What a sad, little pizza I just picked up from this location! I've been eating at All American Pizza for about 10 years -- usually the one in Bethany. The Bethany location is consistently good. This Edmond location is consistently bad. Today, I ordered a lunch special with extra sauce. What I received was a small pizza with NO sauce. There was almost no cheese on the "pizza", such that the entire pizza was only about 1/8 of an inch thick! I could only choke down half of the dry "pizza", before throwing the rest in the trash can. I will not be returning to this location (2nd street, Edmond). read more

All American Pizza - Frozen pizza from a convenience store looks better than this! - Pizza Near Me - Edmond, Oklahoma

See all

Pizza and wings were delicious, service was fast and friendly. Location was comfortable, colorful, and clean.

Great food and service. Try their calzone is is good just get extra sauce. Pick up is better than delivery

Customer service needs improvement................................................................................................................................... Customer service needs improvement................................................................................................................................... Pizzas good though. read more

All American Pizza - Bacon cheeseburger with mustard - Pizza Near Me - Edmond, Oklahoma

This is hands down the greatest pizza restaurant on Earth. No contest. I love this place! I recommend the cheese Alfredo, it is very tasty.

The Edmond location on east Edmond Rd. states they are open until 9 pm. I started calling at 845 to order at Pizza. After 3 calls & no one answering the phone, I thought maybe they were too busy to answer. I live 3 to 4 minutes away & figured I'd order when I got there. I arrived at 8:53. They were locked up, lights out. My thought is..If you stop answering the phone at 845. Maybe reflect that in your closing time. Definitely don't say open till 9pm, when you are not. I love their Pizza..Sucks that you can't get one before closing time, especially when they say they are open. read more

Best local pizza in Edmond. Great overall value with amazing quality and flavors. My 1st choice

I love this place. Cheese-stuffed crust is the best, and they're generous when you order extra toppings. Always friendly and welcoming.

Ordered a cheese pizza and one Alfredo pizza. I was in town visiting and transparently thought I was ordered from Star and Stripes when I noticed this place close to Jimmy John's. The pizza was delivered hot and quick however the pizza isn't great. It's what you'd expect for paying $5 to $8 for a basic pizza but I've had better at Costco if you'd talking cheap pizza. The pizza was rather dry and lacked sauce. read more

I love the box that says "An Oklahoma Original!" One usually thinks of New York or Detroit as bastions of famous pizza, not Oklahoma. To be honest, I have been the target of opprobrium at work once I revealed that every Friday I pick up a pizza from here to take home. Suddenly, all my coworkers encouraged me to seek alternatives. I ignore them. I recently moved to Oklahoma and started eating here because it's close to my house. I keep eating here because it's really good. This place checks all the boxes for me. The crust is the perfect thickness. Not too thick, not too thin, crispy on the edges. Toppings are plentiful and always tastes fresh. What really does it for me is the price. The most reasonably priced pizza in town. Why pay more for some fancy artisanal pizza when all you want is a solid pie to share with the fam? Almost always, the pizza is hot and ready in about 10 minutes after I call. I'm not waiting an hour to get a pie. The staff are super cool and seem to always handle the massive rush on Friday with friendliness and a good attitude. You should tip them well. Staff at the other "fancy" pizza places in town seem to act as if they're doing you a favor by serving you. I've also grabbed a couple of cheesecake slices on the way out, which are also pretty good. Just FYI, there is no seating or dining in, only takeout. This pizza beats any chain in service, price, and quality. It's not fancy, you won't find goat cheese or sun dried tomatoes here. But it's a solid American pie that's quick and delicious. read more

I ordered a calzone to be delivered and was appalled they would even send this out as edible, I got a coupon to try them again, same thing, the oven needs to be fixed bc what is shown on their website does not match either of what I got. Would not recommend. Will not waste my time giving them another shot. I've ordered pizza from them multiple times and loved it but apparently they can't handle the calzones. read more

All American Pizza - Calzone #2 which was to replace the first severely burned one ‍ - Pizza Near Me - Edmond, Oklahoma

