Cool lil pub in Old Colorado City. Had the fish and chips, HUGE piece of fish. Great Chips. Loved the different cut. I would have actually like the fish in 2 pieces. It seemed a bit over cooked on the breading. Beer could have been colder. Waiter was super polite. Very well mannered and communicated well. Nice Irish music playing. read more

Alchemy - Phish N Chips - Irish Near Me - Colorado Springs, Colorado

I'm shocked I've never reviewed this spot before. I've stopped in many times through the years for a drink with either friends or my husband. Idk if I've ever eaten here, so my review is purely for drinks only. The drinks are never weak, the service is always fast, and the ambiance gives dive bar. You can tell there are regulars who absolutely adore this place and I really can appreciate that. The staff is always welcoming and somehow we have always had either a waitress or a bartender make us laugh while here. read more

Alchemy - Irish Near Me - Colorado Springs, Colorado

See all

Absolutely love this place! Highlight of our short trip here. Christian was amazing and held things down. Awesome atmosphere, super friendly, great service, and the food and drinks were amazing. The Jameson honey wings were cooked to perfection, poutine gravy was delicious, and the drinks were fuego. 10/10 will be thinking about this for many nights to come! read more

A patron showed me his giant Nazi tattoo here, not sure if it is indicative of this establishment or of Colorado Springs as a whole but it was deeply disturbing. read more

I went in for dinner and beer. I walked in and the bartender, Blane, let me know that he was running both the bar and kitchen. I figured I would be waiting a while for food and I was wrong. Blane had my order out quickly and it hit the spot just right. He was still keeping up with drinks for everyone. I wouldn't have known he was running both except for him letting me know. Tasty food and cold beer as always! read more

This pub is a solid four star. Cold beers and great mixed drinks. You get the feeling of being in a traditional Irish pub. The staff is fun and friendly. The fish and chips are spectacular. The wedge salad is great as well. Highly recommend this pub for happy hour as well. They also have activities every night. Enjoy. read more

This place is exactly what I was looking for. A cool bar with nice people in a really cool and interesting neighborhood. I'm only in Colorado Springs for a few days, and not familiar with the area. I came in here on a Monday night, windows were open time a good breeze, live music playing, food was surprisingly good. People are friendly but also mind their business. I would definitely come here if you're in the area. read more

This place is ok. The service is hands off and the food was overly salty and average. We dropped by mid afternoon for a late lunch/snacks. Ordering, payment, and any other service other than food being brought out is done at the bar. They forgot our order of scotch eggs. The phish and chips had a very thin layer of fish and a lot of breading. The chips were good. The poutine had too many onions and not enough cheese curds and gravy. The chicken wings were very salty. Overall, the food was fine but nothing to write home about, except maybe the chips. We really liked the chips (aka fries). read more

See all

I cannot eat gluten and have truly missed fish and chips. Their GF fish and chips are on par and even more delicious than some I have tasted in Ireland! The fish was cooked to perfect and the breading was light and crispy! I tasted my son's GF Irish Nachos and they were just as delicious! They also have really delicious drink combos, Alchemy is a must stop when in Old Colorado City! read more

We walked into karaoke and a lively neighborhood bar where everyone is welcome. Irish (our bartender) was so friendly and welcoming. The food was amazing- my fiancé and I had the reuben, pretzels with pot of gold, poutine, and reuben poppers, not to mention the entire staff is super knowledgeable and made me feel at ease with my food allergies. Samson (our chef) truly perfected his craft, please do yourself a favor and try the corned beef, he literally makes it from scratch. Portion sizes were perfect, we actually had all that over two days because we had to go back for more! 1000% recommend! read more

Well, Either their new owner or management. I went there because of the good reviews. I saw Reuben on the menu and that's all I needed to see nothing beats a good Reuben. This was by far the worst ive ever had. I've traveled coast to coast for almost 2 years and I realize that everybody's version of a corn beef Reuben may be a little bit different but this thing was awful. The product was obviously the cheapest stuff they could buy. I choked down some of the meat and just ate the fries. read more

