This was my first time eating at the restaurant and have to say I highly recommend this restaurant. The hospitality from Nik the owner and his staff was outstanding. The food was amazing at the atmosphere was excellent. Thank you again for helping my family out during this time of adversity. Domenic M. Guiliano read more

I am updating my 5 star glowing review from March 6, 2017 to a 1 star on October 4, 2026. In today's time, I ordered a mozzarella and ricotta calzone. Two new pictures for reference. It was very overcooked for my liking. They gave plenty of ricotta like I had asked but barely any mozzarella. I scooped up the mozzarella on my fork to show how little. The waitress from a distance when cleaning another table asked us how we liked the food. When I mentioned the lack of cheese to the waitress, she had an attitude and rudely answered me back from a distance where other customers definitely could hear it. She made no effort to fix it and walked away. A shame it is not the same anymore. Nine years ago, I had left a review on Yelp that 2 Brothers has the BEST calzones I have ever tasted. It was my most favorite calzone place. In recent years, it was already changing. Today made me never want to return. Others can look at these pictures to reach their own opinion. The calzones are no longer like the original review picture here that is cooked perfectly with loads of delicious cheese. read more

See all

Really good pizza. However, I have never paid so much for a small cheese pizza in my life. their website said a small cheese is $8 and extra cheese $2. Fair. Complete market price. I get there and they say $21. The screen shows $14.50 for the small cheese extra cheese and then a N/A bev fee $ 4.50. I said I didn't get a beverage. They said yeah I know we have to manually add a line for the extra cheese charge. So they charged me $21 instead of $10. For a small cheese pizza with extra cheese. Very strange experience. But I guess that's inflation for ya read more

2 Brothers Pizza & Pub - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Salem, Connecticut

Two Brothers Pizza absolutely nailed it. I ordered the 2 Brothers Special Pizza, and it was everything I remember growing up in Connecticut. Now living in Atlanta, this is the pizza that takes me right back to my childhood. Perfect crust, fresh ingredients, and an amazing combination of pepperoni, mushroom, onion, green pepper, sausage, hamburger, and mozzarella. Truly a pleasure from the first bite to the last. I'll definitely be back. read more

We've been wanting to try this place for a while & finally stopped by last night. We were greeted quickly and seated. Our waitress was very nice. The food and drink menu is very expansive making sure to make anyone happy. We enjoyed Cajun wings and a meat lovers pizza. We will be back. read more

2 Brothers Pizza & Pub - Cajun wings - Pizza Near Me - Salem, Connecticut

See all

They claim vets this and vets that but actually treat vets like trash. I went to have a bowl of Gumbo. I thought it was awful. I wanted to pay and leave and go somewhere else to eat. The old lady (mother) came out from the kitchen starting fighting with me, then banned me for not liking her sad excuse of gumbo. What a joke. Never seen anything like it before in my life. Place is a shame. Keep an eye out for nefarious activities. read more

2/10 food no flavor or seasoning and ridiculous prices. $10 for a bowl of clam chowder with no flavor not even salt and pepper. I feel their over pricing does not match the quality of their food. Save your money plum tomato across the street has better tasting food and your paying the same read more

2 Brothers Pizza & Pub - Clam chowder - Pizza Near Me - Salem, Connecticut

Had the Blue Ribbon sandwich for lunch. Delicious grilled chicken breast on a ciabatta roll with bacon, lettuce & tomato topped with mayo, BBQ sauce & cheddar cheese. Such a delicious tasty sandwich that I will definitely order again. Their French fries were the best too! read more

Did you grow up in the 80's and 90's eating Pizza Hut's pan pizza with the melty cheese, soft on the inside but crunchy and buttery on the outside dough, and those bacon-like crispy pepperoni on top? I can just see some ninja turtles scarfing it down. This pizza will transport you back to those days! A great little joint in Salem's "Four Corners" now a rotary so it has no corners, haha. This small was a little pricey but worth every penny. They have a bar, booths, and a little take out area. Stop by for lunch or dinner, some drinks with friends, a kids birthday party, or grab your meal to go. This little restaurant feels homey and inviting. They have a full menu with some vegetarian and vegan options too. Maybe in the future they'll add plant-based cheese to the menu, fingers crossed! It's no joke, this is some seriously good pizza and you need to go out and try it now! read more

