1. Trading Closets

0

Greendale, WI

Cancel

Open app

Search

Trading Closets

3.0 (8 reviews)

Trading Closets Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Trading Closets

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

14 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

13 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

12 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of R U.
0
11
0

13 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

13 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Trading Closets

You might also consider

Alive and Fine

Alive and Fine

4.6(8 reviews)
6.3 mi•Bay View
•$$

There are sooooo many vintage and second hand shops in Bay View, it's actually kind of crazy. I…read morestopped in here a few weeks ago to check it out despite not going to places like this often because of things being overpriced and overcrowded with things. I was really impressed by the quality of things she had to offer. There were some truly unique finds that were so cool that I almost wondered if I could wear a bell bottom jumper with Paisley patterns. There was also a very strange purse that was completely beaded with oddly colors and kind of creepy looking cats. I was intrigued but decided maybe the neon cats would better serve someone else. She also has some art by local artists and interesting jewelery and trinkets. A friend got me a hilarious pillow from there that was a tomatoe wearing stockings and shoes. The prices were very reasonable to me. The more expensive things were the very unique items you would have a hard time finding anywhere else. Of course it won't be as cheap as Good Will, but these clothes are legit vintage. If you like these sorts of things I highly recommend checking it out!

Stopped by while in town on my way to the airport. I love checking out thrift and vintage stores…read morewhen I travel. I found some really cute items. A gorgeous mint maxi dress and cap sleeve blouse and few other items that I left behind, which I was kicking myself when sitting on the plane. Definitely spend some time looking through their racks and tables. Prices were a bit on the higher side for some things and reasonable for others. Will stop by again when I'm back in town.

Photos
Alive and Fine
Alive and Fine

See all

St Mary's Thrift Shop - Men's

St Mary's Thrift Shop

3.9(16 reviews)
8.3 mi

Lovely people! Great deals and I love their inventory. Some of the stuff is a little pricey for…read morethrift store prices, but there are plenty of pieces that are also reasonable.

**July 2025: Tuesday Afternoon Visit**…read more This was such a great charity shop to visit! It was a pretty hot summer afternoon so being inside a well ventilated and ac'd store was a relief. The store itself is styled like a boutique and is a long hallway with different rooms focused on different clients (ie. children's section, men's section, active etc). I did feel like many of the women's clothes were geared towards a more mature crowd, but I appreciated the fitting room to try everything on. Unfortunatley, the things I loved were probably meant for juniors/teenagers and were just a tad too small for me *cries* Nevertheless, I found some really great (like new conditioned) random things like a Superman BBQ Apron (perfect for the summer of Superman), and Michael Kors Mary Jane Pumps that will work perfectly for my Wicked outfit that I'm putting together. I didn't know at the time, but I suspect because I visited during the week of July 4th that everything in store was 50% off, which almost felt like highway robbery since everything was already very inexpensive already! My Mary Janes were $10 and thus $4.50 and the Superman Apron came out to $2.50. This is a great clean, organized and well priced charity shop that I'd love to support again on a return visit. Enjoy!

Photos
St Mary's Thrift Shop - Kids

Kids

St Mary's Thrift Shop - Front area

Front area

St Mary's Thrift Shop - Books

See all

Books

R Vintage N More

R Vintage N More

3.0(6 reviews)
6.3 mi•Bay View
•$$

We wandered around R Vintage during the Bay View Bash - it's a lot bigger than the storefront…read moresuggests. If you're into 50-60's glass, lamps, décor and furniture this is absolutely a place you should be checking out. They've got tons of interesting barware, lamps shaped like flamingos, beer signs for your awesome basement bar and lots of tacky paintings. I was surprised by how much furniture they had - console tables, tons of side chairs and the kind of horribly patterned upholstered sofas that my grandma referred to as "davenports". Speaking of my grandma, I'm pretty sure she owned most of this stuff at some point, especially the matador figurines because bullfighting??? IDK, never could quite figure out what theme grandma had going on in her living room. Anyway, I'd agree with Rachel that the prices on stuff here seem to be higher than at other vintage/antique shops. I'm guessing the high amount of vintage-loving hipsters in BV are driving prices up. Also be aware that the shop is PACKED full, so it's not a great place for smaller kids.

This place stocks a lot of great, mint-condition stuff... most of it mid-century modern. Lamps,…read morecouches, full dining sets, home decor, tables, chairs... they've got lots and lots of great, pristine, old-timey stuff. R Vintage (N More) is hiding right next the Vanguard on KK. Only open sometimes, blink and you'll miss it. I really enjoyed perusing and taking it all in... they've got some really neat pieces, though nothing jumped out at me this visit as a "must have." And honestly, I couldn't help but feel like everything was priced just *a touch* too high. Totally understand paying for quality antiques in relatively perfect condition, but this spot felt almost like everything was priced $50-$100 above fair market value.

Photos
R Vintage N More
R Vintage N More
R Vintage N More - Not tryin to act like I don't need this parrot

See all

Not tryin to act like I don't need this parrot

Lela

Lela

4.5(22 reviews)
7.9 mi•Historic Third Ward
•$$$

This is my favorite boutique in Milwaukee. I have since moved away, but I have very, very fond…read morememories of shopping here, especially when Tracey was around. Tracey truly provided some of the best retail service I have ever received. Talking to her was like talking to a best friend, and she always helped me find exactly what I needed (including things I didn't know I needed yet ;)). All the workers here are very friendly, the clothes are beautiful, and the store smells amazing thanks to the wonderful Votivo red currant candles they use in the store (and sell!).

I really hesitated to write this review, but I decided it may end up being helpful. I adore Lela -…read moreI've shopped there frequently in the last several years and always had a top-notch experience with service and merchandise - used and new. However, my most recent experience was not good and hopefully it was a one-off. I stopped in to browse on a Saturday. I did not recognize any of the women working there (4 ladies), which is unusual because there's usually someone I'm familiar with. Anyhow, I was in the store for probably 15-20 minutes and no one greeted me, no one asked if I needed any help (even though one staff person was right beside me a few times putting clothes back on the rack). At first I was surprised and thought that I should say something to them, like "hey how are you doing" etc. However, they never stopped talking amongst the 4 of them - so much so that if I had said anything I would have felt like I was interrupting them! It was very disappointing and unusual - they didn't even take time to say have a good day or anything when I left. There was a Desigual t-shirt that I wanted to try on and purchase but I decided I wasn't going to give them my business since I had felt unwelcome and ignored. I went home and ordered online. Like I said, hopefully this was a one-off and they were all just having an off day.

Photos
Lela
Lela - Front window

Front window

Lela - Cute dresses

See all

Cute dresses

Trading Closets - vintage - Updated November 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...