I wanted to like this location, but the overall experience was disappointing. The layout of the shop is poorly designed. The seating area blocks customers from getting to the self-serve frozen yogurt machines in the back, creating a bottleneck where people end up bumping into each other and even arguing over who can get through. There simply isn't enough space, and the placement of the chairs makes the flow of the store frustrating. The frozen yogurt itself was also underwhelming. Compared to other frozen yogurt shops in the area, the quality wasn't as good, and the topping selection was very basic with limited variety. There are several nearby competitors that offer better flavors, fresher toppings, and a much more enjoyable overall experience. Unfortunately, I don't see myself returning to this location. read more

Had a great time here with family. Lots of selections with frozen yogurt and toppings but is 87 cents an ounce so it could be expensive if you get a lot. Very delicious overall. read more

16 Handles - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

If you're looking for a place to avoid the fancy froyo mayhem, this is it! No frills, froyo how it used to be. It's sort of pricey but I guess that's the market rate in the city. Was in the area so I came twice in a week. Two downsides were that the tables were a bit dirty and the staff are supposed to do the sampler cups for you. I liked all their flavors. The hot honey was yummy but it had no kick, only honey. read more

16 Handles - Froyo - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

See all

I love froyo and self-serve is so nostalgic to me. To be honest I'm not sure what the pricing was but my cup ended up being around $10. I got: - cookies and cream flavor - tart flavor - strawberry bubbles - cheesecake bites - strawberries It hit the spot for sure and was a nice sweet treat. read more

16 Handles - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

Not the best frozen yogurt but not the worst! Pretty good topping selection too. Almost every time I've gone some of the machines are down, but overall place is clean and ice cream is good! I like the long booth to sit in and service has always been very nice. read more

16 Handles - Frozen Yogurt - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

Nice little selection, they have a new flavor every month. I tried the pineapple vanilla flavor and it was great. I also wanted to try the oatmilk chocolate but the machine was having issues. The girls working there were helpful but you can tell they're over it lmao! read more

16 Handles - Options - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

Good variety of flavors (ice cream, froyo, sorbet, and oatmilk froyo), and love that all the nutrition information is displayed for each flavor. Good choice of toppings (brownies, cookies, fruit, etc.). The workers were also polite and kept the toppings counters clean every second they had. read more

See all

I used to come here all the time and I don't know what happened! It's either about to go out of business or the franchise owner stopped caring. I've visited twice in the last couple of weeks. The first time, there were 3 employees who were sitting down, 10 handles that were even lit up, though not all of those worked. The floor was dirty with trash and waffle cone fragments. Again, there were 3 employees who were doing next to nothing. The second visit was slightly better, with 11 handles lit up. One flavor that was lit up didn't work (birthday cake). There was one employee who was friendly and attentive. The store was clean, but again the experience was meh. The toppings do not look appetizing at all. This location either needs to step it up or close! I can't believe that corporate turns a blind eye to a shop this poorly functioning. read more

I love frozen yogurt. Haven't been to one in NYC in a very long time. Thought of it today and walked to this one. They sold out on the tart flavor. I told the worker and she didn't refill the station. Very disappointed. read more

I want this place to be better because it could be a refreshing, healthy treat in walking distance from where I work. But it's just not. The place smells powerfully of sanitizer. The original tart flavor is so thin and not at all creamy. Plus, it always gives me a brain freeze. The walnuts in syrup are stale. The fruit looks old and moldy. The worst part is, it's very expensive for all of this mediocrity. Employees are generally young and nice, but the product leaves a lot to be desired. read more

Really don't go here. The place is badly maintained and a lot of the handles and flavors didn't work. For the few machines that did work, the froyo came out with an inconsistent texture. What's worse is that we watched multiple customers and kids coming in, getting their toppings and touching the topping spoons with their own froyo. The toppings counter was a mess and all mixed up. Pretty bad waste of money. Would highly recommend not going here, there are better options. read more

16 handles is just alright. I tried them in two locations but the one in Williamsburg didn't have as good of a review as this one so I gave it a second shot. Since last time I spent $12 I wanted to spend a little less so I only tried peanut butter, vanilla and Nutella. It still ended up being around $9 which would have been double this size if I went to Baskin Robbins. Anyway the vanilla was okay. The peanut butter didn't taste very much like peanut butter to me. The Nutella didn't either but it wasn't bad. None of it was bad but it just wasn't fulfilling and was pretty mediocre. I wish the ice cream was more creamy. It feels like it kinda melts in your mouth more than it should. Shout out to the staff though. My friend left her purse and they kept it safe for her to come back later. read more

