(The last time I was in Rahway?  A college field trip to the prison for a class 'History of Punishment' - but that's a blog post sometime in the future over on Medium.) Yelp tipped me off about this place so right before Christmas I ventured down to snag their novelty 'Pierogi Soap on a Rope' (stocking stuffers for the Polish in-laws!) and of course I couldn't leave without at least trying a few of their actual edible items. "Polish Happy Meal" (great name geared towards us Americans, huh?) - killer.  A hearty (sliced) link of kielbasa with three (delicious) pierogi with little containers of horseradish & shredded beets (along with a slice of rye bread) and a side (of course we went with their [homemade] pickles). The Mrs. (from Gdańsk and snooty about her Polish grub) was deliriously giddy with her meal and deemed it, "5 stars!" - who am I to argue?! "Apple Pie-rogi" (I'm definitely digging their marketing department!) - although they recommend to fry in butter (the only way the Poles believe a pierogi can be cooked!) I opted to just bake them without any added fat (much to the chagrin of the Mrs.) but it was still a perfectly delicious morsel. The joint is wheelie small (sorry, I couldn't help myself) - just a tiny window to "grab 'n go" from the workers. Crew behind the sliding glass window - very cool. Pricing - more than fair for the portion size. You bet your dupa I highly recommend this place. read more

I ordered through GrubHub on Friday 7/12 and Sunday 7/14 when Wheelie Good Pierogies was shown to be open. In both cases, my order had to be cancelled because the shop was not open. I was so disappointed because I read the reviews and they're great. I love pierogies. So bummed. I wonder if they're closed for good? read more

While spending all day cleaning my room I decided to reward all my hard work with some pierogis. I ordered the Bacon potato and Cheddar Cheese pierogis and the Blueberry and Cheese Pierogis. The bacon potato and cheddar ones were good, cooked well, however I thought they were mediocre, could've used a good sauce they were a bit dry. Howeverrrr, the blueberry and cheese ones were sooooo good! The sweet cheese with the blueberry was the most perfect combination that I've never seen before with a pierogi. I could probably eat those everydayyyy if I didn't care about my figure loll read more

See all

I'm kicking myself for not trying Wheelie Good Pierogi sooner!! Delicious pierogis served in small or large orders - perfect for a quick lunch. I love their dessert options. I cannot wait to come back and try The "My Girlfriend is Not Hungry" special and bring back a batch of frozen pierogis to serve later for dinner. Fast service. Great pricing. Delicious food. read more

Wheelie Good Pierogi - DELICIOUS potato and onion pierogis with Nutella dessert pierogis to-go. - Polish Near Me - Rahway, New Jersey

There are 3 things on this menu that YOU have to have but get ready because A. You're about to have a new favorite place to order from and B. It's so good you might cry soooo, if you're about to eat this in public then get your sunglasses because this will be an experience! You have to get the 1. Stuffed cabbage (these guys aren't serving monster sized stuffed cabbage which is most commonly all rice and no flavor. This place is ALL flavor and it hits your heart and tears will fall!) 2. If you're a manly man like myself, then you probably don't want to be eating Nutella pierogi in public, save those for later and get yourself some Buffalo Chicken Pierogi because you're a rockstar with exceptional taste like the chef that created this soul touching snack! And 3. Get yourself the chicken bacon ranch meal and forget about life. Be present. Enjoy this holy meal because you'll be hearing angels singing their highest notes when you bite into this heavenly goodness. I'm only writing about 3 things because honestly, your tastebuds can't handle the rest of this menu so enjoy it slowly and order EVERYTHING at least once because your body is your temple and these meals bring you closer to Jesus! Hallelujah !! read more

Wheelie Good Pierogi - Stuffed Cabbage and Hot Buffalo Chicken Pierogi Pardon the mess of my home, I didn't care to clean because I was hangry - Polish Near Me - Rahway, New Jersey

See all

I grew up on potato & cheese and sweet cheese pierogis so I was very excited when Wheelie Good Pierogi opened in Rahway. After the first taste, I began racing on 287 from Basking Ridge trying to make it down in time to get my fix. The owner is very kind and knowledgeable, as well as the staff. A lot of thought goes into the flavors. These are the absolute best pierogis I have tasted. So far I have tried the sweet cheese (by the dozen), potato & cheese, buffalo chicken and the limited edition Thanksgiving pierogi. My mother and I intend to try the spinach and feta cheese pierogi this weekend. Right now it's super easy to call ahead and pick up at the window (contactless). read more

