Holy pepperoni!! Troy's pizza is delicious (I wish that I wrote a review sooner). We had a 20 inch Margarita and a 24 inch pepperoni (get the extra pepperoni). We love the thin crust and it was baked too perfection. We always get it to go so we can have beer or wine with it (that's why I have 4 stars). read more

2/5 - Although being one of the only places in the area to offer takeout slices, it was lackluster at best. We got a cheese and pepperoni slice, but my cheese slice was missing its crust! When you picked up the pepperoni, it began ripping in half at the top. The only other takeout slice option was sausage. We paid $8 for two slices. Unfortunately, the pizza itself had no flavor, which is evident when places like this dump oregano and other seasonings on top to try to mask this! TikTok Reviewer: acaicaitlin read more

Troy's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Port Saint John, Florida

See all

Very much your traditional New York Pizza. Ginormous, thin pizza with a lotta melty cheese and crispy crust. Absolutely delicious! We ordered our pizza pickup and it was piping hot, fresh and ready to bring home. Everyone including the kids loved the pizza. I thought the price was fair for the quality and pizza size. The restaurant is fairly small but you can also dine in. read more

See all

Did delivery ordered an all meat and a Troy's special and they were both very good. Had a garden salad that fed 2 people easily. Only in town for work but this would be a regular if we lived here in St. John. Delivered in 30 minutes also. read more

People friendly, crust good but sauce was weird. Just didn't taste like pizza sauce. So while not bad just not what I personally expect in a pizza read more

Troy's is the best Italian in everyway and Miles around. Large portions and great prices. read more

I have been a loyal patron since the family owned bizarro, which was outstanding! As time is gone, the quality and customer service has gone downhill the past three times I've been there. I've been quoted three different prices and like pizza has not been consistent in any way shape or form I hate to say it I'll be taking my business elsewhere read more

Good pizza , incredible prices, last time my pizza had such a great char to the bottom it was perfect.

Just moved to the area from CT and the wife and I were jonesing for some pizza. After some extensive searching, we decided to give Troy's a try. I was a bit skeptical when I pulled up and the parking lot was empty. Went inside and was immediately surprised by the old school pizza house aroma of the place. I was immediately greeted by a young gentleman with a very respectful tone. I was early and had to wait a few minutes for the pizza to be boxed up. It looked good coming out of the oven. Mind you, this was a to-go order, so I had wait till I got home for the taste test. My wife got a Sicilian cheese and I got the Troy's special. Needless to say, we were both extremely impressed! Definitely recommend and going to make Troy's a regular stop. read more

Troy's Pizzeria- Port St. John, FL- 4 Stars "Oh, joy," I thought as I stared at the window on my random name generator, another Pizza joint. But hey, at least it wasn't a franchise! The name in question was that of Troy's Pizzeria in beautiful Port St. John...oh, who am I kidding, it's OTB and I don't like going OTB, alas duty calls. I truly enjoyed Troy's Pizzeria and recommend it over and other pizza joint in PSJ. As I was debating which bridge to use to cross the river, I looked up and I was there (it's not that bad of a drive after all). The tidbit of information that got my curiosity up was the fact that Troy's touted itself as serving "New York Style" pizza. For those not in the know, NY Style pizza is made with a defining overly large hand-tossed crust that is thin except the edge, this allows for the preferred method of ingestion, the New York fold. Upon entering Troy's Pizzeria I was immediately taken in by how clean the place was. I can get used to this aspect of a post-COVID world as who doesn't like a clean eating establishment? While it was nothing out of the ordinary décor wise, I found it to be a quaint little parlor aptly manned by Amanda. I asked Amanda for one slice of white pizza and one order of their stuffed shells with the proverbial garlic knots and a small side salad. The salad Amanda soon returned with was chock full of fresh vegetables and crisp, green lettuce. Sadly, the dressing was obviously out of a bucket. The garlic knots were just that, garlic knots. They were cooked properly and tasted fine, but certainly nothing extraordinary here. Moving on to the slice of white pizza. What I really like here is the crust. I hate overdone crust and this was obviously made to order, cooked properly and was delightfully amusing on the palate. The toppings were fresh, the sauce was tasty and it folded perfectly! Great job, Troy's!! The stuffed shells, while not bad in any way, didn't make the same impression on me as the slice of pie I just scarfed down did. The shells were cooked properly, the sauce was adequate and the rest is, as they say, history. I must make a disclosure here to my loyal readers. When I am comparing Italian food I rate pizza joints against pizza joints and sit-downs vs. sit-downs. So, for future reference, please don't ask me how a pizza place stacks up against a family-oriented sit-down Italian joint that has the obligatory pizza on the menu. The Big Boy says, "If you're a transplant, visitor, or local in the mood for some up the coast pizza, Troy's Pizzeria is serving fresh slices of hot New York Style Pizza Pie!" #iamthebigboy #bigboydining read more

