Ordered a Hamburger with caramelized onions on it. I ordered it online and picked it up in store. Meat was soft and tender. Very good burger. read more

See all

Worst service I've experienced in a long time. Restaurant was not busy, and they still took 40 minutes to bring me a milkshake... Definitely won't be back. read more

Wayback Burgers - CINNAMON TOAST CRUNCH MILKSHAKE - Burgers Near Me - Evans Mills, New York

We decided to try this place today and it did NOT disappoint. We were greeted by Matt who was so kind, patient with our menu explanation and he made suggestions based on preferences we mentioned. He offered to upsell us on different products but wasn't abrasive when we rejected. We ordered a Rodeo Burger with Mac and Cheese bites and a Salted Caramel Shake and a Cheesy burger with jalapeños and Cajun tots. The mac and cheese bites were SO gooey and good! The cheesy burger was this pregnant girls dream. The Cajun tots with chipotle Mayo had me wishing for more later this evening. Based on both service and food I'd absolutely recommend this place to a friend! read more

Wayback Burgers - CHEEEESY BURGER add jalapeño with Cajun Tater Tots - Burgers Near Me - Evans Mills, New York

See all

Burgers are always fresh, people are generally friendly, but it seems the tables are normally messy. It's a great place for a quick fresh burger and shake. I've never had anything here that I didn't like, even the things I've tried that I wasn't sure I'd like. Give it a try! read more

Door Dash has ruined the Wayback experience. I love Wayback burgers and their fries. But now, thanks to the pandemic, the store is clogged with delivery people waiting for their orders. Even though we the only ones in line to place an eat-in order, it took twenty five minutes to get our food. And the toppings were all wrong, but we had already waited so long we just ate what they brought us. And apparently none of the employees are tasked with emptying the garbage. On the plus side, we saw someone who looked exactly like Steve Perry of Journey. read more

Wayback Burgers - Overflowing garbage. - Burgers Near Me - Evans Mills, New York

The burgers were good, but I think it is way too expensive for what you get. I enjoyed the meal, but the customer service was bad.

Honestly, everything is dry and underflavored. Go to a local joint instead. Or even McDonald's

I love this place, I have celiac disease and I can't have bread and I asked if they could wrap my burger in lettuce instead and without any hesitation they said for sure and did it right up for me. I love it food was fresh and juicy can't get much better than that! read more

The food is made fresh to order and tastes amazing. I got just a good ol burger, fries, and a milkshake and was full. The guy working the register was real cool and friendly as well. And the inside is very nice and clean and overall pretty cool read more

I would like to start by saying that this is not my first time here, I've been here a handful of times and each time is the same. Slow. This last time I waited as the only one in line for 10 minutes before someone took my order. The wait for food is even longer upwards of 30 minutes for a single persons meal (sandwich, side, and drink). Also, they seem extremely unorganized as they had to ask me multiple times which order was mine. I will say though, their shakes and chicken sandwiches are quite good. The food is the only reason I go through the wait. read more

Good service good food friendly people The girl who took my orders name was Kendra she was quick and friendly and had some good suggestions for what to get when I wasn't certain They told me about their rewards program which actually has some really awesome benefits such as free food everyone and again also I had just got off work and walked in 15 min to close they made everything fresh and were just overall awesome read more

went there and took 10 mins just to order the food (even though no one was in front of me). As I was waiting 3 people got their food before me even though they ordered after me. I waited almost 30-40 mins just for my food and it was sitting there all along. When I started eating the food was alright. I would've rather went to McDonald's or Dairy Queen before I go here again. It is definitely over-hyped. Other then the workers dilly dallying the ambiance was fine. But I will not be going here again. read more

We voted from this place twice and both times things were missing from my order. My daughter doesn't like to follow up so we went without onion rings one time and another time we went without two orders of french fries. the one thing I will say is that the burgers themselves are cooked perfectly and they were so good a little messy which is wonderful and my son's french fries I think they were loaded looked really good too and he enjoyed them. I will order the next time and if anything is missing I will follow up with it but if you want a really good burger cooked perfectly try this place read more