I couldn't wait to get back and try each flavor. Buffalo chicken, apple, roasted garlic, potato cheese, potato onion pierogi. Kielbasa too. NJ has a lot of polish food, but not the pierogi variety like Wheelie Pierogi does. Amazing flavors is all I have to say! You don't see buffalo chicken quite often, and this flavor became my favorite. Restaurant was smaller than I thought, but I only got my food as takeout this time. Staff were splendid and nice. read more

This place makes really good pierogis. With that said, there are a few downsides thst prevent me from eating there more often: 1) They have odd hours and you can't get lunch every day. 2) There is no seating. It's takeout only, which really sucks in the winter. 3) They only deliver if you have Grubhub, so forget trying to order for an office if you work nearby. But if you can manage to get there during business hours, try the standard potato and cheese with bacon topping. read more

Wheelie Good Pierogi - Menu on wall - Polish Near Me - Rahway, New Jersey

From the delicious homemade Pierogis- to the ranch drizzle and garnished chives, this place is heavenly! Both the pierogi and kielbasa are immaculate, it's not over nor under cooked. The size portion is fair and the price is very affordable. Staff was friendly, and quick to answer the phone, tender the order and check me out. I ordered the polish happy meal with chicken, bacon & ranch pierogis- it came with a side of sour cream, spicy mustard, rye bread & beet salad. It was fulfilling and more than satisfying. The food tastes so fresh and authentic, there's no doubt in my mind the dough is freshly rolled out. It's location however is tricky. It's tucked between two buildings- so you must pay attention, it's easy to miss. Once you get there it'll be easy to find for the second time. They're open 3 days a week- which is fine! This builds up the anticipation to place my order on Friday's !!! The food was so good I ended up ordering twice, on the same day, within the hour. Ugh! So worth the wait. I strongly advise you stop and try them out this weekend ! Cheers read more

Wheelie Good Pierogi - Polish Happy Meal - Polish Near Me - Rahway, New Jersey

Absolute best pero goes hands down. No matter which way you get them they are fantastic.

I had a craving for stuffed cabbage - Yelp let me to Wheelie Good....was expecting a sit down restaurant - it's not - take out only. Young lady at counter couldn't have been nicer - Cabbage was solid, and, since I was there - had to try the pirogi (although I'm not a fan of them....). As pirogi go, they were good.....Would definitely be back if i lived in the area read more

Wheelie Good Pierogies is so good! We tried a few polish delis in the area, and they are all good, but we think Wheelie is the best for pierogies and stuffed cabbage! We really love their stuffed cabbage, it is the closest to how my family makes it, so delicious! we so appreciate having a great place where you can taste the love and dedication they put into delivering exceptional food! read more

I'm Polish. 100% Polish. I was Miss Polonia 1999. My point is- I know my Pierogi. Wheelie Goood Pierogi remind me of my Mom's Pierogi. Thin dough, perfectly flavored filling and appropriate size and shape. They are authentic. I saw the hands of an angel place those little pillows of happiness on a tray. I've ordered twice now. I ordered them for Wigilia. I've tried, potato and cheese, potato and onion, mushroom and kraut, blueberry, roasted garlic and Nutella. My favorite mushroom/kraut and blueberry. Nutella was a huge hit with my boys. They ate half a dozen at pick up! We love it! You will too! Smacznego!! read more

Love the pierogi from here! today we tried out the buffalo chicken ones for the first time, and they are definitely a new favorite! Would recommend this place to any pierogi lover! read more

Wheelie Good Pierogi - a variety of food items - Polish Near Me - Rahway, New Jersey

Let's dive right in. Wheelie good pierogi is just what Rahway needed! Locals love pierogis and it's about time they had a decent place to buy them. WGP offers traditional fare such as- potato, potato and cheese. As well as specialty and dessert flavors. My favorites were the breakfast pierogi and the Nutella pierogi. They serve them fried, boiled, and frozen. (And I believe they also do catering) No seating so plan a walk around Irving street while you enjoy your delicious pierogi. The inside was decorated with pictures of pierogi and polish pride Tchotchkes, very fitting! I noticed they also had a take out window, when I asked about it they said they hope to be open late night during events to serve pierogi out of the window. All in all, definitely check this place out! It's my new go to spot for pierogis. read more

We had a family emergency this Christmas were we learned our relative who usually makes the pierogis would not be able to make it. Not wanting 10 hungry relatives angry, I reached out to Christina who made us 12 dozen pierogis quickly and for a good price. She saved Christmas for sure, although now I think her pierogis will cause some drama because people liked them better than my relative's pierogis :) read more

I love this place. The pierogis are so good and fresh. The onions they give compliment the pierogis so well.

