Cancel

Open app

Search

Shermans Service Center

3.2 (15 reviews)
Closed • Closed

Services - Shermans Service Center

Routine automotive maintenance

Shermans Service Center Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Shermans Service Center

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Rats nest in the bathroom

The price was good and quality was okay ish, they don't work on anything custom, they don't know how to drive stick here either so if you have a manual don't bring it and the place is disgusting, if your a woman I feel bad if you have to use the bathroom there was a rats nest that's been there forever.

Rotors that were supposedly replaced at Sherman's Service Center,,

See all

9 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Ron C.
24
16
0

2 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 1
Love this 1
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

12 years ago

Best, most reliable shop in Sullivan County. I took my cars here through high school and now that I live out west I wish I still could.

Helpful 3
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 4
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Shermans Service Center

Review Highlights - Shermans Service Center

“Honest, friendly and fantastic customer service!”

Mentioned in 2 reviews

Read more highlights

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Tires 142 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Danny's Complete Auto Repair - DANNY'S COMPLETE AUTO REPAIR....

Danny's Complete Auto Repair

(7 reviews)

I want to warn everyone that these mechanics are thieves and everyone should steer clear of them…read more They lie about time frames and they make up an issue that will get them the most money. They are money hungry and go back on their word and everything they say. Not to mention they also commit insurance fraud and they encourage their customers to do the same. If you're looking for an actual mechanic I suggest going to find a different one.

If i wouldnt have to guve this place any stars i woukd guve 0. Its run by a couple of thieves ..i…read moretook my 2017 there as ibwas getting transmission errors on my car ..I was told that my transmission needed to be replaced and to buy an auto insurance policy for it and come back on a month nd it was fine to drive until then..I stupidly listened to them whej I called a mknth later they told me they would take the car for a few weeks and file with the insurance and fux my car within a few weeks..originally they had told me it wud be 2 days ..who the heck guves uo thier car for 2 weeks..th year is 2025 we don't wait 2 weeks for car reoairs..I was furious and took my car to the Honda dealer..they told me it wasn't the transmission it was the torque converter and if I continued driving my car it can break down at any point..theu repaired the car on 1 business day and I was on my way again..they told me it was super dangerous to drive the way it was and my wife had gotten stuck numerous times in 95 degree heat because of thwm..they wud have replaced the wrong part and it akk wud have been for nothing. Stay away from them they are liars and thieves

J & S Auto Repr

J & S Auto Repr

(4 reviews)

Him being honest he's had my Jeep for a good 3 weeks he would rather cater to the summer people…read morethan the people that support him in the winter months probably still in the same spot it's been in for the last 3 weeks

If i could give this place 0 stars i would. FIRST OFF i should have known off the jump that Joe,…read morethe owner is a very shady business man. Not only was i told to purchase today or he was taking it on a trip the next day but he was very coniving... promised me that he would fix the ac, the heated seat, the trunk the tail light and head light,heater fan ect.... when he came back. So me being a female i pirchased the car w a credit card signed n left.. about 5 days later i went to the shop after the holiday weekend to get the paperwork so i can go to DMV as to this part of purchase is not done there. After going to dmv they advised me i couldnt make the transaction as to the dealer signes in wrong spot. So i drive all the way back to his shop he re signs n i ask do u have the bill of sale for me incase they ask to see it ect.. he advises me just hurry go go go .. u dont need it becsuse im a dealer.. so im already rushing due to the chance if not completeing the tranaction before DMV closes.. so long story.. everything went fine at dmv.. i was happy i could drive the car ect.. SOO I REMIND U I GOT NO PAPERWORK FROM J AND S AUTO no bill of sale no contract nothing but my credit card signature reciept that states i brought a headache... i follow up w joe about the promises and i got put off day after dsy week after week.. In about 2 wks after my purchase i came to realize that there was nooo oil in the vehicle.. i advised him and said u said the oil chamge was done bybyour shop correct he says yes i said who did it he says he did i said ok well there is not one drop of oil, antifrreeze in the car so something is wrong.. he says fill it n any problems bring it to the shop.. so i drive the car anither 700 miles or so n i check the oil its down almost 3 quarts. I bring csr to him at this point i want my money back not happy nothing was done as promised n now this issue.. so after joe and his son inspected for possible gasket leaks ect.. he says i see nothing its dry ect... soo he advises me to drive it another week check the oil kesp track of miles ect.. so i go to nyc and back then to albany n back and drove locally .. i check the oil and im down another 2 quarts or so.. i call Joe up and let him know he says fill it and drive it about 1000 miles let me know what goes on.. so THIS BULLSHIT goes on and on for weeks almost 2 months im told drive it replace oil ect.. soo now im beyond furious.. i bring the car to him n i tell him i dont want the car i want my money he tells me no.. sooo i call my credit card compNy advised them what went on they put a freeze n investigstion on his acct until more detail is gathered.. so after being notified from my credit card comoany they advise me that i signed a bike of sale w the terms sale is final no warantee and the purchase amount was broken down with bullshit lies such as i purchased new set of additional tires i paid dmv fees ect.. im like whatttttt?? I went to dmv i did the paper work.. and THE KICKER IS I NEVER SIGNED IT NEVER SEEN THIS PAPER BEFORE AND AFTER LOOKING AT SIGNATURE NOT ONLY WAS I 100% SURE I DIDNT SIGN IT NOT MY SIGNATURE BUT HE forged my signature n Spelled my name wrong..How funny is that..So after calling n filing a complaint w the state police ect.. he gets a lawyer refuses hand annaylis ect... i give up because at this point im gonna have hust as much money innvested with court as i do the car..So as u know i have went to the extend of filing complaints w fraud thru dmv and fraud the NYS taxation and finace and i file complaints w bbb n the town of fallsburg.. Please im telling u this business is junk Dishonest and not trust worthy.. Ifnhes done all this to me im sure after 2o yrs in business hes done this to more peopke tham just me!!! I was lucky enough to have issues w the csr right away but how many peopke paid w credit card n never got bill of sale ect.. and he made out with all the fees and tax money.. SHADY BUSINESS.. if u decide to go here MAKE SURE EVERYTHING IS IN WRITTING AND U HAVE COOIES IF IT ALLLLLLL.... I am not done with this situation but i promise that he will pay in the long run. Karma will bite him and i pray that anyone reading this doesnt fall into the trap i did!!! MUST have taken advantage of me because i was a female n thought he could push over well he did but... ill get satisfaction here soon..... what goes around comes around.. Be aware. FRAUDULENT COMPANY HE FORGES YOUR NAME TO HIDDEN DOCUMENTS TO AVOID having to follow thru w the agreements n warantees...and he scams the state on oaying taxes after he charges you for them!!!!

