We walked in and there was only the cashier there so I felt great knowing there was no one else around to come into contact with. The toppings were protected by a barrier so only the cashier could put the topping on. Decent selection. Kids enjoyed it and so did us adults. Wasn't told about the rewards app until after purchase. I got in contact with support online and they were able to apply my purchase points to my app when I got home. Will definitely be coming back! read more

This place needs some serious management! It's absolutely ridiculous. Went tonight at 9:10. The place was mobbed garbage over flowing as usual. The drip trays were full and spilling on the floor. Flavors were out. Waited online for 20 minutes and couldn't even get peanut butter sauce. They said they put it away already . I don't really understand why this store is always a mess. Please clean it up!!!! It's unsanitary. And yes as soon as I got home I threw my frozen yogurt out. I was honestly afraid to eat it. That's how bad the conditions were tonight. read more

It's a cute place. Gets packed but at times, no one is there. It's good tho. Topping is always filled and the choices are plenty. read more

See all

As a frozen yogurt lover, I was dismayed by the subpar cleanliness of this establishment. Despite the array of flavors and toppings available, the frozen yogurt machines appeared to have not been cleaned in some time. I visited on a Thursday evening and found the store to be largely empty, with staff more focused on their personal phones than customer service. This store is located in a shopping plaza with more than enough parking. read more

16 Handles - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Livingston, New Jersey

I am loyal customer here and friends and I really enjoy going to get frozen yogurt every time we are home from school. Tonight we arrived to get our frozen yogurt but were denied and told they were closing even though online it said we still had an hour until they would close. Not only were we denied but the lady working was very rude to us, the man working was kind but still a bummer that we didn't get our frozen yogurt. read more

Everything tasted good. They were actively keeping things clean and neat. I would like regular tables and chairs rather than just high toos.

Ants are populous at the Dubai chocolate section. They were also out of Dubai chocolate. however the staff was nice and provided all asked. read more

16 Handles - Ants pouring into the ice cream machine - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Livingston, New Jersey

I recently went to this location and the cost for a medium size of frozen yogurt was $25. I could not believe it - I questioned the price to the staff, but they continued to confirm that yes, the frozen yogurt was $25. I unfortunately will never be going to 16 handles again. read more

Not many fro yo places these days, so I'm glad there's one in the area. I like that they rotate flavors every season so there's always something new. read more

16 Handles - Fro yo selection - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Livingston, New Jersey

I have been here with couple of friends recently, good place for having a diy ice cream , great options and toppings. The place is cozy and have ample amount of seating for people with outside seating as well. The service is good and people are welcoming. Would recommend. read more

16 Handles - a bowl of food in the back seat of a car - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Livingston, New Jersey

See all

16 handles is one of those places that my wife gets random cravings for. Since I go with her I always give it a try. I like the euro tart flavor and it is pretty unique to 16 handles. I don't find it at other frozen yogurt shops. They are very covid friendly with plastic wrap over all toppings. You don't put your own toppings, the staff member does. The one weird thing is there is no fruit for toppings. Come on 16 handles let's get some fruit in there. Fyi, there are no samples because of covid so you get one shot to get it right. Good luck! read more

See all

great! love it here, sometimes the ice cream can be expensive but its pay by weight so... people always nice and sometimes can get busy but i've always been satisfied. since it is a self serve ice cream place make sure you wash your hands before eating your ice cream as the handles are touched by everyone!! read more

I came in here with a few friends. The ice cream was good however the workers were so loud that I couldn't even hear my friends. They were yelling and talking so loudly it was very unenjoyable. read more

$14 for two small, not so full cups? I feel bad for parents who want to get their kids some ice cream. Quality was fine, flavors were good and there are plenty of toppings options, I just can't get on board with these prices. read more

16 Handles - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Livingston, New Jersey

See all

So I came here on national icecream day because 16 handles was giving away up to $5 worth of frozen yogurt out for free but I actually missed it because it ended at a certain time, but it was okay because i actually downloaded the 16 handles app and it gave me over $6 in rewards that I apparently accumulated out of nowhere. So I went down to 16 handles, parking is abundant, there wasn't that many people there, but I was so disgusted when I went in. It wasn't clean and there were ants in the frozen yogurt machines, crawling around (yuck!) the dispensing area. I guess the only good thing about this place was the fact that they give you sample cups so you don't need to buy any flavor you don't want. But other than that, the pricing of the frozen yogurt is a lot pricier than any other ice cream store and the flavors aren't THAT amazing that I would crave it. I definitely will not be back and I'm shocked they even passed inspections (shake my head). read more

The most BORING flavors I've ever seen. 3 stars for the buffet style topping! read more

This is your standard froyo spot. I rated it 3 stars because I wasn't a big fan of the options for flavors and toppings. I understand that it's froyo, but everything is way oversweetened and there aren't a lot of options that can give you a more moderate ice cream. They also don't have coconut flakes, nuts, enough fruit options, or mochi. No complaints about service though! read more

See all

3 stars because my dessert was soooo delicious. I loved the graham cracker flavored ice cream. Lots of topping selections too. The fun stops there because it cost me $17 for a half full cup for me and a regular cup for my seven year old. As much as I enjoyed it, there's no way I'm paying that regularly. read more

The dessert was OK, but not for the $37 we paid for 2 frozen yoghurts. Ridiculously expensive, wont be going back.