I lived in Poland for over 6 years and tasting some of these pierogies definitely made me nostalgic! You come into this cute place to polish music playing and such friendly staff! My new place for when I feel like having a little piece of Poland! read more

Wheelie Good Pierogi - Hot Mushroom, Kraut and Onion Pierogi Hot Potato and Cheese Pierogi Hot BPC Pierogi - Polish Near Me - Rahway, New Jersey

Okay first time trying this place out and it was amazing! Food was fresh, cooked quickly and tasted delicious! If you are looking for your traditional pierogi spot with a little flare. This is it! There is variety of creative flavors that make you want to come to and try everything! I will for sure be coming back to this place as it was delicious. read more

See all

Recently we ordered a few dozen pierogies and polish sausage for my boyfriend's birthday party and it was a huge hit! Well worth the cost and probably some of the best pierogies I've ever had! Especially the roasted garlic. It was so simple, but also just perfect fried up in onions and butter. The fact they offer online ordering in advanced made the whole catering process really simple. Staff there are super nice too. They even offered to help me carry my order to the car. Definitely will be ordering for parties in the future. read more

Ordered catering for about 15 people. Food was great and the perfect amount (didn't know how much to order and the suggestions were a great help)! Christina was very helpful letting me pick up the food early before they were open which was a huge help. Pierogi and kielbasa was delicious... Would recommend and will definitely go back read more

I am born and raised in Poland and these remind me of the ones my family makes. We ordered 16 dozen pierogies for ourselves and friends and family and they were absolutely delicious. The traditional cheese and potato, sauerkraut and mushroom tasted were absolutely delicious. We also tried the buffalo which were great! She also has grilling kielbasa which our entire family really enjoyed. If you want homemade yummy pierogies, this is your place. The owner is also very friendly and accommodating. read more

Excellent pierogi! There is a great variety of flavors to choose from. Staff is friendly and professional. Definitely check this place out! read more

Wheelie Good Pierogi - Logo - Polish Near Me - Rahway, New Jersey

..... this place is wheelie wheelie good! My favorite is the Kielbasa Sandwich ! On the money! Oh and the potato bacon & cheddar Pierogi and they have breakfast pierogis too!! Taking a bag a frozen ones home to the family next visit!!! read more

It's all in the name! They are wheelie good! We keep going back for the buffalo Pierogis. The staff is friendly and the interior is clean and well decorated. read more

Wheelie Good Pierogi - Hot Buffalo Chicken Pierogi - Polish Near Me - Rahway, New Jersey

See all

If your are craving something different and amazing this is the spot. The Pierogis are amazing!!!!!! Not only the pierogis but EVERYTHING. The kielbasa had so much flavor and the stuffed cabbage is some of the best I have ever had. My wife and I tried it all. The Buffalo chicken was delicious but I had to say my favorite (maybe because I have a sweet tooth)was a tie between the Nutella and cornbread. I just couldn't decide both cooked to perfection. Everything was perfect and the hospitality here was second to none. The owner was very attentive and definitely showed how passionate she was about her restaurant. We definitely will be back. I cannot wait !!!!! read more

The pierogis were amazing. I ordered the mushroom, sauerkraut & onion, the bacon, potato & cheese, the buffalo chicken, the potato & cheese, the Nutella and the blueberry. Every single one was delicious. I could have eaten about 20 of those Nutella pierogis. As soon as we were done eating, my fiancé said "I want more, go back!" read more

Wheelie Good Pierogi - Polish Near Me - Rahway, New Jersey

My Favorite Pierogies were the Cornbread Soufflé, Blueberry and Cream Cheese and The Buffalo Chicken Definitely should give them a go

