After picking up my car from this place like he asked (he decided to not stand by his work), I took…read morethe car to another garage, and they told me my car needs a new transmission. They showed me the damage that was done internally to the transmission which destroyed the seal. You could literally move the axle on the trans side up and down a 1/4"!!! So, this is now the second transmission this place has destroyed. Place used to have a real good reputation. Be Aware.

Tried and true, can't find a better auto shop in the Hudson valley! Been coming here for years, no…read morescams or shotty jobs just good people, good service, and honest business. Love this place

I was very happy with the service I received recently here. My vehicle needed new brakes and…read morerotors. Their receptionist (I missed her name but she's a sweetheart) was lovely - got me an appointment in a reasonable amount of time. On that day, I was seen on time and my repairs were completed within a couple of hours, along with an estimate for additional work I knew would be needed eventually - not something I even asked to be addressed, but I appreciated that Dallas was thorough in letting me know and giving me that estimate up front. Final cost of my repairs that day was both reasonable and matched the estimate I received before the work started - no funny business, just straightforward and honest service. I would not hesitate to use this business again!

Dallas & staff are very accommodating and reliable! Fair & friendly and the work that they do is…read moreoutstanding! My vehicles do not go anywhere else!

Tony and his team have completely restored my faith in the car service industry--and honestly, in…read morepeople in general! I came in with a screw in my tire needing a plug after a terrible experience at Mavis Discount Tire, where I was told I needed four new tires and that my tire couldn't even be repaired. Unfortunately, that's the kind of experience I've come to expect as a woman going in for car service alone. This morning was the complete opposite. I brought my car to Tony, and it was on the lift right at 8:00 AM and finished by 8:26 AM. Turns out I needed two plugs, and Tony was honest and straightforward--he let me know my tires are about halfway through their life and suggested considering replacements toward the end of the summer. No pressure, just facts. And then the best part--Tony insisted the repair was on the house. It honestly felt like he knew I needed a positive experience this week. It completely turned my day around. I will never go anywhere else. Thank you so much, Tony and team! As for the review from Rick S below, that's nonsense, when I called I was told very clearly that they open at 7 but techs start at 8. Sounds like this guy has selective hearing! If everyone is raving about the place maybe you're the problem sir, Mavis might be a better option for you.

Everyone raves about this place so I called mid week to make appointment for inspection and oil…read morechange for following Saturday guy on the phone says we open at 7:00 am. I show up Saturday at 7:00 am 1st customer this guy tells me his mechanics starts at eight I go for coffee for about an hour I come back my car is where I left it they're working on someone else's car. Why would this clown tell me when I called for maintenance that "We open at 7:00 what he didn't tell me is We open at 7:00 but we don't do mechanic work till 8:00 took my car and left Another overrated Goshen Business! Thanks Tony!

Simply the best. I recommend Thalmann's to everyone…read more Chris Karson Hurleyville , NY

Troy is so knowledgeable and helpful! Very efficient and save myself time and money. Love this…read morecompany

Very good service, straight forward and no BS Bringing my…read morevehicle back for some maintenance.

How can I start? This mechanic is AMAZING.. I was having a serious noise in my car for over 2…read moremonths. I took my car here they looked at it told me what the problem was and they assured me they can get it fixed. Well...... it only took ONE day(needed parts to be ordered)and the problem was resolved!!!! I know looking for a mechanic is like looking for a doctor you want to make sure you're going to someone who knows what they're doing. Thank God I found this place!!! Would recommend to anyone looking for a trustworthy reliable mechanic.

Fast, Honest and fair prices . What more do you need from an Auto Repair Shop ? I've been coming…read morehere for years and have always been treated right. You will too

Needed my new headlight to be installed and an inspection, called said they could do it right away…read more Total came out to only $50!!! Great service great price!!!!

Tom is hands down the best mechanic I've ever dealt with. He's honest, straightforward, and…read moreactually takes the time to explain what's going on with your car in a way you can understand: no upselling, no nonsense, just real, honest work. You can tell he takes pride in his work and genuinely cares about his customers. It's rare these days to find someone you can fully trust with your car, but with Tom, I know I'm in good hands. I won't go anywhere else.

My car was overdue for annual inspection and Tommy went out of his way to get it done immediately…read more Easy transaction and I would absolutely choose this business for any service or car repair.

A year later and I most certainly needed some work done and this shop delivered a quality…read moreexperience. My SUV suspension just "felt off" and the techs at this shop discovered one of my sway bar links were completely broken. Don't ask me what that is but Good Lord they were able to fix me right up pronto. Thankfully I didn't need to leave my car her for 3 weeks like many mechanics ask you to do, well not exactly 3 weeks but they tend to take longer than a day at times. This team had me fixed up same day. The mechanic also told me my brakes were pretty worn out but that I could go a little longer before replacing them to save some money and get the most from my current brakes (rear). I value honesty and fair prices which in turn gets my respect & loyalty so the fact the mechanic told me my brakes were wearing out but he didn't want to take my money (yet) when I could get more life out of the brakes I currently have really is amazing. I was super thankful for the honest assessment of my brakes and opted to change them now rather than later. Besides I don't drive much so the brakes I had were probably last replaced about five years ago so from years of weather my rotors certainly looked bad, at least to an amateur like me because I'm certainly no mechanic. Overall I am super happy to have found this place and am committed to being a loyal customer for as long as I live in the Goshen area. If I eventually get a brand new car sadly the team here won't see me for a long time until that new car ages but I'd still recommend them in a heart beat. For now we will have a lasting business relationship for the next few years till my current SUV dies on me, hopefully not too soon under the care of these auto experts. Thank you Goshen Automotive team!

Needed a jump after calling several places only to be given outrageous quotes and long wait times,…read moreI called Goshen Automotive. They cane right out and took care of my issue. Went to the shop for them to follow up. Very friendly and the cost of the follow up and jump were much less then the original quotes I got for just a jump. Like hundreds less