What a gem! They have so many items to choose from, you are bound to find something you like!! I ordered coscia on a roll (prosciutto, fresh mozz, Romaine lettuce, sun dried tomato pate, olive oil and balsamic vinegar) (~$15 including tip) I love how much prosciutto they gave me because they aren't skimpy w it at all. Everything was SO FRESH. The bread was not stale. The lettuce wasn't wilted, which is a majorrrrrrr ick of mine. The mozz was really fresh, like they claimed. The only thing I would've liked, was a little less balsamic. But other than that, such a great sandwich and I was definitely satisfied and will definitely be back I ordered in the morning, so it was relatively quick since they have a lot of employees but I do imagine that during lunch, it will be a little bit of a wait. There's some seating inside read more

Toasties - Coscia Sandwich - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

A quick search for a sandwich spot that would cater to my tuna craving led me here. Came in, signs were clear indicating where to order and where to pay. Staff here move fast yet don't lose sight of customer service. I was able to place my order and didn't wait long before taking a seat to eat my sandwich. It was just what I was craving, tasty, fresh and the tuna wasn't overbearing or an insane amount. I'm curious to try some of their other offerings. read more

*** NOW OPEN SATURDAY *** Solid breakfast/lunch spot in the theater district, which has more offerings than other deli-type establishments in the area along with reasonable prices. I usually get bagels or breakfast platters, but I know a lot of co-workers who order sandwiches from there. They are now open Saturday (the bottom right corner of one of the pics shows a sign, "We are open Saturday"). Bottom line, the food is tasty and the service is fast! read more

See all

2 years later. Still just as delicious. 2 hot and tasty breakfast sandwiches. The fruit bowl was so good. The place looks very clean. The service is quick and efficient. read more

Toasties used to be my every day breakfast place when I worked on the east side over ten years ago. Fast forward to this week, my office is a few blocks from here, and my prior office was about a block from here, but I had no idea this location was here. It was the same experience where they have a lot of staff, who are always pleasant and immediate greet you and take your order. I was surprised that the pricing was still extremely fair. I believe $3.90 (tax included) for a bagel with scallion cream cheese. The bagel was excellent, as I was always used to. I would recommend this place to anyone who works in the area or just looking for breakfast or lunch. read more

See all

We had our second breakfast in NYC at this Toasties. We looked up the menu before we went so we wouldn't hold up a possible line upon arrival, which was a smart move. We all ordered our preferred breakfast combos and then the boys and I went to get a table while the husband got in line to pay for our order. This place had a decent size seating area in the back, which wasn't immediately visible from the street entrance and as most people seemed to be getting things to-go, the seating was not crowded. We were all able to bus the table and use the restroom before we left, which was more convenient than walking back to the hotel. Great, quick breakfast. No complaints! read more

They make everything fresh from salads to sandwiches and even have daily specials. This little deli was such a refreshing find during our stay! The salad and sandwich we ordered were absolutely delicious and freshly made. The employees were super friendly and helpful, taking the time to explain how to order. I give it a 10 out of 10! Expect to stand in line to order this place is booming read more

Toasties - They make everything fresh salads - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Great sandwich place for any occasion. You got salads and soups. Can go there anytime of the day for your breakfast, lunch, pre-theatre and dinner plans. A true Time Squares Gem read more

They take your order, give you your ticket, you pay at the counter and the food comes quick. The ladies at the counter are super nice, remember your number and call you when the food is ready. The food is always good and they have good coffee. They do it the right way. read more

Toasties so good went here because I heard Andy cohen mention it and it was so good bagels fresh good service

I was on a mission to find an everything bagel with veggie cream cheese, but when I went in, there were so many options, and it took me a moment to remember why I had walked into here. The people behind the counter were friendly and helpful. You can tell that they want to serve you as fast as possible. There are three places where you can get food served. The first place is where you can order salads and section 4 sandwiches, and then further down, there is a section for hot plates. A man outside asked for money, and I suggested food. He immediately ordered the hot plate with yellow rice, chicken, and gravy. It looked amazing. I stuck with my original plan of getting an everything bagel toasted with veggie cream cheese, and I am so glad I did. The veggie cream cheese has real veggies in it. I'm gonna keep this place saved as one of my favorite bagels in New York. Carrots scallions meat celery can't really tell but something crunchy really good. The bagel was perfectly toasted and delicious. I'm gonna keep this place saved as one of my favorite bagels in New York. read more

Toasties - toasted everything bagel with veggie cream cheese - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

Ordered an Italian sub online, pick up was a breeze. it was delicious, what more could I want?

