One Sunday morning I was having breakfast downtown and saw their Instagram post of a Mr. Hankey doughnut!! I LOVE him, so got very excited and headed right there afterwards. You walk in the door at Gus' and the Vandal stand is right there at the entanceway, with a display of maybe a dozen varieties. I got several all bc they looked cute. They are your standard donut and I would compare them taste-wise to the vanilla dips from Tim's, pretty moist, sweet, crazy fresh. The UFO one had a neon lime filling while the others had no filling. The chocolate peanut butter one is good, and I find more filling. For $1.85 each I think, it's a good deal to just in for one as a snack.
My 2nd visit around 2pm on a sunny, freezing Saturday in Feb - the place was busy! A dozen in line? Staff were going as fast as they could to replenish. I tried the coconut chai this time and it was quite good! The Root Beer Float was ok, had no root beer flavor, which I found disappointing. The Skor Twist is really good, but larger, almost as big as two donuts. The Strawberry Shortcake is very good, quite heavy and I ate over maybe 20 mins.
3rd visit on a cloudy chilly Tuesday in March - we were the only customers in the place. I tried the Freak Lunchbox donut with gummy worms and sour stretchy candy. So pretty! Had no unique flavor, but that's okay. Same with the blueberry dip - expected the icing to have at least a bit of blueberry flavorful, but not really. I like these for the look and they are very fresh (even if other donut shops are fresh, these taste fresher). The Sensual Sensation may be my favorite for taste, with a Ferrero Rocher sitting atop Nutella, with crushed nuts on chocolate icing of a white donut. The vegan Birthday Cake is like a standard vanilla dip, but still good. The Froot Loop one was good, sweet and reminded me a bit of a popcorn kind of flavor, but think that's just me. The Maple Bacon is favorful! For Cinqo de Mayo, they made a plain donut with Mexico flag colors, which was fun. The orange chocolate one was quite good, with a definite orange flavor (moreso than say the blueberry dip had). The Wildberry was yummy! (Purple swirly icing with a wildberry jelly filling, topped with some crushed nuts). The rum & coke is very tasty and filling, albeit no rum flavoring that I could detect, the filling tastes just like the candy Coke bottles that sit on top of the donut. The Reese's Pieces is great but simple, a vanilla donut topped with whole pieces. The Marge (chocolate donut, blue icing, rainbow sprinkles) is simple but tasty. The Kit Kat break donut is large, rectangular with an entire Kit Kat bar inside! (one of their premiums for $4.20) but worth it! The Orange Creamsicle got me excited but it didn't have a strong flavor at all I found. Their "Strange Brew" donut is great - red & black checkered icing on a white donut, filled with tons of coffee-flavored filling, and it is very filling. Their novelty donuts are always clever...a Trump one, and a "Kinky" Trump one for Pride week were hilarious and still delicious. The Mint Aero is good, with chunks of the bar broken atop a double chocolate donut, which may have peppermint extract. The Blueberry Cheesecake is excellent, with a cream cheese layer and big blob of filling, but not as messy to eat as it sounds. The Cookie Monster is so cute, his face in blue sprinkles on chocolate cake donut, with an Oreo stuffed in its mouth. The Girl Guide Cookie donut is delicious with coconut (obviously US styled, as Canada Girl Guide cookies are not like this). The Mud Pie is very good, white donut with chocolate and cookie crumble dip? And the hole filled with Nutella. The Cookies & Cream is pretty good, on a chocolate cake donut with white icing, Oreo crumble? The Cinnamon Toast Crunch one is very good, with lots of whole cereal pieces atop white icing and a caramel (?) drizzle on a white donut. The Unicorn Poop is good, pretty colored sugar and purple icing on a white donut with some kind of filling. The Twixtster (?) is a giant $4.20 one similar to the Kitkat, where it has a whole Twix stick inside a rectangular white donut, with white icing & chocolate drizzle. Filling! The "Basic Bish" aka pumpkin spice filled donut is very good, with cinnamon sugar and whipped cream on top? The Oscar the Grouch is cute and same as the Cookie Monster on a chocolate cake donut.
Been back many times with a line of 20 people ahead of me one Saturday at 10am. One customer ordered customized donuts without telling the pick-up time, so that held the line up a bit. And they will make ANYTHING for a custom order - even hilarious erotic ones! read more