I'm from NJ and for the longest I've been looking for a good thin pizza and this is the closest I've gotten to the best NJ pizza!!!

A great stop for a quick and cheap meal. I've been to Yaghi's twice now and the pizza has been pretty good both times! The staff is super helpful, the pizza slices are massive, and $10 gets you 2 slices and 2 drinks. Not bad! There's a TON on the menu, pasta, wings, and more, even though the shop is pretty small. There's about five or six bar seats by the window and a narrow walkway between them and the register, but that's about it. The place does however seem super popular for takeout judging by all the to-go orders they were preparing on both of my visits. Give Yaghi's a try if you're craving some pizza! They have some yummy stuff! read more

Yaghi's Pizzeria - Storefront - Pizza Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

It's the best. Love the pesto pizza. Wings are best you can get especially when you are ordering out. Get the wings sauced!! read more

Yaghi's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

Best pizza in San Antonio. So worth it and good pricing. Pizza rolls are huge . Pizza came out fast . They have little seating inside but Also have seating outside read more

Yaghi's Pizzeria - Pizza Pepperoni Rolls - Pizza Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

See all

I would come back here again to try the different pizza options. I thought the chicken pesto pizza was really unique because it tasted so different than a regular veggie lovers pizza you would get at Domino's or Pizza Hut. I really liked how Mediterranean it tasted with all the different herb flavorings, and I liked the thickness of the crust. The actual place itself is super small inside and is mainly designed to pickup your order. Service was good, and they gave me extra Parmesan and red chili flake packets when I asked. My only qualm was that I placed my pickup order for the pizza in advance and by the time I brought it home it was not even that warm anymore so I had to reheat it. I guess next time I'll place the order 15 minutes before and just say have it ready ASAP instead of selecting a later time. read more

Yaghi's Pizzeria - Chicken Pesto (Green) (18" Large) - Pizza Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

Staff was friendly -- we saw a few comments about that so wanted to make that a point in the review. It's a true 3 for now but we really want to go back a try their speciality slice, but were disappointed in the pizza we ordered. I personally didn't feel like the pizza had much flavor. I expected the meatball to have flavor, which it was just lacking. Sauce flavor can also make or break for me lol. We are going to be back to try them out for an in person review since we took this to go! read more

Yaghi's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

Our absolute favorite pizza! Every time I order yaghis, I'm nothing but 100% pleased. It's always consistent and delicious. A friend had it for the first time last night and she said it's her new favorite. Don't tell me guests, but we have to hire security, it's so dang good. read more

Yaghi's Pizzeria - My XL pepperoni and Jalapeno, my large margarita pizza, and large The Works, being guarded by my cat. - Pizza Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

Pizza was one of the best I have ever eaten. The wings were also top on my list. Will return again when visiting the San Antonio area.

AMAZING! finally found a pizzeria that serves GENUINE PIZZERIA quality pizzas. The crust was the perfect thickness and was crunchy on the bottom but soft where it should be with a perfect crust. The sauce was flavorful without being too acidic and the seasoning was PERFECTION. AND THE CHEESE!!!!!! I have struggled in vain to find a pizza joint that tastes like home - but, at last, I've found you. read more

We ordered Pizza and Bread sticks for delivery It was the worst tasted days old we had to throw it out cost us over $50 Will never try them again read more

We have heard a lot of good things about Yaghi's and wanted to give it a try so we decided to pick up some pepperoni rolls and a salad the other night for dinner. The online ordering and pickup experience was great (super fast and easy). When we got home we split up the large salad (great size to split for 2 people) and each grabbed a few rolls. The salad was pretty simple but was fresh and good quality. The rolls were still pretty warm despite our drive and the flavors were spot on. We really enjoyed the quick meal and are looking forward to swinging by for a pizza soon as well! read more

Yaghi's Pizzeria - Pepperoni Rolls (already took 1 of the 4 out of the box) - Pizza Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

