Tomaso's quickly became one of my favorite pizza spots while I was in Appleton!…read more I first tried the BBQ Chicken Pizza, then came back a few days later for the Buffalo Ranch Pizza--both had great flavor and fresh ingredients. I went with the pan dough, which gave me the slightly flatter crust I prefer without feeling overly heavy or filling. The service was great, the ambiance was welcoming, and I enjoyed ordering at the bar. Overall, this is easily one of my highest-rated pizza spots in the area and definitely worth checking out if you're in Appleton!

Great experience. First time going it was delicious. Server was a great guy and super nice. I…read morerecommend the Badger! Great pepperoni. Cream cheese balls. Hot honey on the side. CAN'T MISS. So so so good.

Came here two days after they obtained their official certification and if you want some excellent…read morenapoletan pizza, this is your spot! Service was outstanding, sat outside on the back patio which was very nice and surprisingly well concealed from the parking lot next to it, great spot to sit when weather is nice but completely covered if raining as well. Tried two pizzas and the favorite was the dolce e piccante as the hot honey and pepperoni were great together. The prosciutto cotto was also very good and we tried the gnocchi and loved it as well. Finished it off with a tiramisu and it was creamy and rich, just like it should be, served in a small jar.

Authentic Italian pizza in Appleton, WI! All 3 pizzas we got were outstanding. Waiter explained to…read moreus how they are certified Neapolitan pizza. Got 2 red sauce pizzas and 1 white sauce and all were amazing. Save room for housemade gelato and tiramisu for dessert.

HIGHLY RECOMMEND. This pizza is absolutely amazing! It is similar to Chicago pizzas. I could drink…read morethe sauce! I like the Sicilian crust best; both bready/chewy but also with crispness. We drive from Green Bay to get it. The owner is also fantastic. He constantly donates to organizations for the community, sponsors teams, and even has donated free pizzas to low income kids during tge summer.

Best darn wings around. I love them so much, my wife even…read moresurprised me with them for my birthday dinner. I was VERY happy and hungry

Tasty pies we got the Alfredo pizza and pepperoni green olives with cheese bread food was ready…read morequickly and everyone was happy would recommend

There were only 3 people in our group & had a reservation. Service was beyond slow, appetizer took…read more20 minutes to arrive. Then also ordered a pizza and pasta dish. That took 45 minutes. Server seemed to ignore us. People eating at the bar were in and out quicker than we were. Food was bland - not even close to how good it was previously. Reached out to Pope's to tell them about my dissatisfaction and still have not received a response. Have no plans to return.

Fantastic pizza!! Love the place!!…read moreAlso, have good pasta!! Great ambience!! Highly recommend

Stop today for lunch and had our usual medium house special, no salami, fresh mushrooms, and some…read morebeverages. Owner Lori was doing tables and doing everything else along with the other wait staff. I've been going to Sammy's for over 50 years and the pizza Is just as good today as it was 50 years ago. We've never been let down. Best pizza in town try it.

When you come here, expect to wait about 45 minutes to an hour for your pizza. This is part of the…read morecooking process that is very unique to making a crisp, flavorful, lack-of-grease pie. Read the bottom as to WHY. We arrived about 5pm on a Saturday. Not real busy. 1 minute to someone taking our drinks order, 2m30 to having drinks on the table and placing our app and food order. Apps were on the table in 15 minutes. Had an order of the Tracy bread with garlic sauce. Get the garlic sauce and just dunk your sticks like they're Oreos in milk. Delicious. Another 42 minutes and our pies were brought out one by one. Cooked to perfection, the bacon wasn't floppy, outer crust held its shape, and the base crust wasn't thin like a proofed crust. And also... no grease! It was moist, but it was the tomato sauce that was giving it the moisture. Would I order again? Heck yes. Would I have 3 beers before the food arrives? Heck no, lol. LITTLE SECRET ON WHY IT TAKES SO LONG: aluminum pans are used instead of dark pans which would otherwise cook faster. If they used dark pans, the outside and the crust would cook too fast, and the middle would be floppy and undercooked. This and the oven was the key to a stiff, flavorful pie. Would return again. 10/10.

Big joes official pizza review…read more 6.8 Pizza was small for the price Taste was not the best probably won't find myself back into this establishment

Great atmosphere, food and customer service I love this…read moreplace Family, date night, friends, etc

A fantastic spot in downtown Neenah for a great wood fire pizza. The Haley's Comet (added…read moremushrooms) has great flavor combinations. The chicken, bacon, artichokes and onions all play well together. Adding the mushrooms brought a nice umami/earthy flavor to already solid flavor profile. My only small criticism, the pizza could've used another 20-30 seconds. It would've given more crisp to the middle of the pie, and a touch more char would've been . I would recommend swinging in and giving Broken Tree Pizza a try, I will when back in the area.

This small restaurant really had a nice family feel to it…read more Our waitress was very sweet and attentive. She did her best to accommodate us and truly cared about doing the best she could. We enjoyed a delicious pizza and some perch. It was nice and quiet and clean. Great food with a kind attitude. That is right. A true neighborhood/family appeal. Thanks ladies!

Online order was completely wrong. When I called they took no responsibility, simply because I was…read moreupset. Unacceptable! They don't have a good online order record. I got no email or text. Not okay!