Countryside Polaris - Bobcat-mini-track-loaders

Countryside Polaris

(10 reviews)

I was surprised to see some of the poor reviews when I got to Yelp to leave this feedback. My wife…read moreand I purchased a vehicle over the weekend at M&M and we could not have been more pleased with our experience. In reading the reviews that were negative, it seemed that some had not even dealt with M&M and others did not bring their issues to the company, they just left negative reviews without giving them a chance to make it right. I do not feel this to be fair or an indication of a good customer. I started and ran retail companies, and no matter how hard I would try, my employees and I would make mistakes daily and all I could do was work my hardest to make whatever the problem was right. We also received a pretty cheesy promotion in the mail from M&M. It promised a gift, which we got (very inexpensive smart watches). But once you get to Liberty, I can understand the challenge they have in getting customers to drive to a small town, passing numerous larger dealerships, with bigger signs, and more modern buildings, to come to them. I still am not sure what moved me to visit them, I know that the vast majority of promotions are gimmicks, but it was a beautiful day and the drive was pleasant. We ended up purchasing a used Subaru from them. We got there at 2:00PM on Saturday and walked out at 7:20PM with our new vehicle. For me, that was about average for a large purchase. My wife and I present a unique challenge for financers because of our previous history and what we do for work now, but we were able get a monthly payment we could afford, at an interest rate below 11%, with no money down. I realize that this may not be possible for everyone, but I felt that they really tried to help us out. I didn't feel like a number, I felt like a friend through the entire process. This is my experience, it doesn't mean it will be yours. I attempt to be kind and courteous to those I deal with. I try to be understanding of how difficult it can be to make people happy, especially in a culture where few even no where to look for happiness. However it is my belief that the employees at M&M, and their owner are honest, genuine, and do care about the work they do.

M&M can sell cars/trucks (great experience) but its just not worth it to buy from them. This was my…read moresecond and last negative experience. I had previously purchased a Ford Expedition King Ranch and have been happy with the vehicle. Recently I had an issue with the transmission while using 4-wheel drive. I had the vehicle towed to M&M 2 weeks ago on a Sunday and was told the vehicle would be looked at on Mon or Tues. I drove by on Wed and was told they hadn't gotten to it and would get to it before end of week. I came back on Friday and was told customer appointments come first. I asked to make an appointment and was told by the Service Manager that it wasn't worth it because they would get to it the following Monday. I came by the following Tues and the Service Manager gave me a bunch of bs again. At that moment I knew the vehicle would just sit there so I made an appointment at REA Ford and on Friday the 13th with the vehicle still sitting in the same location where it was dropped off 2 weeks prior, I had the vehicle towed to REA Ford and they immediately handled it. M&M Service dept is over matched and not honest with their customers. I wasn't asking to be put in front of the line, I was looking for them to tell me when my vehicle would be serviced but this was too difficult for them to gauge. The service manager is challenged regarding time management and setting customer expectations. Making false statements and having no idea how to manage customer schedules is a recipe for disaster. I'm only a few miles away and want to support my local economy but I'm tired with such shoddy service at M&M.

Shermans Service Center - tires - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...