The best fucking burger I've ever fuckin had Jesus Fuck EAT HERE it's very good and the staff are very nice and helpful especially Kendra she's the fucking best read more

First time eating here and the cheese fries and nachos was completely horrible. most people think liquid cheese when it comes to cheese fries and nachos not to mention that i could get a better tasting burger at Five Guys in watertown. The burgers here are plain and no seasoning. read more

The food is great, but they have gotten my order wrong more than once. Additionally, they can get very busy and are a bit slow. I went during lunch once and was waiting for my burger and fries for well over an hour. Good food, but I wouldn't recommend going during rush hours unless you don't mind a wait read more

This review is strictly for food because we ordered curbside in light of the current pandemic. Order: Rodeo burger (6.99) Double bacon burger (7.99) Cheese fry (5.99) Root beer (2.29) Hibiscus lemonade (2.29) Everything we ordered was correct and the person giving us our food was very polite, as they ran out of the drink I ordered beforehand and he called and gave me a new one. The two burgers ordered were good and I believe were worth the price, however, the cheese fry was literally heated up fry's probably microwaved with cheddar and a few sprinkles of bacon that I could've got at Walmart. They were not worth the price. The root beer was very good, but the lemonade was not in my opinion, it tasted like watered down juice. read more

I come back to this region about once a year (the region, not Wayback) and last time I was here I was satisfied with my order. Maybe it was due to the pandemic or just a different staff, but THIS time I was thoroughly disappointed. It started with the fact they got my order wrong in an exaggerated way. I ordered a single cheese, lettuce/pickle/tomato/shrooms and grilled onions. LUCKILY I'm staying right next door at the Candlewood. Got to my room and checked the burger? No grilled onions, no shrooms. I walked back in and opened the sandwich for them. Their first reaction was, "we can put some one for you?" Um, no. The burger is cold now. I would like a new burger. Didn't get an apology or verbal acknowledgment that they did wrong but she tells the prep person behind her, "That's another one missing stuff they ordered." Another? Then she asked me if I would like bacon on the burger. No. "Bacon" doesn't give me my time back, which is the reason for going to a fast food establishment. I got my burger, the correct way, but it was so blah I almost wished I got a refund. How, when not busy at all, you can't get a simple order right? How are you having multiple orders a day apparently (conjecture on my point) that is missing items? The only reason I am providing 2-stars and not 1 is because they didn't give me a hard time for their mistake. read more

This was my first time at a Wayback Burger joint. I understand these are not regular times. This location is in a desperate need for a deep cleaning. The burgers were the best part but the sides limped in as they were injured in battle soaked with grease and half cooked. Both the fries and the tots hit the garbage as they were inedible. The burger is the only thing that might get me to try a second time. It was cooked perfect and put together well. read more

Wayback Burgers - Strip Mall - Burgers Near Me - Evans Mills, New York

Not one to write reviews but good lord if you want more grease then burger or buns that get the philly cheese steak. Ordered three meals all supposed to come with fries... they didn't. Food was cold, onion rings soggy. Order came with root beer more like lightly carbonated water. Very very dissatisfied will NOT be giving any more business. For a 40$ meal go somewhere else in evans mills or surrounding area. Oh and if you call the number it automatically goes to a recording saying the voice mail is full. Hmmm.. wonder why. read more

Wayback Burgers - Philly cheese steak. That isn't an onion you're looking at. - Burgers Near Me - Evans Mills, New York

I've been here a few times now and thought I would just give them the benefit of the doubt. My wife orders the same thing almost every time, and just about every time they do NOT make the sandwich correctly. We waited 10 minutes to get our order taken, and then waiting for your food is another 20-30 minutes. The business seems to be run very poorly and chaotic at times. Only reason they get 2 stars is because the food is good when made correctly. read more