2 Brothers Pizza & Pub - Pan pizza - Pizza Near Me - Salem, Connecticut

Still one of my all time favorites! 14 beers on tap and I know the owner is a beer aficionado! So it's tasty stuff. Usually has Fix Farm beers on tap and the food is delicious! If you haven't had them I highly recommend the buffalo chicken nachos, and all the salads are huge. Two thumbs up! read more

Was out early on a snowy day to do stuff. Was getting hungry and we knew right where to go and get a warm greeting and a hearty,tasty lunch on a cold winter day. Soup and a meatball grinder and know better place to get a beef gyro .Best ever and always service with a smile. read more

We stopped in for a bite after taking my mom, who is wheelchair bound, to the docs a couple of doors down. We heard from Dr. Giordano's office that the hot dogs (chili dogs) were excellent. The person who greeted us was very pleasant and allowed us to sit at a 6 top due to my moms inability to get in and out of the chair. I found this to be super respectful of our elderly and would encourage the elderly to come here. The chili dogs were excellent and the fries complimented the dish. These were some of the best fries I have had in a while. I rarely would comment on this, but whatever the are doing, don't stop. Again, the waitress/ server was super helpful and pleasant. She focused on my mom which I appreciated as it are her and us feel welcome. Food: excellent 5 stars Ambience: Comforting and warm 4 stars Prices: 5 stars Friendly staff: 5 stars Cleanliness: 5 stars A must stop if only for the hot dogs but the menu was quite full with tons of options. read more

2 Brothers Pizza & Pub - Pizza Near Me - Salem, Connecticut

Good beer selection and friendly staff, but the food just is never consistent. I'm torn because it's a local business and the owner does a great job with veterans and supporting other local businesses, but it continues to miss the mark for us. We've been going here for a few years now and the food is always hit or miss. Unfortunately of the 15-20 times we've visited, we've had to send the food back 3-4 times, and some other times we were just polite and didn't send it back, quickly getting out of there and heading home. It's greek pizza, so if that's your thing they have some good options. I'm not a fan of it, so I don't order it. My wife has ordered the Big Mac pizza and was a huge fan of it. I've tried the pasta dishes and the pasta has been overcooked. The wings are normally a safe bet, but the last time I got them they were undercooked and not crispy. The Rueben is usually a good one to get, but sometimes the bread is way too mushy and not toasted enough. The innkeeper sandwich was a fan favorite and I liked that. The fries are awesome and have always been great. We've done takeout a lot from here as well, usually grabbing a few grinders. Again, depending on who is making it will depend what you get. I'd say 4/5 times it's pretty good. The menu seems like it should be overhauled because they offer a lot of different dishes-I'm just curious what items they consistently sell and which should be removed. The bar is always a treat and welcome, and where we prefer to sit. I can't say enough great things about the bartenders we've met. They are often overworked but they do a great job taking care of us and trying to handle the other customers if other waitresses aren't staffed. I wish they'd have music playing-it's always so quiet in there. We're going to take a pause from this place and explore some other options. It's just too inconsistent with subpar food. If you want to grab a drink and that's it...maybe a side of fries, then have at it. read more

Ok ok ok I GET IT! There are 500 pizza places in the area but wait just a second and hear me out..... We arrived 20+ deep on a Tuesday at 630/7pm and were greeted by a man that called himself "The Greek Freak". He was welcoming and very friendly. The service was great. They cleared out some booths close by and quickly got to work with our orders. The food took no time at all to hit the tables. Everyone's order was accurate, hot, and fresh. I got the Eggplant grinder and you may think that you know how this thing was going to taste (believe me, you can rarely teach an old dog new tricks) but holy Shih Tzu! OLD DOG yes, but doing a nollie flip like a skateboard sequel to "Air Bud" or something!!! The eggplant was seasoned and breaded to per-fect-ion. It was crispy hot and there was plenty of melted cheese and sauce. My only regret was to not know these details in advance and order one for now and one for tomorrow's lunch. Sadly we had to pay and hit the road. I loved the vibe of the place. Very old school pizza place with a more traditional menu but when I spoke to everyone in the group they had nothing but compliments to the staff for making our impromptu pit stop turn into a regular dinner spot for many more nights to come!! read more

