Yaphank Community Pizza

The food and service are still amazing! Have enjoyed this amazing pizza joint/ beautiful Italian…read more restaurant since the 90's...This place has been consistent for 30+ years!

we were there at 5 pm we were only the second table there . The server was trying but she must have…read morebeen new and inexperience, we had to explain what aldente meant, and she was very slow, We split the chicken dish with pasta, it was ok nothing special. The pizza here is great stick to that if your going here

The pizza place

See all

1 Grandma slice, 1 pepperoni and sausage

Capio's Pizzeria & Restaurant

3.8(61 reviews)

3.5 mi

Had take out food was well prepared and fresh not just pizza . Clam sauce was fresh plenty of…read morechopped calm's hey are the right path for good take out or eat in .

I absolutely love their food it's amazing I had the best pizza ever, you think ny style pizza and…read morethis is it. The owners Renee and her husband Paul are great people. I am a big foodie and when I say I love the pizza it's a big rave. If you want an amazing pizza come here.

Wings with sauch

Grilled Chicken Special Hero

See all

Wings with sauce

La Vespa of Manorville

4.4(91 reviews)

2.8 mi

Always have great food very clean. Waitresses are always very nice. Food is always fresh. Whether…read moreyou dine in or dine out. I highly recommend them best pizza.

Hefty slices! The…read moretwo slices and a drink deal for $8 is really good considering you can get any speciality slice. I got a bacon chicken and a chicken parm slice which was definitely enough carbs for the rest of the day. I couldn't finish off my two slices and just picked at the chicken off one of my remaining slices. These slices are certainly a generous amount of food. It is supposed to be order and pickup your food at the counter but my slices were served to me at the table. Certainly can't ask for anything more for the friendly service. The decor warranted more than a glancing look, while I didn't feel I was transported to Italy, it certainly gave a warm feel to my visit.

2 regs 2 grandma

See all

Such a beautiful pizzeria/restaurant

Alfredo's Pizzeria

3.3(194 reviews)

4.1 mi

Always a must order when visiting friends. Take away is always on point. Warm, stays together what…read moreI've ordered, each time has been a different choice. Always with a slice though, even cold it's awesome. This stop I ordered the Burrata & Tomato Small $10.95 | Large $15.95 * Arugula, vine-ripened sliced tomato, roasted peppers, creamy burrata, and balsamic fig glaze. I did C&P this description so everyone could see all the yummies included. I personally would ask for extra glaze when ordering.

Typical pizza place but with a separate dining room on the side. Parking in the back was a…read moresurprise. We have passed this place by for years thinking there was little parking, duh! The friendly waitress Grace promptly took our drink order and gave us time to review the menu. She brought a basket of delicious warm garlic knots and bread with both butter and olive oil balsamic dipping sauce. My husband ordered the Sunday sauce complete either pork, sausage, two large meatballs and a huge dollop of ricotta. He thoroughly enjoyed it with plenty to spare. I had the lemon cream pasta. Very rich but needing more lemon. Such a huge portion I will be enjoying it again. Great to have a local place to sit down and enjoy a casual meal

The Italian Hero

Dining area

See all

Mama Lisa Restaurant

3.8(544 reviews)

4.0 mi

We catered the food for a party. The food was excellant as always . We had it delivered and it was…read moreright on time .Annette B.

What a top notch restaurant. The owner greets you with a smile and a thank you !…read more Our server was Sam and she was terrific. The food was outstanding as usual. Strong. Consistent Solid food. A mastic favorite !!!!

Eggplant parm deliciousness

See all

Southpaw Brewing Company

3.9(147 reviews)

1.2 mi

A first time!! Wonderful! Who would have thought we…read moreold-timers (I'm 95!) would be excited, but GRATIFIED! THANK YOU, Southpaw Brewing!!BDK!

The pluses - food is very good for a brewery. The kitchen has its act together! The minuses -…read morevery very noisy and the service is on the slow side. Also, tables are close together and there are no dividers, which detracts from the atmosphere.

