I visited on a weekday holiday. The store was pretty clean. Most people were buying and then leaving with their froyo. I stayed a while with my family. I never love the metal chairs, but whatever. The taste was just how I remembered it - though I didn't remember so many toppings choices, whee! Bathroom requires a code. read more

The owners are absolutely great, they care about their customers and want you to have a good experience. Very clean and inviting, you must give it a try but prepare to be hooked. My go to spot when in NY. read more

16 Handles - Soooo good. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New Rochelle, New York

The 16 Handles in Westchester is always clean, friendly, and fully stocked with great flavors and fresh toppings. Everything tastes super fresh, and the staff keeps things running smoothly. Perfect spot for a quick, fun treat any time of day. read more

16 Handles is absolutely delicious. It has such a variety of toppings and flavors. The only thing I want to comment on which led to a 3 star review is the cleanliness. This place is dirty almost every time, toppings mixed together, froyo machines are messy, and the tables. read more

16 Handles - Cookies & Cream Frozen Yogurt - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New Rochelle, New York

So decided to go there tonight after a long time. Got the usual, yogurt, some toppings, and whip cream. Went home and all good. A hour half later , I was puking and well, things were happening from the other end. I am hoping it wasn't the yogurt and I hope others didn't get sick but I can only think it was the whip cream. This has never happened before but I am currently sick to my stomach and absolutely miserable. Will not be going back anytime soon. read more

Amazing frozen yogurt and wide selection of toppings definetly would reccomend 5/5 stars.

always a great experience here. Toppings are always stocked & delicious! Staff is friendly & always greet each customer! Deff my fav local spot! read more

16 Handles - two bowls of ice cream and a spoon - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New Rochelle, New York

There are so many froyo chains out there it's sometimes hard to pick out the best of the bunch. Everyone has their favorite, and while 16 Handles isn't mine I do applaud them for trying to make themselves slightly more unique than their competitors. This 16 Handles is located in a small strip of stores; it's kind of narrow inside, so you need to walk to the back before reaching the yogurt. This makes for a choppy flow from start to finish, but hey, you can't get it all. What I like about 16 Handles is they have three cup sizes, and their froyo flavors display nutritional information as well as other useful information. I've had more flavorful froyo at other chains, but 16 Handles' froyo has good consistency and lots of toppings so it's fine. Additionally, you can get little cups to sample the flavors before you choose mmmmmm. Good for what it is - I'm more partial to Peachwave and Red Mango, but this 16 Handles holds its own. read more

16 Handles - strawberry and birthday cake w/ rainbow sprinkles - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New Rochelle, New York

Dirty!!! All the toppings were messy and falling into each other. Out of 4 flavors! In addition, 1 was really watery. Never gonna go to the Quaker Ridge Rd New Rochelle location ever again. read more

Love 16 handles ice cream . However , this location should be kept a little cleaner as far as the eating tables and the topping area . Not to mention the hot fudge dispenser wasn't full so when I pressed it ; it splashed out all over my clothes. Fudge container should be kept full to prevent that from happening to anyone else . Also, all customers should wear gloves when adding their toppings etc . One lady who was ahead of me in line, added toppings to her ice cream & all of the remaining toppings bounced off her hand and back into the topping container. Yuck. Gloves everyone . read more

One of my favorite froyo spots. The staff is always friendly and the location is clean. Only complaint is that I wish they would bring back the Nutella flavored froyo! read more

16 Handles - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New Rochelle, New York

Love coming here with my kids and having the ability to mix flavors and toppings. Have also gotten delivery a number of times and it holds up well. read more

Always great service! Love the curbside pickup!! Very sweet workers and extremely accommodating! Thank you!

Not a large selection of regular ice cream. More selections of Frozen Yogurt and Vegan ice cream. The floor was sticky. The store front windows were dirty. The tables were dirty. I had to ask to have the table cleaned. The staff disappeared in the back room and left the store unattended. I will not be having ice cream in this store. read more

Sooooo good! I'm glad I found this place. It's in a great location, and parking is always available. The place is clean, and the vibe is fun and upbeat. The staff at this location are all warm and friendly and you are never waiting too long on line, which on warm spring days is definitely bound to occur. I have definitely made this Fro-Yo spot my weekly go to place. read more

Yogurt was spoiled my wife and I both got stomach aches Very few flavors. Dina the owner was extremely rude. Will never go here again.