The food at this place is great! However, there are some people who work here who shouldn't! They are rude and will keep you waiting while they f***off and talk amongst themselves. Not a friendly environment here. read more

Came here for our first time! The menu brought us in on how deliciously it looked! As we just moved here wanting to try new places in the area. We got the CHEEEESY burger meal And a Single Cheeseburger meal. With a Caramel Cinnamon Toast Crunch Milkshake. So the first thing that we had an issue was we were overcharged for another burger that was forgotten to be taken off the check. And then when I received my CHEEEESY burger the cheese wasn't melted at all as in pictured.. just pieces of square cheese plopped on. And when we requested onions on the Single Cheeseburger they forgot. Don't get me wrong the food was good, fries were good! Needed salt cause my table the salt shaker was empty and Pretty much the other 3 tables to check for salt and they all were empty as well. And then at the end of our meals we asked where's the Cinnamon Toast Shake and they forgot about it, then when we received it.. it looked nothing as it did on the Menu. Very poor communication. Their crew needs to know how to make the stuff pictured on the MENU and remember orders properly along with greeting and acknowledging their Customers. Could be better at least we came to try it out, but wouldn't be back. read more

Food was pretty good. I ordered the cheesesteak combo. Got a LARGE portion of fries and the cheesesteak was pretty big as well. Wasn't too greasy and tasted great. The staff was also nice. They greeted me as soon as I walked and in and the cashier smiled when she was taking my order. Next time I'm in the area I'll definitely come back read more

Wayback Burgers - Cheesesteak - Burgers Near Me - Evans Mills, New York

The burgers are good and I've also had their shakes. Overall a good place to grab something to eat, don't expect nothing amazing but it's alright. read more

Not a bad burger joint. Patties are a little small for my liking. Took half an hour to get a burger so that was a bummer. Do like how they have fresh LeMonades as well as fountain service. The chili cheese fries were decent. The fries themselves were very goOd. The Mac and cheese bites were very dry and tastes like just some Walmart Mac and cheese with some heaVy breading- defiently needed ranch for them. The bacon burger was good as well as the cheesy burger. read more

This is a great place to grab a a bite, burgers, chicken tenders, tater tots, fries, milk shakes... they have a great menu and the best part is that the food is cooked fresh right in front of you. Better than 5 guys!!! read more

A smaller business for sure and in between a couple other stores so it's easy to pass but definitely pop in and grab a rodeo burger and some fries! The brownie shake is good but pretty heavy with a full meal. I'll definitely be going back, but probably sharing a shake! read more

Was disappointed with today's meal. Used app to order and selected curbside pickup from the options. The order review listed curbside pickup. I arrived at the restaurant about 4 minutes after the scheduled "ready time" but did not see any instruction for curbside pickup so I called from the parking lot and was told they were preparing the order and was bring it out shortly. Understanding that curbside was a new service offered due to the corona virus I was willing to wait but after 20 minutes I decided that was to long. I when in and asked about my order. The cook asked my name looked at the bags and handed one without another word. I checked that my name was on the receipt, took the bag and left. There were 2 customers that left with their orders while I waited outside and 4 more waiting inside when I wet in so maybe 7 orders at 4:15pm was an unexpected rush's and curbside was a new offering so I am willing to write the wait and lack of curbside to that but a smile or thank you would have been nice. When I got home and opened the bag first thing I saw was the frys were missing. Oh well. Then the onion rings were fried to death, so hard they were in-chewable. The chicken tenders were also overdone but edible. The burgers at least were up to standard. Individually none of these things would be upsetting but taken together made us decide that we will wait until the virus is gone before trying Wayback again. read more

Their sides were probably the best thing about this place. Fries and onion rings were great, but the chicken was way overcooked and the burger was subpar. read more