Hardworking Sam working the bar. Very likable!

Fried churros

See all

Kitchen prep

Milano Pizza

3.8(71 reviews)

3.7 mi

I stoped here 9/17 as I have done so many times. Today, like every time I stopped, the service…read morebehind the counter was so good. I don't know why I have not left a review before but the time is now. I usually stop here when I am heading out east and I usually order a hero or two. I love the sauce and the hero's are a nice size. In past visits I have tried the pizza and I can say it it good. Considering it is in a pretty vacant outlet center (Bellport outlet center) you may not think it is good, but it is. Like I said, I have been stopping here for years and I am never disappointed. I am not sure but they have lasted probably longer than any of the other businesses that have come through so that says a lot. Definitely Italian, definitely good.

5-8-25. I had to run an errand and was in the area…read more...... and had a hunkering for some pizza, so I stopped in here for a late lunch. Pretty good selection of specialty slices. It's located inside a Home Depot parking lot and it's not far from Sunrise Hwy. but a little off the beaten path. The pizza was good. I ordered a Greek salad slice and a regular slice. The salad slice was piled high with lettuce, tomato, onions, feta cheese and a few black olives. The sesame crust was a nice touch. Regular slice was decent as well. Plenty of seating inside and the place was kept clean. Staff was friendly and courteous.

Pretty solid pizza joint located in an almost hidden shopping center. Plenty of parking, foods good and the prices are fair.

5-8-25. Greek salad slice.

See all

Pizza was "taste-tested" by my wife. It was approved of for good taste haha

Cafe Gia

3.4(214 reviews)

3.0 mi

What a wonderful surprise! We stopped at Cafe Gia on our way back from the Tanger Outlets in…read moreRiverhead, just looking for a place to eat, and we ended up discovering a little Italian gem! The Italian owner, Dominic, was incredibly welcoming and made us feel right at home. The food was absolutely delicious. We had the pasta with shrimp, which was full of flavor, and the toasted bread with cheese was amazing -- the kids absolutely loved it! But the best of the best was the chicken soup. Oh my gosh! Seriously, some people can't even make chicken soup this good at home! It tasted homemade, comforting, rich and absolutely delicious. Mamma mia, che bontà! I would honestly drive another 40 minutes just to eat this soup again! Great food, warm Italian hospitality, and that wonderful feeling of finding a place you weren't expecting to love so much. Cafe Gia, we will definitely be back! Grazie, Dominic!

It's such a pretty pizza place with nice ambiance they sell this garlic bread with mozzarella,…read moresliced onions and tomatoes and it is Devine! The workers are very friendly, we came at a time they were giving away the dessert for free.

Chicken and Broccoli De Rabe Panini. Some fresh mozzarella also. Very good.

Filet of Sole

See all

Bread Basket

pizzeria Los amigos

4.4(10 reviews)

4.8 mi

This is our second visit. Tonight I ordered a chicken parm hero. Excellent, fresh bread, plenty of…read morechicken cutlets, a nice sauce and cheese. Huge, I could only eat half of it. My husband ordered the Fried Feast, fried shrimp, flounder and calamari. Cooked on point and came with a huge serving of fries. Darn, I should have taken a picture. Looking forward to going back again. Nice to have someplace so close to home

I purchased a slice of pizza for my niece. Halfway through eating the slice, she complained that…read moreher stomach was hurting. So I decided to try it the pizza was inedible. It tasted raw and I am appalled by the fact that this was the pizza that served to me.

See all

Bella Roma Restaurant & Pizzeria

3.5(75 reviews)

4.7 mi

Excellent pizza, beautiful atmosphere, and very personal service…read more Wonderful place, I really recommend the food is great for catering and the sit down atmosphere is wonderful. It's my go to lunch without question, the pizza is that good.

We order from Bella Roma quite often, and honestly, the food is always great. Tonight was the first…read moretime I ordered the lobster bisque (hate summer colds ). Surprisingly, especially for a pizza place, it's FANTASTIC. Thick, creamy, chunks of lobster. I'm so glad I gave it a shot over my usual bisque place! Oh, don't sleep on the Chicken Bacon Ranch pizza! Literally the best CBR on the island.

