Service was outstanding! I made a dinner reservation when we arrived in town after 5pm, [even though the website says reservations must be made before 5pm] and when we arrived, I was greeted by name. Waitress and bartender were very personable and helped us with our orders. Ambiance was super romantic, White tablecloths and napkins, low lighting and candles. Just the way we like it for dinner. Also, very quiet. Food was spectacular! I had surf and turf - plus the trimmings. Hubby had steak and trimmings. [I don't remember all the details because we went there in summer of 2025 - now it's Spring of 2026]. This was one of the most incredible dining experiences I've ever had - in the world! They made us feel like Royalty! I wish that WISH Steakhouse was closer to Chicago - so we could go there for all of our special occasions. read more

Bar tender was poor. Served 2 drinks and moved on to someone else. Looked back and said" oh, were you not done with I group standing next to me. Served martini in a whiskey glass and said no martini glasses despite promoting the martini on marquee. Fish over cooked and dry. Not worth promoting. I'll look elsewhere next time. Not what expect from a steakhouse they promote themselves as. read more

This is hands down the best steakhouse in the area! The steak was cooked absolutely perfect and the bartender was incredible. The best personality and very wonderful to chat with. This is the best place to go for a date night. I highly recommend the steak and the dessert. read more

See all

Absolutely in love with this place! From the very beginning of our night at wish with an amazing old fashion. The service was beyond outstanding- our server Kyle was knowledgeable about the menu and was full of energy! We started with a Caesar salad that as the best ever- tons of parmesan cheese and loaded potato soup. Dinner was the most beautiful Ribeye topped "Oscar style" with truffle fries and garlic aoli. My husband enjoyed his filet side of mushroom's dine perfect with a loaded twice baked potato. We grabbed dessert to go because we just couldn't say No! - Butterscotch Bodoni- cant wait to stop by this diamond again! read more

See all

Start with an Old Fashioned. You won't be disappointed. The drinks, food and service were impeccable. My husband and I enjoyed the lobster bisque, Ceasar salad, ribeye, picanha steak (with a twice baked potato which is just difficult to come by these days) and a mound of parmesean truffle fries with a side of aioli. Everything was prepared exquisitely and there wasn't a bad bite of anything. Our waitress was fantastic, knowledgeable and her recommendations were spot on. Our only disappointment was with ourselves at not leaving enough room to try dessert. Atmosphere was fine, nothing special; the large booths are nice. You need a reservation so plan ahead. read more

Wish - Picanha (butcher cut) with caramelized onions and twice baked potato. Background is the ribeye with loaded potato. - Steakhouses Near Me - Weston, Wisconsin

See all

First time in this area. Had dinner at Wish and it was amazing. I had a flat iron steak and it was the best one I ever had. Cooked to perfection and just the right temperature. Well worth trying, heck it is worth an hour drive to eat here. Staff was friendly, tentative and professional. Made the experience even better. read more

As amazing as the food is, the service is equally as bad. I hate that I have to give such a lackluster review because it was one of the best filets I have had in a long time - juicy, perfectly medium rare, lots of flavor, and covered in mushrooms. However, we waited for over 20 minutes in the seated bar area before anyone approached us about ordering drinks. I had to go to the nice hostess and ask her if I could get on the wait list for a table because we had not yet been helped. Only then did we get served after she told one of the wait staff. Thumbs. Down. The waitress had a bad attitude the rest of the experience and ruined the rest of the meal. Left us with a bad taste in our mouth. Overall, disappointing dining experience for what is supposed to be Wausau's best steakhouse read more

Wish - Exterior of Wish restaurant - Steakhouses Near Me - Weston, Wisconsin

See all

Wish was amazing. The only disappointment was, they took the salad option off their fish fry, which was disappointing. The menu prices are a bit higher, but the food and the atmosphere and service were outstanding. read more

Excellent food & service 3rd visit to this north-central Wisconsin supper club for a large business dinner party. Enjoyed tasty drinks in the nice bar area while waiting for our seating and then our entire 24 person gathering enjoyed a variety of delicious appetizers and entrees. Desserts were also very good for those of us who could find the room to put them down! Can't say enough about how pleased we all were with yet another excellent dinner there with our group! read more

Best steakhouse in Weston Wi. Joel and his staff do a great job. They grow their own herbs and veggies and in the summertime and the French martini is my favorite. Their cheese curds and truffle fries never let me down! On Friday I enjoyed the kale salad and salmon. I don't know how they get the salmon so crispy on top. My family loves the steaks but anytime there's a seafood special or scallops I make sure to order it. Favorite restaurant in Wausau read more

See all

Just.... FABULOUS!! I had an incredible time with my partner here this week. What a special way to celebrate our anniversary. Thank you Wish Staff! read more