2 Brothers Pizza & Pub - Read my full review. This is "Air Bud 2024" starring Dustin Dollin, Tony Hawk, and Benji would be in food form. - Pizza Near Me - Salem, Connecticut

Nick and his family are amazing people Highly recommended. Food is awesome . Definitely Veteran Friendly. Great Atmosphere. read more

2 Brothers Pizza & Pub - Soup and Salad - Pizza Near Me - Salem, Connecticut

See all

First time. Very wonderful Hawaiian pizza I ordered. The staff, AMAZING! Extremely nice. Anytime in the area again, will be back!

Decided to stop in for a drink and appetizers since we have driven by the place so many times and never tried it out. We both were very happy with the ambiance service and as far as food we shared the nachos with chili and loved the. Unfortunately I forgot to get a picture but I will next time. The plate was enough for three people. It was so big we didn't even finish it. The bar is very small and only seats eight maybe ten but it is very comfortable. They have a large menu and we are looking forward to going back to try something other than an appetizer. read more

2 Brothers Pizza & Pub - 2023 menu - Pizza Near Me - Salem, Connecticut

See all

What a WONDERFUL surprise! We drove an hour from home to bring our little pooch to Salem Valley Veterinary Clinic (well worth the drive), and found ourselves with an hour to kill & growling tummies. Our vet recommended 2 Brothers and what a Top-Notch place that is. I wish I'd caught the waitresses name, she said she's been there a while... she was a terrific waitress! Attentive without being intrusive, friendly and warm, and she had terrific recommendations! We had a Greek lemon chicken and rice soup that was delicious (no photo, sorry). My husband couldn't decide and ordered both a burger and a Reuben (which in on its way home with us), and I had the fried seafood platter. The seafood was super fresh! It was perfectly cooked and the batter was perfectly light. It was so fresh and lightly fried, I don't even feel "bad" or guilty , which is a plus! My cole slaw was delicious and even the fries were too. If you're lucky enough to live close to this restaurant, you should definitely give it a try! If it were closer to us, I'm sure we'd be regulars! read more

See all

Really like coming here when we visit CT. Excellent craft beers and pizza, this time we had potato skins and meatballs, and could not be happier with them. I also had the craft stout, and was very pleased with that. They also have an array of desserts (we had the peanut butter blitz! Yum!) and I doubt you can go wrong with any of them. We try to eat here every time we visit, and there's no doubt we'll continue that habit. We'll be back. read more

Great pizza! Service was good and the chicken bites were a good warm up. Would def do it again read more

2 Brothers Pizza & Pub - Chicken cordon bleu bites - Pizza Near Me - Salem, Connecticut

See all

great food great drinks and a wonderful staff and owner just a random stop on a out of state road trip and looking forward to returning

I stopped by 2 Brothers Pizza and Pub on my way home on a work trip. It turned out to be an excellent lunch option. First of all it reminded me of a regional Cheers, a bunch of regulars at the bar and everyone knew each other. I was waiting for Sam to walk out, maybe Norm. The server was very friendly and knew everyone. While the menu was fairly diverse, I went with the roast beef on the pretzel bun, which was excellent. Nice toasted bun and great roast beef. There was a good beer list including Fox Farm, which is right up the road. I would most definitely come back to the 2 Brothers, what a cool local dive. read more

Food fantastic the workers are very good also, my dad's friends with owner of the business of the business so extra free fries overall very good place very clean and staff very well, mannered read more

Love this place. Like the name says, it's owned by 2 brothers. The menu has a ton of choices - I've had a burger there - medium rare, eggplant grinder, Chicken sandwich and Nor'easter roast beef sandwich - best sandwiches around, pizza, and nachos - all delicious. My wife has had a personal pizza there, clam strips, pasta and salads and loved it all. Everyday there are specials and the desserts will blow your mind. And we're both foodies that like to eat out a lot. The beer list is amazing and always has 2 local Fox Farm beers on the list. And there's a full bar, with about 8 seats, 3 high tops and 2 booths in the bar area. And more seating on two sides of the restaurant. You can tell these folks are connected to the community by featuring local fundraisers to help someone in need. We get here every week! read more

2 Brothers Pizza & Pub - Get on the list for the beer mug club. - Pizza Near Me - Salem, Connecticut

While at camp in Salem, we occasionally order from two brothers. Their pizzas are fantastic and their grinders are excellent.

