Great friendly staff. Fair when it comes to prices supplies…read more Most important this is an old school sport card shop where owner is there and can still shoot the shyte with them about assorted and collectibles

I was very impressed with the treatment my son recrived at this Brookfield sports cards and…read morememorabilia shop. My son had his birthday and received a free birthday pack and was very happy receiving an autograph baseball card. The older gentleman Tommy was very nice and personable. A very nice man and knowledgeable in all of the sports cards. My experience at Remember When has made me a loyal customer and I love going back.

I've been a customer of Neil Berman for nearly a decade, and I stopped in on 12/30/25 to add to my…read morecoin collection and help my mom sell some of her silver. Neil is an interesting guy and a total straight-shooter -- he's the only dealer I know who will actually tell me NOT to buy something from him if he doesn't think it's a smart move for my specific collection. While I was there, I saw firsthand why he has been in business for over 50 years. He took the time to explain the current market volatility and refinery backups, even advising some people to wait a few months to sell certain items to ensure they got a better price. He was fair with what he bought from me and provided straightforward advice with zero pressure. Neil is a true expert, and I'll definitely be back to grow my collection further.

I went a few times looking for a straight answer on silver (melt value). Lots of double talk. He…read morethinks he's the smartest man in the world. He has a plaque on his desk which says "mr never wrong". Well... the lot I brought to him he offered $300 for and the very next place offered $1200 (Danbury Gold & Silver - Kelleher Auctions) for the same exact lot. I have never written a bad review in my life... he left me no choice as I wouldn't want to see others get ripped off (not by a little - 400 % more was paid from Danbury). Also, you get the used car salesman "slick" speeches from Neil... "i have been in this business 53 years" and "the math is complicated, you can't do it". Silliness, this day and age anyone can look up the price of precious metals. He just wants to try and confuse the seller and not be honest about his lowball rates. Snake oil salesman. Huge egomaniac. Avoid at all costs.

Jeff Casey was very nice and very reasonable on the prices. I recommend this place. He was great!read more

Such an awesome spot! Tons of Pokemon in stock, every set my son was looking for, they had! So much…read moreto chose from! The guy Alex working was so helpful and so nice. We will be back soon for sure!

Ordered an item through their Walmart storefront…read more I placed an order for an item, and within 40 minutes had some unexpected changes personally, so I requested that the item be canceled. I placed the order approx. 330p est. and requested the cancelation approx. 410p est. The immediate response was "I can't do that because it shipped out this morning". Obviously that would be impossible. According to the FedEx tracking, it wasn't picked up until the next day after several email communications were had. Most of which, the seller was condescending and unprofessional. Since then I have repeatedly asked for a return to processed immediately, and I would send back in the original shipping box. They are rude and unwilling to work with me.

This is such a special shop - seriously, one of the coolest stores I've ever been to. It's packed…read moreto the brim with nostalgia and charm, filled with all the toys of your childhood from the '50s and beyond. Loved all the walkie-talkies, Super Nintendo games, '80s original G1 Transformers, Polly Pockets, Ginny Dolls, Smurf figurines, Rageddy Ann dolls, Strawberry Shortcakes, Furbys and more. John, the owner, is incredibly smart, helpful, and funny. Name an esoteric toy, and he knows it and has got it! We'll make the drive to Pawling just to come back. Cannot wait and am already recommending this shop to everyone. 5 stars!!!!!!

Just had an absolute blast talking to John and making a deal with some of my old collectors stuff…read more He was super friendly and knowledgeable, and wanted to make sure that I got the right/best price for my items. I genuinely felt like he cared about his job which is refreshing. Some places treat you like your stuff is garbage, you DO NOT get that when you come here.

Watch out the owner here weighs all his trading card game packages to sort out the rare cards for…read moreresale on the internet. Anything sealed you buy here will contain nothing but basic cards. He brags about how much he makes on them as well. Not a good place for collectors looking to finish sets or find rare cards. He's basically a cheater.

the only review here is not being honest. the store and the owner are great people. they care for…read morethe wellbeing of their customers and their establishment is family friendly. they host parties for families and friends to celebrate birthdays or events. I would trust going to this store with my kids. The community here is very inclusive

I've only been here a few times, so I can't really speak for anything tournament-worthy, or comic…read morebook-worthy (since I don't collect), but the atmosphere here is really great. MTG products are laid out for you in binders by set, they have a glass case up front for all the higher priced cards, and the staff is super knowledgeable about what they have in stock, which is all a huge deal to me. I've also heard that they recently expanded their store, which is super cool if they plan on hosting larger tournaments. Not only that, but you can place orders on their website and pick them up at your own convenience. I have yet to do so, but a friend of mine does it constantly and tells me that it's so much more worth it than sitting there sifting through cards. Yeah sure it might be a bit difficult to find from the main road since it's in a shared business building, and you might even pass it while trying to find it, but if you want a great experience at a comic/book card collector shop, this is your place.

