Running a comic shop can be tough, but for some stores, the joy of browsing old issues and feeling…read morethe comics is what makes them special. Unfortunately, this store doesn't quite capture that magic. Upfront, I want to say that it appears to have been around for a while, attracting dedicated comic fans. It is doing something right. It also hosts local card tournaments (and maybe D&D?), but I can't speak to the variety of those. This might be their bread and butter. Not sure. The comic section, however, is a mess. As soon as you walk in, you pass a narrow row of shelves about 5 feet tall facing away from you--it's unclear why, but it makes the space feel small or uninviting. Still, it isn't a large space, and it doesn't match the charm of classic comic shops. Felt more like I was entering a dark porn store from the 80s. For my trip, I had read revieews and as a local comic store, I wanted to check it out. I was looking for back issues. Remember stores with hundreds of boxes overflowing with comics packed in too tight to see the comics? Yep, that is this place. Navigating the shop is tricky: new comics are on hanging shelves too close together, forcing you to crouch and strain to see them under the shelf above. Independent comics are on the far left of the store in the back - between the boxes and boxes and boxes and boxes and boxes of back issues. The backstock is packed with rows of comics, about 25% overflow in each box (plus stacks of comics on top of those boxes). Very hard to browse. When you do find a title, the comics tend to be dusty, and although sealed, I didn't have my glasses to check for spine ticks or other issues. But, it can't be good to store comics on top of a box without a lid. If you're hunting for key back issues, forget it--these have been picked over like roadkill in the desert; there's nothing valuable left. Instead, you'll find many comics priced between $1-$2, labeled at $4-$8 or more, but most are from the past and generally worthless. I can't tell if the store is clean, but it felt dirty (maybe the lighting or the dusty boxes?). If I were to advise the store - even though they seem to be doing fine - I'd suggest selling your stock on Whatnot, starting at $1 per comic, to gauge interest. If you can clear out 35% of your back issues that way, you won't need to sell low-value comics at higher prices. I understand the reluctance to take losses - I've felt the same - but if your stock is holding back from creating a warm, vibrant, energetic atmosphere, it might be worth doing. There's no shame in dumping unsellable stock as a tax write-off. Listing those low-priced comics at $4-$6 could generate significant revenue and help the store thrive. Personally, I think this is the best approach, as you don't need to spend hours selling thousands of comics. I will note that the staff were friendly. I spoke with one staff member and they are knowledgeable about the stock they had. My guess is this might be where the store shines for people. The human touch. I so wanted to like this place. But, maybe I wait until I make trips to Chicago in the future.

Absolutely a gem! There's rows and rows of comic books, but they also carry board games and playing…read morecards. Ms. Sadako (owner's mother) is always friendly and sweet; I enjoy the conversations I have with her. It's always fun to just stop by and browse, and they also have a small section of old nostalgic Japanese manga. The owner, Roy, is very knowledgeable and can help you find what you're looking for. He has a great sense of humor and he's full of interesting stories. I didn't grow up near a comic book store, but I hope this is what the good ol' days were like. Just a quirky family business with a strong sense of community. So stay for a while, and enjoy meeting old and new friends.

This was the most whimsical surprise. At first glance this is a college used bookstore where you…read morecan buy beads, incense and records. Don't stop there. The magic lies below. The stairs are steep, but proceed slowly and visit the basement used books. I spent more than an hour. It is organized into sections by subjects, but there is no card catalog. Imagine the best book smelling old school library with history and culture and most eclectic mix of books that you've ever experienced in your life. Most of them run between $4 to $8. Wander. Soak it in. It made me rewind in time thirty years. It will cure all stress and transport to times of old. I miss bookstores like this!!! I left with 8 used books. This place is good for the soul.

