Quaint store. Fresh made waffle with ice cream & hot fudge was delicious! Highly recommend! Outside seating available.

I wish I could say the bad experience ended when we walked out, but unfortunately, it got worse. Despite the place being completely empty, my husband, our three-year-old, and I were told we could not sit down to look at the menu. I'm visibly pregnant, and our child was hot and tired from the July heat. We simply needed a moment to rest while we decided what to order. The handwritten menu is, in my opinion, messy and difficult to read, so we needed a bit more time to look it over. We were immediately informed that waitress service doesn't start till 7:00pm and we were not permitted to sit. My husband stated that we were just reviewing the menu. The girl behind the counter said, "You can stand to look at the menu. You can sit when your food is ready". The tone used was dismissive, sarcastic, and dismissively rude, making the entire experience uncomfortable and hostile. It was inappropriate for anyone in customer service. I called twice later that day, but no one ever answered. Still, I gave them the benefit of the doubt and reached out to via Facebook to express my concerns. What I got in return was more of the same: a snide, sarcastic, and dismissive response that confirmed this is simply how they treat people. Two Cents Plain has a total lack of professionalism and respect. Save your money and take your family somewhere that actually welcomes customers. read more

Minus one bc they don't take credit cards. To their "credit" (Pardon the pun.), they trusted us to come back another time with cash to settle up. But bc they were so nice (and my husband was in a decent mood), we drove to our bank's ATM and returned to pay immediately. Now we know, and will come back another time, bc their ice cream is INCREDIBLE‼ read more

Two Cents Plain - My happy place - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Margate City, New Jersey

I would give zero stars if I could. It's sad, really. I remember going here growing up and even two years ago. Today my family and ai went in and there were about 10 kids in there wrestling in the store and in the back. It was dark and hot. It smelled horrible. I remember it smelling like waffles and being fun and clean. The tables were sticky, and it smelled like body odor. We walked out and asked if anyone who was hanging out worked there. A little girl rolled her eyes and said yes. We won't be back and I wouldn't recommend anyone going there. read more

Went in on Monday because my kid had a coupon for a free scoop. Place was empty and super hot, smelled like curry which was odd. Found out it was cash only, no biggie, but I only had $10 cash and my ATM card, so my wife and I didn't get anything. I asked the girl behind the counter (who looked absolutely miserable that I interrupted her phone time) if we used the coupon, but wanted to add another scoop for my kid, what the charge would be, She said $5. For one scoop? I asked again because there was no way they charged $5 for one scoop and she said yes $5. It's as if they didn't want any business. No problem. We used our coupon for one free scoop and left. There are plenty of ice cream places all over Atlantic County, no need to waste time at this place. read more

I liked the food here, but it wasn't 2 cent, sadly. What a shame, but I get it, inflation and stiff

I've always loved this place for their waffles and ice cream, and make sure to make it part of any visit to the Jersey shore. But I have to say that this visit was a bit disappointing. I don't believe the waffle was made fresh. I didn't pay attention to what the girl was doing as I was talking to someone, but the waffle was not hot and was also undercooked. And there's usually the intoxicating aroma of fresh waffles cooking when you enter, and I did not smell anything. The waffle was buried under mounds of ice cream, and you can't go wrong with Breyers vanilla and mint chocolate chip. The half waffle serving is enormous, and delicious. But the waffle was not up to its usual delicious self, which was a major disappointment. The service was excellent, although odd. One of the things missing was the pretzels on the table. When I asked about them, the young girl said they were not allowed to put them out until after 6 PM. Really? What does time of day have to do with the serving of pretzels? Do I pay less money for ice cream before 6:00? (The answer is NO!) Why should something be served depending on the time of day I come in? And in all the many years I'm going there, that was a first! We did compliment the young girl on her service. I think anymore it's unusual to see a young person doing her job so well, not on the phone, and busy the whole time despite the fact that we were the only two people in there at that time of day. (Our timing was perfect!) I just don't know why the changes in waffles and pretzels This takes my usual 5 star rating for this place down to a 3. I drove 25 minutes to this shop when there were many closer ones. I hope the owner reads this and corrects the issues. read more

Two Cents Plain - Coffee and Rocky Road 1/2 Waffle - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Margate City, New Jersey

See all

I like Breyers ice cream. I didn't need to pay $11 for a half gallon sitting on a mushy under cooked waffle. read more

this place has been around forever and there's a good reason for it... their waffle sundaes lol! love this place and it's old time icecream parlor vibes. read more

