This is a lovely Peconic Bay treat. I go to the North Fork every summer and forgot to get the…read moreweekend hostess a gift. Thank God for Phoebe & Belle! They have a range of items so I was able to put together a great package and the store packaged it beautifully so it looked like it wasn't a last minute gift. Definitely going back to snag some items for myself.

They have the best curated collection of home goods. I always stop by when in the area. Kathy is…read moreamazing and really helped bring my vision for my home to life. She helped me pick out the perfect items.

This is my go to store for fabulous unique gifts. We ordered my daughter's wedding invitations here…read moretoo. Absolutely stunning invites and Mel's attention to detail was the best. I recommend this shop to everyone

The Quick: beautiful stationary, note cards, holiday cards, unique gifts, and everything in…read morebetween. Lots of color and personality and all of these gifts. Customize invitations ( wedding etc ) also available. The Details: I love the art of a handwritten note! What's even better is supporting local artists and small brands at a local small shop in order to write those notes... Genius. Worth a stop if you're in town, they have so many cute gifts and unique treasures some of which are from local artists. I highly recommend The Damage: You pay for quality, everything has a range. Worth stopping in

Handmade items; greeting cards; delicious chocolates and more. Always a surprise and very friendly…read moreservice.

This sweet little gift shop offers all sorts of candies, cards, and other gifts and souvenirs. A…read moreperfect place to stop if you need to pick up a little last-minute something for a host/hostess or guest. They offer a variety of 50-cent postcards for the traveller as well as fun magnets and toys. The owner is very nice and can answer questions about the area. Clean store with great variety and ample parking. Stop in and check it out!

If you're in the area and looking for a nice gift for someone or something unique and hand made to…read moretake home with you to remember your time in Greenport, The Weathered Barn is a must-visit. There are so many handmade items, from candles to soaps to jewelry and more. If there's someone in your life who is hard to shop for (or if you're that person, which is totally fine, just own it), this is the place for you. The service here is friendly and helpful without being overbearing. If you have any questions about any of the items they're happy to answer them for you, but they're not pushy about trying to get you to buy something, either. Definitely worth stopping in if you're taking a stroll through Greenport.

Everything in the store was so nice, unique and tasteful. The owner however was brash and a little…read morerude. When we were asking questions about products in the store she seemed really annoyed that we were bothering her and gave a vibe that she just wanted us to leave. Was kind of a bummer because we were prepared to drop a bunch of money on easter gifts for family. We still bought a few small things. We are clean cut adults and I think we're pretty nice humans in general so maybe we caught her on an off day. We both walked out and kind of were like, that was weird. Don't want to knock the star rating down too far, but wanted to mention this for possible future customer interactions.

So happy this awesome shop relocated to Greenport! They are chock full of the cutest local swag -…read moreshirts & sweatshirts are the softest ever here & the handmade candles can't be beat!!! It's the perfect place to find a Nofo gift. Jen & TJ are the sweetest people & happy to help! Love this place

Excellent store for tasteful and high-quality souvenir clothing. I got pieces for myself, a friend…read moreand my baby niece. Excellent service as well!

i bought some bath salts from here. they were in glass tubes. they wrapped them up really nice too…read moreso they don't break. so many cute things in here! the staff was very friendly as well.

Really cute store, perfect for buying gifts for friends! We ended up getting a boob pot for one of…read moreour friends.

The Quick: Locally owned small business with the best flowers, gardening, and amazing gifts. The…read moreowners are great and take care of their customers. Great bouquets for every single occasion. Absolutely love this spot!

This is not the huge garden center or big box gift store. It is not the local island farm…read more What it is brings cool, chic, comfy and nice all together. Beautifully cared for plants - both indoor and out- garden decorations, lights, pots, accessories. We stopped in to grab solar powered table and hanging lamps we has seen at Orient Inn. And given how terrific this place was. We wound up grabbing a few more things along the way. Really nice stuff. Go.

Costume party, conventions, any type of theme event, this place has you covered! They have ears,…read morewigs, wings, masks, and even a magic section. They also sell really huge and realistic Halloween decorations. They even have a prank section. Now I know where to go for my niche costumes.

This is the type of place you can only find in New York. A smorgasbord of costumes, makeup, horror…read moreprops! Tons of masks, hats, headpieces (think cats, bunnies, demonesses). Tons of prosthetics and fake blood, dyes, wigs, etc. There is a special downstairs section where big time productions like SNL often rent costumes and props. They have entire sections of specialized apparel ranging from zombie to cop to dominatrix and BDSM. Steam punk, cowboys and country, retro 50s, 60s hippies, 70s. Anything you need for Halloween, plays/shows/productions, or events, you can find it here. Tons of people to help at every corner of the store, and all are attentive and kind. Also a lot of photo ops around the store, including a Heath Ledger joker, various Child's Play alum, Art the Clown, Michael Myers, and a ton of other huge animatronics and props.