After moving here a month ago , my son had told me a couple times that All American Pizza had the best pizza in town and the calzones were good too. He's been here for 2 years now. Anyway , the other night he went to get us each a calzone to bring home. He told me the guy who helped him was kind of rude this time and when he asked for Ranch the guy said I already gave you Marinara , which my son said yes my Dad likes Marinara , but I like Ranch for mine. He gave him the Ranch , but again said I already gave you Marinara. Okay was it really a big deal he wanted a Ranch instead ? Anyway , my son gets home with both calzones and goes wow they are way smaller than the last time I got them. I was like yeah they don't make them that small in Las Vegas. Now I got the pepperoni , sausage , and green peppers. It was pretty flavorless. This is the best pizza place in Mustang ? Dang. My son said his was better when he got it last month. The Marinara was not bad , but it didn't save the calzone. I know times are tough and maybe they made them smaller to save a couple bucks , but you gotta have good flavor to get customers to come back. I was really disappointed after my son had told me several times how good this place was and the attitude he got when he ordered this time. read more

All American Pizza - Disappointing. Small and little flavor. Pepperoni , Sausage , and Green Peppers. Calzone. - Pizza Near Me - Mustang, Oklahoma

Fresh and Hot Xxxxxxxxxx Got to use this location Love the thin crust Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx read more

Not only was the guy who answered the phone ans took my order super friendly, but the calzone I ordered was amazing! I did a build your own and loved that you can choose any amount of toppings at no extra charge. I did chicken, bacon and jalapeno and shared it with my mom and husband and we a enjoyed it. I would definitely order it again sans jalapenos because they were way too spicy for both me and my husband and we both love jalapenos and spicy food. read more

All American Pizza - Build Your Own Calzone - Pizza Near Me - Mustang, Oklahoma

BEST PIZZA IN MUSTANG HANDS DOWN! 5star pizza for the best prices in town and I'm from jersey I know good pizza !!!!! read more

All American Pizza - Buffalo chicken pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mustang, Oklahoma

Food is always generously topped and tasty. Bring a pizza cutter. I've never received a pizza cut all the way through. read more

Just moved to Mustang from Houston a month ago. We have pizza every Friday at our house. It's tradition. We normally make our own, but tonight we decided to take the easy way out, and order from All American Pizza. We were so shocked at the prices being so reasonable so naturally, we thought it would be too good to be true and the pizza would likely be just "meh." For the price, we were willing to take the risk. We ordered a stuffed crust half pepperoni half cheese, a specialty chicken bbq and breadsticks. When I tell you that my entire family loved every slice...I promise there wasn't a crumb left in sight. I was so pleased that the pizza was full of flavor, the crust was simple but still great texture, and the breadsticks were cooked to perfection! We all agreed that this will be our go-to pizza place from now on. I'm just sad we didn't order more the first time! read more

All-American Mustang is our favorite! The pizza is amazing ( we are trying to figure out what makes it so stinking good!) and the staff and management are so helpful and kind. We will be back! read more

The inside of the shop is not very clean and is always busy. The pizza is always covered in cheese and it's disgusting, I personally don't recommend. It is affordable, that's why I'm giving it 3 stars. Personally I don't recommend. read more

Excellent pizza and price that you can't beat. Employees are always friendly and fast. Be sure to try the ranch dressing! read more

All American Pizza - Sausage and jalapeño - Pizza Near Me - Mustang, Oklahoma

See all

For the price, the pizza and calzone is good. Has a heap of toppings on both and always has a very friendly staff on hand.

Really doesn't deserve a star... paid 17 dollars for a medium, thin pepperoni and green pepper ... and I got a green pepper pizza that wasn't even done! It was the worst ever! Never again!!! read more

Calzone was tasty, however, the pizza was mediocre; definitely not as enticing as the pictures posted - which is why I originally ordered from there. The size is also very misleading; ordered a large and it was more like a medium. It maybe a large for fast food pizza, but definitely not a large for a pizza shop. read more

Good, reasonably priced pizza and lightning fast service. The owners are beyond friendly, and the venue itself is clean as a whistle. Delivery service available? Yup. Five stars for this locally owned pizza joint. read more

I love their pizza. The people who make and serve it are usually very kind. It's made very fast and has great service.

The hamburger pizza is the best I've had anywhere and is my new favorite craving . . . The mustard and pickles make all the difference. The cheese on the pizza and cheezy breadsticks is gooey and flavorful with the perfect amount on them. The crust is perfectly cooked and what I'd call between a typical hand-tossed and thin crust is thickness. Toppings were excellent quality and plentiful. The place was very clean, prices and deals cannot be beat, and service was fast and friendly. All American easily beats out the more well-known national chains. read more

Our first time ordering from All American pizza. When I placed the order online, it said it would be ready in 15 minutes. 30 minutes after the order had been placed, they had not started making it. Without any excuses or apologies, we were told it would be ready in 10 minutes. 30 minutes later, after asking once again, we finally received our single 1 topping pizza. We have been long time customers of Papa murphy's, and have never received such poor, unprofessional service. We had actually just come from Papa Murphy's as well and as usual, received our order exactly as it should be and on time from Papa Murphy's. We only stopped at all American because my child wanted to try it. We will not go back to this All American. read more

So this review is for the girl who laughed at the fact that they gave Doordash the wrong pizza and did nothing besides pass the buck and refused to make it right. Thank you for making us out of towners feel welcome. read more

I ABSOLUTELY LOVE this place!!! Bestpizzain town at the best prices!!! I highly recommend eating here whenever you're just craving a good pizza! Will not disappoint!! read more

I'll start with the negatives first. The young people at the counters are not the "friendliest" bunch of people. I have yet to find one that has good social skills. Now for the freaking delicious pizza!!!!! I've had just about every combo, my favorite by far is the buffalo chicken pizza (you will however need more sauce, I always ask for extra) I have not found a better pizza place yet! Only reason for the 4* and not 5 is due to the needing extra sauce every time and the social skills from the young ones read more

Can't complain. Over the 50+ pizzas here I've ordered. This is the place to go. This is excellent pizza for this price. Better than any other pizza joint in mustang. Very friendly staff. They smile and ask if you need anything else and not that bs smile. I've had maybe 3 bad pizzas here out of 40+ orders over the years . read more

Ready in 10 minutes. Best thin crust supreme pizza in town for under $10 & they will do special requests. This is a take out, no dining areas. read more

Great pizza for a great price! The service is quick and friendly and the product is excellent. Such an easy go-to because it is so cheap.

The pizza is great is the best and their service is amazing I asked for cheesey bread and they said they had none but it would be done is 5 min fresh and that was the best bread I had ever had read more

Favorite pizza chain in town. Any time I've had a problem with my order they immediately correct it and apologize. Staff is great and service is quick read more

Really great pizza and the prices are awesome! I would totally recommend this place to anyone!

Best pizza for the price. The food is always hot and delicious. The service is always great and speedy. I also like the calzones and the chicken wings. If we have company and want some take out, this is the go to place. read more

Fast, inexpensive, and tastes so much better than Little Caesers! Call in your order! Our favorite pizza place now!

Great option on any night. Just call it in halfway on your way home from work and they have it ready every time. Cheese bread is a great bargain. Staff is friendly. read more

Great local Pizza place!!! I get take-out from there almost every Friday. Inexpensive, delicious, and very fast; I can call in an order and it's ready within 10-15 minutes!!! I recommend this pizza over Little Caesars and Pizza Hut any day!!! read more

Like others have said it's a pretty decent pizza for the price, a great option for nights you don't want to cook! Always ready in ~10 minutes and staff is nice and helpful. read more