Great service as soon as you walk in, little spot to sit and eat by the slice or pie, fresh and absolutely spot on if you want quality and balance. I enjoy the simplicity of the ingredients and seasonings. Haven't had this great of a pizza in a while. read more

See all

Great pizza with a friendly staff. It might be the closest to New York style in San Antonio. The only downside is they have VERY little dining space. read more

This is what you're looking for if you're looking for NY pizza. You walk in, there's a display of pizza, pick your slice wait 3 min for them to heat it and then you sit down at the limited seating on a stool and heat a hot fresh crispy NY authentic slice of pizza. Haven't been anywhere else in San Antonio that hits the vibe and gets the thinness crust sauce and flavor of pizza just right. The service isgreat too never had an issue You don't come here for take out ( you could but it's better fresh). You don't come here with a big group expecting seating and table side service. . You don't come here expecting fine dining. You come here get a quick delicious slice and go. Delicious. Salads were on point too for what you expect. read more

Yaghi's Pizzeria - Cheese - Pizza Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

This pizza is one of the best pizza places in town, if not the best! We drive almost half an hour to get their pizza. The everything pizza is really amazing and I don't typically like everything pizzas. Yaghi's is a must try in San Antonio. read more

MUST TRY!!! Stopped by before grocery shopping and WOW! Many good pizza options beyond pepperoni & cheese. Slices are large, lunch combo is a good deal. The staff is friendly, patient & helpful. I can't wait to visit again. read more

2nd time trying. 1st time wasn't great but I wanted to try one more time before I commented. Based on their reviews they earned that. Ordered to go. I'm sure it's better if you ate there but even with a 10 min drive home the crust was still crunchy which is great. Great tasting pizza. The pizza rolls were also really good and HUGE. It is a little pricey but if you can get past that it's a good pizza. Sadly I'll say there are better pizzas for less money but it's up there in terms of taste and quality. Just not my number 1. Staff is really nice and quick to get your order out. I would recommend but just know it's a lil pricey. read more

Yaghi's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

See all

Never order delivery. Delivery driver literally stole my pizza and they refused to make it right by making another pizza. TERRIBLE customer service. Stole money from me and then an employee threatened me. read more

They are definitely consistent, affordable, and tasty. The whole pizzas to go aren't any better than any other local pizza place in town, but it's a good value, and they are definitely tasty. If it's convenient for you, I would recommend going in for a slice or two. They have several options available, and they reheat them for you, which makes them nice and toasty. I recommend the veggie pizza - they are very generous with the mushrooms! #PizzaByTheSlice read more

See all

There are only 2 places in San Antonio with a slice of pizza incredibly similar to NYC. Yummmm. read more

Yaghi's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

Service is friendly. Salads are good. The slices are served piping hot. I ordered a pepperoni and olives slice and a Buffalo chicken slice and while both were good, they could've used a bit more sauce. It's hard to spot from the road but it's next to the HEB on Babcock and Huebner. The restaurant inside is small and has a windows for people watching and they have a small dining area outside if you don't mind eating outside in the heat. read more

The service was great. I was a little skeptical about the "New York Style" thing but this pizza is definitely the closest to NY pizza that I've had since moving to SA. I enjoyed it and will definitely return if I'm in that area. read more

Yaghi's Pizzeria - Cheese slice and Margherita slice. - Pizza Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

We placed an order while shopping for groceries at H‑E‑B right next door, and our pizza was conveniently ready for us and still tasted fresh by the time we got home! Our box smelled so good during the drive home! We love the yummy and crispy NY style pizza! read more

Yaghi's Pizzeria - The Works Pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

Found on Yelp and loved the appearance of their supreme meat, thin crust. I had high expectations being from the city of Chicago. However, they didn't disappoint. Pizza was perfectly arranged, hot, and we asked for well done OMG it was amazing. The cheese had amazing pull and the glorious squeak when I bit into the cheese. Food was great and service on the phonecwas a 10î. read more