Beautiful atmosphere to have a quiet lunch

Half meatball pie

See all

Front

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

2 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Liz M.

4

6

0

8 years ago

Food is great. Very fresh. Large portions. So happy they are our local pizza shop!

C C.

0

2

0

10 years ago

disgusting food and nasty service.

Yaphank Community Pizza - pizza - Updated October 2026

People who viewed Yaphank Community Pizza also viewed

Alitalia Pizza & Restaurant

3.7

(96 reviews)

Owner was rude to us tonight for no reason. We've been going there for years. Seems stupid to piss…read moreoff a regular customer.

I ordered the chicken franchise although flavorful the chicken was rubbery and chewy. I couldn't…read moreeven eat it. I will stick to my pasta puttanesca! Very disappointing!

Little Vincent's Pizzeria

3.6

(483 reviews)

Little Vincent's Pizza was one of our favorite food finds during our stay in Islip!…read more We stopped in for dinner the day we landed in New York and absolutely fell in love with their cold cheese slice. It was so good that we knew we had to come back before heading home. Sure enough, our last meal before leaving New York was right back at Little Vincent's! The food was delicious both times, and the service was great. Everyone was friendly and welcoming, which made the experience even better. When a place is both your first AND last meal of a trip, you know they're doing something right! We'll definitely be back whenever we're in the area. Five stars from us!

I've heard their heroes are good (never had) but the pizza is trash. The sauce is very sweet and…read morethey don't put enough cheese or cook the pizza long enough. I remember it being better 20 years ago. The workers are nice and polite. Cash only. The only plus for me is that they are open late.

Alfredo's Pizzeria

3.3

(194 reviews)

Always a must order when visiting friends. Take away is always on point. Warm, stays together what…read moreI've ordered, each time has been a different choice. Always with a slice though, even cold it's awesome. This stop I ordered the Burrata & Tomato Small $10.95 | Large $15.95 * Arugula, vine-ripened sliced tomato, roasted peppers, creamy burrata, and balsamic fig glaze. I did C&P this description so everyone could see all the yummies included. I personally would ask for extra glaze when ordering.

Typical pizza place but with a separate dining room on the side. Parking in the back was a…read moresurprise. We have passed this place by for years thinking there was little parking, duh! The friendly waitress Grace promptly took our drink order and gave us time to review the menu. She brought a basket of delicious warm garlic knots and bread with both butter and olive oil balsamic dipping sauce. My husband ordered the Sunday sauce complete either pork, sausage, two large meatballs and a huge dollop of ricotta. He thoroughly enjoyed it with plenty to spare. I had the lemon cream pasta. Very rich but needing more lemon. Such a huge portion I will be enjoying it again. Great to have a local place to sit down and enjoy a casual meal

Bella Roma Restaurant & Pizzeria

3.5

(75 reviews)

Excellent pizza, beautiful atmosphere, and very personal service…read more Wonderful place, I really recommend the food is great for catering and the sit down atmosphere is wonderful. It's my go to lunch without question, the pizza is that good.

We order from Bella Roma quite often, and honestly, the food is always great. Tonight was the first…read moretime I ordered the lobster bisque (hate summer colds ). Surprisingly, especially for a pizza place, it's FANTASTIC. Thick, creamy, chunks of lobster. I'm so glad I gave it a shot over my usual bisque place! Oh, don't sleep on the Chicken Bacon Ranch pizza! Literally the best CBR on the island.

Buona Fortuna Pizza

3.1

(43 reviews)

Our goto spot for Penne and Alfredo pasta. Pizza and other items are good also. Friendly service!read more

A lot of reviews said the owners were rude and how bad customer service is. So, based on that, and…read morewanting an authentic New York experience that includes good Italian food and rude owners I headed over here. Food is great, but so too was the service. I was hoping to get cussed out or treated badly like us Texans expect of New Yorkers, and the aforementioned reviews got me excited about, and yet they were nice! Singing between taking phone orders, polite to me when I took time trying to decide what I wanted, and polite when I ordered. Oh well, at least I had great food.