See all

We ordered the Firecracker shrimp along with an 18" Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza. I ordered over the phone around dinner time and was told that it would be ready in about 30 minutes. When I arrived the food was ready for me to pick up. The pizza was very good and was Not greasy at all (which is a good thing). The shrimp was battered and fried to a golden crisp. They were nicely seasoned and topped with sliced jalapeños and banana peppers. They also came with ranch dressing for dipping. The shrimp were very good and I would order this whole meal again. My family and I have ordered from Troy's several times this year and have not been disappointed one bit. This is probably the best pizzeria around in this area and the prices are affordable too. I will definitely be back. read more

Calzone was fine as usual. Antipasto salad was a ghost of its former self;decorated with meat and cheese instead of the normal generous and tasty portions. Disappointing as this has been our local go to place for antipasto salad. read more

Huge insect in the bottom of my caesar salad .. ruined my family's dinner and my appetite for Caesar salads

Great little place. I hope they do well in this location, my concern is that a lot of restaurants have tried to make a go here and have failed. I will have to say the pizza is top notch, and I'm picky about my pizza. Sorry I didn't get any pictures. I will next time. The service was great. They act like every customer is important to them. Give them a try. They do sell it by the slice. read more

Stromboli was delicious. Pizza was great! Cheese knots could be "lighter", more fluff. Website worked well. Food arrived 18 minutes early. Kind and professional delivery driver. Well packaged/cared for items. read more

They have good pizza, fast delivery, and friendly customer service. They are a bit pricy; however, their pizza is infinitely better than their national chain counterparts. read more

best canzone ever! food is always great and quick service and nice dining area. only pizza joint around anyone should go to.

Top notch pizza shop. I've ordered from them several times and have not been disappointed. As close to NY style as you can get without going to NY. read more

Meh. It's was ok. The Greek salad was really good. The pizza was pretty flavorless. The order was wrong, the workers... I mean, there was a woman uo front by herself and about 6 guys standing around in the back telling her what they needed. You know what she needed? She needed help. Anyway, it's close to home. I might try them again... maybe not. read more

Love their pizza and the rolls ! They are fresh and delivered quickly! So many choices !

We found this place unexpectedly. We stopped in and I got 2 slices of pepperoni and sausage. Sheila and Sandy got a 1/2 meat lovers 1/2 meat lovers with onions. WOW this is really good pizza, a small dining area, self service drinks and clean restrooms. We ate for $25 and left a tip. The atmosphere was nice and friendly. It's located on Fay Blvd near the railroad tracks. The pizzas are great and the atmosphere is friendly and comfortable. Just what a person needs to enjoy a great pizza. I hope everyone enjoys eating here as much as we did. We will definitely be back. read more

absolutely fantastic baked ziti dinners & pizza. Coming here at least once a week :) Thank you troys pizzeria

Pizza is always hot and veggies always taste fresh! Service is normal for takeout pizza. Best pizza in Port St John for sure!

Simply delicious, true NYC style pizza. Sure the other two in the neighborhood are cheaper. And smaller. And made without the quality that you'll get at Troy's. read more

Troy's Pizzeria has the best pizza in PSJ and Titusvillle hands down! We always pick it up and it's never more than a 20 minute wait! Prices are good, and customer service is always great! The pizza has great flavor and not super greasy like most places. I highly recommend the White Pizza read more

Troy's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Port Saint John, Florida

The mixed reviews promoted me to shine a light on this Port St.John pizza-gem! Tucked away in a small shopping plaza (next to a stellar ice cream shop as well, "Scoops") is a small, authentic pizzeria. My girlfriend is a local native and swears by Troy's. . .so instead of going to a typical chain pizza place, we drove over and ordered take-out. We ordered an 18" pizza half tomato half pepperoni and added ricotta cheese. The pizza came out in no time at all and was delicious when we got it home. I usually judge pizza based on three simple categories: 1) Final Product; 2) Ingredients; and 3) Flavor. Troy's received a 10/10 for Final Product, no areas of concern there (it was not soggy, no red sauce on the crust, still hot). Troy's also received a 10/10 for Ingredients (the cheese was plentiful, the pepperoni was thick, and the tomatoes had no middle pits). Troy's also received a 10/10 for Flavor (you can always tell if a good pizza place skimps on their ingredients or not based on how the dough tastes, and Troy's dough was delicious, as well as the other ingredients used). Keep in mind, things happen.This is a small-town business with their own process, not a chain restaurant with corporate training. Don't let one bad experience on a busy night for this business deter you from trying it again (that would be a shame). If something wasn't right with your order, say something. Everyone at the business seemed nice enough and open to hearing how your dining experience was. Enjoy the pizza, y'all! read more