I love yaghi's. I moved out of the area 8 years ago, and every now and then have it delivered for an extra long distance fee. Always worth it and delicious! read more

This place always delivers quality pizza! We love this pizza spot for a quick Togo option. They are little more pricey but you get what you pay for here! It's delicious and we love the thin crust. We always order the pepperoni with basil, can't go wrong! Our favorite is the chicken pesto, it's amazing! The service is always great and the pizza orders are quick when we order 25 mins before we head that way. Quality pizza choice and our regular spot. read more

Yaghi's Pizzeria - Chicken pesto & Pepperoni Basil - Pizza Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

This is a pizzeria like those you'd find in NYC; pies on presentation to order by the slice and options to order entire pies from the kitchen. There's a few counter-style spots to sit or stand at and a handful of double-seater tables outside (technically this means they have a patio). Slices are thin, stay formed when folded and have that great crisp. I had the works which was awesome! Great variation of toppings and this didn't make it soggy or oily. Also had the buffalo chicken which to me tasted perfect; strips of chicken laid across a very made-from-scratch sauce. To me, it tasted a lot like a vodka sauce with a bit more kick. Big fan!! Came with a little cup of ranch for dipping cause it's buffalo chicken. Got both slices to go. The reheat was great and both slices per packaged together in a single box. No overlaying on each other and was surprised they were actually put in a box versus a plate. Made it easy to travel and eat. For less than $10 you get 2-slices and a canned soda. Having only canned sodas also is a cool relation to NYC pizzerias as well. read more

We stopped in for lunch while in the neighborhood. We both had the lunch special that included a slice of pizza, a salad and a drink. The margherita pizza was delicious, but the little bread rolls in the Caesar salad may have been my favorite part of the meal. We will definitely stop by again the next time we're in the neighborhood. read more

Yaghi's is our new go-to spot for when my son is getting a haircut a couple doors down. It's a fun little place where everyone is friendly and greets you as you walk in. There's only a little bit of seating, but it truly has that city pizza shop feel. The sheer selection of the pizzas they have available just ripe for the picking as part of their lunch special is amazing - they have all the basics, but they also have some fun varieties like portobello mushroom pizza (it has red bell peppers, ricotta, and a subtle balsamic flavor), as well as a spinach and garlic chicken pizza. Two slices and a drink for less than eight dollars? Yes please! Full disclosure, the pizzas are very thin, just as the New York Style thin crust implies, but they don't skimp. My son was thrilled that this has become a staple for haircut time. read more

Been back and fourth with this place until I saw the reviews. Don't sleep on it. It's in a strip mall next to HEB but the quality? Worthy. It's NY style so nice and thin. Got two slices to eat in house. Hawaiian and feta. Both were very good but that feta was something special. Great seasoning blend. Also had 12 traditional wings (well done) tossed in honey mustard. Rich and the wings had a lot of meat. This will be a monthly stop from now on! read more

Yaghi's Pizzeria - Pizza pit stop. - Pizza Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

See all

It was suggested by a co-worker that we order pizza since we had to work late in the office. I mentioned that I was not a fan of pizza from around here. As a New Yorker, it's disappointing when ordering pizza since has a tendency to taste like cardboard. However, this pizza made me a bit nostalgic, it definitely has an enriched flavor of authentic stone baked New York taste. I will be ordering from here for our next weekly Friday night family dinner. read more

Yaghi's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

Great pizza. Have tried many things off the menu. All tasted good. Bit pricey. Would recommend to everyone. Quick service

Solid pizza. Buff chicken was great. Supreme was alright. Really great prices especially for lunch. Go if you're craving a slice.