See all

It's pizza so you can't mess it up too bad, but I'd only eat this place if I'm severely hungover. Ingredients are bottom tier, the salad is terrible as well. read more

UCO students, if you're reading this... You have 10% off! So go get your pizza guys! In general the pizzas here are decently priced, but I love that they have something for students, it's very much appreciated! I've had All American pizza about three times now - sometimes for school events, and once just because, and they've all been great. The crust is great, they're pretty generous with the toppings and cheese, and they've got so...many...options. There's an online order form too, that makes everything else just a much quicker process. And it helps if you're into curbside pickup! Thumbs up from me! read more

Very good pizza with lots of cheese. I ordered take out which was delivered hot and on time.

BETTER THAN ALL YOUR FAVORITE PIZZA SPOTS. Was expecting the worst and, got the best. There food is baked to order..which means it's always fresh! I tasted nothing but top flight ingredients. I got a discount code on Uber Eats so I went for it..and, boy did I hit!! Definitely found my favorite new pizza spot..with or without the discount! Let support or local businesses as well!!!(; read more

See all

All American is good, cheap pizza. Is it like a $30 pizza? No. It's just as good as any $15 or less pizza. Our go to is the $15 Family Deal for one specialty and one one topping with either a soda or breadsticks. It's the same price as the pizza and you get either free breadsticks or free soda. I also really like their salad. When I'm craving a Jo's pizzeria salad but I feel like a cheapskate, I get the salad here with their ranch dressing. Gotta love pizzeria ranch dressing. Also, I'll let you in on a family secret here: my husbands favorite pizza is the all meat with a barbecue sauce base. Holy moly. These folks do it best and have never steered us wrong. I love the cheeseburger pizza. Judge not, lest you and your plain pepperoni be judged! read more

This place has gotten better! The pizza we had delivered was hot, fresh, had a great amount of toppings, and the cheese was good. The crust, NY hand tossed, was good and a little crispy even which gave it great bite. I'll come back. read more

Fantastic local pizza place, quick service but doesn't compromise on quality. Will be back many times I'm sure. read more

Good pizza for the price! Never sloppy or just thrown together. And the homemade ranch is yummy!

Pizza is good for the prices. Surprised to discover how fresh their salad's are. Unfortunately, pick up is somewhat difficult.

I love all American. The prices are great and the calzone is so yummy. The ranch is tasty too. They don't deliver but it's totally worth the drive. read more

Ordered four pizzas 30 minutes before closing. Got to the restaurant at 8:59 and the doors were locked. The female counting money said rudely "can I help you". They gave my order to someone else and offered for me to have theirs at no additional cost because they didn't want to restart the oven. Not a good experience at all for my first time dining at this particular location. Just moved to the area and probably won't ordering pizza from here again. I had a house full of family starving and got pizza they did not want or eat. Overall, the service and attitude was horrible!! read more

Simple, friendly, delicious, and best of all affordable. Really enjoy their thin crust!

I ordered half pepperoni, half black olive. When I opened the box my 8 year old exclaimed "they need to work on their math!". It didn't look like they even tried to make it even. This is cheap pizza and certainly better tasting than the major chain hot n ready. You get what you pay for. My kids like it. read more

All American Pizza - pepperoni, olives, and cheese - Pizza Near Me - Edmond, Oklahoma

This is our Sunday go to pizza joint. All American is consistently well made and a great value. So not over look the tasty salads & wings- both very affordable. Fresh and delicious. If you need one or twenty pizzas, this is the place for you. We love it - and order when we have neighborhood parties! It's really good! read more

It's hard to knock this place. I get a large specialty pizza for about 12$. It's always been prepared well. If you want high end specialty pizza that's probably way over priced I'd suggest going somewhere else. Otherwise get your pizza from here. read more

I ordered curbside delivery, and can honestly say, this is the best pizza we have had this year. The sauce has a wonderful flavor which blended nicely w my 1/2 pepperoni and 1/2 jalapeño extra cheese medium sized pizza. My husband raved about his large ground beef, Canadian bacon, and bell pepper pizza. You can't beat their prices and quality of food. Both large and medium pizza was $22.12 which included 20% tip. I would like to thank the owners and workers for providing the best meal we have had in 2 months. We were pleasantly surprised and know that you be would too. Highly recommend! read more