Went to Two Cents Plain on Memorial Day weekend with my husband and in-laws. The place gets crowded, quickly. However, it's cute on the inside - a fun atmosphere. The service is also responsive. Unfortunately, the ice cream left much to be desired. I ordered a peanut butter flavor and it was really bad. Tasted freezer burned. My husband got a waffle with ice cream on it, and the waffle was really mushy. I'm not sure what the fuss is about the ice cream, but it was pretty standard to me. Oh, and it's cash only. Might try it again, but thinking about fighting the huge lines of people and wild throngs of preteens isn't appealing at this moment... read more

I was super excited that they had a vegan menu on the website. The menu online isn't the laminated one they handed me. Nearly $7 for shakes made with water. $13.90 for two shakes. And they were pretty awful. So disappointed. read more

Overpriced Breyer's ice cream. It's crazy in there too. Skip it. Seriously, don't think the lines and the massive amounts of people are sign of greatness. It is Breyer's ice cream. Go to the supermarket and get a half gallon for the price you're gonna pay here. OVER PRICED read more

Wow, what happened to this place? Stopped in last night around 10:30. The place was mostly empty, warm and the service non existent. There were two girls behind the counter. Neither were wearing uniforms and both looked sloppy at best. Completely non professional. I stepped up to the counter and received a gimme a minute. Sure, okay After almost two minutes the girl wearing a Mainland lacrosse shirt asks Are you ready yet? Yes, I was ready two minutes ago. You weren't.. I ordered an ice cream cone on a sugar cone. She brings it to the counter and it's dripping everywhere. As she is telling me she's going to put it in a cup she flips it upside down in a pint sized takeout container. Um, I wanted an ice cream cone. Not a cup of soupy ice cream with a cone on top. I lay a $5 dollar bill on the counter She takes it and asks Did I say $4.75 No, you didn't say anything... we'll it's $5 and change but I'll just take this I guess Try air conditioning the place. Maybe the ice cream will stay cold. Don't let the scent of the undercooked waffles lure you into this place it's a waste of your time and money. Try Margate Dairy Bar right down the street where the food, ice cream and service are all top notch. read more

I think my expectations were set too high when I went off to find Two Cents Plain. I was envisioning homemade ice cream, but it turned out to be Breyers. Don't get me wrong the quality and taste of Breyers is fine, but I had hoped to find something different than I would find at my local supermarket. You also order at the counter and sit yourself where you want. Although they do have glass dishes on display they serve you with disposable even when you stay within the store. We ordered a sundae and a waffle to eat in the Shoppe. The taste of both desserts were very good, but the presentation was lacking. The sundae was served in a plastic dish and the whipped cream did not go above the top of the cup. They may have different size sundaes, but nothing else was offered to me and in that case they should use a smaller dish to make the dish look full. The waffle was served on a paper plate and kind of looked like a pile of toppings. Compared to other places to get Ice Cream in Atlantic City they win hands down. I think the experience is about what you would get at the to go window of a Friendly's. read more

Came here with a few friends and sat inside. Ordered a 3$ ice cream and decided to leave. the owner decided to follow me outside and ask me if I tipped my waitress; who legitimately brought me a one scoop ice cream cone. I said no I did not and she proceeded to pressure me I to tipping. I am paying for your product and don't think pressuring people to tip for a $3 bill is needed. Will definitely not be recommending this ice cream shop to friends. Basic ice cream too. read more

LOVE their milkshakes and waffle! Prices are a little high (depending on what you get), but you do get a good amount of delicious treats for your dollar! I have not had one, but I hear the Sundaes are awesome! I usually stick to my milkshake or waffles here as they are FANTASTIC and I cannot get enough! They also have a vegan menu, so there certainly is an option for everyone! Definitely a Margate staple! I wish they were open year round. Make sure you get the hot fudge! read more

Two Cents Plain is the best ice cream parlour in the AC area. No doubt there are plenty of options, including custard's and juniors, but if you want the best in the area, this is the place to go. I love it for a few different reasons... 1. There is a variety of quirky ice cream flavors including cake batter, peanut butter cup, etc. This place doesnt simply serve vanilla, chocolate, strawberry! 2. The local feel is the best. It is a laid back atmosphere reminiscent of a 50's soda shoppe. A great place to hang out with friends or bring a family. 3. The sundaes! So many different options to chose from, with tons of toppings! read more

