I went in for an inspection, UNBELIEVABLY friendly, helpful and fast. I had no appointment! I could…read morenot ask for better service! Nobody tried to "sell" me anything extra, and as a female it's so refreshing to not be taken advantage of. I will be returning should I have any issues with my vehicle. THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU!

Jeremy & his team have always treated us like family from day one. We take all our vehicles to them…read moreand recommend them to all our friends and family. No matter what the problem is, they are always extremely honest and never try to take advantage of you, like other shops. We wouldn't take our cars anywhere else, from their professionalism and knowledgeable staff we always can count on Middle Country Automotive.

I had a problem with my brakes, I mean a real problem, metal to metal. I brought my car in early…read moreand spoke with Joe. I explained the issue and explained that I needed the car back that day if possible. After a quick walk around he assured me that he could. Well as promised the car was ready mid afternoon. Yes it needed front brakes, rotors, and sensors. Next the bill. Very reasonable and he had warned that it may need new calipers. I expected that it would but he assured me that they were fine. Another repair shop would easily have changed them and charged me. I found them to be reasonably and I will be using them for my new repair shop. Yes I recommend East Setauket Auto Repair

It's difficult to find an auto shop that you can trust and that won't try to rip you off. East…read moreSetauket Auto is different than the rest. Been taking my old beater work Honda here for years and they have been reliable, friendly and most importantly- honest. They've done all my basic maintenance, usually just brake pad, battery, inspection related. Always done in a relatively timely fashion for a fair price. Never once tried to upsell me on extra work in order to pass inspection. My most recent encounter with them, which is what really motivated me to leave this review, was especially appreciated. I don't know much about cars, but there was something a little stiff with my steering, and I thought maybe the power steering or some belt was going. Took it into East Setauket Auto and asked them to take a look at it and let me know what needed to be done. They could've told me numerous things and hit me with some multi hundred dollar charges, but instead they looked at it and honestly told me nothing was wrong with it and no work needed to be done so I picked my car up no charge. That type of honesty is priceless and will recommend this auto shop to everyone who needs one. Great people here. On top of all that the place just looks cool- convenient location in a nice area- retro, old school style office and shop, feels like going back in time in a good way.

Always help me with my car and are honest. A good shop to have help you out and fair pricing.read more

Dont bother. Thought the guy was a stand up guy- he came via recommended from a local there…read more Totally ripped off and let crooks put a tracker in my car. Anthony was pleasant and helpful but I dont like being lied to with a bunch of con. They think I have no idea what went down. It was a disappointment to say the least considering I have been complaining about dishonest mechanics and their shops. Well now he is included. Karma is a bitch. 2300.00 dollars later....

Matt was fantastic.And i'm not sure who took in and worked on our pickup truck, but they say this a…read morelot of money and we're very honest.

This was the best experience I have ever had with getting maintenance for my car. Mark's customer…read moreservice skills are outstanding. They did a video of the work that was done on my car so I could see the work they did. They finished early and completed everything on my list. The cost was very reasonable and certainly better than I expected. My car is a 1998 model with 153,000 miles on it. They could have easily added something to the bill, but that is not the way this place does business. I can't recommend them highly enough.

I really feel as though he is trustworthy!! I found him because of his reviews on "Nextdoor"as…read morewell as his reviews here. While he was working on my car, I was able to talk to some customers in the waiting room and they were saying that they've been coming here for many many years and he's the best mechanic.!!

Most honest auto professionals I have had the pleasure of doing business with. I been a client for…read moreat least twenty years.

I had these guys install two new tires on my car and they were fast, friendly, and polite. I then…read morehad them to an inspection and an oil change and it was an awesome experience. These guys don't mess around, just tell you what you do and don't need, nothing else. Highly recommended.

I do not know how many times, throughout the years Big Charlie and Jr, and their team saved me with…read morevarious car troubles.. they have ALWAYS BEEN RELIABLE , DEPENDABLE, PROFESSIONAL, TRUSTWORTHY, HONEST etc etc EVERY TIME...They have such a great sense of humor, and the service is always with a smile... they can always explain what the problem is and fix it!!! One and done... Catanias is a rare breed of mechanics, that is rarely seen or heard of anymore. Having car troubles?? Come on down to Catania, and let them show you how it's SUPPOSE TO BE DONE!!!!!! Ms.Fields Long Island,NY

Beyond AMAZING! My husband and I have been taking our cars here for quite a few years now! Steve…read more(the owner) is the most honest, reliable, decent human being you will ever encounter! It doesn't matter if your car is foreign or domestic, old or new, he will always be there for you (and take good care of you).... Appointments are definitely a must, because it's always a very busy shop.He does not do things to your vehicle if they are not needed/required. He's just so very honest and decent! His entire crew are the most skilled and reliable mechanics you'll ever know....Kathy who runs the front office is just the best! She keeps the business moving along never missing a beat...I have recommended Penney's North Country Car Care to many family and friends, and everyone just raves about the service provided here.... If you're ever in the St. James area on the North Shore of Long Island, this is where you need to bring your car for anything! Steve is the absolute nicest guy: truly the best! After meeting him one time you will feel like you've known him forever.... P.S.~I'll never take my car to the dealership again!

He's fixed a number of things onmy old commuter Honda since I bought it quickly and affordably.read more

I only wish there was something less than 1 star. It was my first time to MVP because the prior…read moreowner had the car serviced there. It was gonna cost ~ $1600.00 for front brakes, replace alternator, change windshield wipers and new inspection. The alternator was defective and they only going to give me 20% for a new replacement. The wiper blades are broke, most probably not changed and lastly the can doesn't have a new inspection sticker. I WISH I NEVER TOOK THW CAR TO MVP THEY ARE THE WORSE‼

Always reliable. When ever I have a problem with my car I'm always sure it will be taken care of…read moreproperly when I go to MVP