I had a way better experience than my first experience in 2016ish. This place is so much cleaner…read morenow! Way more organized than the dusty heaps it was before. Pricing is a lot more clear. Displays make way more sense now , they aren't just grimy clutter jammed together like before. The girls working there were also super friendly, welcoming, helpful, clean, didn't smell like BO and stale ash tray like prior employees, and they were knowledgeable about everything. Years ago it was a bunch of greasy smelly guys that were more interested in cringe bro gossip, hanging out, and texting than selling anything. The girl that worked there before had the personality and enthusiasm of a wet paper bag. What a huge difference! I just spent $180 on records and will go back in a week or 2 to buy more.

We stopped here while driving through the area on I-90. The store is super clean, well organized,…read moreand all game titles are easy to read (this is a problem at many other stores). The selection was decent for some consoles. This is a solid spot to check out. They also had other collectibles and vinyl, though that wasn't what we were after.

Incredible! Massive bookstore, huge selection, and impeccably organized!…read more Old classics? Autographed hardbacks? 19th Century? Vinyl records? DVDs? Sitting area? You name it - they have it! The only thing better would be a recliner to nap in while my wife browses...

I'm not from this area but I have family in Youngstown that I visit occasionally and I try and make…read morea point to stop in this shop every time I come to town. I've picked up some amazing quality stuff at very fair prices over the years and I'm almost always able to find something I don't have that I need to have (even though I own a few thousand records at this point) among the extensive inventory of used rock. Unlike the previous reviewer I find the prices more than reasonable on almost everything and the owner seems like a fun guy with a good sense of humor. Highly recommended and potentially worth the side-trip for anyone traveling between Pittsburgh and Cleveland.

Underdog Records is a small shop but it has a pretty large selection of inventory for its size. You…read morecan find all the classic rock, blues and soul artists you'd expect, along with a small portion of new popular music. The jazz inventory could probably use some work, but I'm guessing there aren't too many customers stopping in looking for that genre. The man who runs it is fairly friendly and will certainly chat with you while you browse, but if I had any bit of advice for him it would be to lower the price of his records. A Muddy Waters pressing from the 1970s might be worth $10-15 if it is in near mint condition, but anything less than that doesn't warrant such a price tag. I know you have to make your money somehow, but I can't figure out who is constantly buying these records at these prices to keep the place in business. My visit wasn't a disappointment at all, I found some interesting additions to my collection while I was there, it just cost me more than it was worth. It's as cool as a vinyl shop can be, but it's not the first place I think to go when I was to buy more wax.

How am I just finding out about this place now??? Really great retro stuff that's just too much to…read morelist. Very very reasonably priced w everything. It's an actual house they converted into a store. So many rooms themed. Retro video games. Retro dvd and vhs tapes. They have a big sports themed room w tons of old school Browns and Indians items. This place is definitely worth the trip to Akron. Staff was very nice and answered questions. I want that Chief Wahoo neon but sadly it's not working

Such a cool store! Amazing selection, and it's impressive how well organized everything is. Super…read morefriendly staff, even let me charge my phone behind the counter. Came here in a bad mood and after playing Mario Bros. for 30 minutes and checking out so many cool and unique vintage items was feeling like a kid again.

Great time on RSD 2025. Huge selection, everything on my want list and more! Mike kudos to you and…read moreyour staff the crowd was huge and buying was very organized. Can't wait to come back.....

Graham's is open by appointment, which he'll happily make at your convenience. He's got an…read moreextensive selection in his warehouse, so if you give him enough notice and your wantlist, he'll have a stack ready for you to look at when you walk in the door. I found this extremely helpful, and he had quite a few of the things on my list in great shape. He even set the expectation up front that I could be picky. Turned out to be well worth my time! I wandered for a bit among the racks and found a few other titles I wasn't specifically looking for but couldn't pass up, all in the $6-15 range. The owner said he tried to avoid selling stuff in a condition he wouldn't want to play himself, and that seemed to hold for the sample set I pulled. I've known about this store for a long time, but I've only recently gotten into collecting vinyl. I really appreciate being able to check out condition before buying, so a brick and mortar store has a lot of value to me. Evaluate prices in that light. I've had quite a few so-so experiences with buying stuff sight unseen online. All in all, a good experience. I'll definitely be back!

Great selection and VERY reasonable prices. Always an array of great old gear coming through as…read morewell. Short hours, but I stop every time I'm passing by and they're open.

The owner was very friendly. I was on vacation in Ohio looking for VHS Tapes, when I originally…read morecalled the store was closed but the owner called me back. While I couldn't find what I was looking for, the experience I had with the owner stands out as one of the best record store experiences I've had yet and I will be sure to visit here the next time I come to Ohio.

Not as good a selection as Boardman, but still pretty cool…read more Got a guitar hero controller. Good service.

Decided to take my SEALED copy of Zelda:TOTK Collector's edition to maybe sell. They didn't say a…read moreword to me but took it upon themselves to OPEN it and make sure it was legit. If they had asked if it was okay I would have declined. Then after telling its police to open them to make sure it's legit. Only to later switch the story to say it looked tampered with and that's why. After speaking to a manager and an owner their offer to make it right was $60..... I give @exchangestores 1-10 for customer satisfaction. Do better.

Great place to find all sorts of books. They also have other things like wallpaper (a little…read moredated), greeting cards, old vinyl records (mostly country and classical), and some hard to find books. You really need to spend some time here digging if you are looking for something specific. The price point seems fair on most books. Some books seemed more expensive than others. In addition, some parts of the store are a bit dusty and overall the store isn't organized well. They also have an old soda fountain, which I heard wasn't very good. Overall, it was a good stop while I was in town from CA and needed something to do.

Employees are friendly, but the store is filthy, smelly, and disgusting. The clutter and…read moredisorganization make it an unpleasant experience even though there are a lot of books. The building looks ready to fall in. The restroom didn't have a working toilet. I can't recommend this business.

WOW. What a large collection of comics. I don't think I've ever seen that many boxes of comics in…read moreone place! My husband dragged me on a trip down here from Rochester, NY. They were having a 30cent sale on all the $1 comics. He had a plan to go through as many boxes as possible to gather as many missing issues as possible. And we did pretty good. He was able to get over 200 comics for an amazing deal. We finished up a couple of series with issues he'd been looking for for a while. Inside is cramped when there are so many people taking advantage of the sales, but there are just an unbelievable number of comics here. Did I mention just how many there are? A Lot. And I just want to say thank you that they allowed us shoppers to use the rest room to wash hands and use the facilities. When you're there for almost 4 hours, that'd definitely a bonus.

New Dimension Comics is an old school comic shop that boasts an inventory as massive as the Hulk's…read morelimitless strength. This shop has row upon row of packed comic book sleeves, lovingly labeled and categorized by series. They pretty much have you covered from Gold to Silver age comic, as well as a wide range of modern issues. I was looking for some Silver Age Fantastic Four, and they did have some key issues in this area, but I felt some of there key issues were just bit overpriced compared to what I could find on EBay for a similar grade. However, some of their other Silver Age Fantastic Fours were tight in the sweet spot... or as Luke Cage would say, "Sweet Christmas!" The also offer some really good deals on Funko Pops, and I witnessed a blister game of Magic the Gathering being played in the shop. All of this underscores the fact that this comic book shop is a gem and should not be missed. The next time I'm in the area, I'm certain to stop in for my fix of all things comic book fandom.