Great selection of singles and wax, albeit consistently over market. Decent for tournaments and community events, but I wouldn't recommend selling to them.
I brought in a collection after being told they pay 80% of value. During the appraisal, several cards were misquoted--PSA 10 listed as a 9 value, holos marked as non-holo, near mint cards priced as played. I caught these errors, and while they were corrected, I felt concerned for a less attentive customer or kid that trusts their local card store to have the necessary know-how to accurately price cards and gets undercut.
When I was given a final offer, I accepted under the impression it reflected 80% of their own stated value. I later did the math and saw it was actually 72%. I messaged the owner, who said he "wasn't sure what happened" but offered $20 to make it right. When I asked for the full difference, the response turned curt--he emphasized the deal was done and he'd prefer not to renegotiate.
I appreciated being able to pick up any cards they didn't want to purchase at 80% (which turned out to be over half the accepted cards), but even then, I was passive-aggressively reminded that I'd "already accepted a deal." Both owners came off as dismissive and deflective, which made the whole thing feel less like a misunderstanding and more like a tactic.
Writing this disappoints me. I bought cards on my first visit and wanted to support the shop long-term. But the experience was too awkward, and I won't be returning. read more