Omg this place is delicious and reasonable considering how good the waffle ice creams are. We went on Fourth of July weekend and it was packed but got seated immediately, I suppose due to fast turn around times since it's just ice cream. The waffle was light, fluffy and hot with fresh ice cream on top. The flavor of the waffle was the best as well as the hand dipped ice cream. My boyfriend and I shared a half waffle with two scoops and left stuffed! read more

I have been going to Two Cents Plain since they opened in the 1970s. I feel a sense of nostalgia about the place and that is what kept me going back. These days it has become a place resting on its laurels not on its value and quality. My most recent trip was mundane. The young women who work there look real tacky in their spandex clothing. They are not especially friendly and the floor around me was dirty, and the waffles and Breyer's "ice cream" were sub par. I really wondered if the ice cream was genuine ice cream because Breyer's which they serve now makes a "frozen dairy dessert" .. The signage is messed up and needs to be fixed. Sure they may still have the " Hello Lollie" sundae but i am no longer impressed with the place. It doe not give me goosebumps anymore. read more

I really love coming here. It is cozy and everyone there is very friendly. They have a large selection of flavors to choose from. My only wish is that it was not Bryers ice cream but actually handmade. read more

They boast about their vegan menu, but when I walked in there the girl didn't know how to make any of the vegan products. I asked if she could ask management or if there was a guide in the back and she didn't want to do any of that. She was the only one there. She texted her boss after I told her to call... Five minutes later she goes "oh they didn't text me back"... So, I said to call. With an eye roll, she called and said they didn't answer. I blame the owners for not training their employees and having knowledgable staff. The two non-vegan people I was with were disappointed as well. Go to Dairy Bar instead! Went there afterwards and had a wonderful experience. They were very attentive, polite, and had answers to all my questions! The atmosphere and products were wonderful as well! read more

Let me start with the ice cream. It's Great. Make sure you also get a freshly made waffle which is perfect complement if you decide to go. This place gets super crowded on the weekends and you'll have to wait - but it's worth it. So why 2 stars?? About a year ago when I ordered an ice cream cone the girl behind the counter was playing with her hair. She put it in a ponytail, then without washing her hands or using wax paper - grabbed an ice cream cone and proceeded to make my order. GROSS! My friend had exact same experience a few weeks ago - except when she pointed out to the girl she should use wax paper or use cones with wrapped paper - her answer was - "well that's how how we were trained". WRONG ANSWER. This place is so good and I'm sure if the owner knew he/she would change the policy and ensure the people behind the counter either 1) wear disposable gloves when handling cones or 2) use wax paper when holding cones or 3) put paper around base of cone. This is all fairly customary for ice cream parlors. If you goto 2 cents plain see if you observe what I'm taking about and leave comment for the owner. If they change their policy on how they handle food I will change the review to 5 STARS!! read more

My 3 daughters and I were seated a table against a wall in the restaurant that was half empty. I asked to move to a table that suited our needs better. The waitress stated with an attitude that the tables were the same size and I replied that's true but if we are going to argue than she should understand that the table against the wall has half the space of seating we would be on top of each other. She continued to be nasty by saying that we shouldn't be sitting at the other table BC it was for bigger parties. No one else was coming in behind us!! I left and went down to California Frozen Yogurt where the ac works we could sit wherever we wanted and the service was super friendly. Two cents plain lost my business BC of a moody teenage server who couldn't keep her mouth shut. read more

Two Cents Plain brings back fond memories of summers spent at the shore. This classic ice cream shop serves all the classics with so many choices of flavors, toppings, and combinations. My wife and I split a freshly made Belgium waffle topped with warm hot fudge, whip cream, Oreos, & M&M's that was recommended by a wonderful young woman named Devon, who was manning the counter on a busy weekend day. Devon was also so considerate and even offered to serve our daughter's ice cream in a gluten free cone since she can't tolerate gluten. If you are looking for an old school, classic ice cream parlor then Two Cent's Plain won't disappoint. read more

The best waffles on the island. It's perfect sit down for ice cream. They give you water and pretzels while you wait. The ice cream is the best with the world famous waffles!!! read more

A couple friends and I went in for a nice late sweet treat. we all decided to split the bill at the end as many have done before. but this time to our surprise, things took a turn for the worst. The cashier took it upon herself to take out a dollar out each of our individual checks and claimed that it was a "regular fee for split checks to take out a dollar". upon this experience I took the opportunity to call the manager once we left because it sounded fishy. she then explained that they sometimes do this policy and sometimes do not. but like, what does that mean? this is a very confusing and inconsistent policy that sounds illegal and should not be going on. do not go here. they rip you off and are obviously pocketing money. i know it is just a dollar but it's wrong and bad karma will be entering this place. read more

Number 1 ice cream parlor. Old fashioned design. Super friendly owner and staff. Best waffles and sundaes.

