You will find an enormous selection of every category of toys and games and models and dolls and…read morebooks and more at Toys Ahoy. You can complete all your child gift-giving here, and even find some classic favorites for yourself. Proprietor and staff are ever-cheerful and engaging with product knowledge and local lore. Worth the trip from anywhere.

I came here to shop for a gift for a 1 year old. The owner came by and walked me through the toys…read morefor kids and gave me a few recommendations. I went on a whim and bought the items he suggested and they are a huge hit. I will definitely be back!

We are new to the area and shopping for children's gifts has never been this exciting! They offer…read morethe most unique selection of toys I have ever seen. It's one stop shopping for all the little people in your life. Alexandra helped us and has a great eye for fun, chic gifts. She is tremendously helpful finding just the right stuff. With amazing service to match, it doesn't get better than this. Thanks! Kaja

One of my most favorite things about the city. It just says CT when you walk down' 5th avenue and…read moresee the toy soliders at the door. Sure a ferris wheel in Time square is great but this place says Old meets new like no other toy store in America. It has every time you can imagine as well as the new candy store they finished a little over a year ago. One of the few places you can go to get clean bathrooms without a line out the door also. Go to the bottom floor, turn left walk a few feet and THERE YOU GO! Try walking on the huge piano too! ITs great fun.. and this is the toy store that Home Alone was taped in too!

The kind of toy store I loved as a kid. Everything out to try play around with. Every corner…read morecrammed with something you didn't notice last time you were there. The toys can be pricey, especially for toys you could get everywhere but, if your looking for something pretty special, this is a fine place to check out.

I walked in and there were two nasty old women at the front desk. I asked if they could tell me how…read moremuch I had left on a old gift card that I found and they rudely said that I should have written it down. The store still has the same nasty toys that been there for years and a weird old man staring at me in the corner. The staff was cold and rude to me. I do NOT recommend going to this dusty, crusty, and overpriced place.

First and only time shopping was pre Christmas. Got amazing gifts (mostly books), and some…read morehousehold things like bathmats. Loved this store. Will return!!

The rudest, most unprofessional group of people I've had the misfortune of dealing with, not to…read moremention how dirty the place is.

My friend and I were exploring Greenport. We stopped into Goldsmith's. They are a toy store they…read morehad so many toy options. They are known for their choice of rubber ducks. I bought quite a few different rubber ducks for my nieces and nephews, my son, my sisters and some friends. This is a nice toy store!

They sold me a counterfeit Labubu. Didn't think legit stores would do that. The product was no…read morewhere close to being a good fake either and cost more than a real one would be. The clerk looked at me and gave me that "swindled you" smirk. 26 Fed Plaza was notified about them.

Best toy store ever. I go there with my young grandchildren to see train display or by myself just…read moreto look at what's new. I've been there so many times this past week. My granddaughter and I will go in next few for her to pick out her last Christmas present. Service is excellent. I

Ah-mazing! Walking in as an adult, I was lost in childhood. Everything from Lego, Monster Truck,…read moreantique trains and all accessories, children's and adult books, stuffed animals and toys, science DIY's, charm bracelets and dress up clothes, board games and card games ...the list could go on!! Little bit of everything for everyone!

Took my girls to this terrific shop just yesterday, and after a great shopping experience, left…read morewondering why I hadn't found it before. Billed as a "mom and pop" toy shop, it certainly makes one think back to the toy shops of yesteryear for those of us old enough to remember shopping for toys "pre-Internet". A surprisingly strong selection of toys, games and gifts. My daughters are already talking about what they'll pick out "next time".

This is literally the best toy shop I know. The staff is always helpful and cheerful and they are…read morealways well stocked on really well designed toys. Most of the staff at any given time knows all about most of the toys If not all of the toys. Anytime I need to buy a present for someone I can count on the staff to tell me all the good options for all different interests and explain each and every one of them to me. They always have great suggestions, cheerfully take any products back and gift wrap for free. It is a small store but they know their stuff and they do a fantastic job!