I'm mad at myself for not coming here sooner. This used to be the location of a burger place that I loved. So I have a personal vendetta against this place. Well, I finally came here and I'm happy to squash the beef. The frozen yogurt is delicious with plenty of flavors and toppings to choose from. There are even healthier options for the yogurt. I was worried that my cup would weigh too much but it came out to just $10. I'll be back here, a great place to grab some desert. read more

16 Handles - a bowl of cereal with a spoon - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

The only handle needed here is for the Owner to get a handle on cleaning up his business. Was there last night,7/27, and to say it was filthy inside is an understatement. The self machines were dirty and the cup area filled with melted yogurt. The floor was beyond not only filthy but literally sticky on the bottom of my shoes. I wouldn't even consider getting any toppings, as that was a sloppy mess too. If the restaurant inspector came in, the place would get an F. read more

This place is beyond filthy. Not only is it dirty and looks like it hasn't been cleaned or sanitized, THE SMELL IN HERE WAS HORRENDOUS. It reeked of spoiled/rotten milk. It's impossible to ignore. What's worse is that it reeked from the machines itself. The toppings were in disarray, leaving a lot of things mixed in together. Overall, this place needs to be inspected. It's completely disgusting and left me with the ultimate ick. read more

Omg, this was the worst frozen yogurt experience I may have ever had. Where do I start? The homeless woman sitting in the back literally in front of two flavors having an entire conversation on her phone in a 16 handles seat. The multiple broken flavors. The filthy toppings with things littered from other containers in each. Or could it be getting to the register where there is only one employee and being charged over $16 for two teeny cups of yogurt. If I could cuss in this review I would. The only reason I didn't leave it there at the register was because I'd already committed to putting yogurt in my cups, ugh and the poor cashier seemed so resigned. NEVER THE (expletive) AGAIN. Disgusting! Do better owners! And yes you may contact me for a refund!!!! Nasty, don't go here! read more

Great self-service frozen yogurt shop with several flavors! My bf and I visited this fun and brightly lit shop on a Sunday night. There were a handful of people popping in and out while we were there but we encountered no wait or hassle. The shop was very clean and well organized. It had 14 different flavors (2 machines were out of order) at the time of our visit and the huge topping bar was well stocked. The yogurt was tasty. Service was friendly. Pricing was good. We were very happy with our visit. read more

See all

I think frozen yogurt is like that experience a lady needs to comprehend something. "Clears throat" I stay moisture because of frozen yogurt at the right time at the right place with my boyfriend laughing at all of my favorite health freaky fruits and probiotics in what not! read more

16 Handles - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

See all

I actually heard that this place had dairy free options while I was in NY and had to investigate. As soon as I got in, I realized that all the dairy free options contained banana and coconut and I am deathly allergic to both, so there went my idea of a good time! It diddnt stop me from trying everything on the menu though. I actually tried everything I wasn't allergic to and loaded it up with every topping. This place is cute and clean and the service is friendly. If you are not a dairy person and not allergic to banannas or coconut like me...then they have a froxen yogurt with coconut water and a banana cashew nut milk fro yo. I'm not giving it 5 stars beacuse I've seen a whole bunch of frozen yogurt places and there was really nothing extremely unique about this place. It's just a basic little frozen yogurt shop that hits the spot if your in the mood and walking by. read more

16 Handles - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

I love frozen yogurt so I was very excited to try this chain, which we don't have where I live. I enjoyed the unique flavors of froyo and the variety of toppings they offered. The Tahitian vanilla had a subtle but good flavor to it and the toppings were delicious. The mint chocolate chip flavor was also very subtle but tasty. The only downside was their original tart flavor tasted very artificial and they had only strawberry as their fruit topping options. I personally like to get the original tart with lots of fruit when I get froyo so not having that as an option is a bummer. It did force me to try something new though, which I enjoyed but probably wouldn't get every time. Luckily, there are several flavors so endless combination of creations to make! read more

16 Handles - Tahitian Vanilla Bean Frozen Yogurt with cheesecake pieces, cookie dough, and sprinkles - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Overpriced! We were charged $25 for 2 small cups. At PinkBerry, this would have been $12 max. Not sure what's going on with their pricing or how they weigh the cups but that is some definite price-gouging! Save your money and buy a $7 ice cream pint at the grocery store; froyo isn't worth $12 per a small cup. read more

The vegan chocolate and mango sorbetto are good but there was a hair in the PB cup topping but what was really gross was watching two braided women sample every flavor using cup after cup, eating with their fingers and touching every handle then tossing entire cups of food. Truly shocking behavior. read more