Best Irish Pub in town! The food and staff are absolutely phenomenal and the owner Scottie has to be the hardest working guy I've ever met! read more

Alchemy - Reuben poppers absolutely delicious! - Irish Near Me - Colorado Springs, Colorado

See all

GREAT pub to visit. Authentic pub charm and decor. The owner was there and chatted with us and took great care of us. Found out he is the new owner, but they kept the same service and kitchen staff. Good tap selection, full bar, and AMAZING food. Highly recommend the Poutine and the Lamb & Green Chili Stew. Live music throughout the month, Poker night on Tuesday. Sing-a-long on Friday, Trivia weekly (I forgot what day of the week he told us). Wish I lived in Colorado Springs so I could make this my regular pub. read more

My friend and I stopped in on girls day out. We shared the poutine and Irish nachos. OMG this is some of the best corned beef and sauerkraut I have ever had. The poutine was amazing too. We also had a few drinks including the Irish elder which was so refreshing on a hot day and the old fashion which was also excellent! Service was great and we will definitely be back! read more

I was there with a group on a Sunday afternoon. I ordered the "Roasted Brussies Salad" for $16. What I got was a small mixed green salad with three small previously frozen/ thawed soggy Brussels sprouts on top. The salad was smaller than I had gotten as a side salad at other places and the three soggy Brussels sprouts were absolutely disgusting. Definitely not worth it. The person across from me had fish and chips. The fish portion was a nice size but it came with a "side of coleslaw". That coleslaw could have been put in a 1/4 cup measuring cup and still have room in the cup. read more

Not sure what happened to this place. My husband and I used to live going here on lunch dates but the food quality went way down. We were served expired ranch and the pastrami sandwich made us sick. The service itself was good and the bartender/servers were very friendly. If the food gets better we would love to go back read more

Great experience. Had lots of fun at the bar with my group of friends while in town for a birthday weekend. Played games with the bartender and really loved the drinks and the pretzel! read more

Love this bar/pub. A little hole in the wall that has the best gluten free fried fish. Blaine the bartender and the rest of the crew were friendly and entertaining. Will definitely be back. Highly recommended. read more

I went on a date to Alchemy on Sat., and we sat for 20+ minutes. No one came to ask what we wanted. When my boyfriend went to the bar to order, he was ignored. Definitely NOT somewhere ti take a date. read more

Fun little dive bar, wish they poured Guinness properly. Haven't eaten here, but always a fun nighttime scene.

We have been wanting to try this place out thinking it closed at 8 per info. on a Friday night was odd. We arrive 6:45 & place was packed out. Two seats left at the bar & ask about closing hours. Got a laugh & they close when ever they finish like we hours in the morning Tried the Scottish egg. I never had one where the outside was not crispy & the egg was cold. Everyone makes them different but not my favorite. The Ruben sandwich with crispy fries was Awesome & drinks were tasty too! Looking forward to trying other delicious items! read more

See all

Stop by for happy hour and stay for food! We were visiting Manitou Springs and happy we stumbled upon this delish food. Try the Beet Scotch Eggs. Great bartender. read more

Alchemy - Go thru patio but gotta check out the door! - Irish Near Me - Colorado Springs, Colorado

Quality has gone so far downhill here. This place used to be good but my last experience was one of the worst meals I've had anywhere in a long time. I ordered the fish and chips that was $16. It included a singular piece of fish the size of my cell phone, lots of fries, a lemon that was dried up and maybe two inches big, and about three tablespoons of 'coleslaw' - it was spicy but didn't have flavor. This sounds like such an exaggeration, but it's not, I really wish it was. I ended up going home and eating because I was hungry an hour later. The bartender was fantastic though - so sweet and fun. Sadly it's not enough to get me to come back. read more

