!!! read more

If I could give it a zero I would! They always mess up an order if it's more than one item. And seriously for a bagel with pork roll and just cheese on it. $8 I say it over and over again. I'm never going back. I'm done! read more

1000% YES! The selection of bagels and spreads may not be as broad as other local stops, but my god this place beats them in flavor and quality! I got the jalapeño cheddar bagel toasted with a side of regular cream cheese. The bagel was so soft and squishy. The bagel had a sweet flavor to the dough which was complemented by the spicy jalapeño slices on top and salty cheddar cheese. I cannot say enough good things about this bagel. I'll probably wake up tomorrow morning wishing I had another. (Bagel was consumed in record time, so no photos - sorry!) read more

I just moved into the neighborhood, so I was hopeful to have a bagel place practically walking distance from my house. But sorry, no. One of the worst bagels I've had in the area, and that's says a lot considering how many bagel joints are within a few miles. Poorly formed, poorly cooked, poor selection... just an overall disappointing. Clearly, there are a lot of people who don't know what a hood bagel is since these guys have 15 locations (according to their van advertising). Also, no deals on a dozen bagels? That's practically a tradition with bagels and bakeries; bakers dozen! Hello? And sorry, but I can't take you seriously if you sell Blueberry, Chocolate Chip, French Toast, Honey Wheat and Jalapeno Cheddar bagels. Guess I still have to drive for good bagels. BTW, the website menu lists "bagles". If that's not a sign, I don't know what is. read more

This place is rated at 3.5 star average and should be lower. Sadly custom bengals is hard to find but look around as you will find someplace better. why the bad review? 1 they are out of stock of almost all the bagels that they have listed. How do you run out of plain bagels and not have them coming in a few minutes? 2 the bagels are no longer fresh. 3 the 19-year-old behind the counter are deaf. How many times do I have to repeat my order? 4 and lastly there is the long ass line. That's OK talk to the people in the line all of them complain about the service. Someone asked me why I come here once every four years. that's because I have no choice. read more

Stopped by because the open sign was on. Was looking forward to a hardy bagel sandwich after a long day of work. They were, in fact, not open. Totally bummed. *My previous review was for the New Prospect location. Not sure why it's showing here. read more

All Star Bagels - Outside - Bagels Near Me - Jackson, New Jersey

All Star Bagels is a Jackson stalwart. It is a small bagel shop with some good people running the show. The egg and cheese on a roll was solid. The sesame bagel with egg and cheese was also nicely done. The bagels aren't 5 stars but they are a good vehicle for the breakfast sandwiches. Breakfast sandwiches seem to be the go to here. The one negative is the service is slow but the staff are very nice. 4 stars for the kindness and product. read more

All Star Bagels - a bagel sandwich wrapped in aluminum foil - Bagels Near Me - Jackson, New Jersey

Food is always so good. Bagels are fresh and staff is always so kind. This All Star location will forever be my favorite.

Disappointed twice in 24 hours, a new record. Disappointed twice in 24 hours, a new record. I placed an order on a Saturday for pickup by 12:40, arrived at 12:35, and the business was closed. I saw the employee in the store packing a bag which I thought was for me...nope. It was more important that they had something to take home. I contacted the other location in Lakehurst on the phone (different owner), and he offered to drive my bagels to me. This was not his business. I emailed the owner Jimmy, and Jason responded to return tomorrow, Sunday, and they would take care of me with 1.5 dozen bagels. IT GETS WORSE. When I arrived, Jimmy and Jason weren't there. I showed the woman (short, dark longer hair) behind the counter the email, and she said that Jason said to take care of me. 10 bagels she gave me... 10 - Is that what you meant, Jason? Let's review the bagels. Very sweet. Sugar added. The bagel toppings were only on the top, resulting from a quick touchdown. My compliment to them; it wasn't the worst bagel I ever ate. I recommend you travel further for an employee who can count, so you don't have to check. Never in my over 50 years of life has a business ever made it worse by trying to fix a mistakeaced an order on a Saturday for pickup by 12:40, arrived at 12:35, and the business was closed. I saw the employee in the store packing a bag which I thought was for me...nope. It was more important that they had something to take home. I contacted the other location in Lakehurst on the phone (different owner), and he offered to drive my bagels to me. This was not his business. I emailed the owner Jimmy, and Jason responded to return tomorrow, Sunday, and they would take care of me with 1.5 dozen bagels. IT GETS WORSE. When I arrived, Jimmy and Jason weren't there. I showed the woman (short, dark longer hair) behind the counter the email, and she said that Jason said to take care of me. 10 bagels she gave me... 10 - Is that what you meant, Jason? Let's review the bagels. Very sweet. Sugar added. The bagel toppings were only on the top, resulting from a quick touchdown. My compliment to them; it wasn't the worst bagel I ever ate. I recommend you travel further for an employee who can count, so you don't have to check. Never in my over 50 years of life has a business ever made it worse by trying to fix a mistake. read more

