Sweet little stationary shop with unusual greeting cards, paper, and gifts. Don't miss the sale…read morebasket outside on the porch- it's next to the door and I didn't see it until I walked out. They also have a nice selection of pens!

This is my go to store for fabulous unique gifts. We ordered my daughter's wedding invitations here…read moretoo. Absolutely stunning invites and Mel's attention to detail was the best. I recommend this shop to everyone

This is a lovely Peconic Bay treat. I go to the North Fork every summer and forgot to get the…read moreweekend hostess a gift. Thank God for Phoebe & Belle! They have a range of items so I was able to put together a great package and the store packaged it beautifully so it looked like it wasn't a last minute gift. Definitely going back to snag some items for myself.

They have the best curated collection of home goods. I always stop by when in the area. Kathy is…read moreamazing and really helped bring my vision for my home to life. She helped me pick out the perfect items.

I went in here looking for the perfect gift for a coworker. Unfortunately I didnt find what I was…read morelooking for but heres what i did find. Beautiful unique gifts and an awesome showcase of chocolate truffles. The cashier was friendly made sure she greeted and said goodbye to every customer and i would definitely return

The Whalebone is amazing! They not only have the friendliest staff but an amazing array of gifts…read morefor any occasion!!! They have holiday gifts, great items to remember the quaint hamlet they lie in, handcrafted gourmet chocolates and so much more!!! Stop in for a card or balloons or even a Sunday newspaper!!!

A very cute store with a great selection. Staff was very kind and helped my 7 year old find several…read morebooks that he was interested in.

I believe in putting my money where my mouth is. I avoid making purchases on "A----n" as I believe…read morein supporting and therefore shopping and supporting brick and mortar stores for everything I can including books. I discovered Burtons Bookstores on a visit to Greenport about three years ago and have been ordering all my books from Burtons ever since. Scott is always accommodating and I receive my order by mail in a few days or in week if it has to be ordered from the publisher. He even gift wraps the purchase , includes a note and sends it directly to the recipient of my gift. Gail J.

This is the nicest used bookstore I've ever visited. It's charming, clean and very well organized…read more Happens to specialize in all the topics that interest me - art, photography, poetry, fiction. Lovely owner. Couldn't be better. If you love used books, be sure to visit here!

Ok. So why the 5 stars for a bookstore? Because it simply ROCKS, that's why!…read more Here's what happened: Was across the street at Shelter Island Craft Beer Company sampling their wares (see separate review ;)) Noticed a book store across the street. WHA...? How could an independent bookstore survive on insular Shelter Island when a shit ton of other indies, and even mega-book depots like Borders, have been shuttering? We just had to check it out. Plus, we saw some woman with a Boston Terrier the same type of breed we own) either enter the store or perhaps the adjoining house so that sealed the deal for us. I wasn't expecting much: I thought it would be piles and piles of books culled from flea markets and yard sales. Far from it. Though the selections are limited, it is a well-curated store. I, for one, was in awe of the small shelf dedicated to chess books. There were several first editions, one dating back to 1866! And, of course, clocking in at $400, was something that was a joy just to hold! Several other shelves held rare and 1st edition children's books. Stuff you maybe don't want your toddler fondling but maybe something to gift to the Grands to read from over the holidays. In the front was a glass case with books from Alllistair Crowler. A tad creepy for me but hey! It IS Black Cat Books after all. They had some comics and actual pulps in protective covers. We did not go upstairs (I don't know why. It's not like we were in a rush or anything) but it seemed they had CDs and actual vinyl to boot! The whole place was light and relaxing. Comfortably cooled on this warm, late summer day, there were multiple seating options that invited you to take a load off and maybe peruse your selection before purchasing. In small, work areas behind the stakcs and near some of the shelves were many other books labelled for placement. many looked VERY old. I was dying to get my mitts on them just to see what they were. But that would be rude. I mean, it's not like I'm going to find an original King James in here, (Or will I?) Where do they GET this stuff? What WAS missing (unless it escaped me) were periodicals. No newspapers or mags which was actually refreshing. The place was FOCUSED. This is where you come to find good, rare books. This place is out-of-the-way for the rest of us Long Islanders. It takes me a good hour to get to Greenport proper and then a $20 roundtrip ferry ride to Shelter island (car, driver, passenger). But I have to say, it's damned worth it, especially if you are into books. Take a ride out there early. Find that gem (or three). Carefully wrap them in a blanket and secure them under the seat of your car. Hit multiple wineries and a craft beer joint on the way home. Gloat over your score. It makes for a great, great day! Cheers!

Speechless. Amazing place. Owners have keen eyes for design. Worth a trip to the North Fork just…read moreto visit.

Just a really awesome place to browse. You'll find something amazing every time!read more

Wow, pure class is found here at S&M. Simply amazing…read more A must stop if you're in Sag Harbor. Elegance finds its way here. Not a prettier setting to get delicious cold brew coffee or afternoon delight with Rose`. Delicious treats and pies. Great outdoor space. Jewelery, dresses, trinkets and more can be found next door. High end. And now a historical 2 floor sleepover suite accommodations are a beautiful stay. I highly recommend.

If you wanna vibe then this is the place for you but when we talk about how good the coffee was? It…read morewas alright. I got the latte for $7 and it taste like a regular coffee. The place is pretty though. It has a garden that you can chill while drinking your coffee with lots of colorful flowers. Its also connected to a cute botique and that was fun to check while drinking my coffee. This place have a lot of potentials but just really need to improve their coffee.

A nice little shop with some great toys and unique gifts. The ladies that run the store were…read morefriendly and helpful. They wrapped our birthday gift and we felt like the store has an old world charm. Not sure why there are some negative experiences list, but if you come in with an attitude it will not be tolerated and rightfully so! It is the Hamptons so the prices reflect the environment. I would make this shop a regular destination when walking on Main Street.

So rude! Walked in holding a coffee (that had a lid) and was rudely told to step out OR place my…read moredrink in the "drink basket" while I shopped. As if! I am so shocked that you would ask a grown adult to leave a TOY STORE because they have a drink. I walked in a number of other clothing stores for that matter and was not asked once to leave because of my drink. Do they seriously expect me to leave my drink unattended in a "drink basket". These women are crazy. Didn't read the other reviews until after the fact but this place doesn't deserve any business if you ask me! My mom decided to shop around a little and they were even rude to her when she asked simple questions about items for sale. NEVER going here again.