This is my first time here. Visiting from Tennessee and wanted a Gluten free pizza because I have Celiac disease. The service is over the top AMAZING. I also ordered the Gluten free wings. Next time I'm in town, this will be my go to place. I LOVE IT! read more

All American Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Edmond, Oklahoma

What a great tasting pizza for a cheap price. There is a lot of stuff on your pizza also. I don't give out 5 stars often but this place deserves it. read more

Thanks so much for your large sized gluten-free pizzas! They are awesome! Yummy pizza-great value!

Okay I can't believe it took me so long to say something about this place. I only review out of emotion with I am angry and 1 Star or I am so impressed 5 stars other wise I couldn't care less. Okay so I have been going here for years now it is less then a block fast and easy to get to. Pizza is very good on any level salad wings the menu is limited but here is why I am reviewing. These people are amazing at customer service I have in my 52 years never seen suck amazing consistent five star customer service. They are quick in the phone fast in preparation of food always respectful friendly clean. I am so proud watching these young owners run this business. I am older and pizza is not the best diet but these people are AMAZING. Please please please everyone buy pizza wings or salad her often you won't regret it. read more

Visiting family in the area and stopped by to get some pizzas to bring to their house for dinner as this place was close to my hotel. Had no idea what to expect, but glad I did. This is some good pizza and the prices are hard to beat. I got the family combo (Large specialty and large 1 topping + 2L soda or bread sticks for $18). Went with the chicken alfredo for the specialty (GET THIS) and the pepperoni. Both were excellent and cooked perfectly. 4 of use devoured these pies and bread sticks. If I lived here, this would probably be my go-to pizzeria! Overall, very good! read more

So although the prices are reasonable the service is sub standard. I called in a calzone. The person who took my order said 15-20 minutes no worries. I took my time and, and got there 20 minutes later. I promptly paid and she said it would be right up, it's in the oven. I asked if she was sure because it had been 20 mins....so I sat there another 15 mins for her to call my name "Sharon" to give me those hot and ready calzones right out of the oven, for and order that was not mine. Mine had been sitting on the oven top for oh about 40 minutes. So a sorry? Nah! A discount? Nah! I know slinging pizzas is complicated and it's hard to keep track of orsers, but c'mon man! Horrible read more

All American is our go to pizza place. It's super fast, super inexpensive and the pizza is good! It can be a bit greasy. We have had the regular and thin crust and both are great. I always get the veggie pizza and it's loaded with toppings. read more

First time I had this is was ok. Last couple times were not so good. This is average pizza IMO.

Pizza is fast and good. Can't beat 5.99 for 1 topping large! My kids love it and call it "star pizza". When they accidentally gave my pizza away to the wrong customer they made it right by throwing in a 2 liter of coke. This will always be my first choice for pizza. read more

Staff were friendly and service was quick. Pizzas tasted great. Excellent experience.

We just love All American!! My husband and I get a pizza from here at least once a week. They are wonderful. The pizza is super good! The prices are also right on point. I'm so surprised that I can get pizza this good for 5.99 (one topping) or 7.99 (specialty). We also love their breadsticks (4 for $1.99)! We'll never get pizza from anywhere else as long as we live in Edmond! read more

Good pizza and wings at an affordable price. Have to "ask" for the Family Deal, which includes a free 2 liter if you order 2 pizzas. Owner gives it right up if he is there. If it's the younger employees, you have to ask for it. A bit odd. Still, a good buy anyway. read more

I have purchased pizza from this location many times with no complaint but the last time I ordered they made our "double" pepperoni with the pepperoni under the cheese. It was not double pepperoni by far and looked like a cheese pizza when opened. I called and told them that I thought they had given me a cheese pizza by mistake to which they replied that I should look under the cheese. It makes me not want take a chance on them again. I would give a higher star rating but when you screw up pizza there is no excuse! read more