I want to start off by thanking Julio, the manager, and Yoji, our server, for taking such wonderful care of my family and I; the care they provided is reflective of what exemplary service looks like and is congruent with the elegant fine dining experience Yakiniku Great NYC is aiming to provide. I also witnessed the teamwork the staff had for one another, where when our server was busy and the alarm for cooking the meat went off, another staff member stepped up to help us out, which was very pleasant to see!
For the food, we opted for the 8 course at $170 plus their special, the Uni Chateaubriand. Almost every course was unique and delicious, where we especially appreciated the different flavor profiles and unique textures that different meats had; it was also fun to follow along with the illustration where each piece came from and how long to cook it. Our ABSOLUTE favorite was definitely the Enhanced Wagyu Flavor, where the sauce paired perfectly with the tender and velvety Wagyu, as well as the Wagyu Reimagined where you dip the meat in the dashi; the dashi broth is comparable in authenticity to the dashi you get from high end restaurants in Japan, where the flavor is so rich and intense without being overly salty. I'm usually not a big fan of shabu shabu because of how bland the meat is without any sauce, but this dashi made the Wagyu even more exquisite! These are as perfect as they come so please don't change these two!
Now let's talk about some minor areas I believe they can definitely address and enhance to bring out their truest potential of being one of the best Wagyu restaurants in all of NYC. Firstly, the negitoro and the Tsukune come with grated cheese on top. Both of these, plus the sweet potato and the extreme richness of the various wagyu cuts, collectively became a bit too heavy for both of us. I feel like the cheese only masked the true flavors of the Wagyu and didn't add much to the meats asides from making it even heavier than it already was. If I were to modify one of the two, I believe the negitoro was less enjoyable.
Now the biggest letdown was the star of the show, the Uni Chateaubriand add on. Although the uni was as fresh as it can be, and the chateaubriand cooked perfectly, the garlic butter soy sauce unfortunately ruined the entire dish. The sauce itself tasted like straight up salty soy sauce with no hint of butter or other condiments like mirin or sake to dilute it. Since it was dripped onto the meat, uni and rice, we didn't have a choice of just enjoying the dish by itself. Even the garlic pieces were so salty I couldn't enjoy it at all. I'm not sure if the sauce was cooked too long on the grill or if the sauce was inaccurately calibrated, but the sauce tasted like drenching the meat and rice in the soy sauce you'd get at sushi restaurants, except even saltier. Although we really appreciated Julio empathizing with us and attempted to remedy the situation by offering to remake the dish, but unfortunately since we wanted to enjoy the remainder courses to its fullest, we couldn't stomach another chateaubriand without potentially jeopardizing the remainder of the courses; I hope they understand where we were coming from.
They also have no takeout boxes, which I hope they can change, since we ordered the udon for our toddler and she didn't finish it, but we were too full to let it compromise the Wagyu courses.
Overall, we really did enjoy the eight course on its own; if we didn't order the Uni chateaubriand and spent the extra $140 for the both of us, it would have been one of the best Wagyu dining experience we ever had in all of NYC. The amount we spent would've almost covered another 8 course for one of us haha. Despite that, I want to thank everyone at Yakiniku Great for the amazing time and I look forward to another chance to come back to give them the five stars I know they are definitely able to easily achieve! I hope this helps them become the very best Wagyu restaurant in all of NYC! read more