Donatina Neapolitan Pizza Cafe

3.9

(210 reviews)

Good food, great service, and a classic pizza shop ambiance is how I describe Donatina's. I had the…read moreAla Vodka Spicy Pepperoni slice and the Detroit style pepperoni cup slice. Both were very good, especially the Detroit Style Pepperoni cup slice. The cheese crust, the sauce, and pepperoni was delicious. The Ala Vodka slice was really good too. The crust was decent. Great service, and great selection of pizza. Looking forward to trying the Jonny Gravone Detroit style pizza next time!

Pizzas are outstanding. So is service. A+. My husband and I are there at least 2x a weekread more

Fratellis Restaurant and Pizzeria

3.8

(13 reviews)

This is the true New York slice! I've tried every pizza in the United States and this guy !, a…read moreblock away "?, has figured it out!! While I'm making this review I'm trying to save a lil piece to post.. but I almost ate the whole pizza

Wanted so much to enjoy this pizza Went in for a few…read moreslices. Oh the crust was paper thin ( love crispy thin crust) but this was so undercooked and mushy. Needed a fork to eat the slice. The first time in my life I could not eat the crust, just too undercooked. And the slice was swimming in grease. And the end of the slice was folded over and dragged across the counter by the "chef" before being dumped on the paper plate so it needed to be cut off and tossed in the trash. Actually all 3 slices we had should have been tossed in the trash. So disappointed First time..... Last time.

Carlos Pizza - Manorville

3.9

(118 reviews)

Food is fantastic, the staff are young and rude as hell. I live in Maryland, but Im originally from…read morehere. So when I come to NY I always make sure to get some pizza while I'm here. I went here twice on my most recent trip. First time I walk in, I am looking at the pizza in the case, and I get s few awkward stares. Finally someone walks up and says "do you need help?" And I say "yeah" still deciding what I want. She said "okay.....?" And chuckled rudely as to say "spit it out" - ordered left. Rude Second time, I called in 3 pizzas. I walk in to pick them up and unfortunately I had to interrupt the girl at the counter glued to her phone. Eventually she said "need something" ... what? No greeting, enjoy, have a good day, nothing. Said the price, charged me, and walked away. $85 for 3 pizzas. Super overpriced. No customer service, way overpriced, absolutely fantastic tasting pizza though.

Absolute dog water. bbq chicken slice was dryer than a nun. even the garlic knots, just terrible…read more if i could leave zero stars i would.

Ciao Bella Pizzeria

3.8

(14 reviews)

You are welcomed with a large display of fresh baked specialty pizzas. The smell of garlic and…read morefresh sauce is in the air. Tonight I order their Famous Chicken Franchise and OMG it was fabulous. The chicken was so fresh and tender, I always get worried that I am going to get that pre-made rubbery stuff when I get chicken at a pizza place but this was high end, top choice fresh made tender finger licking good chicken. The sauce was delicious and perfectly balanced. It also came with a side of penne in the same sauce. My hubby tried the fried chicken and shrimp parmigiana and it was also unbelievably fresh and tender. The only complaint I would have is the side of bread they give you was not fabulous. It was the only thing left on the table and that's saying a lot in my family. I would love to see them pair up with Giunta's Meat Farms for the freshest most desirable bread around, in my opinion.

Cio Bella is a great pizzeria tucked away inside a mini plaza of stores. The owners are amicable…read moreand are always customer-focused. The food is prepared exceptionally well, and the pizza is cooked to perfection. Not much of a selection of good pizza in the area, so when comparing to the selected few in the area, Ciao Bella is perfect. I highly recommend a fresh pie, grilled chicken heroes, and all pasta dishes. Update: The original owners moved on and sold the establishment to new owners. The pizza is okay.. Additional updates are coming soon.....

Umberto's of Lake Grove

3.0

(204 reviews)