We arrived promptly at 9:52pm to a locked business with a closing time of 10pm. The workers on duty saw us outside but refused our entry. Fuck this place read more

Really horrible "yogurt" tastes more like sorbet... Ordered on door dash came completely melted and with no toppings. Every time I try this place it just gets worse. In person horrible as well. Head to Morristown for good frozen yogurt. read more

I've been to other 16 Handles and other store like them before. With the other Froyo place in town closing, my wife and I were excited to have a new local place to get our fix. Today, at about 2:15 PM, we visited this location. There was another couple in there enjoying some Froyo action, and a few kids who came in after us. While at the dispensers, a song comes on (Undressed by Kim Cesarion). First off, the subject matter of the song is completely inappropriate for family friendly establishment, but it was also the uncensored version, which drops the F-bomb at least twice. My wife walked over to the cashier, who was the only employee around and said "If we had kids in here, I would be very upset right now. This is completely inappropriate for a store that is family friendly!" The cashier responded by ignoring her and texting. Will not be returning until this place anytime soon. Edit: typo read more

Love this place. It is newly renovated and the staff are super nice. My baby loves it!

My kids and I have visited the store twice. I don't have any problems with the service, and we were able to go in and out quickly. It is expensive, but it can be under control if you don't put in too much topping. The reward program credited me with $5 for my birthday, and it was a great treat. Make sure you monitor your kids when they put the toppings, so that you won't get a price shock. I will visit again. read more

I agree with other reviews. I used to take my boys here all the time before Covid and although pricey it was manageable. We stopped by on 2/24/2021 and 2 small cups came out to about $25. We will not be back. read more

My favorite fro-yo place. It has the best yogurt & topping selection. And the store always keeps very nice and clean. read more

16 Handles - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Livingston, New Jersey

We passed by recently and really enjoyed the frozen yogurt. The shop was very neat and clean, and the staff was super patient and friendly. The variety of choices is great. Just a little crowd. My kids just loved it and will return for more. read more

I really like this ice cream shop, for the first time visit the place very clean, staff attitude is very good, will recommend friends to .

It funny that you say that I'm mistaken. Because that is exactly what I payed! Just take responsibility for what you are doing and try changing. read more

I was happy to see a new frozen yogurt shop close to home. There was one across the street we used to frequent but it closed a few years ago. Bonus that it's in the same center where we just ate dinner. As the name implies, there are 16 flavors (hence 16 handles on the machines) including some sorbet. Tasting cups are available if you ask up front. A sign is clearly visible to please only use the cup once. I understand. Some people get obnoxious with the free samples. Different sized cups are then filled with your desired flavor, whatever toppings you want, then you place it on a scale and the price is based on weight. It was amazing and funny to me that this simple concept was like brain surgery to a group who came in behind us. My watermelon sorbet was really delicious! I especially liked the, "strawberry pearls" I put on as a topping. Think caviar but filled with fruity gel. Pretty cool. The only thing I took issue with was the puss on the person behind the counter. Would it kill you to crack a smile?? read more

I normally go there on weekday with my kids. It's their favorite place. They love their yogurts and toppings, and you can't go wrong with sample before you buy option is always a plus. yesterday was the first time we went there on weekend, it was a little crowed though. we sugguest to go there on weekday if you have young kids. read more

My family really enjoy the ice cream at the store. There are many selections for the ice cream and it is very tasty. The cashier are pretty nice and the store is very clean. It is a very great place to chat and get together with friends and family. We highly recommend the store. read more

I prefer frozen yogurt shops that aren't overwhelming with topping choices and offer standard flavors along with a twist. 16 handles offers that. read more

It is said," sharing is caring". I can't wait to share the best frozen yogurt with you which is located in the town-the 16 handles. The store reopen after Covid -19 pandemic. it was so amazing that quality of frozen yogurt was so fresh and the flavor with the colorful toppings gave us a delightful summer feeling. impressively, the service was so incredible as we received the bags with such nice and clean pack. The whole family loves the store so much! Thank you 16 handles!! read more

I'm not even a huge frozen yogurt fan, more of an ice cream fan myself, but 16 Handles frozen yogurt is awesome. I highly recommend the pecan praline!!! read more

Came in today for frozen yogurt and was not disappointed. Great service from the greeting at the door to the explanation of the rewards program I signed up for. Store was very clean. Great variety of toppings and the yogurt was awesome. Will definitely be back! read more

The place is nice looking and the flavor and topping selection is great. What goes downhill from there is the fact that 2 yogurts were $30. They are .30 cents an ounce more than any other yogurt place in the area and has the same taste. This is a one and done place for me. read more

Perfect place to go out for a post-date dessert. Clearly 5 stars. We always go there for celebrations, after dinner, last minute plans! The best for all of those. Line always moves quick never a problem with waits. Perfect location. Clearly 5 stars. Cashiers super friendly and willing to engage in conversation. Highly recommended. read more

Great flavors, love the mint chocolate and grapefruit. It surprisingly pairs well together! I don't like the parking situation at this location, as there are many stores and places using the same one. The employees were helpful and it was very clean in here. I wish they had paper dividers in the cups to separate flavors! Although my flavor combo was good, the option to separate would be nice, as I have seen other froyo places offer this option. read more

I feel like 16 Handles should be busier and full of life, with its bright pink and green lettering and array of colorful toppings lining up the joint, but frankly, it's kind of depressing. While there are some good flavors of yogurt to choose from and they're not skimpy on samples, it's just got a sad little vibe to it. I don't understand why no one is ever in here. Outside of that, it's clean and there's a decent amount of seating, both booths and chairs and tables. Benches can also be found outside. They carry Skinnygirl flavors which is trendy, along with your basic vanillas, chocolates and such. There are a ton of toppings to choose from - chocolate chips, gummy bears, tons of syrups, sprinkles, M&Ms -- you get the picture. Definitely good for the kiddies. There's no minimum on credit card purchases which I appreciate. The staff here is lackluster. They're always on their phones and/or they don't pay any attention to you, even at the register. read more