The best bagel I've had in years. Classic NYC counter service, lots of options. Relaxed casual atmosphere, limited seating.

Great lunch spot, full deli, salad bar and menu. Many long-time employees, efficient and kind. Dependable option for a range of things. read more

Toasties - Salad bar - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

I really like Toasties. Both their breakfast and lunch sandwiches are very good. There hasn't been much of a line when I've gone and they make everything pretty fast. read more

This was a second visit for us and the food was spot on. Breakfast for two for under $20 is hard to beat in the Times Square zone. I had a double egg sandwich with bacon and American cheese. My wife had had French toast and both were very good. We ordered online from our hotel on 50th street and walked down and lucked into one of the few tables they have. I watched them process orders like a machine. Walk in orders moved very quickly. When I visit NYC I try not to eat some place I've tried before but Toasties is an exception to that rule. read more

So so delicious! This was our last meal before leaving NYC and it was awesome. Everything was made fresh and the staff was so nice especially Jasmine who helped us decide what to get- the menu had a lot of great options. read more

heard a lot about this place from coworkers...after months I decided to give it a try I ordered the "meatloaf" and "mac n cheese". my coworkers lied. that stuff reminded me of tv dinners from the 1970s. form molded Salisbury meat substance and the pasta "cheese" concoction was a mess. the low standard food there is embarrassing. Zero stars=not worth mentioning...​ read more

Delicious breakfast sandwiches. No frills, but quick and tasty. We enjoyed it. Thank you.

We were walking around the Rockefeller center area early morning while on Christmas vacation. My kids wanted a NY deli breakfast. I turned to yelp and found Toasties. As soon as I walked in this was the kind of deli I grew going to when I lived in NY, so I knew this was the perfect spot. The service was quick and efficient. The atmosphere gave you NY in a hurry vibes, people coming in ordering and leaving. We sat down to eat and of course I had to get a baconeggncheese with a regular coffee. It put everyone in good spirits to continue walking around the city! read more

Toasties - Baconeggncheese - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

See all

It's a convenient stop for me to get lunch. I usually get either a sandwich or wrap. Service is relatively quick but gets packed during lunch. read more

Nice fast, hot, and tasty breakfast! You can build your own breakfast sandwich. You get a choice of bread, bagel, roll, ect then can add what you want to it, from sausage, bacon, egg, cream cheese, to salmon, tomato ect. Stop in and grab a fast breakfast bite! read more

Toasties - Sausage, egg, and cheese on a bagel - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

See all

A mid go-to for a quick lunch. The atmosphere is really casual, so I guess it's a convenient spot for a quick bite. But the quality of the food did not meet my expectations. Emily Waits Sandwich (6/10): The bread was kind of stale, which was a huge disappointment and kind of ruined the sandwich for me. On a positive note, I appreciated the subtle honey flavor that added a unique touch to the sandwich read more

Toasties - Emily Waits - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

Great variety of options. Gave my kids (NOT from here) a taste of what a real sandwich/bagel shop is like the ones I grew up with here in NY/NJ. Quick, efficient, great food. Fed the family of 4 for $40 read more

Vacation in NY, this was everything I wanted! Bacon egg & cheese on a roll, you can't go wring ordering this. Service was quick. The coffee was great too! Casual environment, limited seating. read more

Toasties - Bacon Egg & Cheese on a Roll - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

Food was good and service was fast! I had a grill cheese and a croissant egg and bacon sandwich. It had tables to sit a place to grab a quick bite. read more

After checking in to our Hotel, Toasties was our first stop for a quick bite before waking around Times Square. We just missed the lunch hour rush so the wait was not as bad although the place was still a little busy. The food was good, but because of the lunch rush some of the hit food was no longer available as they had ran out. read more

See all

Very quick takeout breakfast and lunch place. Really fast service. Amazing actually. And my bacon egg and cheese on a toasted sesame bagel was really yummy. read more