I happen to be in the 9th Avenue area yesterday after 7pm and checked twitter that the new 16 Handles was having their Grand Opening today. I thought hey why not I can check it out. I am a fan of ice cream/frozen yogurt every now and then. This location is the 5th outpost in Manhattan. I got the small yogurt and mixed the Peanut Butter, My Greek Honey and Red Velvet. I kind of thought the new feature flavor- MY GREEK HONEY! was the best. Red Velvet, I do love as cake, but as yogurt, not so much. Only in small doses lets just say. Peanut butter flavor was pretty delicious as well, I recommend you try that one. Toppins I got were: Hot Fudge(so good), cookie dough crumbles, graham cracker and strawberries. -Since yesterday was the official Grand Opening, the also offered a 16% discount all day. They closed I believe at 2 am at night. The price is actually 52 cents per oz just based on weight, no matter how many toppings or anything. - My dish came to $4.94 after the discount and tax added. I was shocked but I guess I didn't pour as much out as I normally do. I usually have a hard time keeping the weight and cost under at least $6.70. Great job 16 Handles to open a new spot. -The location is a good spot, right on 8th avenue and the cross street is 19th street. read more

Most authentic flavors, I have tasted in the "fro-you" innundation NY has received. Flavors like coffee break, strawberry banana, salted caramel and root beer float. Big clean corner spot in the hood with cushy green seating. A good spot before or apres film at Chelsea Cinemas. The toppings are standard......, but the yougurt yummy, read more

16 Handles - my yogurt cup- oooh tasty - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

It was after dinner and my sister and I really wanted something sweet. We didn't want to commit to a dessert at a restaurant and each wanted a little something different. So off to 16 Handles we went. The variety of flavors here is pretty good. You can sample them before you go all in for your yogurt cup. There are sugar free options, sorbets, yogurts and gelato. The toppings are a free-for-all and are arguably the best part of this place. I really liked the Reese's cookie dough and all the cereal toppings. The raspberry drizzle was great as well. Pricing is comparable to other self-serve frozen yogurt joints. read more

Really great dairy free options both w/ cashew milk and sorbets. Got the chocolate hazelnut truffle. Amazing! read more

16 Handles - Front counter - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

Although the yogurt tasted fine, the trays under where one gets the yogurt were very messy and needed cleaning

Good vegan froyo options here! There is usually at least 1 to 2 sorbet options and 1 soy froyo option, labeled clearly as vegan!! This 16 handles usually has the soy "creamy" froyo although I haven't seen it at other locations. I think this is what sets 16 handles apart! You can usually find sorbet dairy free froyo at other stores though. Even the toppings are clearly labeled if vegan. Lots of fruit at toppings bar! They are willing to give sample cups so that's nice! Price is reasonable. I got a reasonably big cup for $3.70! I like the acai sorbet a lot. Really refreshing. The soy vanilla froyo is delicious and super creamy! I like the vanilla over the chocolate which wasn't chocolate enough for me. From what I remember it tastes like soft serve ice cream! For non vegans: they have waffle cones if you want to put your froyo in it. Great variety of other flavors too! They also have these awesome cup dividers if you wanna get 2 flavors without mixing. Genius! Nice clean store. Overall I would definitely come back here for my froyo fix !! read more

16 Handles - Vegan soy chocolate froyo..acai sorbet. Smart cup divider! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

How did I not know about this amazing and delicious confectionery? My boyfriend had been raving about '16 Handles' for awhile. I'm not a fan of frozen yogurt, so I didn't think anything of it. I didn't even know they sold other types of frozen treats. But lo and behold, we were in the area and he suggested we get some after a long day of biking. The store is taking great measures to reduce the occurrence of COVID-19. Upon walking in, there is no indoor seating. You must grab a pair of gloves prior to serving yourself. there are a number of machines in the back of the store with a variety of soft serve, frozen treats including traditional vanilla ice cream, frozen yogurt, sorbet, and even an oat milk ice cream. It's a great place for anyone who likes frozen treats but either doesn't consume animal/dairy, is allergic, or in my boyfriends' case, is lactose intolerant. After choosing your soft serve, there is a bar of toppings to choose from. I mean everything from cereal, cookies, to gummy bears, and chocolate syrup. It's truly a place to 'have it your way'. I opted for a little of plain vanilla ice cream and birthday cake ice cream topped with Oreo cookie pieces and whipped cream. My boyfriend had coconut flavored frozen yogurt topped with coconut flakes, rainbow sprinkles, Cinnamon Toast Crunch cereal, and gummy bears. The price of your treat is based on weight - so you can splurge or be as light as you want lol. My boyfriend got a large cup, I had a small. Altogether $28, not bad in my opinion. As far as the taste, it was absolutely delicious! The texture was very smooth and creamy. Not too sweet either, altogether a great balance. Service was attentive, kind and patient. Overall, a great experience which I will share with others. I will definitely return and I hope they open more throughout the city (pretty please!). read more

