Definitely over priced and not worth the money. We just got in town for work after traveling all…read moreday and we were hungry.. Ordered banana peppers as a topping.. got a pizza with green and red peppers. I called and asked if I got the right pizza. Attitudy Judy told me I did, didn't acknowledge the mistake after I asked about it... Large pizza, crispy chicken salad & 2 cannolis... $70...

If this is New York pizza, then New York pizza is awful. Maybe just call it substandard pizza?…read moreRude people to boot! It has all the class of a hot dog cart.

I lived in Carthage a long time ago. I was at the original location across the street that burned…read moredown over 20 years ago. This place was still pretty good. Attentive service. I was alone and I was seated immediately. The restaurant was clean. Nice decorations. I do love pizza, but I've been eating a lot of pizza on this trip so I got a pasta dish. The manicotti. It was a little heavy on the cheese on top for sure. It was good but in the end, I guess I wish I would've got a pizza. Standard selection of National and some regional beer. I got a bottle of Yuengling. Street parking out front, parking lot in the back. There's a rear entrance as well.

Excellent quality and menu selection. Service is great as well as the atmosphere. They have a…read morerestaurant in Carthage as well as Great Bend, NY.

Great food. Great people. A nice restaurant in a small town…read more Clean and friendly atmosphere with views of Lake Ontario.

This was mine and my wife's first time at this restaurant. The staff were all very friendly, and we…read morewere sat even before our reservation time. The ambiance was a nice docile one, with not many people in the restaurant that night. Luckily my brother and sister-in-law frequent this restaurant so they were able to gives us the details of what they thought was good, but I don't think you could go wrong with anything here. For the table we ordered a large antipasto salad with the Wise Guys dressing, the garlic knots, the mozzarella moons, and the fried meatballs. The salad was SO DELICIOUS. All of the vegetable tasted fresh with just the right amount of meat and cheese mixed in. The Wise Guys dressing was the star of the show though. This dressing has such a nice balance of flavor, but also that zip that salads need. The garlic knots were also so delicious too! The knots themselves were crispy yet fluffy... and they had a generous heaping of butter and garlic atop them. The mozzarella moons and meatballs were good but not special like the other two. I got the sausage riggies for my main course... and it was so good. First off, they give you an absolute heaping portion. I have had some good riggies in the past, but I think this may have been my favorite. The sauce was a great blend of creamy with spice from the hot cherry peppers. The sausage was also so flavorful yet not too rich. I would definitely recommend this restaurant to anyone who is looking for some good Italian food in the area.

On vacation and its my husbands birthday. I asked on Old Forge fb site for a restaurant…read morerecommendation. Frankies came up a couple of times, and there are no a lot open on Tuesday. We went early at 5pm. Hostess gave me a hard time when I wanted a better table for my husbands birthday and refused. Fortunately the food was good but the charges on the bill were more than the menu prices and the prices on the website! No one even said happy birthday to my husband even though I mentioned it a few times. Wait person was great. Not a good special occasion place.

The price on the menu was not the price they charged on our bill. The greens were so dry we had to…read morecut little pieces no liquid at all. The pasta was cold and microwaved. Frank and Tina would never serve a meal not freshly cooked. The service was good. There were only about three tables with customers. very sad to see this. They did change the bill to match the menu. The lady that did it was not happy with us.

The place itself is dark / rundown and could use a thorough refreshing. Parking lot is rutted…read moregravel. There is a small bar and a dining area lit with strings of small lights. Waitresses come to the table. We take out pizza from Garramone's, because it is better than any place nearby. The dough is Not yeasty and the cheese is not a hard plaque. The mushrooms are not from a can. The sauce is flavorful with oregano and garlic; the sausage has good Italian flavor. We used to like the chicken francaise and meatball sandwich, too. But now "fine dining" is so expensive! So we take out the pizza.

Had a wonderful dinner with family. Appetizer of rice balls was amazing…read more Everyone loved their dinners. Chicken parm, linguini with Alfredo sauce and broccoli, spaghetti, meatball with long hots and steak. Dinners came with salads and bread. Which a lot don't do anymore. So very much appreciated that. Our waitress Paige was amazing. Had a wonderful sense of humor. Would definitely go back.