As I write this review, I am dreaming of the waffles and ice cream that I waited so long for in summers past. Don't be intimidated by the lines this place sometimes gets. There's a reason why this place get's so busy, it's that it's pretty much as good as you can get. The waffles and ice cream are beyond perfect. They make a fresh waffle, put a few giant scoops of whatever flavor you want on them, and then watch all your friends try and mooch a taste. read more

Ice cream is delicious. There is a variety of ice cream flavors and you can get lots of toppings. Best Ice cream place around!

12.25$ for a fuckin waffle and ice cream, two cents my ass. tasted alright but nothing spectacular. I reccomend kohr bros. the cashiers are foreign and hot. i don't give this place a baaaam, a green eggs and haaaam, or a peanut butter and jaaaaaaaam. read more

Two Cents Plain - more like 12.25 plain - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Margate City, New Jersey

Asked for a medium vanilla soft serve in a cup with fudge and sprinkles and received a spoonful of ice cream drowned in a pint of fudge. Took 2 bites and the ice cream was gone and was left with a gross cup of fudge. When I politely asked why I was given such a large cup with such a little amount of ice cream, the worker then told me it was because I got fudge, in which I had to pay an extra dollar for so it should not have compensated for the lack of ice cream. A single girl waited on us for our orders one by one while 4 other workers sat behind the counter on their phones without acknowledging us. We ordered a waffle with ice cream as well and we were given a cold premade waffle that was sitting out on the counter instead of making a fresh one. We then sat outside to enjoy our expensive ice cream when what seemed to be the owner began taking in tables and chairs surrounding us and sat on a chair next to us and waited for us to leave. We felt uncomfortable and got up and the second we left she removed the table from under our feet, 3 hours before closing. After all of this, we watched from our outside seating as a worker sat on her knees and ate ice cream from behind the counter. It was evident that she wanted us to leave so we did. All in all poor experience and will not be returning. read more

Holy Moly, go with any of the Sundae's, Milkshakes or splits. This place NEVER disappoints! Recommend do NOT sit outside, they cannot serve in the proper plating so be sure to get a spot inside. The staff is always friendly, it's amazing. read more

Best waffles and ice cream I've ever had. Can't be beat. Don't listen to the haters. My waffle is always crisp and not mushy. I've been eating here for 25 years. Eat in the store for best results. ;) read more

Excellent ice cream but waffles are not cooked enough and come out mushy. We told owner but they were not responsive

Just kind of so-so. Ice cream was decent, nothing special. Decor was boring and service was okay. Not a memorable experience. Might go back, might not. read more

Wow, really? I've been a customer at Two Cents Plain for literally 25 years. However, tonight will be the last time I go there. The owner is completely inappropriate and unappreciative of her customers for what is, no joke, literally Breyers ice cream. My friends and I showed up 15 minutes before closing time and the owner threw us out with no apologies on a June weekend. I mean, really? This will be the last time we patronize this store which doesn't even have the capability to make their own ice cream. Just go to Wawa across the street if you want the same exact Breyers ice cream for half the price. read more

First off, the owner at 2 cents is a disrepectful nasty woman with no manners or good customer service. I was meeting up with my friends to get some ice cream and enjoy my MDW weekend. The owner asked me if I am eating here and I said "no thank you, I actually just ate and i feel sick". And she said "Did I ask you that?", in a rude tone that made me feel disrespected. As a business owner myself, I know how to treat my customers whether they are buying from me or not. For all of the fellow yelpers, I suggest not to go to 2 Cents when in Margate. I like to to enjoy my ice cream and have a nice time with my friends, not be treated disrespectfuly by employees! read more

Advertised as being "vegan friendly", which consists of bananas and ice in a blender.

Love this place! We go often and always enjoy the waffles and ice cream. Staff is always friendly and quick!

Spent $12 on a waffle and ice cream with a few friends. The waffles are rather large and sharing one seemed very appropriate. The owner of the establishment (a short, brunette woman who walks around the shop with an obvious attitude) made it her mission to stop at our table often and harass us to hurry with our dessert. The entire experience was rather disturbing. The way she lifted my friend's arm off a chair behind us without excusing herself was the last straw. We left $13 on a $12.10 bill in all singles to prove a point. She counted it out in front of us and then sarcastically exclaimed "Wow, thank you!" It's a shame because the other employees are young and friendly, the owner is just a massive b*tch! read more