This is such a great hole in the wall. The food is amazing and the service is fast, even during the super busy weekday. I was tempted on rating this lower so it won't be discovered by fellow travelers like me. The pastrami was flavored perfectly, and the soup had plenty of chicken and noodles. Keeps up the excellent work! read more

Came here because of the yelp reviews and ratings. Being our first time in NY, the workers here are super friendly, patient and helpful!! With such a huge menu to choose from, we ordered a cinnamon raisin bagel, French toast, Philly sandwich, house combo sandwich and chicken parm sandwich. It took a little bit because they had to cook our order, which is totally understandable! This place gets crowded so we ordered at a good time! The French toast was good. It wasn't super eggy. It had just enough cinnamon too! The bagel was delicious! Funny tho, cause it was just a bagel, but it warm and toasted with cream cheese in the middle!!! It was so good!!! And it was big! The chicken parm sandwich was good, very filling! There was a good balance of sauce to chicken. It wasn't dry or over flowing with sauce. The house combo sandwich (it has salami, pastrami, cheese and coke slaw) actually was from yelp. I didn't see it on the regular menu. It was good too! The meats weren't too salty like some other places can be. Lastly, the Philly sandwich (roast beef w/cheese, onions and peppers - but we left out the peppers and onions). This sandwich probably could've used the peppers and onions for moisture and texture cause it was a bit dry and one noted. I think it needed the onions and peppers for the crunch, but my daughter doesn't eat those things. But she said it was good and was happy without them in it. Overall, we had a great experience and delicious meal! I would definitely recommend this place!!! read more

See all

My go to sandwich place when working in the office. The sandwiches are reasonably priced both when you build your own, or order one of their sandwiches off the menu. If you go during peak lunch time, the line can be a little bit long, so recommend ordering online. I usually get the "Eat your Greens" sand which, and for a veggie sandwich it's really stuffed with all the toppings. I really love the sweet pepper, avocado, and carrots, along with the honey mustard dressing. They also offer salads and smoothies! read more

Toasties - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

Some of the fastest and best sandwiches you can get in midtown. Be careful during peak hours as it gets crazy busy. I like to order ahead and then just weasel through the crowd to pick up my order with no hassle. They make a mean turkey club and the tuna BLT is so good. If you're looking to be naughty and treat yourself then order the Chicken Cheddar! I eat here several times a week. read more

Want the New York Experience? Come to Toasties! Food was amazing!! they have a mixture of sandwiches and a food bar to choose from! food bar didn't look too appetizing but their sandwiches were BOMB.COM - I ordered a sesame bagel with ham and cheese (they were out of eggs :( ) but i heard someone order a chicken parmasian sandwich which made me consider ordering another one! lol - My mom ordered a tuna sandwich which was also scrumptious - I was people watching and just felt the "new york everyone is busy and in a rush to get somewhere vibe" -ALL the staff were super kind Overall would definitely come back read more

Toasties - Ham ( i think) on a sesame bagel with american cheese! - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

This is the second year in a row I have used Toasties. I just wanted to take a moment to thank you and your team for the incredible breakfast you all provided us. It couldn't have been easy to get 28 meals to us during breakfast rush but it was SO good and appreciated.Everyone involved commented about how amazing the meals were and how all the accommodations were perfect! You have been requested for next year so guess we will talk again next February. Best wishes and greatest appreciation. Nicole L. Ridgewood Montessori School read more

Delicious food and fast service We visited for breakfast and really enjoyed their sandwiches and challah french toast read more

A must try is the E to Z sandwich on an everything bagel. Chef's Kiss! Only reason I didn't give 5 stars is cuz they toasted my bagel a little aggressively, but maybe say lightly toasted if that is your preference. Would definitely go back ! read more

Bagels were pretty good just know there is super limited seating space but what else is new

Best Deli places in Times Square!! Run don't walk to get yourself a super yummy breakfast or lunch. read more

Toasties - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

They make a decent sandwich, but raised prices again. And, closed at 2:30p on a Friday???? Would've been a 1 star, but they do make a quick decent sandwich. read more

Needed an early breakfast and we were staying just north of Times Square. I came across good online reviews for Toasties, so made that my destination. We got a variety of food - a peanut butter wrap, a mexican wrap, and an egg/bacon wrap. Plus a bagel with cream cheese. All of it was really good and made to order in about 5 minutes. Definitely a handy place for a quick bite! read more