Unlike other reviews, there were two employees at the hostess station. They asked if we had a reservation, which we didn't, but were seated right away. They even seated us a few minutes before their service time began. The staff were very positive and attentive. Drinks came out quickly as well as the cheese curds we ordered. The curds were quite good and the coating was somewhat different than you would get at most bars or restaurants. We all ordered a steak. Two filet, one ribeye, and one flat iron. I had the flat iron. It was cooked to medium rare as I had asked. It had a well seasoned, nice crust to it. It wasn't quite as tender as it was billed to be by our server, but it didn't lack flavor and was good. We had dessert and we all enjoyed them. A Key Lime Pie, two Tiramisu, and a Butterscotch Budino. I ordered the Budino (pudding/custard type dish) I think the place could survive by selling just this. Yes, it was that good. Now on to Yelp. Just like I am not impressed with a four or more "Best Of" award being displayed by a restaurant, I feel Yelp needs to purge reviews of over five years especially if there is a good number of recent ones. My POV is that things change and places go through various changes. Some of the reviews are even laughable due to the lack of telling the reader why they thought a place wasn't good. read more

Late on a Thursday night. Coming from out of town we had reservations. Upon arriving it seemed we didn't need them. Maybe due to the late hour. I ordered a martini and was surprised at the $11.50 price -- there was a $1.50 upcharge for Bombay Sapphire (OK) and a $2 charge for being straight up? WTF. Cost them a star. Rail old fashions are $6.00. Steaks are $29-$40 and come with a choice of potato or veggies. The steaks are dry aged up to 40 days, came rare as ordered and were excellent. Soup and salad are extra. The lobster bisque was very good. Save room for dessert and have a brandy alexander. It's large and shareable. read more

See all

Absolutely amazing! Will definitely be back! Crab stuffed mushrooms were so good! Amazing service! This is a place that wants to earn their customers, and they definitely have earned one in me! read more

Hostess crabby old lady. Service pretty slow. Nothing special food was pretty bland. For $100 plus many better choices.

My wife and I visited on a Saturday with a 7pm reservation. From the hostess to our waitress Cindy to the food everything was top notch. Cindy was friendly, checked on us, and helped us make decisions throughout the entire night. I told Cindy that I like a medium rare steak but in most places they come out pink. I like my steak red, but not rare. She introduced me to rare plus which I got on the wagyu picanha. It was perfect and like butter. I'm a convert. My wife's filet was also great. The calamari was also great not an easy get in Central Wisconsin. I loved my butterscotch budino. We've been talking about the meal all day. Well done! read more

Wish - Heart of ribeye with golden beets and wagyu picanha with a baked potato - Steakhouses Near Me - Weston, Wisconsin

See all

Wow! This place was above and beyond my expectations and is probably the best steakhouse I have been to in Wisconsin (including the larger Milwaukee area ones). We started out at the bar for some excellent drinks and service as well as the ahi tuna starter. I went with their filet mignon which was done exactly as requested and was like butter. A place they also shine is their sides which often feel like afterthoughts elsewhere - their loaded baked potato was stuffed and extremely filling. I can't wait to go back again! read more

We went here for our 16 year wedding anniversary last night and let me tell you! We had one of the BEST waiters I have ever had going to a restaurant. And the food was absolutely on point! My goodness I have never had such amazing food from a place before! And the atmosphere was so welcoming walking in . We will be back 100 percent for more thank you to our waiter who was amazing beyond belief! read more

Me and my friends had a friends' night out (if that's a thing) and the experience was quite delightful. The setting was good, staff were all friendly and helpful since it's the first time there for some of us. We had fried calamari and cheese curds for appetizers. My kale and apple salad was phenomenal. My prime sirloin got done right, melt-in-the-mouth medium rave. If it's not for the sautéed mushrooms being too salty (hence 4 star), it would be one of the best steak I have ever had. If you're into steak, fed up with Texas road house and willing to shed a few extra bucks for a premium steak, it's totally worth it to give Wish a try. Texas Roadhouse bread is still better ;) in case you wonder. read more

See all

On a Tuesday evening. No hostess to greet, but a sign pointed to the bartender, who we could not find for 5 minutes or so.. Once seated, the service was awesome. The prime sirloin was perfect as was the chicken breasts. All in all a great meal, very fair prices, good portions and great atmosphere. read more

Just not up to par for a high-end steakhouse. From the tasteless lobster bisque, tough and overcooked Waygu steak special, to the wine list that actually has 14 hands by the bottle, just falls short. Atmosphere was nice which was the highlight of the night. I hope this establishment can improve to make this a viable option for our area. read more

Always great food and service! It's a hidden gem in our area. Love the lobster bisque soup!

Excellent food, great service. Wonderful place for a special occasion. I would go more frequently if I could afford it!

The food here is amazing. Table of four, everyone was super happy with their orders which were all cooked perfectly.