If you like to explore this is the place for you it's filled with so much located not far from…read morePurdue University. It's seems to take up most of the block each section is a treasure trove in itself from Books, Records yes vinyl and knock knacks. We all know college and their parents are on a budget so the price range here is perfect. I can say honestly no one will walk away empty handed and remember if you can't find it just ask and the staff here will direct you to the right spot

This is a cute little shop! I went with some friends for Free Comic Book Day and was nervous…read morebecause of the broken website but they had a great selection of FCBD comics. It seemed that everyone there was an experienced comic enjoyer and I felt a little bit like I was stepping on toes, but no one was rude and the man behind the counter was friendly. This was my first time in a comic book store so I don't have much to compare it too but the whole time me and my friends were saying it was a neat place! Definitely could use a working website though, and the lack of recent Yelp reviews made me worried it wasn't even open, so I'm leaving a review for posterity.

For a mom-and-pop comic shop, they had an okay selection. Nothing too exciting but a decent…read moreselection for their space. The store lacks signage / labeling for what product is in what area. The prices are pretty reasonable but the guy who works there isn't very friendly.

This was my second time visiting west Lafayette, and I had some time to kill before meeting with my…read morestudent so I decided to explore. Happened across this store and was excited to check it out, I was browsing the books, and walked to each different section, there were so many fun crystals, clothes and Knick nacks! I could have spent hours browsing, but I'm glad I was able to find some fun treasures! Can't wait to go back!

I could spend all day in Von's, just because it's so big! Every topic under the sun. If you don't…read morego downstairs you miss 60% of their stock of books.

I've been buying comic books from Shawn for nearly 35yrs! All the way back to Barb and Dave's…read morestore on 17th Street (and the original store on the Square!)! He's knowledgeable, friendly, and knows his business. I'm proud of him and what he's built there on 'Geek Street'! Keep up the great work, Mr. Hilton!

This is a small shop that is long and narrow with graphic novels down one row and comics (old and…read morenew) down the other. The space is a little cramped if multiple customers are shopping in the same area. The novels are displayed in easy to find order. The older comics are filed in boxes alphabetically and have some vintage items, but definitely are weighted towards more newer material. So, finding some specific older issue is hit or miss. But at least it's worth stopping in to check. The man working the front counter was friendly to customers as they entered or were leaving. He seemed willing to carry on conversations with customers that were interested in between sales as well. Note that this location doesn't sell much merchandise since there is a specialty store for toys/collectibles just a couple doors down. This is a place for reading material. Nice selection and there's a good chance to find what you are looking for. Review #3732

Best comic shop in Indy. After 50 years they must be doing something right. Used to play Heroclix…read morethere. Sad to see no more gaming after Covid....oh well

I used to think that Downtown Comics Castleton and Circle City Comics (formerly) used to be my…read morefavorite comic shops, but now Comic Carnival is my favorite comic shop to visit! It also a perfect shop for pop culture fans. I love the selection of new and old comic books that I can find (such as Marvel, DC, Image, IDW, etc.), the good customer service I can provide, how much any of the comics cost, and everything else that makes it fun to visit! I sure hope a next comic shop will be my second favorite like Comic Carnival!

I've been a loyal customer for about 3 1/2 years. Simply the best option for your comic needs, the…read morestaff cares and will always try to help you in any regard. Not only in purchasing a vast array of books but also the community they've built. Book clubs every month, hosting watch parties, collecting vintage media. A giant backlog of single issue comics at a great price. Truly the best option for the nerds of Indy.

This store is phenomenal. It had a great selection of comics, aswell as volumes and compendiums on…read morethe shelves. The prices were good too, with comics being pretty cheap, especially compared to prices in other stores. The man running the store was very nice and talkative aswell, helping you if necessary. Amazing store, deserves way more attention

This is a pretty big store for such a small town. They have new and used comics, dvds, graphic…read morenovels and gaming equipment. Their hours are really limited, but they seem to be open 4-6 most days of the week. They had D&D and Magic, and host some gaming events. The owner is an enthusiast, and very knowledgeable; you can tell he's passionate about his shop and comics.

I got profiled so hard here. I got ID over a Teen comic, I'm 19, and the whole time I don't think…read morethere was a moment where they took their eyes off me. When I went up to pay, the guy said something about IDing me to make sure my card is mine and to keep everyone safe? Just overall very unprecedented.

literally the best place ever for old and new games aswell as anime knick knacks. nice workers too!read more

Large selection of games and consoles. Store is clean and well organized and makes it easy to find…read morespecific games.