Hidden little gem in the area. A TON of pizza options in the general area but many are inconsistent…read moreyet this one is consistently right. Ask for it how you like it and they deliver. I've also found their crust to be the closest to a thin crust pie like up north. Garlic knots are average, nothing special but it's also hard to screw that up. Only suggestion would be on the Stromboli, fillings should go to the ends. Theirs (like many in the area) was empty the last two slices. All in all this is a good place to go for pizza, can't comment on the rest of their menu. I've heard good things about breakfast but can't speak to it myself.

The pizzas are fresh and the cannoli here is delicious. The owner clearly doesn't trust his staff…read morethough and so does everything, making the dining experience hectic. This place needs waitresses, preferably locals and not illegals

Food was excellent The pizza was amazing. They really know what they're doing. I called and order…read moreon the phone. The wait time was not that bad. The ingredients were fresh tasty and I asked for a thin crust. It was Mui Bueno absolute perfection. Thank you so much very satisfied customer here.

Giving this 5 stars for the grandma and chicken parm square pizza and the super hard working staff…read more We ordered take out on a Friday night and it was very busy so I knew we were in for a really good pizza. The sauce on the pizza was really good and the well done thin crust was so good. They also have a dining area- with servers if you what to dine in. Planning on trying there dinner entrees next time.

We came as a crew because our boat dock isn't far from this amazing restaurant! From the minute,…read morewe stepped inside of this gem, it was a feast for our pallets. And I have to say this, Lisa is unbelievable. Fabulous so good at her job. The owner was amazing as well and the place was packed. Take a look at what we all had.

Pizza was inedible. Plain large. Everything about it was wrong... sauce spread ...floppy pieces…read more. never again

Fantastic pizza ! We are so glad to have a neighbor place to get some food now again! Thanks for…read morestaying open year round for us all!

EVEN MORE AMAZING food and service! They've upped the ante and keep raising the bar! WOW!!! The…read moreinside (ambiance) is more comfortable than their first year too! A DREAM!

LOVE IT HERE! The food is great, and service too. Cozy and quaint. Management is wonderful,…read moreespecially Fred - he always stops by the tables to see how we're doing, and I notice him helping out servers or bussers when he can as well. Owners are always present and really care about their establishment. Whether its or summer or winter the vibes are always top tier.

Went to East Bay Saturday. It was crowded and they sat us in the pizza part of restaurant. There…read moreis a main attractive room with music, which was filled. They sat us in that part of restaurant which has a separate door for takeout and tables for pizza. This was disappointing because I did mot want to have dinner in a pizza joint! With that said, the food was quite good. I had Chilean Bass. The size was large enough for two people and the fish was creamy as it should be. My companion had delicious Lasagna. I must say the staff is quite attentive . The owner is a delight and makes you feel very welcomed! They also make a good Negroni! Next time I will ask for main dining room when I make reservations!

Delicious food, great customer service. Absolutely recommend! Everything we've gotten has been…read moreexcellent. It's very hard to find descent Italian food down here so make your next stop to eat at Fusaro's!

Totally downhill. If you're going to give me a $28 pizza, give me a twenty eight f-ing dollar…read morepizza! A meat lover's pizza is not supposed to look like a cheese pizza with a few things sprinkled on it. After the third time of it getting worse and worse since it was sold, we go give up! We tried, they gave up on everything. Size, amount and quality has died. There's plenty of other places in town to choose from. Delivery was fine though.

I have been to Slice House Toms River several times. I really like it. This pizzeria on 37 has…read moreenough room for casual eat in after counter ordering. SH does a large takeout and delivery business as well as the store ordering. Parking is easy out front. The place is clean and service is good. It is a bustling place at times with young people running the front. The pizzeria boasts many, many selections of by the slice as well as a menu of pies to order whole. Lots of add ins and drinks both bottled and fountain style. The pizza is tasty. It is served hot. I especially like a cheese pie but found their specialty pies like the cheesesteak & chicken parm pizza delicious also. The cheesesteak in particular tastes like a breakfast pizza due to its cheese, cheesesteak that is seasoned like sausage and it's white cheese sans sauce. It would be over the top great with sautéed onions, mushrooms and green peppers on it. The chicken parm with red sauce and chunks of chicken with yummy cheese is also tasty. They have salads, Stromboli, sandwiches, garlic knots etc to add on. I really like the entree Caesar salad. The dressing is good and the lettuce is fresh. It comes with toasty bread. I will continue to frequent this quintessential Toms River pizzeria as it checks all the boxes

Friendly service, I think this is my new favorite spot when I am in the area! They have a to go…read moremenu with coupons you have to ask for if you don't get it. The eggplant parm is made fresh and delicious! they have an assortment of pizzas too. Garlic knots are also my favorite from them one of the things I definitely judge a pizza place on. Stop by get a slice!

Located in the famous "Ship's Wheel" location, I wanted sooooo badly for this place to be good…read more I've gone 3 times over the last 3 years and I can fairly say it just isn't very good. Pizza is a 5/10, cheesesteak is a 2/10 (i've never had a cheesesteak with lettuce, tomatoes, and mayonnaise. It is in all probability the worst cheesesteak I've ever had. After the fact, I read their menu and they do advertise it as a California cheesesteak). Lastly, prices for mediocre food are out of control. After my third and now final visit to Ray Sunset Pizza, back we go to Surf City Pizza

The pizza here is absolutely delicious! Thought it was a little pricey per slice but the quality…read moreis there. Would definitely come back when I'm in the area.

We ordered a large pie with pepperoni and extra cheese for delivery. It arrived piping hot and was…read moredelicious! The delivery driver was a doll too. Had no problems with service as others had mentioned. Staff were friendly and efficient. The pie was well done and had a nice amount of sauce and cheese. The pepperoni was especially good. Gets 4 stars for the crust which was a little too thick for our liking. Would definitely try another pie or something else from this new pizza place.

Staff have been extremely rude and dismissive on multiple occasions. We order from here at least…read moretwice a week, so we are regular customers, but the staff often act as though we are inconveniencing them rather than appreciating our business. They are frequently on their phones or involved in personal conversations while customers are waiting. We've literally sat there watching our pizza get cold while employees finish their conversations instead of attending to customers. They weren't even busy -- they were just being nasty and dismissive. I always go out of my way to be kind to people in the service industry because I know it's a tough job and that not everyone is nice. That's why it's especially disappointing to be treated this way when we're simply trying to order food. On one visit, a girl working behind the counter was having a very loud conversation about how her boyfriend had pulled a gun to her head. Regardless of the circumstances, that is an extremely inappropriate conversation to have openly in front of customers. We have been loyal customers and order at least once a week, but enough is enough. Between the rude attitude, employees being on their phones, letting food sit while they finish conversations, inappropriate conversations, and lack of cleanliness, we've had enough. We won't be coming back.