Great place for custom cocktails and some unique pub foods and some classics with a twist. Always a homie feel with either service inside their small pub or in the beautiful back yard. I came here for my first date with my wife and now five years later we are still coming back to celebrate at this place, where we first fell in love. Lotta love for this place, hope to keep coming here for at least the next 60 years. read more

Alchemy - Delicious poutine with duck! - Irish Near Me - Colorado Springs, Colorado

the service was good. Very nice waitress. Really disappointed in the Rueben sandwich. it used to be the best Rueben in the city. Had dinner there tonight and it was one of the worst I've ever had. Not sure what happened but nothing like it used to be. Very disappointing. Ambience is ok. It's what I expected. read more

the potato wedges are literally better than french fries. crispy on the ends. the chili wings were exactly what I was going for, tangy with a kick. and the classic reuben was just perfect. read more

See all

Just ignore the Irish pub feel if you don't like it; the food is more than worth it! We came in right at opening, and were promptly seated and taken care of. The food took a while to come out, but we were in and out within an hour. The food was much better than I expected from a pub. Most of us got the Pickle Chicken sandwich, and it was perfect. Moist chicken, a great breading, and a great marinade (or however the chicken was flavored). The Reuben was good as well, as reported by the person who had it. While none of us got alcohol, from conversations I heard around us, the bartender knows what she's doing in that department. read more

Awesome ambiance, great music, great drinks and great food. Ash provided great service read more

Alchemy - Veal skirt steak - Irish Near Me - Colorado Springs, Colorado

See all

My dinner was good but my guest was disappointed in hers. Too salty. Only a partial menu due to construction. I will try again in a few weeks when they are back to fullspeed. read more

Best cocktails ever. Divey atmosphere. Walk through the kitchen to the back door to sit outside on the patio. They have fairy lights and you can see the tops of the mountains above the fence. I ordered the Alchemist cocktail. If it's named after the joint you know it's one of the best. Gin Rum Lemon Thyme Ginger. I was expecting a short whiskey glass, but this bad boy came in a HUGE mason jar. It was very balanced and not overly sweet (I like to taste my liquor). Beautifully presented. The food is way better than normal bar fare. I got the Dublin Lawyer which had shrimp, lobster, and gnocchi in a cream sauce with a kick. It went down fast and wasn't overly filling. My partner got the Chi Kan Bang with drunken beans. The beans were spicy and had a chili powder seasoning. They were tasty and fresh. The sandwich was good and could have been saucier. Street parking. Wasn't very busy on a Sunday night. Would definitely recommend stopping in. Everything on their menu seemed like a solid option! read more

Alchemy - Dublin Lawyer (front) Chi Kan Bang (back) - Irish Near Me - Colorado Springs, Colorado

See all

First of all... They have sad Saturday's and Friday cry-day they play emo/screamo/metal music on these days If it isn't a phase for you (if you know you know) def check this place out on one of these days. We came in on a Saturday and they had a beautiful playlist of old emo rock Bands that we were jamming to as we were eating our delicious food. Our server Tyler was great and attentive. He made us feel right at home. The hazy IPA and ginger cider are delicious! LGC was delish and full of flavor. A bit of a small portion but worth a try. Hangover cure was good Farmers burger had delicious flavor 10/10 recommend read more

Alchemy - Inside/vibe - Irish Near Me - Colorado Springs, Colorado

We spent a long weekend in Old Colorado City/Manitou Springs and one of our primary reasons for the trip was to try the food. Alchemy was by far the best restaurant we tried on our trip. Alchemy is quite a bit smaller than I expected - just an old bar with maybe 10-15 tables in the dining area. Its a dark and moody bar of the kind you see a lot in Colorado's foothills/mountain towns. As you can see in the photos, we decided to order several entrees and share everything "family style". We did this because there were so many appealing items on the menu that we really couldn't make a solid decision. Everything we tried was great. Literally the only thing we tried that we didn't absolutely love was the cauliflower soufflé that came with the Tri Tips dish but even that was quite good. The stand out was the Dublin Lawyer which had a thick, spicy and rich sauce and was loaded with seafood. Our server was really fun to interact with and clearly knew her stuff. She made sure our drinks stayed full without being overly obtrusive, which I always appreciate. Alchemy was so good that my partner said he'd be willing to drive down to the Springs just to go there for lunch then drive us back home to Aurora same day. read more