Excellent service from Missy . The restaurant was SO busy and she did such a great job serving and making drinks all by herself. The pizza was so different from any pizza in the area and it was delicious!!! read more

2 Brothers Pizza & Pub - Meat lovers no hamburger add fresh garlic. Delicious!!! Amazing crust - Pizza Near Me - Salem, Connecticut

Was just looking for a simple great meal and a good beer. We have been to 2 Brothers before and knew they wouldn't dissappoint. Opted for burgers and a beer, perfectly on point read more

Pizza review. Driven by this place a hundred times but never noticed it driving by. It blends in, at one of those dinky strip malls, on the side of the road near a traffic circle. Beachgoers get off the highway but head south at that traffic circle and most likely don't see it there either, so I'm going to guess all the business comes from the locals, and based on the reviews Ive seen, many seem to appreciate the place for its beer selection. If you check out the pics section for this place, the only menu pics you find are the drink menus. Sooo... the beer drinkers seem impressed! But I drink two beers a year, so I am not going to be enticed by mere booze. If you got PIZZA in your name, you gotta bring the goods. Some relatives were staying at a nearby campground and when we visited they suggested the place. They were fans, I said I'd buy, and forty five bucks later we had two pizza's. The small was known as the Mediterranean Pizza. which was tomato, Spinach, Fresh Garlic, Feta Cheese, Mozzarella. Sounds ok, was a change of pace. But the crust lacked any crunch, and was just kinda...there. Same with the large which had hamburg, mushroom, peppers and onions. Sauce was something you would get at any number of CT pizza houses, did the job, but nothing to write home about. Notched it up another star for the mozzarella on board, it did have good cheese on it. Same crust issues were going on, barely made a support for the toppings, the whole slice just kinda sogging out. I suppose you could blame it on the topping selection which helped in greasing it out, but things would improve with a few more minutes in a pizza oven. Limp pizza? Nayyyyy. Notched it up another star for their mozzarella, it did have good cheese on it. Crew was friendly. Always a plus. There are a zillion pizza places in CT, and there are a bunch of really good ones, this wouldnt be my first choice, but if its any consolation, Ive had worse. Better than a Domino's, ( where I'd rather eat the box). ;) Better luck next time!! read more

I joined my parents for a visit here, and the staff was exceptional. They remember their repeat customers. Everyone was friendly and quick without making us feel rushed. The food was also great! A small salad is actually pretty big. And there is a gluten free crust option for pizza. My dad is in a wheelchair, and while they don't have automatic doors, the doors are wide enough that his elbows didn't bump the frame. The staff was accomodating. Wonderful experience! read more

First visit even though we live just down the road. Won't be our last. Husband had a personal size pizza and I had the nightly dinner special. Both excellent and took home leftovers. Place packed when we left. Husband loved the local beer they poured and we stopped at the brewery down the road to pick up a growler on the way home! Nice seeing local businesses doing well and supporting each other. read more

2 Brothers Pizza & Pub - Today's special...chipotle chicken tortellini - Pizza Near Me - Salem, Connecticut

See all

I saw the specials listed for today on Facebook. There was a sandwich I believe it was called the Bullseye. It had a 6 oz steak on ciabatta roll with carmelized onions, and Gorgonzola cheese. It tasted heavenly!! The steak was cooked to my liking, the onions were perfect and the cheese topped it off very well. It was listed as a special, but I hope they keep it on the menu. I will be going there very soon and I hope this is still on the menu read more