I'm Polish so naturally I'm extremely picky about pierogis - when I say these are the best I've ever had I do not make that statement lightly. We saw this cute little pierogi place in downtown Rahway and on a random Thursday night decided to take some out for a treat. We got spinach & feta, mushroom, potato & cheese and blueberry. I was blown away by just how fresh all of the pierogis were. The blueberry especially were absolutely out of this world. Classic potato and cheese was exactly how an authentic Polish pierogi should taste. We are hoping we can take out more pierogis for holidays such as Easter and Christmas Eve when our family has pierogis. Please please please try the blueberry - they are phenomenal! read more

Phenomenal. This is authentic polish cuisine and it's sooooo good. I got the kielbasa with the bacon and cheese pierogis OMG tastes home cooked. read more

Great pierogis, wide selection, taste great. Best stuffed cabbage in gravy ever. Fast service, easy online ordering and quick pickup. Will be back. read more

Stopped by one night and ordered the buffalo chicken and the BCP (6 of each). I'm not a huge potato fan but these were pretty good. They were flavorful and filling. The hostess was pleasant and willing to answer our questions. We will be back to try the dessert options. read more

I called just as they were closing. The most extremely pleasant and nice girl that answered took my order anyway. When I arrived I was greeted with much happiness. I ordered 3 each of 4 different kinds. Potato and cheese, potato and onion , roasted garlic and potato and bacon cheese and potato. My daughter and I enjoyed them very much. Our favorite out of the four was the roasted garlic and potato. The potato and onion was great also. Some of the best pierogis I've had in awhile. I will definitely be back soon and often. If you haven't tried this place yet you are definitely missing out on some Wheelie Good Pierogis. read more

Ordered takeout last week for the first time from here & the food was really good. The fried garlic pierogis were delicious but the 3 stars is because for what it was and the portions we got, it was unnecessarily expensive. read more

Whoa, this place is the real deal... The traditional pierogi are truly authentic (I'm Polish so you can trust what I say), as is the stuffed cabbage which is quite possibly the best I've had (second best in case grandma is reading this...) I usually stick to the traditional flavors, but I have to say that the specialty pierogi I've tried here are excellent... especially the breakfast flavor. Imagine a killer Jersey breakfast stuffed into a pocket of fried dough. Yeah, they are that good. I'll be back to try some of the other flavors (and the kielbasa sandwich) very soon. The staff is super nice, and the place is very cozy (keep in mind there is no table seating so this is primarily a take out joint). Keep up the good work and see y'all soon! read more

I thought they were good initially but then i called earlier this week Monday it may have even been Saturday to see if I can place an order AND NEVER HEARD BACK FROM THEM UNTIL JUST NOW DEC 23rd! At 4 pm letting me know they r only open for another hr!!!! Obviously I won't be able to make it down there so I'm scratching this pierogi place off my list they're nowhere near like my mom's homemade pierogies anyway so no sweat off my back!!! But if u want to stay in business especially in Rahway for chrissake check your messages And get back to your clients ASAP!!!! otherwise they will never order from you again like me!! read more

Tried this place on a whim and I'm hooked now. I've had the kielbasa sandwich, the Buffalo chicken perogie and the blueberry and cheese perogie and everything I had was delicious. The buffalo chicken wasn't too overpowering or spicy like some places can be and the blue cheese was good quality. My boyfriend has had the bacon, cheese potato perogies and the roasted garlic and (for once) agreed that it was great. The owner is really sweet and you can tell she takes pride in her food and it's ingredients. Basically, it's all made with love! read more

Wheelie Good Pierogi - Buffalo Chicken perogie - Polish Near Me - Rahway, New Jersey

See all

Was so delighted to find this little shop after my 20 mi trail race in the area! It was the perfect refueling I needed. I split an order of 6 and did 3 potato-onion and 3 potato roasted garlic. So delicious and the girl that took my order (maybe owner) was very helpful and sweet! I definitely recommend and when I am in the area again I will be sure to stop! Got some blueberry ones for dessert too : ) I loved the pierogi gifts available too! read more

Tried WGP since we were in the area and I love pierogi. We decided on a few types , bacon cheddar were excellent , Buffalo chicken not to be missed , potato and cheese excellent as well, mushroom needed a bit more seasoning . Kielbasa was very good as well. We will definitely be back to continue to explore the rest of the menu . read more

Is the plural of Pierogi pierogies? Sweet cheese Pierogi, what a hidden gem. Will be back for more.