I use to go all the time but stopped for awhile. The bagels are good but every time you get cr cheese they are very chincy with the amount they put on. The pork roll egg and cheeses have also been the same, a bit scant on the portion. Tried again and I'm just done. Paid extra for specialty cr cheese and there was barely any on there. The picture is cr cheese AND butter and it so chincy. There are way to many other bagel stores to go to in the area. read more

All Star Bagels - Bagel with cr cheese and butter - Bagels Near Me - Jackson, New Jersey

Overall **** Bagels the way I like them, crispy on the outside and soft on the inside, friendly service and throw in some interesting sounding specials like the Avocado BLT that my wife regretted not getting along with their support of St Jude's makes this a winner in my book. Setting *** Next to a 7/11 in a sort of dumpy looking strip mall is All Star Bagels. Nothing about the place wowed me and it is more generic local bagel place but it looked generally clean. They put a lot of money into the menu boards but not much elsewhere. The coffee area is a bit disheveled as some things aren't labeled and you have to move from one area to another to finish up your coffee. Service **** Lots of very friendly, young staff working with a ready smile. Food **** Finally Pork Roll, Egg and Cheese done right! Crisped up thick sliced Pork Roll, eggs over medium, gooey cheese on a toasted bagel. It took a while to receive but worth the wait and may have been one of the best I've had. Unfortunately the Chocolate Chip Muffin may be the worst I've ever had as it was dry and tasteless. My son tried his best to power through it. The coffee I felt was good, not great and the only sweeteners offered was sugar or Sweet & Low. Value **** $4.50 for my sandwich is a bit higher than I pay in NYC but this quality was much better. All in for the sandwich, muffin, two coffees and and apple juice was $13. read more

All Star Bagels - Special Menu *20% donated to Children's Hospital - Bagels Near Me - Jackson, New Jersey

I paid for 4 bagels but when I got home there were only 3 in the bag. Make sure double check your bag. The bagels were very good, though. read more

What an unexpected surprise. Happened to be passing through the area and stopping into the excellent neighboring pizzaria and saw this bagel shop. Where I live in Delaware, good bagels don't exist. The locals think the bread served at Dunkin or Manhattan Bagels are actually bagels. Yuck. So when I see a bagel shop in civilization, I stop and give it a try. These bagels are excellent. A nice sweet flavor reminiscent of H&H. Good size too. Wish I bought more to freeze! read more

We were visiting from out of town and got bagels on our way out! The staff is so sweet and thoughtful! They cut up my daughter's bagel in 4 so she could eat it well, and they gave us extra bagels for the road! And their bagels are delicious!! So glad we stopped here!! Phenomenal place!! read more

Really great little bagel shop, and I am happy to say this is the longest any business has ever lasted in this location. Super great for the high school kids to stop by-and even gain employment, which I love! Staff is really friendly, and eager to please. Obviously, try the PR Egg & Cheese! read more

I am reviewing this solely for their insane breakfast sandwiches. Every once in a while, I order their Slider sandwich and cry tears of bliss with every bite. I have never come across a breakfast sandwich better than theirs and really feel like it is a little known secret in Jackson. The place is family operated (and I love listening to them banter back & forth as they take order after order - this place is always packed!) and I have never had a bad experience. Highly recommend to anyone who takes their breakfast sandwiches seriously. read more

All Star Bagels - Slider breakfast sandwich: pork roll, egg, cheese, hashbrown, salt, pepper, ketchup, and a little dash of heaven all served on an egg bagel. - Bagels Near Me - Jackson, New Jersey

Closes at 1 but they lock the door at 12. Probably should just change your hours instead of leading customers on

This bagel shop is great! Delicious breakfast sandwiches. Awesome bagels. And the staff is super friendly. I recommend getting a pork roll, egg & cheese on an everything bagel or try the "Grand Slam". read more

Awesome bagel spot. Super convenient location. Really friendly staff. Bagels all taste really fresh and delicious. Love the french toast bagels, toasted, with cream cheese. Also recommend trying the pork roll, egg and cheese or bacon, egg and cheese bagel sandwiches. Outstanding! Give it a try! read more