16 Handles - Vanilla ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

I stumbled upon this location around where I work. It's an average size for a frozen yogurt shop. They have a fair amount of seating for the actual size of the shop. What I really like was their assortment of flavors. They had a good variety, only 2 of the flavors stopped working. The amount of topping they offer is what I love the most. And if you are vegan, they offer a lot of vegan options. The one thing I didn't like, was the amount of children that came to this location. It's definitely not a location I would actually sit and enjoy my yogurt, I'd rather take it go to avoid the noice and the crowds. But if you're in the neighborhood, definitely stop in. read more

16 Handles - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

This place is great! I loved TCBY but I think 16 Handles beats it - they've got more flavors and toppings! I definitely recommend, and I want to try their smoothies next time. read more

Not sure what the rave is, this stuff has no taste unless you load it with toppings. We got three different flavors all were equally bad. Worst was the price almost $80 Per. Go elsewhere read more

Omg. This place stinks!! I came here with a girl and had such a bad experience. The server could barely understand me, it made me feel like I was talking in another language.. I do not recommend. In fact, I strongly advise against. P.S. I'm so ticked off. read more

Yum. My go-to dessert place, where I can choose unlimited flavors and toppings in custom ratios. I'm very particular with my cravings, and get annoyed with other places limiting flavors or toppings, and then also deciding the portion of each ingredient. This location is great in that they seem to participate in all the special deal days. (not all locations seem to participate) Tip: always get a few paper sample cups from the register before heading over to the flavors, so you can sample a few first. They always have new flavors, even if you're a regular. read more

I got the Euro Tart, the Green Apple Sorbet, the Mango Sorbet & the Mint Chocolate Chip. The 1st 3 were tart. It was good. The service was good. Not much more to say. 1st time at this location & the experience was good. I never finish my froyo though no matter where I go cuz I can't take too much frozen food. read more

16 Handles - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

See all

I am really surprised by all the high ratings. I have been to this location several times and use the app regularly. However I have never seen all 16 handles working. At least one is always broken. Isn't that false advertising? I went there last night and 2 handles were broken. The prices are also super high and the don't show the calculation of the price on the receipt. I got a half-filled pink cup with no toppings and it was $7+. Not sure if they raised their prices or what but fro yo should not be this expensive, even in Chelsea ... read more

16 Handles - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

I LOVE frozen yogurt, and 16 handles has the best flavors. I typically go for the fruitier flavors, but the location in chelsea has a tendency to stock on the creamy kind. Even so, 16 handles never disappoints with their toppings, including mochi, fruity boba, cheesecake bites and the syrups which no one else has like raspberry and honey. I give this location 4 stars because it is smaller and so it tends to crowd, and i've accidentally found myself in someone's froyo before. A few times upwind coming here, one or 2 of the flavor machines have been out of order, but besides that the service is friendly and helpful if something is missing and generous if you need a taste test. read more

16 Handles - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

Great name! You know, like 16 Candles movie from the 80s??? Great yogurt shop that was just a few blocks from where we called home for 8 days in NYC. They have great flavors (pomegranate something was the best). I got plain tart and coffee flavor. People working there were helpful and nice. Asked for samples and they were helpful. Made recommendations. Crowded at 10pm on Friday night as it should be! read more

I might be one of the only people in New York that's still 'team fro yo' and loves 16 handles. I've been here a couple of times. I feel like fro yo places are slowly starting to disappear now that people are realizing its actually not healthy for you. (Rip Yogurt Land) lol. Duh. I usually consume an entire portions worth of soft serve on samples alone before coming to a decision. But I still stand by with one of my favorite flavors being their peanut butter. They now have more outrageous toppings. I came in for their promotion of a free 3 ounces off an order. You can get entire black and white cookies, enormous balls of cookie dough, animal crackers, rainbow cookies, like coconut bars. I'm legitimately impressed. I didn't go so crazy on toppings the last time I went in and just got a scoop of cookie dough on some peanut butter/mint/nutella weird mixture. I kind of like this location more than the one in the east village. There are less drunks and more children and feels more family oriented. I actually was able to sit down at a table the couple of times I've been here and chill and enjoy my soft serve without some girl squealing in my ear. Two thumbs up. read more

16 Handles - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New York, New York

Fro yo at its best--they even have an icecream or two! The edible cookie dough topping is worth the visit!