Great food! Love the atmosphere when you walk in. They have so much in their menu it's hard to pick…read morejust one.

I would LOVE to give a review of this place, but the hours absolutely SUCK here. They close at like…read more6, but they are backed up for hours by then, so if you don't order by 3-4, you ain't eating here. I have tried FOUR. TIMES. to get SOMETHING from here, but they are always closed, sold out, or have a "MINIMUM two hour" wait. I assume that means the food here is great, but I might not ever know because you have to sleep outside to place an order. I'll certainly update when I actually get to try the food, but oh my god is it almost impossible to order here.

Sorry didn't take pictures but ordered 4 pounds of chicken cutlets and they were phenomenal…read more Pounded paper thin and crispy very fresh. There was a mix up with the order but they made it right. Will definitely be ordering them again

We stopped by on a whim and everything was delicious. I had a The Italian sandwich and it was…read moredelicious. It had a lot of fresh meat and some cheese. I did add some vinegar and that was a great addition. The people working there very kind. I hope this pace is very successful. We will definitely go back.

I've had several sandwiches from here, and still haven't had a cheesesteak yet!…read moreThere's nothing to dislike about this business. They greet you upon entering and are very accommodating. Everything is housemade here. That's what drew me in for a meatball parm, which was very good. The hot roast pork is delicious. The Italian hoagie had me taking an afternoon nap and smiling through it after eating it... But their hot roast beef is melt in your mouth amazingly good. I have never had a roast beef sandwich this good before... Do not choose what to have in the order I did. I could kick myself for not having the roast beef a long time ago.

Unfortunately my 2nd visit was not good. I got the cheesesteak with cooper , fried onions nothing…read morespecial What I got was an Onion sandwich. So many onions it was ridiculous. Couldn't eat it. Felt sick after. So definitely won't out this in my rotation. Shame. Nice customer service though!

OMG! I had the #2. Wow!!! That was sooooo delicious. I mean freshest tasting goodness! I mean…read moreWOW!!! My dad and husband had the 9th & Christian and they both said, VERY GOOD! We will be returning!!!

delicious sandwiches. amazing options. service is quick, excited to try out more optionsread more

Super friendly staff, loved our meals. Very accommodating; they were able to make me a cheesesteak…read morein a bowl to assist with my gluten free needs. Definitely plan to return and explore more options!

Unreal cheesesteak (get the cooper sharp!) and great service! I'll be back next time I'm in town!read more

I got the Diablo Spicy Ham Hoagie and it was literally the best sandwich I've ever had from…read moreanywhere. The staff couldn't have been nicer too. I'm telling everyone about this place!

Having moved from PA to Jersey last year, I've been told by many that Pal Joey's is THE spot. This…read moreis the spot locals grew up going to, and still frequent for a classic nostalgic hoagie. My girlfriend loves their Italian, but I opted for a turkey and cheese hoagie, and a chicken cutlet hoagie (suprimo). Listen, I get it now. These were great sandwiches. They had so much flavor for the simplicity of the ingredients on each. The cutlet had great, homemade taste and the sweet roasted peppers were the chefs kiss. The turkey and cheese had the right amount of everything on it. The only thing I've noticed both times I've been there is that the seeded rolls are significantly harder than the non seeded. I'm not sure if they just sat out a while, but regardless it didn't take away from my experience, just something I noticed. Service is always quick and kind, and the inside has that old deli feel to it with some booths to sit in. Good quality flavor is always going to have people coming back!

I ordered a special Italian and a cheese steak at the counter. I was told 15-20 minutes so I…read morewaited.. and then I waited another 20 minutes until someone asked me if I was waiting for a GrubHub order. I explained that I ordered at the counter about 40 minutes ago and what it was. They brought it out shortly and did apologize for the wait. The cheese steak was good but the special Italian wasn't that special. Plenty of toppings but not much meat and the roll was a little stale. Definitely not what I was expecting based on the reviews. I can check it off my list.

The sandwiches were great. Immediate service and food was done pretty quick. The inside reminded me…read moreof a pizza shop in the city.

The italian pastries and muffins are good. The pizza is ok. The service is good but the pricing is…read morehigh. The store is fully stocked with precooked food, pasta, cake, etc. the bread is good. Being from South Philly I am use to good Italian bread. Moving to NJ I have to adjust to the bread. Rolls and breads are good but not as good as I am use to. The staff is very nice and accommodating. Store is clean and merchandise is fresh.

I heard so much about this place but was extremely disappointed after my visit. There were many…read morepeople on hand to help customers but we were all stand around waiting for them to pay us attention. Wasn't sure what to try so I picked up the Cole slaw and cake. 2 of my favorite things. The Cole slaw was mushy and had no taste. The cake was a bit better but definitely not worth returning for. Pass for sure.

Same sandwich different day- 5 years later. Sans mask! Girl…read moretook my order over the phone and it was ready when I arrived. Exactly as ordered. Ate half while there and took the other half home. Totally awesome. Loved it. Unfortunately hit a craft fair taking place and it was difficult finding parking and maneuvering but I pulled it off! Will return!

We ordered GF muffins for a Thanksgiving dessert option in two varieties: pumpkin spice and…read morecinnamon apple, and both were moist and delicious, with a nice texture and composition. Highly recommended, just be prepared for the price tag.

Amazing customer service and very nice! Bagels are the best! Everyone should come here for the best…read morebagels.

Wonderful service and delicious bagels!!! The owners are so nice and the bagels are packed full of…read moredeliciousness!!