I really love how the burgers are freshly cooked on order. Great selection and variety of burgers to choose from and the customization choices you have. The staff are friendly, the restaurant is easily accessible with plenty of parking spaces. Cleanliness standard is pretty high as far as I can see, which is one of the things I look for when I visit restaurants. Few cons I can think of is the wait time. I've been to plenty of other fresh burger joints and the wait time for here is a lot longer for some reason. Another con I have is the pricing. It's definitely towards the high end considering that it's still fast food. I always wondered what made it so expensive? Are the burgers organic? are they using GMO free products? Or do they not use any frozen foods? I feel like $22 for 2 classic combos is pretty expensive. But other than that, I definitely recommend family and friends to try this place out. Great quality food, cozy environment! read more

When I walked in the first lady gave me the ugly look & she rolled her eyes at me, she's seems pretty rude & bitchy, I'm like "is that how you treat all your customers?" She needs to clean up her act or get her fired, I'm never coming back there again if she's gonna act this way, is she racist or something? Or is she one of those rude & obnoxious people? I hate people like that! Anyways the other lady is really nice & helpful read more

Excellent burger and fries place. Very good fast food on the idea of a Five Guys, but with less grease. Stopped in right at closing, staff said " fine, no problem, glad to make more burgers". The friendliest group of young workers who really seemed to like their jobs. Would try any of these based on this locations food and employees. read more

The burger was fresh the onion rings good shake ok, the cost is were it didn't get a 5 star rating, everyone one was nice but a twenty dollar bill doesn't go far here read more

Wayback Burgers - Burgers Near Me - Evans Mills, New York

See all

Really good! I had the cheeeesy! Definitely reminded me of an old fashioned good ol' burger!! Super greasy, but that's to be expected with a cheesy, fatty, buttery crust cheese burger! ;-) read more

I waited for over 45 minutes for a chicken sandwich while door dash orders seemed to keep jumping my place in line. When I asked for my money back because I needed to be somewhere I was laughed at and told that they don't do that. I later contacted the store owner and he told me that he was going to send me a gift card. He never sent anything and stopped responding to my messages. read more

Yes it's a more expensive burger, but it a great treat once in a while. I love the freshness of the burgers and deciding exactly what you want on them. Yes they take a few minutes to cook, but for goodness sakes, calm down and relax. The special when we dropped by was a Philly cheese steak sandwich, which was cooked from frozen meat. You can get this at Jrecks. Stick with the awesome burgers. On a side note, they pop up specials on their Facebook page every now and then. Wayback also is great about doing fundraisers! read more

Wayback Burgers - Philly cheese steak with Irish Nachos - Burgers Near Me - Evans Mills, New York

See all

Wayback is getting five stars because their malts are so delicious and perfect. they have great staff, lively, Energetic and very prompt. and the burgers they make to order are delicious especially for the fact that they have jalapeños that you can put on them. you have a different vibe and atmosphere than smashburger but due to your malts, you're better. read more

I moved to the area about 2 years ago and wayback was our neighborhood favorite. Fresh burgers every time and I loved the rewards program. It is also our local go-to when family comes to Town. However, over the last couple months we have saw a shift in food quality and customer service. This is the first stop my mother makes when she comes to see us. She ordered a burger and added bacon. When we got home the bacon was missing and the sauce they charged her extra for were missing as well. Later in the week she decided to eat there again before she left town. I took her receipt in with me and the guy at the counter told me I should've called back the same day and I need to speak to a manager. The manager was not there and he wasn't sure when he would return. I was Disappointed at his response and lack of customer service. I decided to check the food I ordered on this visit and to my surprise the bacon was missing again! Also I'm disappointed that we can no longer redeem and earn points. Every time I visit the cashiers Say their system is old and they can't do it. This is unacceptable especially when this fast food establishment is on the pricier side. The great food and the discounts from time to time compensated for the price. Looking forward to improvements! read more

How does a hamburger restaurant run out of meat???????? Tried to eat there but the young lady advised me that they are "out of meat". Terrible management when that is your main product!!!!!! read more