Good pizza spot supposedly they make everything from scratch, the pizza wasn't all greasy like most places. read more

Yaghi's Pizzeria - Meat lover - Pizza Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

You know what better than croutons on a salad?!?! lil baby garlic rolls on your salad. Honestly, the baby knots keep me coming back! The food here is always so good and fresh! Got a slice of margheritta pizza today and it was delicious. Flavour, crispy crust, and packed with fresh ingredients! Service is super quick and everyone is friendly. Love sitting outside here, there isn't a lot of room for groups over 3-4 but it's perfect if you're on a solo Lunch break or just grabbing a small bite. For $7.99y you get a slice and drink here. And for $8.99 plus tax you can add on this small salad. Also got a brisk tea! read more

See all

This place looked promising. As a Jersey Native and 110% pizza snob, I got really excited when I walked into this pizzeria. There was a faint nostalgic smell. I saw the pies available and was slightly disappointed. You could tell the slices had been sitting out for a while. Not to worry, I knew the guys would reheat the slices. Then I found out the price and felt even more disappointed. Each slice is about $3.50 - $4.00. I saved my judgment on the prices until I took a bite of the slice. I was given my reheated slice and got excited again. The weight, feel, look - this slice had it all at first touch, but then I took my bite. The flavor was absolutely lacking. The dough, the sauce, the toppings. Ugh. So disappointing. Which brings me to the price. This type of slice in NY/NJ would go for $1.50-$2.00. I'm not saying this is a crappy slice of pizza, but back home it would be considered a crappy slice of pizza and you'd be okay with that because you paid $1.50-$2.00 for it. Comparing this pizzeria to the other "NY style" pizzerias in San Antonio I'd have to say this one comes the closest. This one really got my hopes up, but it turned out just okay. I'm still on the hunt for legit NY Style pizza here in SA! read more

See all

My favorite pizza in San Antonio. Their pizza rolls are very good too. I like to get pepperoni with ricotta cheese pizza rolls. It's kind of hard to choose exactly what I want each time because I like so many of their pizzas and rolls. It's a little pricey (like everything else now) but worth it. read more

Yaghi's Pizzeria - Margherita pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Antonio, Texas

Pizza rolls are delicious. Pizza itself is pretty good, a little on the bland side. Reminiscent of NY pizza but not spot on. Overall pretty good pizza. Would love to go back and try the specialty pizzas read more

Hey! Hey! HEY! my yelper BESTIES....I am BACK with another another review and you KNOW I had to try ANYONE who challenges New York Pizza....I am on my way because I miss my home SO much...so guess what?? LETS GOOOOO!!!! Ok so this place is located in a shared parking lot with non other than HEB...but it does share the space with other companiesies as well and thats a good thing. I do like that when you put a business around a big store like HEB there is always parking so that is BIG PLUS....another thing I like is being that the place can only accommodate a small amount of people you do have the option to eat outside... love that! I order the Xtra large pizza which was 1/2 cheese only with extra cheese and the other side was chicken and spinach so you KNOW I was excited....I also told the guy I traveled all the way over here to compare when you said NEW YORK STYLE...he laughed and said I wont be disappointed...ok I love when your cocky about your food but watch out because I did say I am comparing lol..I alo got a calzone just because I miss New York calzones so ok...went shopping...got my food..on the way home...LETS GO!!! Now I am going to be VERY fair...I did taste a little of home..the crust is thin and the cheese and sauce matched up...It was very tasty and I caught the vibe...the ONLY thing that I would like to see is... 1. A thicker crust...I NEED that crust...thats what makes it New York also baby! 2. A bigger pizza...There were 3 of us eating it and usually we have a couple of slices left...well everyone had 2 and to be called an Xtra Large there was nothing left...didnt seem that big... I will also say the calzone was not the best....it looked like they took a pizza and doubled it over...it was flat and not plump at all.. had very little ingredients. I think this place could REALLY become a go to BUT they need to think about the things I said and they could be A1 and then I would be back! thumbs up guys was really close! read more

See all

I had the 16" Margherita pie. It was perfectly cooked. All of the ingredients tasted super fresh. The crust was nice and thin New York style. Great undercarriage. No flop. I want to try every pizza on their menu. I just wish I lived closer. read more