Technically more of a 4-4.5 due to a terrible experience with their service and line system once (they skipped our number completely even though we kept checking and we waited forever), but tl;dr the beef brisket noodles are really good, with just a slight medicinal flavor.
I've tried the three treasures one, the 崩沙腩 kind (the one that was listed first in their beef brisket descriptions that apparently sells out really fast), and the fingertip brisket one, and they have all been good. I especially liked the 崩沙腩, but you won't like it if you prefer your beef to be very lean. All the beef has been super tender and flavorful. The intestine in the three treasures one was too chewy, so I prefer going for just brisket. You get to pick from a few different types of noodles but those seem pretty standard and don't seem to be made in house. I always go for the wider egg noodles if you're looking for a recommendation. All the noodles come with scallion and a few chunks of turnip, so I also recommend ordering their seasonal vegetable dish if you want some greens.
Service-wise it's overall very standard for HK. Apart from the noodles, the drinks are also all standard and good, but everything is on the pricier side (~10+ HKD for a drink if you ordered a bowl of noodles, ~70-93 HKD per bowl). Compared to Sister Wah around the corner this place's beef is more tender and the broth more unique, and it's also Michelin recommended. The lines here tend to be smaller, too, and the portions reasonable and much larger than Kau Kee's. No clue why this place isn't just as popular as those, but I'm more than happy to spend less time waiting in line. read more