We ordered a pizza for take out since delivery was a bit steep. Went in & was "greeted" (scowled at) by an older guy who said it'll be a few more minutes. When the pie was ready, it was handed to me with a "here ya go". Then got a "look" when I didn't put a tip into the jar. We've ordered delivery from them for a good number of years with no issues. Now we get treated like something they scraped off their shoe when we go in for a pick up order. Very telling about what they really think of their customers. read more

It's ok, nothing too great about it but better than the regular oops Dominos out Pizza Hut

Always a good hot pizza. Won't order the wings again but it's a pizza place and that's what they do good. A nice thin crust without being too thin. Lots of toppings and the orders are always correct read more

This place is amazing! They have amazing food! They also give back to the schools and community! Troy's the best!

Came here through passing ordered a meat lovers with mushrooms and their cheesy knots! Everything taste great and staff was nice as well.

The staff is rude and lies. Took my money and when I asked for a refund can't seem to figure out why it didn't work correctly. After waiting an hour and having to come in for a refund you bet I'm mad. He even said I told him to shut the F**k up - really what are we children now? Wouldn't let me talk to the owner, of course. Do yourself a favor. If you want pizza in a decent time frame don't go here. If you want decent service, don't go here. I will never go here again for sure! read more

Our family loves this pizza place. When we moved to PSJ we tried a few pizza places and this is the best one in town! The staff is always so nice. Food is ready fast. My husband is from NY and I'm from Chicago, we are very selective about our pizza and this one is excellent!! read more

Decided to try Troy's again. They have tried to brighten up the inside. The staff was friendly and the pizza was very good. The crust could have been cooked just a little longer. But overall a better experience then the other pizza places in PSJ read more

When we first had Troys we LOVED it! However as the months went by they started not tasting the same and they have been not adding as much toppings and even cheese. Not sure how many more chances we will give before finding a new favorite! read more

Friendly service and great pizza! The white pizza is my favorite while my boyfriend goes for all the meats. Best part is they'll let you split a pizza with two types. read more

Troy's is a great pizzeria! If you prefer the pizzeria style to the chain places, they are definitely worth checking out! Everything is fresh and tasty. The menu has about what you'd expect and then some. Try the white pizza! Delicious! We also got the cheesey garlic knots with bacon once. It was fantastic. Highly recommended! read more

We get pizza from Troy's often. We have been since before it was Troy's. I didn't notice much difference after they changed over, so that's good. We've never had a bad experience with the food or service. The pizzas are big and yummy. The crust is always cooked perfectly. I like to get the garlic butter for an extra 50¢ to dip my crust in to. Te garlic knots are good. Not the best I've ever had and I think they could use more sauce, but I like them anyway. We'll certainly continue to order pizza from Troy's. read more

As part of a fundraiser for the Space Coast Jr/Sr High School's Marching Vipers we decided to have food from Troy's delivered to the house, and help out the school's marching band along with it. My experience was a bit mixed tonight. One the one hand the service on the phone was friendly, the delivery was fast, and the food showed up piping hot. On the other, the food for the most part was just okay. The cheese pizza was huge, definitely big enough for plenty of leftovers. My wife's calzone was stuffed with cheese and I do mean *stuffed*. So, if you're a mozzarella lover, this is your kinda calzone. I had their spinach roll and was pleasantly surprised to get two (of which one was more than enough for me.) It was interesting to note that the calzone was so overly stuffed with cheese that the added ingredients she requested (mushrooms and onions) were a bit lacking. While my roll was equally prepared with plenty of cheese and spinach (good too.) Next time we might just stop in for dinner and get a feel for their place. I'm looking forward to that... read more

This is a solid pizza place, from someone who has had pizza from over 1,000 different places over the years. If you are in the area or passing through, definitely stop here and pick up a slice or a pie or whatever. read more