Been here a few times in the past. Recently visited after moving out of state five years ago…read more Ironically the vibe of this place never changed. Not one person greeted me when I walked in (which to an extent is a huge pet peeve of mine). What made it worse was eventually an employee (I believe the owner) looked me right in the eyes and didn't say anything and just ignored me. They had some good comics hanging on the wall and stuff seemed fairly priced. But honestly customer service and feeling welcomed goes much farther to me as a customer. If I don't feel welcomed or wanted then why would I bother wanting to give you my money? I'm not sure how people stay in business when they're not social with their customers.

I tried to comment on Troy Emmi reply but I ended up updating the hole review. I don't know if…read morethere's a feature on here that I can reply to the owners comment but there is something that I need to say that's going to be listed down below. 8/15/21: After writing this review on Yelp Troy Emi (head at Fanboy Collectibles) decided to post all of my personal information Full name, Phone number, Address, and Email address and to a different site for everyone to see. What is something NO BUSINESS should do with a customer's personal information. I'm not going to allow someone like this to steal $210 and then post all of my personal information on another site. I will be contacting his Police Department as soon as I can in his Township about him posting my personal information. Troy Emi has a history of doing what he did to me to other people aswell. Only customers had this same experience of him stealing and robbing them out of money. He stole my $210.00 an what he's doing now it's not acceptable. On top of that when we first had this issue what I forgot to mention was that he was sending me rude and nasty Facebook messages and Emails due to he was upset with me more or less of him harassing me and calling me racist slurs. The guy is not professional whatsoever and he should probably not even be running a business if he's going to act like this. Original review written: on Google. BEWARE OF THIS COMPANY. Stole $210.00 of deposits I had with this company. They closed my account do to I got in a damaged statue and after I told them the problem with the statue I got in they closed my account and kept all the pre order deposit I had with them. Before this I was shopping with this company for 2 years but right when I had a problem they closed my account and stole my deposits I had on my pre orders with them. Best to buy somewhere else. I would not recommend this company whatsoever 2/11/22: Saw that Troy Emmi cared to reply back on 1/28/22 but Troy didn't tell the truth again. In Troy Emmi reply he said "This customer has made these claims that we have stolen this money on multiple social media platforms and Yelp. To which we always reply with all of the information we listed above and have stated we have all of the e-mails, screenshots and sales orders to which we've referred and can gladly make them available." I these had a BBB claim upped about Troy Emmi at Fanboy Collectibles because of him taking all my personal business information that I gave him and posting it on a different website for everyone to see. Troy never provided any of that information that he says that he has whatsoever to the Better Business Bureau. Almost as if he doesn't happen. The only thing he did was talk negative about me as a customer and about my past negative business experiences with other companies and businesses. Also the worker at Better Business Bureau I spoke to them by phone and she also said I should probably contact consumer relations about him or a lawyer do to him stealing the $210 of mine but most definitely about him taking all my personal information and posting it online. So Troy Emmi at Fanboy Collectibles is now believing that BBB is wrong? Also I did try to contact consumer relations by phone but because of covid data on take phone calls and to set up a complaint on this site is kind of hard for me. Something else Troy Emmi has said is "As for these new claims. If we were harassing you on Facebook why would you not just report us to Facebook? They would immediately close our account." Troy Emmi has me Blocked on Facebook. It's kind of hard to report something when you're blocked Troy. Now I have screenshots of that and everything else proving my point if you want it. So the first picture is of me logged into my Facebook and Gmail account and the 2nd is of me when I'm not. So yeah. Blocked. So yeah. I do care about this because I'm not going to have something steal $210.00 from me first and 2nd post my personal information online and have that be OK. Troy Emmi did this samething to another customer if you look at the reviews left to his company.

What a great experience. I was at the recent NY Comic-con…read moreand was looking for some rare statues for my collection. There were a few vendors selling what I was looking for and were close in price between each other. After explaining my situation to the owner of Fanboy, Troy Emmi, he took his time to go over different options and even was able to help me preorder some rare items on his site, that no one else had available. He was basically 10%-15% below all the other companies and I have purchased about 4 more items since then and all we delivered as advertised in perfect condition. Some of these other reviewers seem to be focused on shipping issues which any owner has no control of.