I love love love this All Star bagel. So much so that I am there every single morning Mon-Sat. As soon as I walk in they are already grabbing my bagel as they know what I want. Their coffee is amazing. I was always a Wawa person but they definitely top that in my opinion. Bagels are always fresh. The staff is always super friendly. It's a very homey feeling place. I will continue to go there every morning! read more

All Star bagels are the best around! They have great flavors, my favorite is the French toast! Their seeded ones are great too because they are just covered with lots of seeds on top n bottom, and all around, Yum! The people that work their are very pleasant and provide good service. I buy a dozen bagels plus 3 free with the coupon and it comes out cheaper than any other place around. We eat some and then freeze the rest for the week. They're still great after freezing as long as u freeze them right away after purchasing. Now go get some! read more

They are the worst bagel store in jackson. The staff is rude, they mess up the order and forget that your waiting for your food until you remind them your still there and then give you cold food. The food it self is not that great either. I won't be going back to this place ever again read more

My husband gets breakfast sandwiches here almost every Saturday! Sometimes he'll pick one up for me and our 2 teen aged daughters, too! We love them! Best pork roll egg and cheese in Jackson!! read more

The bagel was amazing! Kitchen is a little slow but worth the wait. The staff and management seemed to be very disorganized. Overall it's worth the value and the quality of food is great! read more

I'll be honest, the food and turnaround time was excellent, but the service itself was deplorable. When placing my order on the phone, I experienced some of the poorest customer service ever, but I was willing to excuse it since I figured it was a busy morning and the inside of the shop was loud ("Don't beat yourself up, Niko Z. Everyone knows onions and broccoli in an omelet is a delicious order; the young girl just couldn't hear you, that's why she was a total jerk and yelled 'that doesn't make any sense.' You'll dazzle her when you pick your whole order up in 10-15 minutes. Hang in there."). Unfortunately, when I arrived at the store, I immediately realized that the jerk from the phone might be the nicest thing going there. The two other people on staff were rude, disrespectful and plain nasty. They didn't have any memory of my order at first (remember, I was the monster who put onions in an omelet), told me I gave them a different name (pretty sure I always nail that when placing orders), avoided eye contact (I'll give you that considering I was pretty hung), and appeared to bark rather than talk. Shame on you, All Star Bagel. Do more (but you are NAILING the bagels). read more

Fiance went back to try mid week-less rush..they couldn't mess up, right? Got the right bagels at least. He ordered two sandwiches; one bacon egg and cheese one pork roll egg and cheese. Got two pork roll.. So disappointed. This place regardless of wait had become our go to. Don't think we will be back. read more

They actually toast the bagels, which is a plus. The downside was the everything bagel lacked flavor. It also lacked the chew of a traditional bagel. read more

Bridgette and Stephanie make me feel like family walking in here. Outstanding service and not to mention the breakfast sandos are spectacular. read more

All Star Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Jackson, New Jersey

I have tried a lot of bagel joints in Jackson, and to be honest they're all over priced and suck compared to all star, they have the best bagels around and my favorite thing is the grand slam on an egg everything bagel. Good job guys! read more

All star bagel has great food and friendly staff. They seem to always have fresh bagels ready to be ordered. The only down side is if they are busy which happens often on the weekend they can be a little slow but it's worth the wait. read more

New to the area looking fir a great bagel shop. So glad I found this gem. Everything is delicious and fresh.

I've never eaten here before. I tried though. I work across the street in the meridian building and I wanted to get a bagel during my lunch break at 12 pm since they are so conveniently close and the doors were locked. They lights were on inside and the "open" light up sign on the window was on. They say there are open until 1 pm but doors were locked at 12? I will NOT be attempting to eat here again.. read more

I would love to give them a 5 star rating, but sometimes the wait for a sandwich is just too long. Also they have messed up my sandwich more then once, which isn't too big of an issue. Not sure how the person had hair in there food. I have been here 3-4 times a week for about a year now with no complaints. read more

I've loved All Star bagel for over 16 years. They really are the best bagel on the east coast. Possibly the world.

Worst Customer service ever!!! No really! Who yells at customers??? Apparently the owners do. They don't have any respect for anyone. The place is dirty, and everyone is nasty. Go somewhere else!!! read more

The food is good but during both my visits here I don't think I've seen any of the employees wearing gloves. Sanitation is a must and this why I'm giving a 3 instead of a 4-star review. read more

They close a little early for me, but they have amazing bagels and are a great choice for meetings. We usually choose them for our large morning breakfasts. read more

Best bagels ever highly recommend All-Star bagels every location is wonderful and the service is always friendly and quick I wouldn't go anywhere else read more