See all

Went for St Patrick's Day because, you know, it's an Irish Pub. Very disappointing. They were completely unprepared. There were only two meal options to choose from. We all got corned beef and cabbage. It was served on a paper plate with literally corned beef (which was tough) and a bit of cabbage. No soda bread, potatoes came out about halfway through the meal with zero seasoning. On a day that you would think they would up there game...it was more like they didn't care at all. read more

Visiting Colorado Springs for work and my coworker recommended that I visit Alchemy. I'm so glad that he recommended them! Several great beer choices on tap. However the LGC dinner was what stole the show. LGC is a Lamb Green Chile the is absolutely amazing. It's so good that I came back two days later to have another go. I wanted to try other things on the menu but had to have more LGC. I guess I will have to come back again to try something else. read more

Alchemy - LGC. Lamb and Green Chili. To die for! - Irish Near Me - Colorado Springs, Colorado

Erin was tbe absolute best. She took care of us more than what she was she was supposed to do. She truly worked her ass off and truly loved every customer and made us feel at home. If you don't give her a raise, you are absolutely insane. She can go anywhere so make sure you keep huh? God boy!!!!! read more

The service was ok and the food was not at all up to par with what I've been told. Some of it was ok and some of it was bad. The main seating area felt cramped. I felt sick after eating the Alchemy Burger. I don't see myself giving it a second chance. read more

Try the appetizer salmon plate! It was delicious and fresh-tasting. We were surprised at how fresh the salmon tasted, Colorado being a land-locked state and us being from California. They smoke the salmon in-house too. It says it has lavender flavor in the description but I did not find the lavender flavor to be too strong. We had the pleasure of sitting next to the executive chef, Jeff (sp?), during our meal. He was happy to give us several food and drink recommendations. I tried the drink (now have forgotten the name) with coconut vodka, cilantro, and sriracha - I thought the flavor combo was so strange hit it was SO good. I really enjoyed the flavor combo. Jeff said that was inspired by a soup with similar flavors. Let me tell ya - it works! We also tried the fish and chips. Fish was good. Chips - undercooked in the middle. Mac and cheese lacked flavor in my opinion, but to be fair, I have had some truly spectacular macaroni and cheese. I prefer a creamy texture; this one was more starchy. I told Jeff my feedback, which he graciously accepted and thanked us for it. We finished our meal by sharing a drink with Jeff, and I found it really special. I felt like a regular even though it was my first time. The waitstaff, bartenders, and Jeff were very personable and I would return if I was in Colorado Springs to be around the people again. read more

See all

Decent food and alright staff. Our waiter was doing double duty but was a super nice guy. We got the special- pork with some delicious sauces, tacos, and kiddos got fries and chicken. The place was loud with lots of people so I didn't feel too awful about my two year old being loud ! read more

OUCH ... I hope I just came on a bad day. But the beer/cheese soup was just average quality, thin, ham and bean soup (very salty) with maybe a shot of beer and a pinch of cheese. The scotch eggs were made with red-wine marinated hard boiled eggs ... and were not at all crispy ... or flavorful. The prices were very high, even for a touristy location in the off season. I will not return. The bar-tender was loud and intrusive ... though very friendly. read more

Absolutely a hole-in-the-wall place and that's a good thing! Loved everything about this small, well decorated place. Makes you feel like you've stepped into an Irish pub in Ireland. The food is sensational! Tried both the lamb green chili and pickle & chick. Both were delicious and the service was friendly! read more

Alchemy - Irish Near Me - Colorado Springs, Colorado