Ordered their small cheese pizza, 10 wings (medium) and their fried cheese curds. ($44 total)…read more The cheese curds were pretty decent but that's where it stopped. The wings had zero flavor. Their homemade blue cheese was pretty good. For a "pizza" place it honestly was probably the worst restaurant pizza I've had in a very long time. No flavor to their sauce, the dough was super meh and the cheese was tasteless. I feel like they just buy $1.99 Tombstone Pizza and reheat it. The lady that took my order had no clue how "hot/spicy" their wing sauce was, couldn't give me an estimate on how long it was going to take (the place was totally empty). Every time the upstairs apartments flushed the toilets you could hear it in the dining room. Very unappetizing.

Pizza is always the best around and Prices are affordable...They even have a cheeseburger Pizza…read morethat's a must try

Cold beers, solid menu, and a slice window for the pizza enjoyer on the go! Staying up the street…read moreat a BnB in the area, this place was a great later at night spot to enjoy some food. The seafood options were pretty extensive, and we wanted to try all of it! Went with the clam chowder, salad and some garlic and butter shrimp - not picture a slice to go! Salad was good, big enough to split, the chowder was excellent, the shrimp was very tasty and a good slice as well. With plenty of tasty beers on tap, this place really had everything going for it. Though it was later at night, our service was great at the bar. Solid spot overall and I definitely made sure to recommend to other folks from out of town in the area looking for a great lunch/dinner or even a late night slice.

Our first trip to Tony Harper's did not disappoint!!! It was…read morea fun atmosphere that got busy while we were there. Clearly the locals know what's good! After reading Yelp reviews we decided to try the Philly cheesesteak and it was 10/10!! Fresh, hot, plenty of toppings on a hot crusted bun! We also had the SRQ chips! They were SOOO good. If I were to get them again I'd ask for extra balsamic. Personal preference. The Sunday Funday Special was large cheese pizza and 10 wings. $18.99 The pizzas was good (my husband loved it) I thought It needed more sauce. It was thin crust and I reheated leftovers in air fryer and added red sauce and it made all the difference! I really liked it the second time around with a little more sauce! We got the two wing sauces that the review recommended. The House whiskey sauce & the orange teriyaki sauce. They were both phenomenal. I honestly can't pick a favorite. I would order both sauces again! We were kind of bummed that they no longer had sweet potato fries, but the SRQ chips were an excellent replacement! Made us forget about the sweet potato fries immediately! We got waters to drink... All of that food and our (cash) bill was $49!! Saving 1.50 by not using a card. The servers were very good. They basically both ran the entire dining room and bar flawlessly and with great attitudes!! I'd highly recommend!!

We stopped in for a pizza with the kids and the arcade to beat the rain while camping in old forge…read more The pizza is a nice blend of NY thin crust, sweet sauce, and not as spongy as what we see in Buffalo. For wings outside of Buffalo, they were very well dressed and served correctly (blue cheese with chunks of blue cheese). The staff were also great and knowledgeable while addressing questions with our daughter's food allergies. Our daughters loved the old school arcade from our childhood with tickets and games we grew up with. Will definitely stop by again the next time we are in town.

We spent the week leading up to Labor Day in Old Forge.... Stopped at the arcade. The owner…read morecouldn't be bothered to add more tickets to the machines and the lady behind the desk was on her phone. We stopped second time to turn in our tickets and the man working the counter was rude and rushed us to pick prizes and wouldn't give my son 2 cherry lollipops because they were half way down the bin. He also threw the prizes on the counter and kept rolling his eyes at us. Very rude. We will never come back and we come to Old Forge on vacation yearly.

Great pizza, reasonable prices. It's a local spot, right next door to The Boondocks. They even have…read moresardines, which I hate but my husband loves. I asked for a half-half pizza, with the sardine side clearly delineated. They did not fail!

The pizzas and subs are horrible and not good at all. Save yourself some time and go somewheres…read moreelse.

The food is great and the customer service is phenomena! We were in and out in under an hour. Our…read morefood was delicious. Our waitress and the staff (especially Krissy P) were on top of everything and so sweet. 10/10 recommend!

Absolutely delicious pizza and pepperoni knots!! We got a small pizza and 10 wings to share and it…read morewas the perfect amount of food. The cheese ws perfectly melted and not stringy when the pieces were pulled apart, and the dough was thick and fluffy without being too heavy! My husband enjoyed the wings as well! We ordered takeout, but there was nice sesting inside and friendly staff. Street parking available up front.

Good pizza, polite and helpful service. No online menu or ordering. Calling in and pick up were…read morefast and accurate.

This is a situation where if I could select 0 stars I would because we were never actually served…read moreand instead were yelled at to leave. We entered the pizzeria with a service dog in training and were immediately confronted by a small dog that was completely loose and growling at the dog I was training. My dog stood still and did not vocalize or lunge back. Someone who worked there then came out and yelled at us to leave because dogs are not allowed. My dog was wearing a vest from the non-profit organization that he is from that identifies him as a service dog in training. As a service dog in training he is not covered under ADA, which I fully understand and respect. However, I am typically at least given the opportunity to explain that I am training the dog, and once the establishment understands the situation and sees that my dog follows all the same rules as a service dog, access is typically allowed. My issue with this place is not that we were denied access but the way the situation was handled. I understand that people bringing their pets with them everywhere and the entitlement that sometimes comes along with that is a problem. I understand and actually appreciate strict no pet policies, and respect a businesses decision not to allow a service dog in training. But, the fact that there is a confrontational dog completely loose in the pizzeria while being yelled at to leave because dogs aren't allowed did not sit well with me. I always try and put myself in the shoes of someone who is blind or has a disability that requires the use of a service dog, and after experiencing how we were treated I did not want to support this business so we ended up getting pizza elsewhere. It was a very unfortunate experience. Hopefully the dog is much friendlier to people, but even still, not everyone wants to be greeted by a loose dog nor do they want a dog loose in a place they will be dining.

Definitely over priced and not worth the money. We just got in town for work after traveling all…read moreday and we were hungry.. Ordered banana peppers as a topping.. got a pizza with green and red peppers. I called and asked if I got the right pizza. Attitudy Judy told me I did, didn't acknowledge the mistake after I asked about it... Large pizza, crispy chicken salad & 2 cannolis... $70...

If this is New York pizza, then New York pizza is awful. Maybe just call it substandard pizza?…read moreRude people to boot! It has all the class of a hot dog cart.

Ordered 2 pizzas for pickup 2 weekends ago: 1- Cowboy= Sweet…read moreand smokey sauce. Topped with mozzarella, chicken, red onion and smoked gouda. Personal size = 12.95 2- CBR= Chicken bacon ranch. Buttermilk ranch base topped with mozzarella, chicken, and BACON! Personal size = 12.95 Both were fantastic and ingredients were super fresh. LOVED the Neopolitan crust. I lived in Italy for 6 months so I've become a bit of a pizza snob.... and Puterko's has lived up to my standards! If I'm back in the area, I will definitely stop by to try their other specialty pies.

Heavenly hand-tossed pizza, adictive breadsticks and outstanding wings. You can't say much more…read morethan that, but wait there's more: the service is exceptional. All in all, this little eats spot smack dab in the center of Indian Lake is a definite must-visit pizzeria every chance we have.

Used to have excellent pizza. Joe has since moved on and sold his business. There's a new place…read morewhere Lancia used to be, but it's not Lancia.

The food was amazing. The service was good. They people there were kind and helpful. And I highly…read morerecommend this spot!

The food is so good there i love their pizza . The service gets better and better each time we go…read more The Ambiance is amazing as well