Great Place would recommend to try rib eye awesome taste .... Service was excellent.. would try clean an friendly place out of the way but easy to get too read more

Great food and service! Loved the quiet and peaceful atmosphere as well. Will definitely be returning in the future for special occasions with my fiancée. read more

Wonderful meal! Ate at bar. Great bourbon selection. Terrific steak, brussel sprouts with bacon and maple syrup, along with a smoked salmon appetizer that great! Service from bartender Sydney was top notch. Great place. Will be back! read more

Food was great! I got the special of the day which was a 6 oz sirloin with crab on top! Baked potato was pretty average, but still good. The Mile High Chocolate Cake was a very good dessert that could feed the whole table! My waiter, Kyle, was the absolute best. This review would have been a 4/5 but he made it 5. Needs a raise! A bit pricey but not unfair. Highly recommend! read more

Stopped in on a business trip. Had the filet dinner and desert were great. Bar area was nice. Will be back.

Ha! High prices for crap food, and that's if the server doesn't ignore you. Another bust for area restaurants.

In what was seemingly the middle of nowhere Wisconsin, Yelp helped me find this great restaurant. I suspect it might deserve 5 stars but I didn't get a chance to try enough of the food to really feel I should give it 5. I had some soup - delicious! and one of those soups that makes you think, "Really? Those go together?" Well they did! Also had a a small steak, very tasty, and the sides, let's see. I can't remember what they were now 10 days later, but I remember they were very good. Something with ... doggone it! I just can't remember now! But anyway, if you're in Schofield, Wisconsin, I absolutely insist you go to Wish if you'd like a great meal, and it appeared that they had a good selection of wine and beer. read more

Wish - View from - Steakhouses Near Me - Weston, Wisconsin

We were there last weekend. We both had the ribeye, which was prepared well. Likely the best I've had in town, although there are perfectly fine steaks to be had at other places for less. Didn't care much for the mashed potatoes, as they seem to be heavy on butter and very light on other dairy. The asparagus was heavy on oil, but very good. Nice beer and wine selection. If you like a good ribeye and don't care about the price, this is the place. read more

Good meal however the portions were a little small for the price. Desserts are excellent the Budino and creme brûlée. Will go order out again. read more

This is a fabulous place for a quiet, and relaxing dinner. We started our evening with a bottle of wine and the calamari appetizer, it was brought to our table hot and the aroma of the sauce set the stage for a delicious start. The wait staff was very attentive but we never felt rushed. We both chose the steak specials which were on mark, hot, juicy and done to perfection, every bit was better than the last. I can't say enough about this fine restaurant, we will definitely be going back. read more

When you pull into the parking lot On a Dimly lit evening it doesn't look like much but the food and service are out of this world. Beer selection is really very good as well with something for everyone. Say in the bar and had a quiet dinner. With great service. read more

First time tuck WiSH and it didn't disappoint! I made reservations on opentable.com and put in a note that was pour wedding anniversary. The hostess greeted us with a "Happy Anniversary." The bar area was nicely updated and the dining room had a nice, private layout. Husband ordered ribeye, while I'm picky and the chef accommodated a special chicken pasta order. The cheesecurds were the best we've had in the area. Plus, half-price bottles of wine in Mondays! Oh, and free ice cream or sherbet on your birthday or anniversary! Well done, WiSH, well done! read more

See all

We've been to Wish twice since moving to the area, the first time while looking for a house and then most recently for my wife's birthday. It is fantastic! It's almost as good as Cattleman's Steakhouse in Fabens, TX. The first time there I had the filet and it was cooked perfect and melted in my mouth. This time I decided to try their chicken parmesan since it was their special for the night...it was amazing! Especially for being a steakhouse. I went with a cup of lobster bisque and my wife had the soup of the moment (can't remember which one), and they were both amazing. We will definitely be spending far too much money on this restaurant in the future! read more

This place was mediocre at best. I got the 12 Oz ribeye. The meat was cooked well, medium rare, which is a plus. That being said, there was very little seasoning added and was a pretty bland. The fries were pretty much generic frozen fries. I even had a clump that was frozen together and then cooked in a clump. Ended up being cold in the middle. I gave them an extra star because the salad was really good. I got the one with the blue cheese crumbles. The service was fairly standard, nothing special. They do have a free wifi. The building is nice and cozy too. Overall, save your money, go to Texas roadhouse. For the same price as a single meal l, you can feed your wife and have money left over, and have a better tasting steak. Happy eating. :) read more

The food was fantastic. Service was great!!! Atmosphere was comfortable. Read a few negative reviews but completely disagree with them. Would recommend it to most anybody. read more

My wife and I have been there twice now. The first time there it was extremely busy. It was a winter's night and a big group was there. And our order took forever. We got a free dessert for our wait. Tonight, a summer evening, it was quieter and the service very good to excellent. The ambiance is very nice. It's a very comfortable place to eat. The couple we were with liked their food as did we but none of us would rave about it. I had lobster bisque: very good. My entree was grilled tuna served on a bed of spinach. It was OK. There was a serving of rice that was very plain. None of the entrees at our table were presented in an inspired way. My dessert: a hot fudge "Sunday" was excellent. I will return there only if I have a hankerin for a big steak. read more