Let me sum it up this way: $17.35 for one half-filled medium cup of froyo with some nuts and hot fudge on top, and a medium strawberry smoothie. Yeah, seventeen dollars and change. Is this owner trying to punish us for Covid? Sure seems so. I was a regular, but until prices return to earth I won't be going back and neither should you. read more

My daughter loves to come here. They have great flavors and good customer service. read more

16 Handles - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New Rochelle, New York

Excellent quality frozen yogurt with an abundance of interesting flavors ranging from classics (e.g. chocolate and vanilla) to some creative, less typical options. The yogurt was somewhat pricier than other similar shops, so I'm giving it 4 Stars overall. Quality & Taste - 5 Stars read more

Now they make us download a new app to disguise higher prices and fewer rewards. On my most recent visit, they neglected to give me my receipt, which I needed to get "credit" in my newly downloaded app's account. When I called to discuss, they experienced a "technical glitch" that deducted a reward I had earned. So now I've paid double, over $20, for a small frozen yogurt w hot fudge. A manager called and promised to rectify within the next business day. It's been 5 business days without corrections to my account. read more

I love 16 Handles, and I am very happy that there is finally one here in Westchester. The employees are very pleasant and helpful. There are so many different flavor options (hence the name 16 handles), but I usually stick with the salted caramel. It is absolutely delicious! Next time I will definitely try to be a bit more adventurous! 16 Handles definitely blows red mango and pinkberry out of the water. Keep up the good work! read more

This place is the place to be. The flavors offered are more than you could ever imagine. Pick your flavor and top it off with anything your heart desires. There is indoor seating and a bench outside. Enjoy! read more

16 Handles - Pumpkin Pie!!!!!! This stuff is amazing. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New Rochelle, New York

This is definitely my daughter and I's favorite spot for frozen yogurt! There is not much to say except for this place is clean, the staff is friendly, and yogurt is great. With young people buzzing in and out, this yogurt shop is happening. Mix a few flavors - or a bunch! Our favorites are the Euro Tart and the Salted Caramel! This place is our favorite go-to! read more

16 Handles - My daughter's favorite - Euro Tart and Strawberry Lemonade! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New Rochelle, New York

Uberrr excited that there was a 16 handles in NewRo! I frequent the ones in the city so was happy to find one close to home. Ventured there this wknd and although the staff were soooo nice, was a little disappointed in the lack of toppings. No mochi, no marshmallows, and nooooo whip cream :( boooo! Otherwise still yummy froyo flavor choices. read more

It is GREAT to have a froyo place in this area of new ro now. The flavors are delicious and it seems that they switch them out a lot. For me personally there are a few downsides. They are all kosher (which is great!) but it means they do not have all of the toppings you would expect. Notably, they are missing gummy bears which makes me very sad. Also, it is VERY crowded and there is rarely anywhere to sit in the store and the line is long. read more

Totally self service which is nice. Can get loads of toppings and it's bought by weights. Can pick from a cup, a cone, or a bowl with a cone which is obviously what I went for. Friendly staff. Lacks Seating which is a bit of a pain but other than that, a great place for an afternoon snack read more

This is my daughter's favorite place. Whenever we are in New Rochelle, a stop at 16 Handles is a must!

Once I read the ingredients, which the store has available but hides in a draw, I was so diasppointed. I am not sure how they are allowed to call it yogurt. It is all chemicals. I can't pronounce most of the ingredients. Nothing you get from the farm. That is why the calories aren't that high. it is mostly fake. read more

Your average 16 Handles (if you like the chain, you will like this one). I go for the toppings, as the yogurt is kinda meh. If you want really good yogurt, granted less flavors, go to All Good Things in Scarsdale. The only reason I'm giving them 4 stars is because, like I said, the toppings are great and the hot fudge is particularly good. Lastly, I like that they let you sample all the flavors before picking...don't be shy. read more

I visit this location often, it is very organized and clean. The yogurt is so yummy and the staff members are always friendly.

BEST FROYO! 16 handles is self serve froyo but it takes just like ice cream. The flavors and toppings are endless and amazing. Honestly my favorite place! Its a must have! read more

This location is brand new & I'm very happy to have a Sixteen Handles in Westchester! The employees were VERY nice & helpful. One of the girls encouraged me to try the many different flavors & was not annoyed to let me try the samples. I picked the Cinnabon flavor (DELICIOUS) and the peanut butter. I think it was better than Red Mango & I love red mango! I'm definitely going back! read more

Antionette helped me tonight. She made my visit amazing. Five Stars! Give this girl a promotion!

My first visit went amazing! I brought my friend from the city to get some some frozen yogurt but we weren't expecting such amazing service! A high schooler helped us out with picking out which flavor of yogurt was best and even gave us some samples to try! Would recommend to anyone, and ask for Antoinette as she has superb taste!!! Thank you to the staff for a great end to the night! read more

Usually very clean and running efficiently. During summer season, it's hard to find a space to sit, but that's ok. Love going here for a treat! read more

Great flavors, great customer service, and a very friendly environment. The best place in town to get froyo without a doubt.

Delicious frozen yogurt with good service and moderate prices. On the level of Red Mango; it provides the quality any frozen yogurt lover should be looking for. read more

The type of peanut-butter-based fantasy I can recreate in this place is shortening the length of my life undoubtedly, but geeze would I have it no other way. read more

16 Handles is the best (though they need to get Mochi at this location!) Coming from the city, it's great to have an outpost nearby. Gets very busy after sundown on Saturday, but they do a good job keeping it clean and well stocked with all the toppings. read more

Great service, and their staff is polite, especially some of their newer hires. The only downfall is that I feel like a lot of the flavors are the same, let us have something new!! read more