The food is delicious !! We have ordered almost everything off the menu in the last four years, we have resided in Salem. The service is always with a smile, warm and welcoming staff in every area of the restaurant!! You can take out or eat in. Sitting areas as well as a bar, make it great if you want to stop in and have a drink before heading home, or bring the family and enjoy the cozy spaces to have a bite to eat. Recommend anyone looking for some awesome pizza (kids favorite!) to be sure and stop in. You may find yourself there a lot more in the future. read more

This is definitely not just your standard pizza place. The seafood here is absolutely, positively amazing! If you order the fish and chips you'll see what I mean. Super crispy outside but moist and tender inside, really an excellent batter which I venture to say has beer in it, and so flavorful! Everyone in our party was just really impressed with the food and the service. Another star dish was the stuffed sole, cooked perfectly and generous amounts of crab stuffed inside. The marinara sauce on the pasta that came on the side was also really very good, I'm just still in shock at how perfect everything tasted, you know how hard it is to find a place like that only to realize it's hundreds of miles away from where you live? *sigh* They have several craft beers available on draft and bottle/cans, and if there's something you're not sure about on draft, they let you sample first before committing to something you wont like. I found the prices for beer to be extremely reasonable starting out at $3. I would go out of my way to come back the next time I visit Connecticut, it's worth it. read more

See all

Love the food, Love the booze, love the people and love the 2 Brothers who own/operate it. I always feel so welcomed when I come here. The food is always hot and made to order. I've had some really amazing pizzas here. If you're ever in the area, stop in and give it a shot. You won't be disappointed. read more

Ordered pizza from here hoping for some amazing pizza. Terrible. I Never went back. It's too bad since I was hoping for a good pizza joint for my craving pizza nights close to home. read more

So we entered into a pretty busy restaurant, the waitress was extremely nice and asked us how many. We said 4 adults 3 kids. She said about 20 minutes, no problem willing to wait. I don't know if it was the kids or the fact that we were people of color but the boss/manager comes up to us, with this energy that was that of someone who didn't want us in the restaurant. He comes up to us the wait is 45 minutes. He was trying to get us out of the restaurant and not trying to keep us there at all. I feel bad for the servers that lost out on a tip, but there manager likes to judge a book by its cover. If you want to support a man who is rude and perhaps racist eat at Brothers. read more

Went for the first time tonight, ordered fried mozzarella they were really good! Also ordered loaded baked potato skins those were okay. Got an extra cheese pizza it was so good!! All the food was excellent! & you know what was even better?! A pizza place with cocktails! But we both ordered a Long Island iced tea, it didn't taste like there was barely any alcohol in it... LIT is always our go to drink but I don't know if I would order a cocktail from there next time, I will definitely be back though. The waitress barely checked on us though but it's a pizza place ‍ she seemed overwhelmed and super busy it was a Wednesday afternoon. (I couldn't picture it on a Friday night) The hostess checked on us though, took our dishes, got us boxes, brought us the bill, etc. But the food was great, I definitely recommend it, still giving it 5 stars, maybe the drinks will be better next time! read more

Great Food, Outstanding Service, Fun place to be home town feel! Would recommend this place

Prices posted online are not current. So expect to pay 15-30% more. Prices are super expensive compared to the local competitors. I'm not averse to paying higher prices for quality and great tasting food. This place is average at best, especially the pizza. I ordered a small pan pizza with pepperoni which cost over $16.00... i wouldn't complain too much if it tasted good - it didn't. Th same pizza is between 9-$12 elsewhere. FOOL ME ONCE ONLY as I am never going back. read more

2 Brothers Pizza & Pub - Pepperoni Pizza. If it looks good, that is all it is as it doesn't taste great - Pizza Near Me - Salem, Connecticut

We arrived at the shore just as a tropical storm hit the area. After driving around downed trees and power lines to find a place open for dinner, we found 2 Brothers. They were filled to capacity, but we waited just a short while for a table. Although the staff was surprised with such a busy Tuesday night, they clearly worked together to take care of their customers dining in and carrying out. We chose pasta dishes and were not disappointed with the flavor or generous portion size. Spaghetti with two gigantic tasty meatballs and full-flavored sauce was more than enough for dinner and lunch the next day. Likewise with the cheese stuffed rigatoni special with chicken, sausage and veggies. This place is definitely on our list of places to return when we're back in the area. read more