Ordered their small cheese pizza, 10 wings (medium) and their fried cheese curds. ($44 total)…read more The cheese curds were pretty decent but that's where it stopped. The wings had zero flavor. Their homemade blue cheese was pretty good. For a "pizza" place it honestly was probably the worst restaurant pizza I've had in a very long time. No flavor to their sauce, the dough was super meh and the cheese was tasteless. I feel like they just buy $1.99 Tombstone Pizza and reheat it. The lady that took my order had no clue how "hot/spicy" their wing sauce was, couldn't give me an estimate on how long it was going to take (the place was totally empty). Every time the upstairs apartments flushed the toilets you could hear it in the dining room. Very unappetizing.

Pizza is always the best around and Prices are affordable...They even have a cheeseburger Pizza…read morethat's a must try

Very beautiful atmosphere and workers are very nice. It's a really good place to stop when on…read morevacation. I highly recommend :)

08.31.96 Had dinner…read morethere this evening. We were sat next to a bunch entitled river people (wasted adults) outside, yelling the whole time. They were clearly over-served. It felt like spring break for older people. We just wanted a nice quiet birthday dinner. The food was fantastic (always is) and the staff was great (always are). If you see a bunch of entitled River people there yelling when you arrive, keep walking. I'd be shocked if they tipped well.

Passing through Brockville, Ontario to Maine. Checked the reviews of restaurants in the area and…read moreThe Mill was the winner. In a former grist mill, it sits near the St. Lawrence River. Nice and quiet. Cindy was our server, she was attentive and knowledgeable. We started with drinks and the French onion soup and caprese salad. My husband truly enjoyed the soup, piping hot and delicious. The caprese salad was okay. Invest in the good buffalo mozzarella or at least the larger sliced cheese. A tad over dressed. I had the sole with potatoes and veggies. It was to come with a lemon beurre blanc sauce that didn't seem to be very lemon forward. Hubby had the rigatoni calabrese, very good. The star of the meal was the chocolate cheesecake. Decadent, light for a cheesecake, wonderful crust. Overall a pleasant meal.

So delicious...We enjoyed our food and specially blackened grilled chicken...This place is in…read morehistorical building but it somehow looks modern...The quality talks here and definitely im suggesting this place if you craving italian food...

The company was better than the food. The ambiance looked inviting when we walked in. They were…read moreable to accommodate our group without a reservation on a Monday night. The bread was wonderful and definitely my favorite thing. I ordered the Haddock with broccoli risotto. The haddock was bland and the risotto was soupy. I'd heard good things about it and maybe it was an off-night. I just wouldn't order that again.

Sharing apps at Pete's Trattoria in Watertown. Clockwise from left, bacon wrapped scallops, Utica…read moreGreens, half-hots, roasted beet , walnut, goat cheese salad. I had Sauvignon Blanc. Tiramisu to go. We ate in the lounge, because their dining room was 'fully committed' until 6:30- it was 4:45. I was surprised as it was early on a Thursday in the winter, but maybe I shouldn't have been! A wholly satisfying experience. Our server was terrific especially considering she also had a full dining room. This is a classic Italian restaurant we are blessed to have.

One of the best in the area, and definitely the most consistent. Always a very good meal at a fair…read moreprice. Billy's hospitality is best experienced as sit down. Tables can be tough to get, don't hesitate to do take out!

We went there for my husbands birthday on a Facebook recommendation. The hostess was rude. We…read moredidn't have reservations but it was 5pm on a Tuesday in August and there were 4 people in the place. I asked for a nice quiet spot telling her it was my husband's birthday. Without so much as a "happy birthday " she said here are the 2 tables I have. Pick one. One was by the kitchen door and 2 more in the middle of the restaurant! You would think they would have some romantic corners for couples since they claim old world italian ambiance. The waitress was very pleasant but also not even a happy birthday greeting. Our food was ok. Nothing special. We took most of it home. Thought they would serve warm bread but no, cold. No reason to go back there again.